Comments about ‘Former BYU quarterback John Beck signs with CFL's BC Lions’

Return to article »

Published: Tuesday, March 4 2014 11:25 p.m. MST

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Christopher B
Ogden, UT

CFL is clearly the landing spot for quarterbacks for QB university these days.

Hard to see Jake Heaps going anywhere but the CFL too, if he can make it to the CFL.

Best of luck John

Big 12 Call Yet?
Ogden, UT

Is there even a single QB from QB University in the NFL?

Uncle Rico
Sandy, UT

I think John Beck still owes his career to Jason Beck for pushing him to be better.

Sandy , UT

I wonder if it will ruin his weekend having to sign with the CFL. Good luck John.

Palo Alto, CA


Remind us which pro-football team Utah's Sugar Bowl MVP is playing in.

BYU has 5 former QBs who have been inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame.

Call us when Utah wins its 1st national individual award of any kind.

Plano, TX

Live your dreams !

2013 Ute Seniors SWEEP byU 4-0
Ogden, UT


Nothing to point to currently so you're still living in the past?

Utah has a QB starting for a playoff team and has an incredible NFL record.

And if you want to compare any other positions in the NFL, lets do that!

PAC man
Anaheim, CA


Nothing to point to EVER, so you're forced to beat your chest about lesser accomplishments.

No Super Bowl MVP's; no NFL MVP's; no Heisman Trophy winner; no college or pro Hall of Famers, so tell us, what incredible NFL record?

Richmond, VA

Good luck to Mr. Beck!

The minute I saw the headlines in this article I knew certain BYU haters will make the first posts to mock and ridicule and true to form, they did just as I thought they would. I suppose this silly and childish bantering back and forth about "my dad is better than your dad" will never end with some fans. It's so sad when we can't cheer for each others' success when we're not playing.


chris b / 2013

This article is about John Beck and has nothing to do with u.

River Falls, WI

Despite several down years at the QB position BYU still has multiple former QBs making a living playing football. Congrats to John making money for doing what he loves.

springville, UT

How many bowl games did John play in? 4 How many bowl games will the Jr's to be get to play in at Utah? 0

Park City, UT

No Y QB's in the NFL currently, but there is one pending his completion of college play.
Historically though, the school up north doesn't even want to go there...

west jordan , UT

I never felt that John was given the time to grow as a QB at the NFL level. Going to the CFL is better then nothing and who knows maybe he will be able to get the growth and expereince to maybe one day come back to the NFL. Good Luck

Sandy , UT

@ trueblue you really think taysom is playing in the NFL can he even throw? I guess we won't even find that out this year with their schedule.

West Jordan, UT

Actually Brad Sorenson QB with the S.D. Chargers is a former BYU QB via SUU ... Good Luck to J.B.

Frisco, TX

The Ute naysayer makes it sound like the Utes have filled the NFL with QBs.

Kudos to Alex Smith. I cheered for him with the 49ers and Chiefs.

But how many QBs from BYU vs Utah have played in the NFL over the last three decades, how many have won Superbowls, and how many have many MVPs and Heisman Trophy's? I suggest U pick a different argument. Sure the CFL is not the NFL, but both Beck and Max make some good money in the NFL and now playing in the CFL is still better than pumping gas and living in your mother's basement.

Or even looking forward, one has to admit that the QB pipeline for BYU is more promising than for U. But with seven QBs on scholarship on the hill, who knows, maybe one will surprise.

Enid, OK

I agree with the comment above that John Beck got really hosed when he was thrown into the game far, far too early in his first year at Miami. Not good.

Not sure what happened (asn in "why") he didn't perform solidly when he was able to start in Washington. Did he have no talent on offense to help him? That's what happened to him with the Dolphins.

Regrardless, Beck to Harline is still the best college football play EVER!!! I was there along with my (then) 10 yr old son.

Good luck, John!


Another class act getting a well earned chance to succeed. This man is a student of the game and prepares well when given the chance. For his size he is one of the best qbs we've seen at BYU in many years and hopefully that translates to the CFL. Here's wishing you the best.

Salt Lake City, UT

Now this IS something to cry about.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments