Mitt Romney's Mormonism and its potential to help the faith become more "mainstream" present a threat to many evangelicals, who have been seeking to point out why his faith is not Christian as one way of competing in the "marketplace for souls."
That's according to the authors of a new poll showing "intense bias" among evangelicals toward Mormons. Brett Benson, assistant professor of political science at Vanderbilt University, said the Southern evangelicals surveyed "were offended when they hear the Mormon claim that they are Christians. They become defensive and don't want to allow them that status."
Benson said that, for many, Romney's candidacy "presents a risk in allowing a Mormon to occupy a mainstream position, where they could risk losing the standing they have relative to Mormons, and that has a lot to do with this 'marketplace mentality,"' as both groups proselytize and seek to share their version of Christ's gospel with the world.
"If you can define Christianity in such a way as to exclude Mormons from that group particularly in evangelical academic conversation when you ask why they are unwilling to allow Mormons to have that designation, you run into this 'I just thought the club was closed' mentality.
"Both are proselytizing faiths. If you can define Christianity in such a way as to exclude them, you exclude much of your competition. That's consistent with much of the message we run in our analysis" of poll results, Benson said.
John Geer, also a political scientist and Benson's colleague on the survey at Vanderbilt, said he thinks Benson's interpretation "makes good sense, but it's not my idea." He said he believes "that's partly what's going on. There are incentives in these competitive conservative churches" to emphasize theological differences between Mormonism and historic Christianity. "They don't want the competition."
The survey sampled 1,200 Americans and another 600 Southern evangelicals so comparisons could be made between their responses.
Leaders of the Southern Baptist Convention the largest denomination among evangelical Protestants began publicly voicing their opinion that members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints are not Christians in the mid-1990s, as the church's missionary effort produced record numbers of converts. They have continued to insist that theological differences eliminate Mormons from the "Christian" club, while Latter-day Saint leaders have steadfastly maintained they are, indeed, Christian, in the sense that they worship Jesus Christ as the head of their faith and redeemer of the world.
Benson, who is a Latter-day Saint, said the survey did not break out evangelical leaders as a separate group, so his ideas about how they feel are simply an opinion. But he believes the key to Romney's ability to attract evangelical votes rests with their "elites. It comes back to that earlier notion about the competition in the marketplace for souls."
Many feel they're in a corner, he believes, because the most financially viable GOP candidates are Romney whose Mormonism is the stumbling block and Rudy Giuliani, "who in their eyes is morally reprehensible. (Fred) Thompson and (Mike) Huckabee are not likely to win, so then they get Hilary (Clinton)" in the end.
"I suspect if those elites would open the doors to the club and accept the fact that the LDS Church is a mainstream religion, I think a lot of this bias (reflected in the survey) would go away."
When asked why Democratic House Majority Leader Harry Reid, who is also a Mormon, doesn't draw the kind of scrutiny Romney does, Geer said the difference is party affiliation. "The Democratic Party base is different than the GOP (where most evangelicals affiliate), and that's the key part of this. I don't know whether that would suddenly change if Reid were to run."
Another indicator that some evangelicals may be swayed through their church affiliation: Operators of a Web site, www.godvoters.org, call themselves "Christian Voters of Iowa" and say they have sent a survey to each presidential candidate. Their 30 questions include:
• Whom do you think Jesus wants as our next president and why?
• Do you believe Jesus to be God or the Son of God?
• Do you believe Jesus and Satan were once brothers?
• Which books do you believe to have been inspired by God and without error?
"If you are a pastor or attend a solidly Bible-based church in the state and wish to be the first to be e-mailed the presidential candidates' answers to our questions that we hope you will share with your flock, you're welcome to e-mail us," the Web site says.
Conversely, there are several Web sites that indicate denominational affiliation supporting specific candidates, including evangelicalsformitt.org, latterdaysainstforhuckabee.blogspot.com and mormonsagainstmitt.blogspot.com.
Romney has actually been endorsed by a few evangelical leaders, including Bob Jones III of Bob Jones University; Robert Taylor, a dean at Bob Jones; John Willke, founder and past president of the National Right to Life Committee; and Paul Weyrich, co-founder of the Moral Majority.
E-mail: [email protected]