Quantcast

Comments about ‘Can Devin Mahina help bring glory back to tight end position at BYU?’

Return to article »

Published: Saturday, July 12 2014 3:00 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Taysom4Heisman
Heber City, UT

A lot of people think that the tight end has no place in an up-tempo, read option offense.

I completely disagree.

If anyone knows who Colt Lyerla is, you know why I think a big, powerful player at TE/FB can be a great change of pace to an otherwise lightning-speed attack.

Unfortunately, I don't see Mahina as the guy who will bring the TE position back. I think Colby Jorgensen is the guy. He won't do it this year, but by the end of his career I think he will be a very successful tight end and will hopefully start up the TE factory we had with Harline, Coats, Pitta, and George during Anae's first stint.

With that said, I hope Mahina does turn out to be the guy and wish him the best of luck this year!

stanfunky
Salt Lake City, UT

Another year, another article about BYU tight ends (not) returning to the glory years. Until Bronco takes it seriously and includes them, the offense will sputter. TE's are the safety valve when things break down and in their best years, BYU has utilized them.

Bountiful Guy
Bountiful, UT

I would love to see Mahina bring back the glory of the tight end to BYU. But it takes an offensive coordinator, QB, and most importantly a game plan to do it. BYU's best players rarely see the ball in their arms, and it's not their fault entirely. Good luck Mahina. I would be most pleased to see you have a great year. Will we see 2-3 QB runs per game, or 15-20?

Y Grad / Y Dad
Richland, WA

In the past I've loved the play in the BLUE zone where the qb essentially options the tight end. Coming around the end and they isolate one defender who has to go for the qb or drop to cover the TE.

Don't know how many touchdowns I've seen with that play, but obviously not enough in recent years.

Cosmo's Cousin
Holladay, UT

BYU is on the way back to glory. Devin and especially adding Harvey Langi will be the pieces the Cougars need to get the national championship in football back to Provo in the next couple of years.

Tuffy Parker
Salem, UT

If you want to bring back the "glory day" of the TE, just put some plays in where the TE is relevant and then throw the dang ball to him.

sg
newhall, CA

Simply put, Bronco and Anae are not fans of the TE. Too bad. Anae is an average offensive coordinator. If this team's offense sputters like it did last season, Anae will be done and gone, and let's hope he's gone. He was a failure his first time around and his second chance hasn't been stellar at all. Hill is a good QB, but not even close to Heisman calibre. Why? He simply can't throw down field. He'd be a better receiver than a QB. He's quick, utilize him as a receiver...he loves to run. I'm not expecting much from the boys in blue this season. Off season, all talk; let's see what they got come August.

CO Ute
PARKER, CO

Y fans can get all blue in the face but the 'tradition' of tight ends left a long time ago. BYU has one player in the NFL playing tight end. As for current rosters before teams cut down, that is the same number as USU has. Utah has two and their offense has been terrible the past few years.
You can only live in the past for so long.
That said, I wish Mahina the best for a successful year and maybe he can start up what has been missing for a while.

Tom in CA
Vallejo, CA

sg -

Don't be too cynical. Steve Young took time to develop. Taysom Hill will have a break out year in 2014.

JSwaggDaddy
Heber City, UT

@sg

"Simply put, Bronco and Anae are not fans of the TE."

Uh. Harline, Coats, George, Pitta.

"He (Anae) was a failure his first time around and his second chance hasn't been stellar at all."

Our offense was consistently a top 25 offense in his first stint. We were virtually unstoppable from 2006 to 2009. The main reason we didn't put together a BCS season in those years is our defense got torched by TCU in 2008 and 2009, and got off to slow non-conference starts in 2006 and 2007.

"He (Hill) simply can't throw down field."

I'm not saying Hill was Peyton Manning last year, but his passing numbers were actually pretty solid if you take out the first 3 games. He shredded Houston and USU through the air and was decent against Wisconsin and Washington. Hopefully he will be better than decent this year against the best teams like Texas and UCF, but he wasn't as awful as people think, outside of the first 3 games which included wet weather in 2 of them.

RBN
Salt Lake City, UT

@JSwaggDaddy

"his passing numbers were actually pretty solid if you take out the first 3 games". You mean once they got to the easy part of the schedule his passing numbers improved?

That's like saying Travis Wilson had a good year if you take out the two games where he had 9 interceptions. Or he had a great season if you only count third quarters.

JSwaggDaddy
Heber City, UT

"You mean once they got to the easy part of the schedule his passing numbers improved?"

Virginia and utah were not great teams. Yes, we lost. Texas is tough (and we beat them) but virginia and utah aren't exactly juggernauts.

Utah State, Houston, Wisconsin, Notre Dame, and Wisconsin are all tougher than Virginia and utah. And Hill was still very improved in those games.

So Hill actually improved as the schedule got harder.

Cougar Claws
Lindon, UT

The TE and FB "positions" change depending on the type of scheme. It depends how many backs or receivers that you have in the formation. If you run a 4 wide receiver set or "spread" formation that is designed to spread the defense out and cover all ends of the field, then you may be running a double tight end set where both of the tight ends are flexed out as inside receivers. Those inside receivers could also be substituted for the shorter, quicker slot receiver types. Both formations are intended to create mismatches. The TEs are supposed to create more of a height mismatch, while the slot receivers are intended to create more of a quickness, speed mismatch. When you run this formation it changes the TE's role in the offense. You may also put in a double tight end set that is a power run formation where you have a fullback and two tight ends in an I formation the way you see Stanford run sometimes. Some schemes actually take those positions out of the equation if they are purely a speed option scheme, etc. So, the TE and fullback positions have somewhat changed with a changed offense.

Duckhunter
Highland, UT

I've always enjoyed seeing the TE perform at such a high level at BYU but honestly I'm not married to any single position. All I care about is that the offense is good, moves the ball, and scores. I don't care who gets the ball or how they get downfield and into the endzone just that they get downfield and into the endzone, a lot.

Two For Flinching
Salt Lake City, UT

@ JSwaggDaddy

BYU beat both Utah State and Houston on the road, so what makes you say they were both tougher than Utah, who beat BYU at home? Not to mention Utah beat USU and finished well ahead of the Aggies and Houston in the final Sagarin ratings.

RBN
Salt Lake City, UT

I think a better way to look at Taysom is to look at how he performed against teams from power conferences and Notre Dame. He was 124-266 (46.6%) with 6 INTs. Tough to spin that as a successful season.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments