Quantcast

Comments about ‘Bible survey: Many Americans aren't as scripture savvy as they think’

Return to article »

Published: Thursday, April 24 2014 6:38 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Ralph
Salt Lake City, UT

The beautiful thing about the Bible is that it can say anything you want, depending on what behaviour you need to justify.

I can show in the Bible where slavery, revenge, sexism, war, etc, are supported and encouraged, and then call myself a fundamentalist Christian.
Or, I can show, in the same book, where those things are frowned upon, and call myself a fundamentalist Christian.

The way we interpret the Bible, or any other religious text, is based upon who is the current, authoritative voice on the matter (e.g. the Pope).

It's the same with the Koran or any other "official word of God".

Take the good and ignore the rest, just don't tell me the Bible is the unerring, infallible word of God. It may be the word of God, but it certainly isn't infallible.

BYR
West Bountiful, UT

Dunning Kruger effect. Google it.

toosmartforyou
Farmington, UT

To use a scriptural phrase, "words without knowledge" comes to mind. Many who profess the Bible to be the Word of God have no knowledge of what it says and certainly wouldn't agree with its concepts and teachings if they were presented as a poll, beginning with "Do you believe...?" Then look at their faces when you say "This is a quotation from the Bible, XX Chapter and ZZ Verses...do you want to rethink your position?" The back-peddling will be amazing, along with all the explanations about it being true but "not literal" etc.

Alex 1
Tucson, AZ

I've heard people say, "I believe the Bible to be inerrant in every verse. I don't pick and choose which verses to believe." To them, I would say, with all due respect, you are either Biblically ignorant or you are not being honest. I believe the Bible wholeheartedly, but I admit that I do not follow the whole Bible, don't think it is inerrant, and don't think that it is necessary that I do. That doesn't mean that I don't believe in the God who inspired it, nor do I believe that I am not obligated to search for the words of God in the Bible. The promptings of the Holy Ghost give life to the Bible verses, and when I feel the flow of pure intelligence in me, I know that I have heard the voice of the Lord and heard the Word of God. When the scriptures and inspiration come together, the elixir becomes scripture to me and I become accountable.

Dennis
Harwich, MA

Being "Scripture" savvy seems about as important as being "Lord of the Rings" savvy.

Stormwalker
Cleveland , OH

To my experience most religious people have a relative handful of proof-texts ripped from both textual and cultural context. The passages can then be twisted to mean whatever it needs to mean in the new context.

Sodom is a perfect example. From Ezekiel to Jesus himself, living in the culture, the story of the cities of the plain was a warning about treating visitors badly, a warning about abusing strangers instead of extending hospitality and protection. Today, ripped out of the original cultural milieu, the story has been turned into an indictment of homosexuality and nothing else. Meanwhile, the still relevant warnings about pride and refusing care to strangers are ignored.

Tyler D
Meridian, ID

@Stormwalker – “Today, ripped out of the original cultural milieu, the story has been turned into an indictment of homosexuality and nothing else.”

Has there ever been a book in history that can offer confirmation of such a wide ranging and diverse set of prejudices?

One of the most surprising things I come across regularly is how often in discussions with Christians the most appropriate response to their objections & equivocations I can offer is to simply say “read your own sacred book.”

Bible illiteracy seems rampant among people of the book and is equaled only by the parts of the Bible Christians either ignore, whitewash or compartmentalize such that it won’t touch their faith.

There are entire sections of the OT and even some of the NT (Revelation) that present such a barbaric and abhorrent view of God that I can think of no other way to explain how this book is so revered other than to suggest millions of people must have coke-bottle thick rose colored glasses when they read it.

Stormwalker
Cleveland , OH

I was in middle-school when I first read Robert Heinlein's "Stranger in a Strange Land." It is a very grown-up novel and has a lot of discussion of various complex ideas. One subject tackled, almost through-out, is religion. One discussion includes the story of a group of kids making fun of Ezekial's bald head and God sending two bears to rip those children to shreds.

My mother was very upset when I talked to her about that passage, and wanted to know how God could justify it. I don't know if she was familiar with the story before that, but it really bothered her that she didn't have an answer.

We discussed some other passages - all things Heinlein had touched on in SIASL. She did know about - or couldn't explain - any of it.

The Bible is a collection of stories designed to create a tribal identity - like the legends of Olympus. Trying to use it as a template for life today makes no sense.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments