Comments about ‘#BrightonStall: Twitter reacts to strange tactics during 5A semifinal’

Return to article »

Published: Saturday, March 2 2013 9:26 a.m. MST

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
carman
Wasatch Front, UT

There is no excuse for the poor sportsmanship required to hold the ball for over a quarter. It was a disservice to the players and fans. Lewis made the right call by letting the Bengals embarrass themselves and not react.

3for5spotshooter
Sun Valley, Idaho

Perhaps no one is old enough to remember...

Ron Abagelen coaching an undersized team against a power team in the state in 1972...

the score was 5-2 at the half and Abagelen's team went on to win...

And Abagelen went to Weber State as a head coach...

The Brighton coach had the right idea....

I would have used the old Missouri W offense of Norm Stewart...

With no clock this is the only way to beat a power team...

Great coaching...

0-0 for a quarter was very cool...

the game is about the players - NOT the fans...

It is a sport...

It is not about entertainment...

I appreciated the nature of the strategy...

Braxton
ogden, ut

Wonder what the message was during the coaches pre-game locker room talk was like..... You guys can not beat this team so lets not try. Lets just hold the ball. I want my 8 dollars back.

Ville
Salt Lake City, UT

It was lame. Earlier in the year LP beat Brighton by 20 at the Knights court. Looks like this strategy or lack of it got the Bengals beat worse by 26. Guess it didn't work. Hope the UHSAA can get some fortitude and put in a shot clock like college has and most other states do for HS.

eagle
Provo, UT

It is simply strategy and ultimately it didn't work. LP advances.

I remember the days of Loyola Maramount and how they would score 150 points. They played Alabama in the NCAA tournament and Wimp Sanderson tried to slow down the game and hold the ball. And it nearly worked. But it was the strategy that gave his team the best chance to win. The Brighton kids aren't egotist dummies, they know they had no chance playing straight up and their coach gave them the best chance to win.

Again, like said above. Ron Abbeglen did the same thing in the early 1970's. Heck he slowed down the game against NC at Weber to stun them in the tourney. And heck Dean Smith invented the four corners to try to beat John Wooden and UCLA...

cedarpost
Washington, Utah

You play to win the game. Bightons best chance to win was to slow it down. I would have held the ball when they were up at the very beginning tho.That would have put the pressure on lp.

caleb in new york
Glen Cove, NY

but one of the important purposes of sports is to help people get exercise and they didn't get very much exercise in the second quarter.

BamaFan
Spanish Fork, UT

I went to several HS Basketball games this year and although I didn't witness a team hold the ball and stall for 11 minutes, I did see multiple games where posessions went over the 4 minute mark. This isn't a "strategy" it is an admission that our athletes can't compete with yours and therefor we have zero chance of beating you without sticking it to the student athletes, student sections, parents, etc. What this adds up to is the UHSAA has to put in a shot clock for next season. It simply is time and overdue. Fans do not want to come to the games and watch great student athletes hold the ball at the top of the key. They want to see these athletes get up and down the court and compete every posession. Not too mention, those who are lucky enough to continue their education through athletics in college will be better prepared.

mattmo
Gallatin, MO

Basketball is entertainment not holding a ball for 11 minutes. Boring, Boring, BORING. You see if you don't entertain people will stop coming to the games. No people no sport. If your going to lose might as well sweat a little bit get some exercise and have fun doing it. It's not always about winning it's about getting better and entertaining the crowd.

benjoginko
Cottonwood Heights, UT

I don't get why people think it's bad sportsman ship to play the old 4 corners hold the ball game. No one called Dean Smith a poor sportsman when he did this regularly back in the 70's. he won a lot of games.

H-TownTiger
Hurricane, 00

just because it's been done a lot in the past doesn't deem it as sportsmanlike... it's one thing to keep passing the ball around running the clock, but when you deliberatly(spelling?) stop play and hold the ball and do NOTHING is completely unsportsmanlike...it shows an attitude of quitting, which can be classified as unsportsmanlike as cheating in some situations.

Uncle Sam
West Jordan, UT

People, this is not a case of a strategic "four corner stall" here. Brighton literally stood at mid-court and held the ball for 12 minutes. They did not dribble, pass, or do anything other than just stand there.

Some of you old timers are envisioning this amazing strategic plan that may have worked back in 1965. Throw it all out the window people, Brighton STOOD STILL and held the ball. That is it. They did NOTHING strategic.

It was unsportsmanlike and a complete mockery of the game of basketball.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments