Comments about ‘Sober man gets arrested for DUI in Arizona’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, June 10 2013 11:45 a.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
American Fork, UT

I think there are a lot of people driving today who would fail a field sobriety test for one reason or another. This is because, essentially, they are impaired. Be it physically, mentally or emotionally, there are a lot of people out there who would never think of drinking and driving but are not capable of operating a motor vehicle as if they're sober. I'm not saying that was the case here, but it is a double standard.

Bountiful, UT

Serve and Protect? I don't think so. Not serving neither protecting.

This is happening too often. I was pulled over once because my friends were doing the YMCA with her hands with the radio playing that song. The officer asked me if I was drinking. None of us were drinking. In fact, we don't drink. The only thing that officer could smell was chanel #5, lancome, tommy girl and bath & body fragances. `He didn't ask me to take any test or walk the line but I did wonder if it was inappropiate to have fun when driving.

I am going to make sure to put some visine in my eyes next time I leave the pool and go driving!

Provo, UT

Happens all the times in small towns. Impossibile to prove racism with these facts.

Chris B
Salt Lake City, UT

If he was driving erratically(which at least from the article is not entirely being disputed) then he deserves a ticket and should be pulled over.

I don't care what the cause of his driving erratically was, if he wasn't safe, he deserves what he got.

Alamosa, CO

I don't know if this was a racially motivated situation as I cannot speak for the officers involved. I can say that they clearly screwed up and they clearly need to pay for their mistakes. They seemingly, purposely told the guy he was DUI even after he explained his red eyes and bad hip. Then the test was negative and a drug expert says he never would have arrested him. Make them pay but if it was not a racial issue please don't make it one now.
There is just too much hate in the world as it is.

Uncle Rico
Sandy, UT

Unless your a minority somewhere, you have zero clue of how this feels, only maybe what it looks like. Although I detest lawsuits, he should sue.

@Chris B

Sir, after seeing your ridiculous ongoing sports post, I wonder if anyone takes you seriously.... seriously.


He said he has been pulled over 10 times in Sunrise, it would be nice to know if that is within 2 years or 20 years or? If it is 10 times in only a few years then it seems like he MIGHT have a good case of DWB (still need to know all the circumstances).

I'm white and at most I've been pulled over once every five years driving about 20,000 miles a year.

Stink Bug
Billingsley, AL

The problem is not the man's race or DUI. The problem is that the police departments around the country are being run as para-military operations, not local law enforcement. Don't know who they are bulking up for, didn't know we had a pending invasion but seeing it in every state. DOJ is passing out armored vehicles and tanks to the local police and I guess they are getting a big thrill being bullies these days. Look up the woman who was beaten at the police booking counter (while in cuffs), the woman that was shot to death at a Cosco (sample lady, had a knife and scissors) in Washington state last week in a fully crowded store, it goes on and on. They keep the 'Cops' show on to desensitize everyone to their new role. We, the public, have eaten it up for years. Getting pretty scary.

county mom
Monroe, UT

I understand the officers concern, when he crossed the white line.
Drinking and driving is one of the biggest killers on our roadways.
However once he passed the test and explained himself, I don't understand why he was not allowed to go on his way?

John C. C.
Payson, UT

Driving after midnight back to Fort Leonard Wood I felt a bit drowsy. I exited the freeway and pulled into an empty lot for a nap. Waking up to a bright light and a torrent of accusatory questions from a police officer, I did my best to explain. He said my slurred speech was of evidence of intoxication. For just a moment I felt what it was like to be an innocent suspect--powerless and afraid. Then the moment passed. You see, I was white and had the I.D. of an Army officer. A different color and a different occupation and I might have learned how hard life really is in this prejudiced society for the rest of us.


DWB is well known here in the south. I does not surprise me one bit that a small AZ town might have the same sorts of cops.

I hope he gets his settlement, and then some. Sometimes the only way to make bigots change is to force them to change.

And Chris -- even if he *did* cross the white line, that should only have earned him a simple ticket. Not $5,000 worth of trouble, getting his car impounded, being handcuffed and taken to the police station, and so on. That is waaaay beyond acceptable.

I've been stopped for suspicion of DUI twice. I wasn't, either time -- both times I was just tired, driving very late at night on nearly empty roads. (Once was in SLC, incidentally.) If I had been black, I can easily envision that my treatment would have been much worse than it was.

I know it. I Live it. I Love it.
Salt Lake City, UT

Uncle Rico,

I actually agree with Chris B to a point...

As we age our mental and physical motor functions decay, for many it is severe and with growing health problems due to the growing trend of certain lifestyles, this decay will only be likely to increase.

I have had loved ones who I love dearly. I didn't want them driving at all. As selfish as it is, it had nothing to do with protecting everyone else (that was just a plus that made sense), but protecting my loved ones. I didn't want them hurt.

I don't think we should throw the book at people for mistakes that are much more ignorant or naive than a petty crime. I simply think we should be alert and pro-active about who drives and under what conditions/influences, etc. I'm sure Chris B's main point had more to do with that principle. I would hope we all agree on that part. How swift and severe punishments are I understand disagreement, but solving problems ought to be everyone's priority.

Provo, UT


Actually, it is kind of inappropriate to have fun while driving. If you're friend is waving her hands all over and everyone's singing a loud song, you're certainly not paying as much attention to the road as you would be if all of that weren't happening.

There's way too much distracted driving, talking, texting, singing, eating...it's dangerous. It puts everyone on the road at risk.

Riverton Cougar
Riverton, UT

It is ridiculous to give someone a DUI when tests show that he is obviously sober. That is blatantly wrong. If he was doing something wrong, then punish him accord to his deeds.

That being said, other comments on this article have it right; there is not enough detail to come to any conclusions about him being targeted by police. My cousin gets pulled over a lot, but I don't think the police are after him necessarily (although some corrupt police departments might see that a driver has traffic school or a ticket previously and nail that driver so the city gets more revenue).

Taylorsville, UT

The problem with drunk driving is that it causes ERRATIC driving. The drunkenness alone is not the problem. People posting on this board seem to be implying that it's okay to drive erratically as long as you're not drunk. Before we just "send him on his way" there should be some investigation as to why he couldn't stay in his lane. That's a serious problem, whether he was DUI or not.

Silver City, NM

Police are generally getting out of control. Even here, in Podunk, NM, the police have an armored car. It is time they remembered that they are merely overpaid public servants, and not hired to bully the public at their leisure.

As for the FSI? Lots of people would fail it. This is why most civilized nations do not use it. I would almost certainly fail because of a hearing problem in my right ear that interferes with the sort of equilibrium required to pass these idiot tests. And race? Don't know... He may well be right about that... After all, look at the nut running Arizona these days.

county mom
Monroe, UT

THE MTN MAN, I sure hope you never ever wander out of your lane of traffic, if you believe crossing the white line is always ticket worthy.
It was said he crossed over out of his lane so the officer pulled him over.
They did not say he was swerving all over the road. Erratic driving is an other can of worms and we see it all the time from those on the phone and texting.
I happen to have raised a houseful of children and am truly grateful for carseats.
I can not imagine the kind of erratic driving I would have done with my children crawling around the car and fighting. I don't know how my mother did it.
It was bad enough having them throw things at each other across the car. I don't think there would be any mothers driving at all if crossing the white line occasionally was a federal offense.

West Valley City, UT

Last week there was a similar story about a black truck driver with a bad leg that had the same .000 BAC that was arrested and jailed for 17 days in Box Elder County even though he passed the sobriety tests He was never charged. He was stopped by UHP.

Maybe these guys should have been charged with DWB-driving while black.

Park City, Ut

Surprise indeed! Uhh why did they have to take this poor man to the police station to give him a breathalyzer test, don't police officers usually have those on hand? I guess they thought it would save them some money just to have one in the back of officer Rubble's office. Bad.

Sacramento, CA

I thought of all the things that happened that shouldn't have, what added insult to injury--and was totally disgraceful--was that in spite of passing the sobriety test, he was handcuffed and made to sit on the curb, at age 64 with a hip replacement due in two days. I'm 66, no replacements, but the aches and pains of age and some seizures make themselves known, and can just imagine how uncomfortable this man must have felt, and how much that night cost him in discomfort. Docs don't replace joints unless there is a clear need. I hope this gentleman wins his lawsuit, at least to pay for what this needless charge has cost him, and that Surprise has learned not to charge innocent people any more.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments