Comments about ‘High school baseball: 5A tournament looks as competitive as ever’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, May 13 2013 9:05 p.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Parry is a Farce
Layton, UT

"Syracuse (9-8, 8-2) edged out Layton to secure the Region 1 championship"

No Layton and Syracuse are Region 1 co-Champions. Syracuse just won a tie-breaker to get the #1 seed from Region 1. And IMO, the tie breaker they used is pretty unfair. The tie-breaker is "head-to-head record" which they split their 2 games so that does not break the tie (I think this part is fair). Then they go to "record against highest placing common opponent", which is Davis who finished 3rd Layton was 1-1 against Davis while Syracuse was 2-0. While that seems OK on the surface, why not use "record against lowest placing common opponent"? Layton wins this by going 2-0 against Fremont while Syracuse went 1-1.

It is all spelled out before hand, so everyone knew what was involved. But why does Syracuse get rewarded for beating the 3rd place team when they lost to the 4th place team and Layton gets punished by losing to the 3rd placed team but they beat the 4th place team? Seems to me a coin flip is a more equitable approach.

Raymond, 00


Of course you think it's unfair, you are from Layton. Just be happy you made it to state for once.

Parry is a Farce
Layton, UT

Has nothing to do with me being from Layton. I think it is an unfair system for deciding a tiebreaker.

salt lake city, UT

Just wondering, what would you suggest to make it fair? How would you decide a tiebreaker?

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments