Comments about ‘End of an era: Huntsville bookshop closing, monastery not far behind’

Return to article »

Published: Sunday, Aug. 17 2014 3:05 p.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
utah, UT

I remember my friend from the monastery Brother Mark.
He was such a peaceful, humble man.
I hope the remaining monks are taken cafe of. ^_^

Provo, UT

I too visited this monastery on a couple of occasions and know colleagues who went there for the peace the place afforded from this beautiful, but crazy world. The kindest souls made bread and honey...but best of all, they were truly interested in their customers. May our Heavenly Father bless you, all!

John Charity Spring
Back Home in Davis County, UT

Shame on those who have driven this monastery out of Huntsville.

Bountiful, UT

Please, read the article. The monastery isn't being driven out. There are not enough monks young enough to maintain it. They currently do not even have the resources to train newcomers if they were to join.

Farmington, UT

@ John Charity Spring--
Perhaps you misunderstood: the monastery is not being driven out of Huntsville. The monastery is not attracting new monks. As a result, those few remaining (only 10) are too few and are not physically able to manage the workload of the income-producing activities which supported the monastery. I suppose you could say "shame" on young people who either don't feel or don't respond to the monastic calling, but it seems a stretch to accuse them of "driving this monastery out of Huntsville."

I am saddened that the monastery is on the way out. It is truly a place of refuge in a beautiful valley. We loved going there to buy honey and interacting with the brothers there. I hope they are found a peaceful home for their waning years.

Old Scarecrow
Brigham City, UT

John, did you understand the article?
No one has driven the Monastery away, there just were no men coming to join the order in recent decades. The men who remain there now are very aged, and many have passed away. Why would someone using the pseudonym "Charity" make such an unkind comment?

Here, UT

The monastery has been a good neighbor and we're going to miss them. Father Allen has been especially neighborly, helping others when they were in need.

@John Charity Spring;

The monastery is not being "driven out". They have had no new recruits for several years now and the brothers are all getting (very) old. Did you bother to even read the article? They've been there an average of 60 years; they have 10 brothers left is all.

liberal larry
salt lake City, utah

Its a shame that the monastery is closing. I've stayed at the Trappist monastery in, Conyers Georgia, and they seem to be going great guns.

I wonder why there is such a difference in their fates?

Farmington, Utah

I don't think anybody drove the monastery out. Without new recruits joining the monastery can't survive. It is a sad thing, but certainly a sign of these secular times.

Duchesne, UT

I am sorry. I loved going there and I loved their honey. It will be greatly missed.


I grew up in northern Utah and went to the monastery several times. Their bread and honey were the best available anywhere, the monks were friendly and they were well received by the entire community. It is sad that their numbers are dwindling to the point that they can't sustain themselves. Sad to see it go.

Tyler D
Meridian, ID

I’m curious why the monks don’t rent out their monastery as a retreat center? This seems to be the model for most of the thriving monasteries around the country, with many having a rotating group of extended stay residents taking on many of the duties necessary to run the grounds.

Seems a shame to close such a beautiful place for want of willingness to change the business model.

Scott H
Ogden, UT

I have visited the monastery a number of times over the years, beginning in my childhood. In times past we enjoyed eggs, bread, and honey from the monastery. I appreciated the devout brethren and the serene atmosphere. A few years ago we took our kids up there and got to sample the wonderful wit of one of the leading brethren. But even then he admitted that the monastery's days were numbered, since steadily fewer people were seeking a life of devoted asceticism.

South Africa, 00

I visit the monastey three times. In 2008 I met Fr's' David Altman, Leander, Patrick, Br Thomas and associates. I enjoyed the quitness and the chanting of prayers. My first time enjoying lunch with Monks from the Cistercian order. I will miss you but we will meet as Fr Patrick said " on the way to heaven" May God bless you all for the work and frienship to all people out there. Johan Van Rooyen.

Here, UT

@Tyler D;

They do retreats if you're interested.

one old man
Ogden, UT

I mean no disrespect here, but I'm curious. Can someone explain the reason for the name "Father Mary Patrick?"

Manti, UT

That's a real shame. There is such an ethereal atmosphere in that monastery. I wonder if the Catholic Church is going to sell the property to someone who will build more condos or time shares. I sure hate to see something this unique, especially to Utah, fade into the misty halls of the past. This is very sad.

Idaho Falls, ID

I remember feeling sad when the beautiful St.Mary's school on the east bench of Salt Lake was torn down. Such a shame.

us, CA

One old man: Can you explain Carroll O'Connor? Catholic priests and nuns take the names of saints and other biblical figures. Sometimes they choose t xheir names and sometimes they are assigned to them. They are meant to convey reverence and respect and personal association.

Altamont, UT

So when they do close, where will the brothers live? I wish that had been explained better.
Maybe they don't know yet?

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments