There are few if any admirable political figures in Washington, D.C. these days. But one whose under-the-radar work calls for high praise is Ed Whitfield, R-Ky. Whitfield's stalwart concern for horses is nothing short of spectacular, particularly given the fact he hails from the bluegrass state.
In Kentucky, the political muscle of horse breeders and trainers (many of whom oppose animal welfare laws because they interfere with profits) reigns, or should I say, reins supreme. I have written about Whitfield in the past, but his nonstop push to protect horses from neglect, slaughter and abuse deserves revisiting.
Whitfield most recently worked with a small group of members of Congress to stage a recent subcommittee hearing on thoroughbred racing. At that hearing, members of Congress publicly "scolded the horse-racing industry for endangering thoroughbreds with lax drug policies and faulty breeding and said the sport emphasized greed over transparency," according to Sports Illustrated.
Such "scolding" was long overdue. The subcommittee's investigation pulled back to reveal just the first of many layers of cruelty to which the proud thoroughbred is sadly subjected. But the hearing was a start and a good one.
Thoroughbred racing and other equine sports have produced a number of well-publicized recent tragedies, which is why Congress is finally starting to take reform seriously. The list began with Kentucky Derby winner Barbaro's "euthanizing" after shattering his leg at the 2006 Preakness, the second event in racing's Triple Crown. I put the word "euthanizing" in quotes because "slaughter" is more apropos. Then this year's Derby second-finisher, Eight Belles, shattered her leg and was destroyed while a horrified live TV audience looked on.
Most recently, the trainer of Big Brown (who won the first two races of this year's Triple Crown) very publicly stopped doping the horse and Big Brown fizzled at his next race, the Belmont. Message to the American public: Most horses must be loaded up with harmful, performance-enhancing drugs to win.
Last week's subcommittee hearing was a prelude to congressional consideration of a federal governing body for thoroughbred racing. The industry has sworn to reform itself in the past and has failed miserably. It is currently governed by a patchwork of mainly lax state laws. At the hearing, Stone Farm's Arthur Hancock testified that "the industry was too fractured and perhaps too dysfunctional to organize itself and needed federal oversight to rid the sport of drugs and stop fatalities."
Stone Farm has bred three Kentucky Derby winners. Hancock, like Whitfield, deserves some kind of medal for "outing" his own industry like that.
Few industry representatives are that honest. More typical is this ditty from Alex Waldrop, president of the National Thoroughbred Racing Association. Waldrop posted on the group's Web site after he, too, testified at the hearing: "The hearing is yet the latest example that our industry needs to act responsibly, collectively and expediently on a range of equine health and safety initiatives. Otherwise we can expect Congress and others to push forward with an agenda to act on our behalf."
Read that as code for, "If we don't start cleaning up our own very dirty act, we will have it cleaned up for us by federal authorities." Luckily for the horses and unluckily for the profit-motivated humans, it's probably too late for self-governance.
Whitfield deserves extra credit, but he is no longer the only member of Congress active in this cause. Self-described "lifelong equestrian" Sen. Mary Landrieu, D-La., is now a major supporter of horse protection legislation. Rep. Jan Schakowsky, D-Ill., who chaired the hearing. is now also on board.
But Whitfield has toiled for years to prompt Congress to become proactive on a variety of horse protection fronts. Before he took up the cause of thoroughbred racing reform, he led the so-far unsuccessful move to ban horse slaughter in the United States. (NOTE: State laws shut down the last three U.S. horse slaughter plants in Illinois and Texas. But on a national scale, horse slaughter is still legal in the U.S. because Congress has been unable to pass a federal slaughter ban.)
Bonnie Erbe is a TV host and writes this column for Scripps Howard News Service. E-mail [email protected].