I thought the refs did a decent job. There are points of emphasis this year that
were called. Hands to the face or helmet is one of them. And we got nailed
twice. I think there were only two questionable calls against us. Not bad...just
could have been no-calls. But no one on here complaining about the refs talked
about Matthews getting lucky on what was looked clearly to be offensive
interference. Rather than complain about the refs one might want to look at the
total lack of discipline on the field. Late hits, holding, and the fishing reel
thing...Plus the giggling on the sidelines that ESPN cameras picked up.
And five guys at home for one game suspensions. lack of Discipline Seems a
little pervasive to me. Hope they win in Texas but I wouldn't bet on it.
Not with what I saw Friday.
Two things about this game:1. The referees were OVER ZEALOUS to call any
kind of penalty they could...They were ridiculous..Both teams were totally under
the control of the referees...very poor officiating.2. BYU better
get their act together on HOW TO TACKLE...or TEXAS will barbeque them this
coming Saturday...I give the defense an D- for their tackling
efforts...The offence a B+... (P.S.: I was a teacher before retiring)....Good
Luck Cougs..Be watching you Saturday...
@ Riverton CougarNot all BYU fans whine abut the refs, but I
literally can't think of game (win or lose) where a few fans didn't
complain about the officiating. From my perspective it seems that a large part
of your fan base has a serious persecution complex.
2008-2013 average penalties per game per team: 5.8Byu penalties per
game 2008 7.8. (most 12, away)2009 7.2. (most 10, away)2010 5.4 (most 14, home)2011 5.8 (most 10, away)2012
6.2 (most 12, away)2013 7.8 (most 14 twice, both away)2014
15.0. (n of 1, away)BYU record in frequent-penalty games: 7-1Moral: Expect the probable & stay composed.
2-4-flinching: Yes, there has. This wasn't one of them.
@Two For FlinchingYes, well officiated games happen very frequently.
This game, however, most people feel that the officials were throwing the flags
too often. I don't know how that could be taken to say that BYU fans think
every game has bad officials. If you don't want BYU fans to define Ute fans
with such broad stereotypes, please don't do it to BYU fans.
Does anybody know if there as been a well officiated game in the history of BYU
Allowing referees to assess penalties on the basis of their anti-bullying
hypersensitivity was never a good idea. It's football!! When a guy is a
loudmouth jerk onfield, generally the players will take care of it. I played
before most of the present namby-pamby nannyism set in, and we had very little
problem with "excessive celebration". A player's own teammattes
would get on a jerky player or there would be payback along the way. We
didn't worry about words or "offensive motions". Idiots were
"helped" off the field and such action was seldom necessary. Everyone
knew how it went. The refs in this game were awful. Not for or
against anyone specifically, just lousy refereeing. I chalk it up to first game
of the season and give them a do-over. They need it.
Not a particularly enjoyable game to watch--I agree with the TV announcers that
the refs seemed to be trying to call every penalty in the rule book at least
once--but infinitely better than last year's opener against Virginia.
I'm sure the Cougs will be better with their first-string corners and
running back, and the D-line will probably be more effective when they can drop
fewer people into coverage. Taysom looked pretty good--glad to see him passing
downfield and sliding instead of taking repeated hits.
Typical BYU fans...you would think we'd lost by 25 reading some of these
comments. Y'all need to calm down, it was the first game of the year and
was sloppy at times, but it also looked pretty darn good at times. And asking
coaches to yell at players for a mistake? C'mon...I've been to
practices, I have a friend who's a GA and these guys ARE held accountable
and ARE yelled at in practice. What good does it do to yell at a senior who
already knows he made a mistake in front of everyone? None whatsoever except to
make certain fans feel better I guess. Trust me, Fua will be calked out in the
film room and practice by his coaches and teammates. Embarrassing a player in
front of everyone doesn't produce results...there may be some players that
respond to that but not most (and certainly not a senior who's leadership
and play on the field is valued).
I don't think the officiating was one-sided, but I have to disagree that is
was "excellent". It is true that BYU committed way too many personal
fouls and holding penalties and that was the main issue.That being
said, there were some bad calls on top of that. One that comes to mind was the
call right before UConn's touchdown, the pass interference call on an
obviously uncatchable ball.BYU needs to better discipline their
players. BYU can't afford that kind of performance against Texas; they are
going to need every single yard they can get. While things like undoing a
turnover because of a personal foul or changing a 3rd and long to a 1st down due
to excessive celebration had no effect on the outcome of this game, those same
kinds of things could be the difference between a W and a L next week at Texas.
It was a sloppy game by both teams, but the yellow flag parade was ridiculous.
If you think all those calls were accurate and relevant you are biased and must
have had the sound turned off as even the announcers were miffed by some of the
calls. Still there were lots of stupid mistakes by the players and coaches. I
doubt we will see 15 penalties next week. I think last nights refs just had
first game jitters. They played a better second half!
Mendehall's Cougars Great from the starting gate!"Eye of the
Alani Fua had the personal foul for doing a reeling in the fish action after a
sack. He tweeted out, let me fish, caught a 10lb carp and cost me 15 yards. To
which Taysom Hill replied, fishing season is closed. Another person tweeted,
better be glad you weren't elk hunting, who know's what the refs might
have done, probably ejected.I agree with Taysom, personal
celebrations are about the individual and not the team.
The excessive celebration penalty has got to go in college football ! In 1 game
it's a penalty and in the next game it's not. In 1 conference
it's a penalty and in another loo fervency it is not.
Yes, some of the calls were nit-picky, but you can expect that in a first game.
Refs are trying to establish high expectations for the season so they don't
have to fight it all year. And yes BYU made a lot of mental errors, but you can
also expect that in a first game. I think it is actually really good for BYU
that they got flagged so much, but still walked away with a big win and looked
good. This way they will have plenty of motivation to clean things up, but
still can be confident and have momentum behind them.I would be
curious to know what BYU's actual yardage for the game would have been if
you add in all the yards they had gained, and then had taken away from
penalties. It seemed like every penalty came at absolutely the worst time,
often after big gains. They moved the ball well, but some series it seemed they
ended up going a lot farther than 100 yards because of being set back so many
I have to give both teams credit for "hanging in there" with the parade
of yellow flags that were called on what it seemed every other play. I thought
for a while that the refs wanted the spotlight instead of letting both teams
just play the game. Even Greg W. said, "Refs could actually call a penalty
on every single play in ANY game if they wanted to be that technical!"We switched back and forth at commercials to the Houston game. Those
refs in that game let a lot of close calls go. Since we play Houston, we could
see the same refs as in the UConn game again. The players will have to sharpen
their plays and especially not make late hits.It was so exciting to
see Taysom Hill shine in spite of all the penalties. It didn't seem to
phase him at all. He has the maturity to put every call behind him and move
forward. That's the mark of a real leader, and it showed Friday night. The
defense was also superb in stopping UConn twice within 10 yds. of the goal.Congratulations, BYU, on a huge win on the road. Go Cougars!
I love my Cougs. That being said, they did not play like they were a P5 level
team. In addition to lack of discipline from players, Bronco makes very poor
decision about wanting UConn to re kick and then he gets a penalty. Also, why
can't we find corners who can stay w/ the receivers? So frustrating. Bronco
needs to pick it up with having himself and his team better prepared. Especially
if he is going to talk about them being deserving of P-5 status.
Seriously, fellow fans, let's stop blaming the refs for our sloppy play. I
was sitting low to the field last night and no one on either side thought the
refs were off in their calls. It was a big joke in the stands. If we
give up points on a drive due to penalties - it's our fault and not the
refs. I thought our players were sloppy and you can call it first game jitters
or whatever, but in the end our guys need to control themselves. I'm tired
of not seeing our coaches say anything - especially on a costly call. I'd like to go back to the fireside again to the Q&A and ask the
players what responsibility they feel to their teammates and to us as fans when
they commit a personal foul on national TV. The majority of the players are
great young men most of the time, which is remarkable, but our guys
shouldn't be committing personal fouls or taunting. Period.
I was at the game sitting close to the field. We all agreed that the refs called
an excellent game and the calls were legit. I don't agree with the minority
of our fans who think the refs are out to get us. Every game is played in a
different venue with different refs and this crew was one of the best.
Let's stop making excuses!!It was just a sloppy opener. Our
guys made tons of mistakes. What I can't stand are the personal fouls and
taunting. These are just plain stupid and senseless on the part of our kids. I
expect our coaches to get in the players faces when the drives for the other
team keep going because our guys just can't control themselves. Like Alani
Fua who was called for "taunting" after holding UConn to third and long,
keeping the drive alive. Fua is a Senior and mentioned as a top NFL prospect. In
other words: "NO EXCUSES". But when Fua went to the sidelines after a
stupid penalty - nothing. No coach even breathed a word.
Those bad refs. Why can't we ever get perfect ones? There must be some
around the country. They always effect our games. Only us...always
2fef:"That's right. Every ref, every single year has it out for
BYU. It has absolutely nothing with the fan base playing the victim every chance
they get."Lets not attribute this to all or even most BYU fans.
I thought the officiating was awful also but only because they didn't let
either team play ball. It was called way too closely...and BYU got away with
some &.UConn got away with some. I don't think either team was favored
just called too tightly. Officials are trained and taught to not be so tight
that they become the focal point of the game and these officials obviously
didn't follow that formula. I don't think the officials in this game
had it out for BYU but they certainly could have kept the hanky in their pocket
on numerous occasions on ticky tack stuff for both teams.
The reffing was bad. Not in favor of BYU. Not in favor of UConn. It was just bad
in general. There were so many calls that were clearly not penalties. There were
a couple catches that were ruled incomplete or vice versa. There were times in
this game where it appeared the refs had no idea what the rule was in a
particular situation. They had to gather and discuss things multiple times.It wouldn't surprise me if this was a Pac-12 crew. I don't
know if it is, but someone should look it up and let me know. Pac-12 refs are
clueless. If you don't believe me, watch the end of Wisconsin vs. Arizona
State last year. Or watch any part of the BYU vs. utah game last year, which was
that exact same crew the week after they gave the game to ASU.
The yellow flag parade was ridiculous. Inexcusable. Lots of room for
improvement.Taysom seems to have improved on his passes, O-line
looking somewhat better. Lasike had some moments and I'll be glad for
Jamaal's return.A shame that 3 players broke team rules and
were suspended for this game, especially Johnson, who blew his chance to play in
front of his family and peers.Go Cougars!
"but I guess the Cougs should get used to this."That's
right. Every ref, every single year has it out for BYU. It has absolutely
nothing with the fan base playing the victim every chance they get.
Sorry, but some of those penalties were connected to phantom calls. BYU was
penalized on one end-zone pass interference call (that contributed to
UConn's only touchdown) that was the result of a receiver being slowed at
the line of scrimmage before the ball left the quarterback's hands.One UConn pass was reviewed after it was called a completion and the officials
ignored the fact that the ball was raked across the turf for a whole yard before
the receiver could elevate it off the ground, and they failed to reverse the
call. I could go one for the rest of my word allowance, but I guess the Cougs
should get used to this.
I thought they were such bad calls against us. UCONN was fouling us way more and
not getting called.
Did the refs fall asleep in the 2nd half, or did the teams really play better?
They let go two consecutive pass interference calls to help UCONN out. The
penalties on BYU were embarrassing, incongruant with Mission of representing the
Church as players say they want to do. Hope in Texas they can win the score,
and play clean.