Comments about ‘Dan Liljenquist: Negative impact: the Affordable Care Act, pensions and hourly workers’

Return to article »

Published: Thursday, Feb. 27 2014 12:00 a.m. MST

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Hayden, ID

Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius says there is “absolutely no evidence” that the Affordable Care Act will drive down employment, despite a report from the Congressional Budget Office released Feb. 4 predicting fewer people would be working.

“There is absolutely no evidence, and every economist will tell you this, that there is any job-loss related to the Affordable Care Act,” Sebelius told reporters in Orlando, Fla., on Monday. “Part-time physicians are actually down since 2010, not up. The number of full-time workers continues to increase. I know that’s a popular myth that continues to be repeated but it just is not the case."

Your government lied to you and is still lying to you America! What are you going to do about it?

salt lake city, utah

No one should apologize for the ACA because of stories like this. The villain here is the Granite School District not the ACA. It's obvious the district carved out a specific category of employees to treat differently than other employees (not provide health insurance ).

My bet also is the other villain is the story teller. Chances are the security guard job is not a full time job and was simply abused by the district. The character in the story probably has insurance through another source (Medicare etc.), and took the security job as a supplement and now has to work a second part time job. Pretty much no harm no foul.

If this is not true, and the story's character was trying to live on and buy health insurance on $12 and hour shame, shame, on the district.

American Fork, UT

Aren't the pension story and the ACA totally separate of one another? Besides, why aren't you wondering very loudly why a 15 year veteran of the school board, even as a security guard, is only making 12 bucks an hour? That's pathetic. If someone had that kind of seniority as a staff member of a school division back in Alberta he'd be making twice that or more, and have full benefits including pension and health care. And not the namby pamby mess we got with the ACA. Maternity and sick leave, too. Instead of worrying about blaming the ACA for making things worse, consider that they weren't good to begin with.

Orem, UT

I see pragmatistferlife is taking a chapter out of the Harry Reid playbook. Any story that casts Obamacare in a negative light must be a lie! It doesn't matter if you liked your doctor, health insurance plan, or your working hours before this disasterous law took effect. Bureaucrats in Washington D.C. know better than you what is good for you. If you don't like the changes, you have no right to complain. Any complaints are just lies.

Did I miss anything?


You can blame (alleged) ACA costs on the Feds, but the far-more serious fiasco with the State Retirement System rest squarely with the State Legislature, Dan.

Still Learning
Salt Lake City, UT

I work in the SLCSD and I am also an hourly employee. Luckily, I have my social security check coming in, so I am not as bad off as the example Dan gave of his friend in the Granite school district. What makes this cut so disgusting for me is that I am in no way part of the school district's medical care costs. I am on Medicare and have a Medical Advantage plan with Select Health. My costs did not go up for 2014, but 2015 will be a different matter. So, what the ACA did for me was to cut my wages and face me with an eventual extra premium or reduced benefits if Obama does pull money out of the Medical Advantage programs. It will be interesting how many of these painful problems will be addressed in the elections later on this year and in 2016. I was simply screwed because I happen to be in the hourly pool. Thanks to Dan for the explanation. Hope you will send a link to his article to your friends.

There You Go Again
Saint George, UT

"...15-year veteran paid at an hourly rate of $12, received a letter from Granite’s human resources department announcing that “in light of new rules for the Utah Retirement System and the Affordable Care Act” all hourly employees would immediately and without exception be capped at 29.5 hours per week...".

Business owners at any level can cut wages/benefits then blame it on the ACA and get away with it...

Granite School District is late to the table but is simply following the script...


When the long awaited/anticipated Republican ACA is implemented...all of these cuts in compensation packages will be re-instated...


one old man
Ogden, UT

More political game-playing as still more loyal conservatives try to find ways to make ACA fail.

Pleasant Grove, UT

The Supreme Court says Obamacare is a tax. Is it any surprise that people are altering their economic behavior in order to avoid paying it? I guess it's a surprise to Obama voters. Everyone else saw this outcome a mile away.

Salt Lake City, UT

Obamacare is Not BushCare, so you libs cant blame anyone else for the failure.....there is only one failure I see. OBAMA!

Thid Barker
Victor, ID

Old Man; Obamacare is failing because of conservatives?....lol

Saint George, UT

And why wouldn't anyone with a lick of common sense not want this abomination to go away-and as fast as possible?

one old man
Ogden, UT

Yes. Had the conservative machine simply joined in and worked to help make ACA a successful bill and law, it would fill a vital niche for all Americans. Instead, they kowtowed to the insurance industry, the GOP, and all those who wanted to make sure we didn't have a Black president any longer than one term.

If the GOP ever had a better idea, we never heard it.

Ernest T. Bass
Bountiful, UT

If there is one thing Dan has proven, during his time as a legislator, it is that he did not care one bit about pensions and hourly employees. Look at his record, each and every year he attempted to take away the benefits of State employees, all while he never gave them a pay raise even though they are underpaid compared to industry standards.
Can't take anything this guy says seriously.

Orem, UT

one old man: The GOP had several ideas how to solve the health insurance problems. Liberals didn't want to hear any of them. It's your own fault "you never heard it".

For your other point...I guess if all the conservatives would just turn into progressive liberals, all the country's problems would disappear. Right? Too bad that isn't how this country works.

To take the other side...Had the liberal machine simply joined in and worked to help make energy independence a top goal, we would be already weaned off foreign oil. Instead they kowtowed to the environmental groups.

Had the liberal machine simply joined in and worked to make a national flat tax, then the economy would be booming and everyone more prosperous. Insead they kowtowed to the whole "income inequality and redistribution" crowd and the Obama economy remains in the dumpster.

...and on, and on....

salt lake city, UT

Republicans playing with employee contributions are to be solely blamed for the loss of pension funds. Can't blame that one on BO.

LDS Liberal
Farmington, UT

Didn't you just love Dan's response --

So sad,
Too bad...

Blame Obama and the ACA,
but this man's job is on the STATE level.

Irony Guy
Bountiful, Utah

Baloney. Organizations that are capping employee hours are simply using ACA as an excuse to beat up their employees. It would be nice if workers had some leverage to demand that employers stop this charade, but they have none...especially in Utah.

Saint George, UT

First, the Republican charade, then the Democrat charade, then the blame the other party charade (with the blah blah blah of the pristine character of each party's leaders) and on and on and on the story goes? Both party's leaders are controlling and corrupt and the followers are fools to put it mildly.

Morgan, UT

Obamacare is an unmitigated disaster. It was built on lies and deception.


* Obama and the Dems lied about the cost of Obamacare: They told us the cost would be $900 billion; actual price $2.6 trillion

* Obama lied to the American people about being able to keep your health insurance if you liked it

* The CBO Report from 2/4/2014 projected that Obamacare will reduce the number of hours Americans work by the equivalent of 2.5 million full-time jobs. Factor this with our current real unemployment of over 14%. But not to worry, the Dems say this is a good thing.

“this was one of the goals: to give people life, a healthy life, liberty to pursue their happiness. And that liberty is to not be job-locked, but to follow their passion.” -Nancy Pelosi

* Let’s not forget the 5% of Americans who lost their health insurance coverage under the “Individual Mandate” portion of ACA. Those who were able to sign up for Obamacare, now have higher premiums and deductibles. They don’t qualify for the subsidies under the ACA.

Hope and Change!

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments