Quantcast

Comments about ‘Ten Commandments come down in Oklahoma school district’

Return to article »

Published: Tuesday, May 14 2013 11:40 a.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Blue
Salt Lake City, UT

Wallpaper you home with the Ten Commandments if you like. Plaster them all over your car. Decorate your front lawn with them. Paint them on your roof so you can seen them from the air. Recite them with your family every morning around the breakfast table and again each night as you go to bed.

Just don't expect public institutions to be used to express your private religious beliefs - even if your beliefs are popular. That's now how our government works.

LValfre
CHICAGO, IL

Well said Blue. Display them all you want but until you're willing to let Islam, Buddhist, Atheist, and any other teachings publicly displayed you can't hang on to only Christian ones.

A Scientist
Provo, UT

Another victory for the US Constitution and the First Amendment!

zoar63
Mesa, AZ

The U.S. Supreme Court has its own display of the ten commandments. Nobody seems to have a problem with that. Who are they going to sue, the Chief justices.

FT1/SS
Virginia Beach, VA

And the morality of our society continues to decay. The founders, and their intent of the constitution was in the seperation of church and state to keep religion from ruling the people. As was the case in Europe during there era. However, there intent was also to have a christian influence among the people to keep good moral values. They spoke of God at all of there civic events of the day. That's how Republic's survive, and they understood it! Empires rise on good morals, and come crashing down on immorality. The American Empire will come crashing down, try reading a World History book on empires. Better yet, read the writings of the Founding Fathers.

Tyler D
Meridian, ID

Yes, because without these anachronistic commands to not worship graven images or covet manservants, the children of OK will slide head long into moral decadence… please.

LValfre
CHICAGO, IL

@FT1/SS

"And the morality of our society continues to decay."

Morality is subjective. What you're saying is YOUR morals or decaying in society. This isn't YOUR country though. Would you be opposed to Sharia law being posted in some public buildings? You shouldn't be. If Christian teachings are public .... any teachings should be public.

"They spoke of God at all of there civic events of the day. That's how Republic's survive, and they understood it! Empires rise on good morals, and come crashing down on immorality. The American Empire will come crashing down, try reading a World History book on empires. Better yet, read the writings of the Founding Fathers."

All great empires fell for economic reasons. Had nothing to do with morals. Once could say at Rome's height they lacked 'Christian' morals the most when you consider the slavery, forced battles, sex lifestyle, etc. In fact they fell AFTER becoming a Christian nation.

sharrona
layton, UT

RE:Tyler D, The second table of the law(Ten Commandments): Commands 5-10: teach reverence for others, are horizontal and are ethics. Our Relationship with Others 5.Honor our father and mother. 6. Do not kill 7.Do not commit adultery 8.Do not steal 9.Do not bear false witness 10.Do not covet.

Today, society has reversed Jesus' summation of the Law: "You shall love your neighbor with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength... and you shall love God as you love yourself. By making man the center and measure of everything, the ethical center is always changing. Truth, goodness, right and wrong are no more than what human opinion currently holds them to be—modern floating ethics.
The impotence of this system is further sealed by demoting one's love for God to second place, which is really to give no place at all. This effectively removes the power to love others, because God's Word tells us, 'We love because he first loved us'. 1 Jn. 4:19.

LValfre
CHICAGO, IL

@sharrona

"This effectively removes the power to love others, because God's Word tells us, 'We love because he first loved us'. 1 Jn. 4:19."

The fact that you believe one who doesn't believe in God effectively doesn't have the power to love others is the reason your faith scares me so much. Absolutely stunning.

Thankfully things are changing with the new generation of church goers.

Tyler D
Meridian, ID

@sharrona – “The second table of the law(Ten Commandments): Commands 5-10: teach reverence for others, are horizontal and are ethics.”

I have no problem with 5-10 (although when you read #10 it does sound a bit silly… did God really need to provide a laundry of items, especially given the limited space on stone tablets, to make the point that coveting is bad?), but these ethical precepts are not original to Judaism.

But to go on and assert that a lack of belief in the God of Abraham necessarily implies moral relativism and decay is a gross fallacy. This is easily demonstrated by an unbiased examination of other cultures, beliefs, and ethical systems.

Take Jainism – a religion of India that influenced Gandhi. The main precept of Jainism is as follows:

"Do not injure, abuse, oppress, enslave, insult, torment, torture, or kill any creature or living being."

Captures in one sentence a sound ethical foundation without the metaphysical silliness of jealous Gods and graven images… not bad for a religion that does not believe in a creator God, yes?

sharrona
layton, UT

To: Tyler D, The 10th commandment sounds a bit silly… did God really need to provide a laundry of items?
“you shall not covet your neighbor's wife”. VS The 4th vow of Jainism, denounced any contact, mental or physical, with women or eating or drinking anything Mahavira did not only renounce women for good. The renunciation of all external pleasures and things owed to the fact that “Women are the greatest temptation in the world.” You agree?

The Concept of Truth In the east, truth comes through intuition. It’s apprehended apart from the cognitive thinking process. In contrast, Christianity teaches that truth comes through revelation. God’s most complete revelation is found in the person and through the work of Jesus Christ who was none other than God Himself in human flesh. The truth, according to Christianity, is understood with the mind and is then embraced with the heart

george of the jungle
goshen, UT

If you never know what is expected you can be as blameless. Ignorance is no excuse to the law.

Tyler D
Meridian, ID

@sharrona – “…Women are the greatest temptation in the world.” You agree?”

Interesting question – well it’s certainly a fact that sex has been the downfall of many religious person. With the exceptions of the need to eat and breath, the need for sex is probably our most powerful urge. The Buddha was known to have said (paraphrase) – “if we were subject to another temptation as strong as sex, becoming enlightened would be all but impossible.”

Despite the doctrines of bookish theologians, it strikes me as highly plausible that the phenomenon of what the East calls intuition (or insight) and the phenomenon of what the West refers to as revelation, are referring the exact same thing. That they are labeled and understood differently I think has everything to do with culture and nothing to do with the underlying reality of the experience… my 2 cents.

G L W8
SPRINGVILLE, UT

In all these discussions, what's going to hold sway: God's word, or man's philosophies? Seems to me we ought to give God the chance to speak for himself, which he does through the Holy Spirit--for those wise enough to seek it.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments