Only Helmuth was excommunicated, but it was done without the knowledge or
consent of the church leaders in Salt Lake. So after the war when they found
out, his membership was reinstated and it said on his record,
"excommunicated by mistake." DodgerDoug, the filmmakers
didn't say anything about Netflix, but they did say it will be available
nationally on DVD in April.
Is it true they were excommunicated?
How can I see this movie? Will it be available on netflix?
I am grateful for those who have the courage to do what is right.
I was lucky enough to be at this screening and they said it would be out on DVD
in April. Also, regarding the comment in the review about the boys
not looking like they had been in prison: I believe it was common practice for
them to clean up their prisoners before trial. I have seen a lot of other movies
with people on trial before the People's Court and they all are clean and
don't look beaten in the least. I believe it had something to do with the
fact that they didn't want people to see how badly they had treated the
Will this movie be available in DVD format in the near future??
Encouraged? No. No member has ever been encouraged to disobey the law where he
or she lived, even when that law is wrongheaded and unfair, not to mention lots
of other things that would take all my word count. But no one who obeyed laws
passed then was punished by the Church for doing what they were required to do,
either, since they were, as the citizens of their homelands, required to do it.
That said, still, do we not make much of, for instance, the revolutions in the
US and other countries because they led to a form of government
"approved" by those whose words are most heeded today? We often forget,
are many different stories to be told. All are right, and all worth acclaim, all
those who took part did well, did the right thing. And yet, they all did what
appears to be opposing things. Like an impressionist painting, Life, from close
up, doesn't resemble at all what it is. Only the Artist knows.
These young men are rightly regarded as heroes today, but I doubt their
activities would have been encouraged by the Brethren is Salt Lake had they
known about them, just as nothing was done to encourage LDS members in Iron
Curtain countries later on to oppose their Communist rulers.