Comments about ‘Steve Eaton: Merit badges should be available for adults’

Return to article »

Published: Friday, Jan. 17 2014 5:05 p.m. MST

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Ultra Bob
Cottonwood Heights, UT

Sorry Steave, you're too late. Adults already have a merit badge system. Their merit badges are in the form of cars, boat, clothes, houses and a number of other things. They don't put them on a banner, they drive them, wear them and live in them. Sometimes they forgo some merit badges for others, like sending them to schools.

Salt Lake City, UT

I like it Steve...good idea.

North Salt Lake, UT

Sounds like your company needs to go with the O.C. Tanner model of recognizing employees. Go to their website (not the jewelry store) and you'll see what I mean.

Springville, UT

Man Scouts!

Scott H
Ogden, UT

From what I read in the scriptures, it looks like every genuinely good act will be rewarded far beyond our earthly comprehension. That is, unless one insists on receiving earthly rewards "that they may have the glory of men" (see Matthew 6:1-6).

Provo, UT

I would earn a few. I'd even like to complete my Eagle scout award, having left off shortly after receiving the Life award!

An 'Eagle for Adults' would still be great!

Midwest City, USA, OK

They have merit badges in the military, but whether or not you get them is based far more on opportunity, timing, and social connections, not so much effort or education, which makes it worse than if there were just no merit badges at all.

G L W8

“Eagle for adults”—I’ve thought about this many times, because my scoutmaster earned his as an adult before the age limit was imposed. There were trade-offs: he was an excellent example for us boys but there was a definite attitude that we could always do it later.
The truth is, adults involved in scouting do the Eagle requirements many times over as they work with boys. But the award itself gives the boy an experience at his level that loses its force and effectiveness once adulthood is achieved. Exceptions can exist, of course, and I believe my scoutmaster was one of them. But for most adults, the rank would have little or no meaning.
Scouting has ample opportunities for adult recognition. Specifically, with the Eagle Rank, moms and dads are recognized with a parent pin. Other adults can be honored with an Eagle Mentor pin, which is very meaningful because their selection is done by the Eagle recipient—a proper honor, because the boy himself recognizes the dedication of the adult volunteer, family member, or friend, that has assisted him along the way.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments