Maybe. Maybe just coincidence though. If there really is such a thing, which is
questionable at best. Children tend to be much more in tune with the Spirit than
adults are, so this is entirely possible.
As long as we're in this mortal life, we'll have as least two sides to
this question, which is very old. Historically speaking, it goes back at least
to the European Middle Ages, long before modern science crept into the picture,
where a common question was "If God loves us so, why does he allow us to
suffer?" Those who ask this question don't accept that we are mortal,
God is Eternal: "For my athoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your
ways my ways, saith the Lord.For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so
are my ways higher than your ways, and my cthoughts than your thoughts."
(Isaiah 55:8-9)We had a tragedy many years ago, but my mother was prepared
for it in a series of dreams. Non-believers may well ask: "Why her and not
others?" The answer is found in how willing an individual is to accept
God's thoughts and ways, exercising faith. "The Prophet Joseph once
declared, 'Where doubt is, there faith has no power.'” (Gordon
B. Hinckley, quoting from Lectures on Faith, Salt Lake City: Deseret Book Co.,
1985, p. 46).
Sometimes in the grand snipe hunt that is religious life, we experience illusory
correlations between our ritualistic religious practices and ambiguous events.
These moments allow religious interpretations and supernatural attributions to
events that can leave even some skeptics tempted to wonder, especially when the
events involve innocent children whose welfare tugs at our heart strings.But a god who would seemingly randomly save some innocents but abandon
countless others to suffering and destruction is either not the loving and
benevolent god religion preaches, or is just as apathetic and indifferent to
mankind as is an indifferent naturalistic universe some attribute to atheistic
science.Either way, no one can ignore the fact that countless
innocent children suffer and die around the world with no "savior", and
that fact reflects very badly on any theistic proposition.
Coincidence back and forth, from the view point of mortals, everything is just
bang...a concidence.I will ask you next life when God will call on
you to go to earth to save one of your great/gandchildren, but please do it in
such a way, that people cannot use it against religion or their test of life in
faith. Difficult.The oversight God has does give us enough room to
choose in each instance, but his knowledge is far from shortsightness, in his
world there may be pleasant circumstances, but conincidence is far from divine
thinking.So here we are again. I was trying to make a smart guess,
how God might have interferred in her life, by touch, urge or fear, or by
language of a child that could not be pronounced in words at that time : Hence
...I really don't know !Let it be, it was a sweet story to
encourage her for a life time.Leave it this way.
desertYou are really reaching there with your explanation, and you
are basically making things up. She was asked and said she didn't know. It
is that simple. Sometimes we do things and we don't know why. Like the time
I was riding my motorcycle at night and was approaching a light and it turned
yellow - with plenty of time for me to go through. I decided to slow down and
stop instead. Well just as I did a car went flying through the light the other
way. It may have hit me, it may not have, but it would have been close. That
doesn't mean god told me to stop, it just happened to work out that way.Conversely, there are many incidents per day of people who have the
opposite fate - decide to stop only to get rear ended by another car... It is
@ comments and stuffTo the reader of circumstances and spiritual
promptings it needs some reading in between lines to come up with what actually
happened.She shrugged her shoulders saying : I don't really
know.For a child this is an indication of hiding something, like
have a plan of her own, or having thought of coming back inside to do more
important bussines such as her doll in need of something etc...that is when the
Spirit is interferring on the level of a child.Speaking to the child in
the language of a child.They are not adults and do may act odd, heavenly
assistance is still playing a significant role, since you need to look at the
outcome.There is no such coincident.
checking it out again, i didn't find a source for speculation that the girl
received any promptings. she responded to mother with, " I don't know.
" mother returned to her housework with a mild curiosity of why the girl
came inside earlier than she would have anticipated.it is a sweet little
story, but ... just a story
Thanks Lillian Robinson, thank you Mother Stephanie Robinson and DN Jason
Wright.Lillian, I cannot stop thinking about your story, it was
meant for the day but seems to become a good night story forever. You should
know, this is the love for life that keeps us going and makes us hope that many
of us will be spared the same way. God may bless you. Thank You.
what a sweet story. we need to hear good news too
In raising our own little children, we often must deny them things that they ask
for because we know it wouldn't be good for them. We also give them
unsolicited, spontaneous acts of tenderness just because we love them. It might
seem capricious to our children if they bothered to try to work out all the
reasons why behind every one of our actions, but most children are just glad to
have parents who love them and who they can trust. That's no different
from how God treats us, His children. Last year a friend suffered the
heart-wrenching sadness of finding her grandson dead in her backyard pool -- the
gate was still locked. They have no idea how he got in there. I imagine that a
part of their agony was wondering why they weren't prompted in time to save
him. God did not send us here to be free from adversities and pains of all
kinds. He sent us here to learn to walk by faith, and a large part of that
faith is trust. And Christ isn't just our redeemer; He's our healer
Thanks for sharing this experience in this article! It's a great reminder
to remain worthy of those sacred promptings. I know God has a plan for each of
us, and those little promptings that come are His way of helping us achieve our
own unique plan.
RE: Mountanman, as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the
judgment.(Heb 9:27). Heaven awaits those who live a holy and spotless Christian
life, on the contrary, hell fire awaits sinners, those who refuse to receive
Jesus Christ (Luke 16:19-23).@1.96 Standard Deviations, D&C
137:10 says, "[...] all children who die before they arrive at the years of
accountability are saved in the celestial kingdom of heaven." Then
Abortion would be a better method of saving souls than what anti-abortionists
favor now (let the children grow up and hope they convert).
@And_Im_a_Mormon:"Let's not forget about the hundreds of people
who heard a prompting, just to go back inside their house to have it explode
from a natural gas leak."How would we know? Those people are
dead. Facts, not speculation.
As she was moving back into the house, there was something missing in our
observation.She might not have been saved by divine interference
alone, but if her mother had forced her back outside, what then ?Once again, I went back over the years of my own childhood, and I must admit
there were many occasions at which I was preserved, but in a manner that would
not make me recognize divine assistance, but as children used to think and
plan.How often however, parents and adults are offended by the way
children respond and act.It might be God who has spoken to them, we just
need to be careful about each move we make to adjust children to their new
environment.NOT meaning everything children do and think will lead
them to safety!But we are having a hard time to recognize them being
near to God, when danger is at hand.And her miracle is never to be
compared to other children, because our limited understanding of God's love
for each case will give us false assumptions in return.Thanks for
Good things and bad things can happen to everyone. But, if you have received a
spiritual prompting and followed it and in the process have avoided a tragedy,
you know that promptings can and do happen. God has his own purposes and it will
all make sense someday.
"Is that the price god is willing to pay for the parents to be stronger - to
take their child away from them? I highly doubt that."Looking at
the price God himself willingly and voluntarily paid so that we could be
forgiven of our sins, one is forced to conclude that any hardship we face in
this life pales in comparison. It doesn't make our difficulties trivial or
easy by any stretch of the imagination, but it does provide a different
perspective.God deals with individuals based on the needs and
circumstances of each individual. There isn't a rule that says, "If God
saves one child, he must save all children." We should be grateful for the
blessings we receive, and learn and grow from the experiences we have when the
desired blessing is withheld.
DocHolliday:As far as a child's welfare is concerned, D&C
137:10 says, "[...] all children who die before they arrive at the years of
accountability are saved in the celestial kingdom of heaven." How merciful
of a loving God this is!As for the parent(s), I highly recommend you
watch the true account of a man whose pregnant wife and two of his children died
in a car accident due to a drunk teenage driver. Do a YouTube search for
"Forgiveness: My Burden Was Made Light." The video is a little over 8
minutes and is the first result. Truly this good man's account
will answer your question a lot better than I can! I sincerely hope you can find
value in this short video. Please see it!
1.96 Standard DeviationsSo young children who die have been prompted
from above? Children so young that they can't even walk or talk? There are
unspeakable tragedies that happen. How can a child death somehow benefit the
parents to make them 'stronger'? Is that the price god is willing to
pay for the parents to be stronger - to take their child away from them? I
highly doubt that. Not a chance.
I had an earlier comment about this story but the DN censors placed it hold. It
did not contain anything offensive or any personal attacks, but was just adding
a rational/scientific perspective to the discussion.No doubt it will
be “released” after everyone has viewed and commented on this
article… in the meantime, enjoy the uplifting feelings.
Thank you. We need more uplifting stories in the news. This is something I will
share with my family and is a good reminder of not only being thankful, but also
Brahmabull. Jesus taught us, "All things are possible for them that believe
(have faith)". That adds up very well and explains why some people get
promptings and some don't. And I might add, we are all appointed to die but
what is important is not how we die but how we live! One day we will be judged
not on how we died but how we lived in faith and obedience.
Brahmabull:One other thought why God allows bad things to happen to
people. Consider Alma 14:10-11:"10 And when Amulek saw the pains
of the women and children who were consuming in the fire, he also was pained;
and he said unto Alma: How can we witness this awful scene? Therefore let us
stretch forth our hands, and exercise the power of God which is in us, and save
them from the flames. 11 But Alma said unto him: The Spirit
constraineth me that I must not stretch forth mine hand; for behold the Lord
receiveth them up unto himself, in glory; and he doth suffer that they may do
this thing, or that the people may do this thing unto them, according to the
hardness of their hearts, that the judgments which he shall exercise upon them
in his wrath may be just; and the blood of the innocent shall stand as a witness
against them, yea, and cry mightily against them at the last day."God received in glory those who were being murdered by fire. God also
permitted this to occur so the blood of the innocent acts as a witness at the
final judgement against the evil people.
Brahmabull:You made an assumption that deserves some scrutiny. How
do you know those who die or are severely injured receive no prompting or help
from above? God knows what is best and he deals with us justly and mercifully on
an individual basis.Here are some other thoughts:1) One
can receive a prompting and decide to ignore it or may fear to heed it2)
One's spiritual condition may be such that he/she is not receptive to
promptings or is even in "tune" with the "signal" God sends3) God's wisdom is much greater than our own. Some of us need to be
brought down low before we can be lifted up to a better (spiritual) condition4) Tragic situations often act like a refiner's fire. Help from above can
come after the trial of our faith as opposed to prevent a problem from occurring
in the first place.
I have a hard time believing god prompts some so that they may survive, but
allows countless others to die, with no prompting or no help from above. It
doesn't add up.
Let's not forget about the hundreds of people who heard a prompting, just
to go back inside their house to have it explode from a natural gas leak. God
works in mysterious ways...
Contrast this story with the many other stories where children, or whoever, get
injured or killed. Of course a death or an injury can be seen as an opportunity
to draw closer to a deity through adversity. It's a win-win in either
situation for faith, I guess.
I believe the Lord spares up from some tragedies and not from others - but both
are important for our growth.When I was about this girl's age I
was protected as well. Suddenly I was in grave danger where I was standing and
within seconds I was moved out of harm's way in such a manner that it would
have been physically impossible for me to have moved myself, and no one had been
near me. I believe fervently I had received divine help. However, I have not
always been so miraculously spared.I am happy for this family. The
mom and the author were wise to use this as a teaching moment. Aknowledging when
we have been divinely protected can give us the faith that, should we not be
spared on other occasions, the Lord is with us still and will see us through.
Great story! Thanks for sharing..