Comments about ‘10 moments that made BYU and NFL quarterback Jim McMahon famous — and infamous’

Return to article »

Published: Tuesday, Oct. 15 2013 5:25 p.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Orem, UT

The first bowl game I ever attended was the Miracle Bowl, so naturally, Jim McMahon became one of my all-time favorite BYU players.

I sincerely hope Jim finishes his degree so he that can be inducted into the BYU Hall of Fame.

Scott Farcus
Beaver, UT

I think Jim McMahon was byU all time best!

I admired his defiance against Coach Edwards in the Miracle Bowl when Edwards was ready to quit sending the punt team out on the field, McMahon refused to get off the field, McMahon created the Miracle.

As he said in a local TV interview "I did it my way"

Granstville, UT

The hypocrisy displayed at BYU surrounding the McMahon hall of fame never ceased to amaze me. As Jimmy Mac says in the article, he was followed around for 5 years, so everyone knew what he was doing. But, strangely enough, after the Miracle Bowl, when his eligibility was used up, he was "asked to leave." He was enrolled and intended to graduate, but his expulsion eliminated that possibility.

But, every time the Cougar Club wants to raise money, they ask Jim to come back so they can parade him around as a BYU legend. To his credit, he obliges, but no one will make mention of the fact they kicked him out of school, and he still is not inducted into their hall of fame.

By the way, the rules for membership into the HOF were changed AFTER McMahon was expelled. Prior to that incident, graduation from BYU was not a requirement. They made it so, when it became clear McMahon was on to bigger and better things, namely winning a super bowl, and not likely to return.

Utes home for the holidays
Sandy, UT

The hypocrisy is that ute "fans" love McMahon for his atypical BYU behavior, and yet would be secretly taking pictures of him engaging in anti-honor code behavior if he were a player today. At the very least, they'd be calling for his suspension from the team, even though honor code rules don't impact them at all. Holier than thou attitude on the hill has never been more rampant.

Fairview, UT

It would appear Jimmy Mac has as much a "case" against Budweiser as against the NFL for any damage sustained to his brain. Still, he was a pretty darn good quarterback.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments