Comments about ‘Dick Harmon: JD Falslev's broken hand a sports tragedy for BYU star senior’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, Nov. 4 2013 6:15 p.m. MST

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Salt Lake City, UT

First time I saw J.D. I knew he was going to be a great one. I appreciate his heart and his spirit. Get Well soon J.D. Want to see you in San Fransico!!
All of Cougar Nation

Salt Lake City, Utah

Water Park? It's freezing outside. Whose hair-brained idea was that? Geez Louise.

Idaho Falls, ID

Indoor water park, surfing on the artificial wave. I'm sure the coaches are regretting that decision.

From Ted's Head
Orem, UT

While it is a tough break, Falslev has proven that he has what it takes to excel despite the odds and I expect that he has many successes ahead of him in life once his football career is over. I imagine most schools have their stories of walk-ons who with superior effort and tenacity rose to outdo their more highly recruited teammates. Ansah, Van Noy, Falslev, and there are likely many others who have outperformed their expectations and can hold their heads high having done their very best. It's been a pleasure to watch these fine young student-athletes.

Springville, UT

I hate accidents, especially of the kind that are preventable, freakish or not. I kind of agree with the previous comment... a water park?

Let's keep things to a nice calm level during football season like Chucky Cheese, Trafalga, Ping Pong, Monopoly...

Good luck JD on your recovery, hope to see you in December!

Tom in CA
Vallejo, CA

A major bummer for JD. His absence could be a negative factor on Saturday - hopefully not. Hope he recovers fast enough to suit up again this year.

Washington, UT

It's amazing how these kids do really dumb things. It's the football season, they should not be doing anything but playing football, going to class and dating girls. A water park in late October...in Provo?

Salt Lake City, UT

I don't want to harp but young people think they are invulnerable and immortal which leads to accidents that can be prevented. One role of a team member is to consider the good of the team when you act on and off the field. It is hard to rein in the impulse to "dare and do" but the loss of playing the rest of the season for this young man and the loss of a team mate could have been prevented.

This may be why professional athletes have very specific contracts with lots of things permitted and prohibited. Hope this is a learning event for the coaching staff, and players as well.

It's also a great lesson in life, it happens.

Glad it wasn't more serious and it sounds like he'll be fine with some time to heal.

Ernest T. Bass
Bountiful, UT

This is horrible news. Hope he can play in the bowl game.

Salem, UT

Water Park- yes bad idea- but given the events of the last bye-week- partying in Vegas with pictures I suppose a water park and an injury are an easier sell to upper admin at BYU

Whoa Nellie
American Fork, UT

Unfortunate for BYU as Wisconsin will be punting a lot on Saturday.

So. Cal Reader
San Diego, CA

"'He’s a kid you’d want your daughter to marry,' said David Strunk, who worked in the offseason with Falslev at Sleepy Ridge Golf Course in Vineyard." Stop already. I stopped reading the article after this statement. Just write the article about Falslev's injury and impact on the team. I don't care about this "personal" aspect that has zero to do with the injury. I hope David Strunk enjoys his "15 minutes of fame."


I don't want to see him in San Fransisco. I want to see him in Arizona! Can I get an Amen?!

Sandy, Utah

@So. Cal Reader

Harmon was trying to show his character... Take a chill pill and go read some military battle field reports if you want all details and no story.

Henry Drummond
San Jose, CA

You really hate to see season ending injuries. I wish JD well in the future - he sure was fun to watch.

The Middle Of, UT

Who reads Harmon? I am only here for the comments.

Mesa, AZ

I think Mendenhall needs to man up and admit this was a bonehead thing to do. Any serious athlete is paranoid during the season not to do anything out of the ordinary. Surfing? Surprised he didn't have them breaking in some of his horses on the ranch. I say BM sits out a game and thinks this one over.

St George, Utah

I have heard that Falslev is a great kid and a good leader but.... Every time he fields a punt I cringe.

He is clearly a very emotional player that has a lot of heart, but is far from an impact player. I am sure the team will miss his presence in the huddle though.... oh wait we don't huddle anymore.

Lindon, UT


. . .as in the BCS bowl game? AMEN!

East Salt Lake City, Utah


Let's keep things to a nice calm level during football season like Chucky Cheese, Trafalga, Ping Pong, Monopoly...


Rancherito's ... well before midnight, nothing good happens after midnight.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments