Ben Brewer, Deseret News
East High School vs. Mountain View High School football game at Mountain View High School in Orem, Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2012.

East (3-7) at Herriman (8-2)

4A state tournament first round

Saturday, 5 p.m.

Parry’s Power Guide: East by 18

All-time series: First meeting

Coach vs. coach: First meeting between East’s Brandon Matich and Herriman’s Larry Wilson

HERRIMAN — For a first-round game, it truly doesn’t get any more intriguing. Between the quality of play from both teams, the relenting controversy, and basically two would-be region champions squaring off simply to earn a berth in the quarterfinals is unprecedented.

After one of the most bizarre, head-scratching, emotional situations in Utah high school athletic history, Herriman will host East, arguably the best team in 4A, Saturday at 5 p.m. at Herriman High.

“Honestly it wasn’t just about a Herriman game, it was about what we thought was an irrational decision,” Mustangs coach Larry Wilson said of the ruling that allowed East to participate in the 4A playoffs subsequent to being found guilty of playing with ineligible players. “Whether the decision would have been no forfeitures or all forfeitures for (East and Timpview) — people may have agreed or disagreed, but it was a punishment that would have been applied across the board to the offending schools.

“I think that’s what frustrated a lot of people, and then when there was no rationale as to why that decision was made and to try and find those answers led more to it than anything else."

However, ironically, the decision ultimately could serve a better interest for the Region 7 No. 1 seeded Mustangs (8-2). If East (3-7) were to retain its No. 1 seed instead of its current No. 4 position, the two programs, assuming both advanced past the first two rounds, would have eventually met on a neutral field at Rice-Eccles Stadium. In this scenario, Herriman gets a crack at the Leopards on its home turf in front of what’s sure to be a record-breaking crowd.

Nonetheless, Wilson still preferred the other route.

“We really haven’t really thought in terms of when we’d rather play them,” he said. “I think that obviously if we play them as the No. 1 seed at Rice-Eccles Stadium in the semifinals that would have only meant that we were fortunate to win the first two games, which would have been significant for a third-year program.

“For a new program that has never won a first-round game (and is) trying to establish (itself) as a legitimate team, those are benchmarks that every team certainly works for,” Wilson continued. “I guess because of what it would have meant to our program we would have rather got them in the third round because that would have been huge to our program.”

The Leopards, who enter as 18-point favorites, were perhaps the most dominate team in the state before the sanctions were levied against them. East, operating from the triple option despite calling off the dogs in many lopsided fourth quarters, rushed for 2,683 yards and 43 touchdowns.

Ula Tulutau carried the bulk of the production with 1,012 yards and nine scores. Quarterback Issac Valles has been incredibly effective directing the passing game with 13 touchdowns and only one interception while completing slightly over 70 percent of his attempts.

Defensively is where East has truly shined, and up until its first “true” loss against Logan in the final week of the season, in the midst of the sanction hearings, it hadn’t given up more than 13 points in a single game.

“They know it's going to be a huge challenge. East is a great football team, there’s no question about that. Anybody who would say otherwise probably has never seen them play because they’re a great football team — one of the best in the state obviously,” Wilson said. “Very talented, very well coached. We’re certainly aware of the challenge and knowing that we’re going to have to play probably our best game of the season to have an opportunity to be successful against them.”

The Mustangs certainly have the offensive power to compete after scoring 50 points or more five times this season. They’ll need big performances from Francis Bernard and Tueni Lupeamanu to pull off the upset and secure the first playoff win in program history.

“We don’t have any history or that tradition or foundation to draw from so everything that we’re doing is brand new,” Wilson said. “When things are brand new, you never know how you’re going to respond.”

East statistical breakdown

(Note: Does not include play-in game stats)

Scoring offense: 43.1 ppg

Scoring defense: 10.3 ppg

Passing leader: Isaac Valles (51-71, 71.8%, 922 yards, 13 TDs, 1 INT)

Rushing leaders: Ula Tulutau (128 carries, 1,012 yards, 9 TDs), Preston Curtis (33 carries, 435 yards, 8 TDs), Jewka Patetefa (44 carries, 248 yards, 8 TDs)

Receiving leaders: John Fakahafua (19 rec., 338 yards, 3 TDs)

Tackles leaders: Sesi Salt (31 tackles), Zach Swenson (26 tackles)

Sack leaders: Korey Rush (9.5 sacks)

Interception leaders: Preston Burnett, Jewka Patetefa (2 INTs)

Herriman statistical breakdown

Scoring offense: 43.7 ppg

Scoring defense: 13.9 ppg

Passing leader: Tueni Lupeamanu (73-126, 57.9%, 1,206, 10 TDs, 5 INTs)

Rushing leaders: Francis Bernard (93 carries, 87 yards, 14 TDs), Brandon Farmer (69 carries, 911 yards, 7 TDs)

Receiving leaders: Connor Johnson (18 rec., 327 yards, 3 TDs), Jordan Drage (13 rec., 224, 1 TD)

Tackles leaders: Ben Richard (81 tackles), Sialao Mobley (50 tackles)

Sack leaders: Tueni Lupeamanu, Kalisis Moli (2.5 sacks)

Interception leaders: Francis Bernard (4 INTs)

Felt's Facts for East High School

All-time record: 521-341-31 (99 years)

Region championships: 32 (1917, 1919, 1920, 1921, 1922, 1923 co, 1925 co, 1926, 1929 co, 1934, 1935, 1936 co, 1937 co, 1938, 1939, 1940, 1942, 1943, 1952, 1953, 1955, 1956, 1957, 1960, 1962, 1964, 1966, 1973, 1996, 2006 co, 2007 co, 2011)

Playoff appearances: 40 (including 2012)

All-time playoff record: 46-24-2

State championships: 15 (1917, 1919, 1920, 1921, 1922, 1923, 1925, 1926, 1943, 1952, 1953, 1955, 1956, 1964, 1974, 1996)

State championship record: 12-3-1

Felt’s factoid(s): East has the most consecutive non-losing seasons with 37, from 1932-1968. … East also has the most state championships, 15, since state playoffs began in 1919. … East is tied for the state record (with Skyline) for winning consecutive championship games, five (1919-23).

Felt's Facts for Herriman High School

All-time record: 20-13 (3 years)

Region championships: 1 (2012 co)

Playoff appearances: 3 (including 2012)

All-time playoff record: 1-2

State championships: 0

State championship record: 0-0

Felt’s factoid(s): Herriman became just the 10th school to qualify for the playoffs in its first year of football (2010). … Herriman is one of only 11 schools to have a perfect home playoff record (1-0).