Comments about ‘High school football: Bingham bowls over Bonneville (Idaho) in season opener’

Return to article »

Published: Sunday, Aug. 25 2013 12:54 a.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
KamUte
South Jordan, UT

Most teams can compete with Bingham for a quarter due to adrenaline. Bingham simply wears teams down as nobody plays both sides. Bonneville was a decent team that will do very well back in Idaho. A thousand fans were obviously disappointed with the outcome. Most teams simply don't realize the feeder system that Bingham has in South Jordan. The kids are taught Bingham pride from 2nd grade up to high school. Kids want to play at Bingham.

UtahBruin
Saratoga Springs, UT

Not to disrespect Bonneville, but I would have rather seen Bingham play the Idaho state champ from last year, Madison HS from Rexburg. I just think Utah football is better and very underrated across the country. Year in and year out we are beating teams from Texas, Colorado, California, Hawaii, Florida, etc. I know we have taken are lumps as well by some of these same states. But I would love to see Utah on some of these ESPN HS football games pitting states against states. Last years games at Rio Tinto was a match up of some of Utah best against some of the other nations best. Why not work on some of that. Does Comcast have another classic this year with two great games?

ribel
Layton, Ut

It was a win that took awhile to get going but not a lot to brag about. They were playing a team that enrollment wise is a 3A team in Utah that had its first winning season in some years last year.

markymark
HERRIMAN, UT

I think that team would beat a lot of teams in utah and will do well in Idaho. That being said I don't think anyone is bragging about the win. There 1st string was good but after that it went down hill fast. Bingham needs to clean up the penalties which a lot of comes with a first game. Congrats to the Bees for coming down and playing well. I went to the Fremont Jordan game Friday too and Bonneville was a way better team than Fremont. Bingham's real test will be against Valor Christian, they will be the best team that they play all year. The McCaffery kid is the best player I've ever seen play in high school.

IndeMak
South Jordan, UT

It didn't matter who was out there, they were still going to lose with the horses on Bingham's side. Two best teams this yer are East and Bingham. Both are too big and too fast and too deep again.

Cougars1
Bluffdale, UT

UtahBruin,

Riverton is playing Madison in Pocatello this Friday at the Rocky Mountain Revue. When they got invited Coach Miller said the only way he would go was if they could play the best team in Idaho. Looking forward to it.

adwight
AMERICAN FORK, UT

UtahBruin you'll get your fill these next few weeks. Jordan is playing a team from California. Lone Peak and Bingham are travelling together to Colorado to take on two of the best teams from Colorado (I think Mullen has dropped off a bit, but they're still a quality program). Alta gets another big team from back east. East is playing Kahuku. Should be fun to see how Utah stacks up. Per capita I would say Utah has the best football in the country.

J Ram
Chubbuck, ID

Cougars1, I hate to tell you this , but the Madison team Riverton will be facing will not be close talent wise to the team that won the 5A state championship last year. They graduated around 20 senior starters from that team. All of their recievers, and the QB last year were over six feet tall and fast. That was a special team and you won't see that from Madison again for awhile. I hope Madison can play with Riverton. They have visited Holt Arena in the past and have done very well in the dome. I don't think they have ever lost there and I don't expect them to on Friday. I want you guys from Utah to understand that every game this weekend in Holt arena pits a smaller Idaho team against a larger team from Utah & Nevada. I would like to see our schools play against teams closer to their same size and I know you would see better matchups. Just so you know Idaho enrollment numbers include freshman and Utah's numbers don't.

Braxton
ogden, ut

I watched Valor Christian on ESPN, they are legit. #5 is shifty and one of the best running backs I have seen. Bingham better bring more than I saw Saturday or they will get run over. Good luck. #fingerscrossed.

J Ram
Chubbuck, ID

Cougars1, I just want you to know that the Madison team that Riverton will be facing does not have near the talent that last year's state championship team had. They are losing around 20 senior starters. All of their receivers and their QB were over 6 feet tall and very fast. They run a spread offense that just created match up nightmares for the defenses they played. I bet they scored over 35 points a game. Madison is also a much smaller school than Riverton. Madison's enrollment is around 1350 students and that includes Freshman. If I am not mistaken Utah only counts grades 10 - 12. That being said I hope Madison gives them a good game, but Riverton has done very well in the dome in the past and I expect them to continue to do so on Friday night. I believe Riverton has never lost in the dome. I wish Idaho schools would play schools closer to their same size, every game in the dome next weekend in the dome pits a smaller Idaho school against a larger out of state school.

J Ram
Chubbuck, ID

Sorry, for the double post I didn't realize they had to be approved.

Gunner
South Jordan, UT

J Ram, actually the schools in Utah from the Canyon school district does include enrollment from 9th grade. They changed this year to 4 year high schools including 9th graders.

Parry is a Farce
Layton, UT

For classification purposes, I believe UHSAA uses only the grades 10-12 numbers.

BigBenzo88
Herriman, UT

adwight - Having played high school football in Ohio and then having followed high school football in Ohio, New Jersey, California, Illnois, Missouri and Utah...I don't believe Utah has the best football in the country...per capita or not.

I think that due to open enrollment...Utah has created a few super-schools that have very good football teams...Bingham, Jordan, Cottonwood, East and Timpview. As a whole...Utah football has a long way to go. The day that Utah ends open-enrollment...you will see a sharp rise in the level of Utah football, a rise in the competition and a rise in the number of good teams.

Consistently, the Top 5 states for high school football are Florida, Texas, California, Ohio and Pennsylvania. Utah typically comes in somewhere between 20 during good years and 35 during bad years. The things the top states do that Utah needs to do: No open-enrollment, using power rankings for playoffs instead of region wins, reclassification less often (Utah does every 2 years), keeping open-enrollment/private/parochial schools in the same region/division/conference.

In the end...Bingham is a good school and the 5A champ will go through them.

FatMan86
West Jordan, UT

I've lived on both sides of the border and am very familiar with the Idaho schools. I do believe the talent level in Utah is superior. That's not always a guarantee of an automatic win though. That said, I'm certain that the very best 4A or 5A in Idaho, be it Madison, Highland (Poc), Couer D'Alene or Blackfoot to name a few, would get throttled by Bingham on a neutral field. If you ever look at the Boise State roster (Boise being the most successful college team in the Mtn West region), there aren't many Idaho kids on it. It is however loaded with California based talent. In Utah however there is a higher proportion of Utah kids mixed in with the imported talent.

Scots
Ogden, UT

Who watched Bingham vs Valor Christian last year? Christian McCaffery scored 3 TD's in that game and Nonflammable still won 21-20 in OT. But Valor Christian looks better this year.

J Ram
Chubbuck, ID

FatMan86, I disagree with the statement you made about the talent level being higher in Utah. I believe the overall talent is similar in both states. It is hard to compare because Idaho schools rarely play Utah schools that are similar in size. Case in point this weekend at the Rocky Mountain Rumble in Pocatello Madison with a 4 year enrollment of 1373 plays Riverton with a 3 year enrollment of 1998. Take away Madisons freshman and they would be around 1030. They will be playing a school almost twice their size. Minico with a 4 year enrollment of 995 will play Park City with a 3 year enrollment of 998. Take away Minico's freshman and they are around 750. That is not a huge difference I like that matchup. Finally, Shelley with a 4 year enrollment of 613 will play West Jordan with a 3 year enrollment of 1821. Take away Shelley's freshman and they a have around 460 students. Look at the size difference that is close to 4 times smaller than W. Jordan. Look at Bonneville with their 4 year enrollment of 1302 playing Bingham with a 3 year enrollment of 2495. How can you compare states?

Gunner
South Jordan, UT

If we're talking strictly talent, enrollment really doesn't matter. We're not talking enrollment per capita. Just total talent. And Utah has the edge on total talent.

papi_chulo
Ogden, UT

I think Bingham should just start scheduling the University of Utah and play them every year. They are obviously way too good for any other high school team in the nation and they need to just make it a college program over there in South Jordan to start competing with the big boys.

razorback
South Jordan, UT

he's baa-ack! Fromont's looking impressive.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments