Comments about ‘Salt Lake City School District sets new policy after outcry over dumped lunches’

Return to article »

Published: Friday, Feb. 7 2014 6:55 p.m. MST

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Glendale, AZ

Super! They came to their senses and are implementing good, common sense and thinking about the kids for once. Good job.

Potsdam, 00

Now you see, it works. Cheers to that and to Texas.

(S.t. a public outcry is not so bad after all)
(Of course thanks to DN reporting)

City, Ut

Love it!

The light gets shined on stupid, wrong and bad--and in a short amount of time, gets turned into smart, correct and good.

Oh, that everything wrong in the world could get fixed this fast and easy.

W Jordan, UT

We probably just created another entitlement.
And we wonder why the new generations grow up believing they're entitled to everything.
I'm sure when the parents decide to show up or answer the school calls to pay their bill the child will have already graduated.
I hope the state decides to go into parent's bank accounts and take the money if the shameless parents refuse to pay since their kids get fed anyways.

Walt Nicholes
Orem, UT

And now we will have a different problem entirely. Some parents - not many - will, knowing that their kids will be fed, no matter what, simply not send in any money for lunches. They will try to game the system.

But I believe that the good people of the district, if allowed, can donate to a fund to feed the children, and make the school less dependent on the government for this money.


So very glad to see this! Last week's incident was frankly a disgrace and not the way one of the richest countries on Earth should treat their children.

Nies, MI

Earlier articles on this subject referred to the employees being on "paid leave" while this one simply says they are on "leave". Which is it? Paid or unpaid. Unpaid leave is a punishment. Paid leave is a vacation. Also, how long will these employees remain on "leave", who are they and has anyone heard from them? I would like to hear their side of the story.

The Netherlands, 00

I am glad that the school district changed their policy, and children will not miss their lunches anymore.

terra nova
Park City, UT

This has been an education for certain educators. But have they learned anything?

It is astonishing that common sense did not prevail and prevent this whole mess. That a whole new "policy" needed to be developed is telling. And frightening.

The this is the same mindset that gets a first-grader suspended for sexual harassment after an innocent kiss on the playground. It is the same stupidity that has the same kid up on charges for bringing a plastic knife to school in his lunch!

"Lock and load, the kid has a weapon!"

It is the same benighted mindset that forbids a teenager to have some Advil in her locker. You have to deposit it with the school nurse - and it isn't going to happen easily.

It is time to begin educating our educators (or rather, the administrators making these foolish rules) about the benefits of actual common sense.

Ferron, UT

First everyone should understand to embarrass students is not right.
Now I have said that, it is a shame that parents do not have to be responsible for their kids anymore in this district. If they don't want to pay for their student's lunch that is just fine, the tax payer will pick up the tab. I wonder if this can extend to me, I don't want to make my car payment, do you think we could get a policy that will allow me to keep my car and the taxpayer will make the payments?
This could all have been avoided if parents would have paid their bills.

Highland, UT

Great News! I hope this policy spreads thru the whole State. If the district can afford to dish up a lunch and then dump it, and then turn around and give a milk and fruit, adding waste upon waste, then they can afford to feed a hungry kid, regardless of their parents ability to pay or not. Yes, go after the parent - leave the kid out of it. Sounds like the district will be throwing away their little red "happy face" stamps to remind kids to tell their parents they are out of money too.

Now, let's get Chef Gordon Ramsey to have a little talk with Michelle Obama about the quality, flavor and texture of those "healthy" school lunches that get dumped by thousands of kids voluntarily! "School Kitchen Nightmares" - he can help Michelle to come up with a different menu to attract more paying customers!

Orem Parent
Orem, UT

Yeah let's not worry about parents paying their bills. The government can fund it through our taxes. Not that I want a kid to go hungry but if the parents would take care of their responsibilities then this story never would have happened.

On the other hand
Riverdale, MD

Kudos to Salt Lake City School District for getting this one right, finally.

Iowa, Iowa

I can see abuse of the lunch program possible if parents now know there children will be fed whether or not they pay for it. What does a school system do to non paying parents? They should have a list of students without paid for lunches and feed them a couple of days and then refer them to police for parental abuse. I can see you don't have money for a school lunch but a PBJ sandwich or something else provided by the parents is what i called for.

my two cents777

I could not believe what I was reading when I saw the article about school lunches being trashed and children bullied about their bills- which they have absolutely NO control over. The district is doing the right thing now- they seem to be on track- and, I would also like to see the person who actually TOOK lunches from hungry children FIRED. Those actions were uncalled for and cruel. In Utah of all states! The state that most consider a good example to other states. You looked really bad, Utah. :(

Joan Watson

One cant help think back to 1940's, when in the Farmington Elementary school a bowl of soup was served at noon to each student, because many families were poor. Now of course in our affluent society, school meals offers a full course menu. If some schools cannot afford to freely provide noon meals to every student, perhaps such should be scaled back to what is affordable. Or raise the price of a meal to students who pay - to make up for those who don't.

Redding, CA

Good result, no more trashed lunches, nor hungry or embarrassed schoolkids.
But to the school workers I'd ask if they really learned a necessary lesson of life, yet. Those school workers have a job, a job they can hardly be fired from, a job with health insurance, a job with a retirement plan, in short they have a job that gives them a decent life. The parents of the schoolkids are financially weaker, they have an intermittent job if they have a job at all, no health insurance, no retirement plan, no paid sick leave, no paid vacation, but they have children who they are sending to school = good for them.
Get a real lesson, school workers, get off your soft chair, get away from your desktop computer which can seemingly show these problems and tell you how to solve them, Get Real, people, find and work on solving more real problems. This rule was wrong to have on the books.
And thanks again to that guy from Texas, we should all be ready to help like he was.

play by the rules

Free everything for everyone. Supply and Demand = the world is flat as we are ever learning and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth. Yes it was wrong to take the lunches away, but if we teach kids that there is such a thing as a free lunch how long can our society actually last?

bountiful, UT

Really??? They needed a new policy. Common sense wouldn't have worked? Apparently not.

Clearfield, Utah

Well here is hoping other school districts will follow suit. I know of at least one other district that has the same policy when it comes to giving fruit and milk when a student does not have enough money in their account. I also know they are told to let their parents know they need money. I think its time the Legislature gets involved and correct some of these issues by passing laws that will help the children of this state and hold the parents accountable when they are not fulling their responsibilities as parents.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments