2005: TCU 51, BYU 50 (OT) An 18-point TCU rally results in overtime, where a muffed PAT attempt and a Cory Rodgers TD prove to be the difference. The final score is still debated to this day, with some BYU faithful claiming Rodgers fumbled the ball before crossing the play.
2006: BYU 31, TCU 17 This game changes when linebacker David Nixon forces a fumble by TCU QB Jeff Ballard. The Cougars take the turnover the other way for a touchdown and a 10-0 lead. BYU never trails in earning its first win over a top 25 team since 1999.
2007 BYU 27, TCU 22 TCU comes as close to ending BYU's 11-game home win streak as anyone has. Once again, a sack by Nixon, this one on TCU's final drive, proves to be huge.