Quantcast

Comments about ‘How the Amish save money’

Return to article »

Published: Tuesday, May 6 2014 2:25 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Hutterite
American Fork, UT

You forgot one thing. Socialism. Collective ownership and a sense of responsibility for the whole. My namesake hutterites practise this as well, albeit at a different level.

patriot
Cedar Hills, UT

for starters they don't have a $650 a month SUV payment and I doubt they care too much about having a $600 smart phone to play internet games all night out in the hay field.

gee-en
Salt Lake City, UT

Yeah, Hutterite except you forgot one thing: Without the freedom and the associated capitalism of the United States there would be no Hutterites or probably even Amish. You see, the great country that is the United States was the only beacon of freedom for groups such as these to practice their religion as they saw fit. Countries that were Socialist, Communist, Dictatorial, etc. have always persecuted, driven off, or killed groups such as these.

Outside-View
Federal Way, WA

Another point regarding socialistic "having all things in common" is that the people who participate in this lifestyle would need to be committed to a values standard as well as to each other. Just trying to "legislate" the sharing of property will not work.

For me, I would not want to try and live this lifestyle until the Lord comes and tells us to.

Ranch
Here, UT

@Outside-View;

Your comment indicates that you believe that is the way the Lord wants you to live. So, why wait until told to live that way?

Midwest Mom
Soldiers Grove, WI

The Amish also don't have insurance. Our local hospital cuts them huge deals and doctors even makes house calls. Not specifically fair. They also don't have any expenses connected to higher education, however they do make use of their neighbor's technology by hiring them to drive them places, use their phones, use trucking services to ship their products or help them move. They also take advantage of professional services like hospitals and they use fossil fuels to power their generators.

So, yes, there is much to admire about the lifestyle of the Amish, but much of that lifestyle is made possible by the rest of the community.

Ranch
Here, UT

Midwest Mom says:

"...but much of that lifestyle is made possible by the rest of the community."

As it is for everybody. Nobody lives in a vacuum and all the things you also enjoy were made possible by "the rest of the community". Roads, schools, hospitals, parks, water, electricity, ... You see where this is going? You also sound jealous, which begs the question, why not live like they do if you're envious of what they enjoy?

Jamescmeyer
Midwest City, USA, OK

@Ranch

On the contrary, his post seems to indicate that it is -not- how the Lord has instructed us to live.

As a greater misunderstanding in general, the law of consecration is not socialism. It is a willing covenant, and its participants still own their own property, increase their possessions through labor, and are granted "according to their wants and needs", not according to an arbitrary sense of "equality".

Regardless of what does or does not factor into the lives of the Amish, the principles of thrift and recycling are universal.

Midwest Mom
Soldiers Grove, WI

Ranch -- I live in a very rural area, with large Amish populations. As I said, I admire them for some of what they do, but not all. I bear them no ill will and I am not jealous of them. But I do get tired of the stereotypes that the Amish are better than anyone else. Many people see the Amish as some sort of bucolic ideal. That they are not. Their education is limited, with resulting ignorance. Many Amish are sweet and humble, yet like other cultures, they have their rogues and charlatans. Some I've dealt with are incredibly sweet. Others shrewd and ruthless in their dealings. I've had an Amish man look my friend and I up and down as he chuckled rudely. We've seen sexual abuse of an adopted niece by her uncle and cousins that the Amish community tried to hide and when the girl ran to local authorities for help, she was shunned. The perpetrators of this abuse were given light, work-release sentences. A few months for repeated rape. Their quaint appearance and cultural ignorance inspire assumptions that they are innocents, but they're just like everyone else.

Floyd Johnson
Broken Arrow, OK

Socialism is not a major part of the Amish community. They purchase homes and farms individually, and each family unit has a goal of independence. They do have close knit communities with frequent social gatherings. However, pot luck dinners are not synonymous with the common definition of socialism.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments