Comments about ‘Better than Harvard? Minerva Project aims to transform elite education’

Return to article »

Published: Thursday, Nov. 7 2013 4:00 a.m. MST

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Sasha Pachev
Provo, UT

Good article, except Khan Academy is misspelled twice. There is a sound in a number of languages transliterated as kh. It is absent from English and takes some work for English speakers to learn.

XelaDave
Salem, UT

A considerable numbers of "if" statements seems to pervade the model- a big part of what one pays for at an Ivy League school is the alumni and the network they provide- as we all all know the best idea or thinker in the room is rarely the one that wins the day- I wish the world was about what you know- we would all be better off- but the more pragmatic side tells us it is about who you know and often who you know is not all that bright but they have the money and other resources- sorry but that is why they fly first class and you drive a 7 yr old car but know deep in your heart you are smarter than they are- and that got you what?

Arizona1
Tucson, AZ

I like the idea of getting teachers who can teach. Many universities that require extensive research by their faculty tend to have teachers who can't teach. At the same time, from the sounds of this article, these students will not have access to a world class library--or at least not for the duration of their education. The article mentions that they will fill in the gaps with open-source information. That's all well and great, but from my experience as a graduate student, some of the most insightful educational experiences I had came from my research in libraries which provided a great deal of information that cannot be found online. Until they can get a library like Harvard, there will continue to be a number of important areas where they can't even hope to compete with Ivy League schools.

common twit
Salt Lake City, UT

I always admire people who try to improve the system. Post secondary education is a failing system. It is better than not having an education but it is not practical for most people. It takes a lot of money and a maze of arrogant professors to tolerate. Then, there is no guarantee of a career.
I don't know for sure but I really doubt a Harvard/Yale education is far superior to Snow College. However, XelaDave is correct. It is about the networking. Most people don't go to Harvard because they believe it is a better education necessarily. It is because it will say "Harvard" on the diploma.
MIT is a different story. Students go there because they want to be mentored by some of the smartest people in the world. I believe students actually go there to learn.
So, after my rambling, I guess what I am trying to say is I think this is a good deal. I wish them luck. The have hundreds of years of tradition to battle. It sounds like the kind of environment I would thrive in.

HardRains
Draper, UT

I hate to be cynical but this sounds like another for-profit college marketed differently to avoid the stigma of current for-profit colleges. If it were as affordable as SLCC/Weber State then maybe they'd have something.

junkgeek
Agua Dulce, TX

The best thing that Harvard researchers ever did was get other universities to stop competing with them.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments