Comments about ‘BYU football instant analysis: Cougars lay an egg against San Jose State’

Return to article »

Published: Sunday, Nov. 18 2012 12:10 a.m. MST

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
I Bleed Blue
Las Vegas, NV

Well, at least we have women's soccer to cheer for.

Sandy, UT

Lark Carma

Everett, WA

When BYU has to depend on an on-side kick against a lowly WAC school, in order to have a chance to win the game, something is very wrong indeed.

Provo, UT

San Jose State isn't that lowly. They actually lost to Stanford by the same margin as did Oregon. They have won 10 games this season.

Mission Viejo, CA

Worst offense I've seen at BYU since the Crowton debacles. Another three turnovers by Nelson. O-line couldn't block a high school defense. Defense flat and unprepared the entire first half. No pass rush, no pressure until 2nd half.

It is hard to blame Doman for the play calling. There were dozens of open receivers. But Nelson couldn't hit them. The sad thing is, playing an injured Nelson will have caused him to be classified as the worst BYU QB in the last 30 years. He simply can't make the passes. Is Lark that bad that they didn't put him in when Nelson was stinking up the joint?

So who gets the blame for keeping Nelson in the game? Doman or Mendenhall? And blame it is.



Though I'm not a BYU fan, it's glaringly obvious that Mendenhall should get the blame here. He continues to play an injured QB just because he admires Nelson's grit and determination.

Those "Rudy" kinds of QBs are only effective when they give 100% effort 100% of the time. But they must be healthy.

South Jordan, UT

While I appreciate the QB's grit and determination, it's past time for coaches to play someone who is healthy. The list of turnovers due to injuries to the QB is far too long.

Henderson, NV

With this loss, for me it is now official: This season is a failure. To not win one 'close game' against respectable competition is pathetic.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments