Quantcast

Comments about ‘How the Fourth of July combines patriotism and faith’

Return to article »

Published: Friday, July 4 2014 7:30 a.m. MDT

Updated: Monday, July 28 2014 10:50 a.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Hutterite
American Fork, UT

Faith, for those who claim it in the limited context it usually takes here, is infused in and modifies most everything it's claimants experience. At least, that's what they say.
But it isn't necessary. July 4th, halloween, the solstice, golf, even tax deadline day, can all be richly experienced as part of the human experience without permission, or guilt, from someone claiming to reveal divinity.
In fact, some of these experiences, such as the fourth of July, are arguably better left as Thomas Jefferson said they ought to be, on the other side of the wall. Let's honour the vision of the wise, learned men, elites of their time, in the founding of this nation. And remember the stamp of it's humble origin, rather than attempting to place a veneer of divine infallibility on it.

gmlewis
Houston, TX

America is exceptional because of its history and constitution. At its inception, Americans were exceptional because of their adoption of the exceptional concept of self-government. This couldn't have happened without the aid and influence of divine providence. Since then, other people have adopted this concept and have manifested their own version of exceptionalism.

I believe that America is an exceptional nation, and hope that one day many other nations will emulate her and become fully exceptional, too. I know, "when all nations are exceptional, none of them are." To which I reply, "Wouldn't it be wonderful if the whole world became exceptional among the billions of other worlds."

Chris B
Salt Lake City, UT

During the 4th of July celebrations I'm reminded of many studies, including one done at Harvard, that says that republicans are more patriotic and that children who attend patriotic events are more likely to become republicans. This is not surprising of course, but fun to remember.

USA!

Tyler D
Meridian, ID

“Lacy Cooke encouraged readers to use the holiday to get to know neighbors of different faith traditions and denominations.”

Or get to know your agnostic or atheist neighbors since many of the Founders were in fact closer to their sentiments than those of a church member.

Stormwalker
Cleveland , OH

Waving the flag saying "my country right or wrong" is not patriotism.
Sloganeering about "protecting freedom" while making war to protect oil company profits is not patriotism.
Sending the poor to war while the sons of the powerful get deferments is not patriotism.
Declaring war and not funding veteran's services is not patriotism.
Mistreating minorities under the banner of "religious freedom" is not patriotism.

Patriots don't get rich dismantling American companies and sending American jobs overseas.
Patriots don't force their religious views onto their neighbors.
Patriots don't close the borders of the country that once proclaimed "give me your tired, your poor..."

Patriots don't scream the chorus of "Born in the USA," they know the verses that talk about the mistreatment of Vietnam Nam Vets and the betrayal and destruction of the working men and women in this country.

Patriots are appalled at privatized prisons and the abuses covered by the war on drugs, at hungry children and underfunded education while we spend billions on war.

I am a former Navy Hospital Corpsman. I volunteered and served 8 years. I am a patriot. I am not conservative or Republican.

Gildas
LOGAN, UT

I don't know if other nations should emulate what 'America' has become although they might profitably emulate what it once was, maybe two hundred years ago.

TheProudDuck
Newport Beach, CA

"Or get to know your agnostic or atheist neighbors since many of the Founders were in fact closer to their sentiments than those of a church member."

Name five.

I'll spot you Franklin, Jefferson and Madison. Who else?

And would even those men be properly classified as "atheist or agnostic" by modern Dawkins-Harris-Hitchens standards?

TheProudDuck
Newport Beach, CA

"The latter assumes our nation has claimed favored status with God."

I see no such assumption. Where is it?

You can leave God clear out of it, and still note that as a matter of objective, secular fact, America is an exceptional nation. No other nation served such a prominent role in creating the modern liberal democratic consensus. At the time the United States was founded, there were only two other countries in the world that were remotely democratic -- the Dutch and Swiss Republics, both of them quite small. No country had ever demonstrated that democracy could "scale" -- could function in a large enough polity to bend the arc of world affairs towards self-government.

America did. And that is a good thing. It is just chest-thumping USA! USA! We're number one! chanting to say so. It is simple, objective historical fact.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments