Quantcast

Comments about ‘BYU football: Bronco Mendenhall closing in on 100th game’

Return to article »

Published: Thursday, Nov. 1 2012 8:10 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
chubbuckidahocougfan
Chubbuck, Idaho

Here's to hoping Bronco doesn't get to coach a hundred more games. Hoping for a change in 2013.

wer
South Jordan, UT

Bronco is our man!!

rafinsure
Elk Grove/U.S.A., 00

The reality is that both teams are where they're supposed to be at this time due to their increase in level of competition and their recruiting limitations, and Coach Mendenhall is doing the best he can with what he can get. BYU will always be a mid-major because its recruiting base is very narrow due to the university's honor code. It will get a blue chip player on occasion and perhaps have a break out season once every decade, but this is how it's going to be. Coach Mendenhall does need to make improvements to the team's offensive coaching staff, but this will prove difficult because good and experienced offensive coordinators who are willing to live according to BYU's honor code are hard to come by. Also, BYU needs to join the Big East to make scheduling easier. If Notre Dame had to make an arrangement with the ACC for five games, BYU needs to do something similar.

Mountanman
Hayden, ID

Balancing the need to win with the school's honor code and the missionaries coming and going in and out of the program makes Bronco's job perhaps the most difficult job in all of college football. He has many admirers and only a few detractors. He has done a magnificent job!

SoonerUte
Salt Lake City, UT

I don't understand Cougar fans wanting to get rid of Bronco Mendenhall. He's brought you a wicked tough defense. Worst case, you "demote" him from head coach to defensive coach (he'd probably prefer that). But get rid of him altogether? Why start from scratch?

Y Grad / Y Dad
Richland, WA

SoonerUte

Because some folks just can't see the bigger picture. "Just win, baby!" just doesn't work at BYU. Cling to the standards, and if you "win the WAC championship", keep trying for better competition. If the ranked teams on your schedule knock you down, get back up. But don't lose sight of the mission.

Now losing three in a row to Utah? Well, that is thin ice, I can't debate that. But otherwise, you take it all. And be grateful.

Rational
Salt Lake City, UT

rafinsure

BYU's supposed "lack of talent" played 3 nationally ranked teams tough, and were one or two plays, or one or two poor coaching decisions, away from winning 2 of the games. BYU has been a top 25 program for 40 years.

The honor code isn't a limitation, it is a preference. There isn't an inverse correlation between honor code compatibility and athletic talent, and it is silly and baseless to say there is. Many great BYU athletes have been non-Mormons. Ty Detmer, Marc Wilson, Tom Holmoe, Clay Brown just off the top of my head, and that doesn't include Jim McMahon who isn't exactly honor code compliant, but who, nevertheless, married an LDS BYU coed. In basketball, Kresmir Cosic, the greatest BYU player ever, comes to mind.

Good and/or experienced coordinators hard to come by? They ran Norm Chow and Robert Anae out of town. While I had some problems with Anae, most of his shortcomings could've been overcome by a head coach who understood and took responsibility for the over all program, not just the defense and firesides.

You are right, however, that BYU needs some kind of home.

Solomon Levi
Alpine, UT

SoonerUte

I wouldn't pay too much attention to the constant whining of BYU "fans" like chubbuckidahocougfan.

The truth is, Bronco's record at 100 games compares very favorably with LaVell's 100 game mark.

Overall Record
LaVell 69-30-1
Bronco 72-28

Bowl Wins
LaVell 0 of 4
Bronco 5 of 7

Top 25 Finishes
LaVell 2 (20/16, 13/12)
Bronco 5 (16/15, 14/15, 25/21, 12/12, ur/25)

Conference Championships
LaVell 5
Bronco 2

10-plus Win Seasons
LaVell 1
Bronco 5

Of course, midway through the 1980 season, LaVell had built the BYU program from scratch, Jim McMahon was having a record-breaking season, BYU's QB factory was in full production, and the Cougars were just getting started on the greatest period in BYU history culminating in a national championship four years later.

Cougar Claws
Lindon, UT

Listen guys, as horrible as this whole Riley Nelson debacle has been, Bronco is a great coach and he is a guy who gets the most out of what he has. Bronco Mendenhall is also a guy who holds players accountable in terms of the honor code, academics, and so on. The worst thing that could happen to BYU football is for another coach like Gary Crowton to take the reigns when Bronco is done. With all of that, BYU is STILL winning almost 10 games a season. You also have to remember guys, Like it or not guys, we will likely never have the same recruiting advantages as programs like Texas, USC, Florida, Notre Dame, Ohio State, and so on (and neither will Utah). So when you consider the talent level BYU has in comparison, Bronco Mendenhall has done some pretty amazing things. It's just a really ugly situation that we ended up with a fullback as our quarterback who's starting because he tries hard and has good character. Let's just wait until we get a decent quarterback as it has taken a while for Bronco to recruit defensive talent as well. Things will work out.

TheNun
Granstville, UT

How can rafinsure make the statement byu is "limited" in its ability to recruit. Name another school that lays claim to a built-in talent pool of over 14 million prospective recruits.

Even Notre Dame can not make that claim, as there are many, many other catholic schools in place, and the talent pool byu has has a staunchness like no other affiliated school can duplicate.

Whoa Nellie
American Fork, UT

TheNun
Where or who are those "14 million prospective recruits" for BYU? They sure ain't Mormons because most church members are female and most of the males are high priests.

dalefarr
South Jordan, Utah

Bronco improved the program tremendously from the Crowton years. Here's hoping he learns from this year's mistakes and seeks the best and the brightest for assistant coaches. LaVell did that.

So. Cal Reader
San Diego, CA

"There's no doubt that Mendenhall has BYU's program in a much better place than when he became the head coach in December 2004." I agree that Coach Bronco has greatly stabilized the program. However, I also believe that he has done as much for this program as he can. He's provided TREMENDOUS direction & leadership ... up to the last 3 years. I don't think he's the coach to get the Cougs to the next level of national respectability that Holmoe, et. al. talk about. He is a great coach in a mid-major conference like the MWC and has dominated teams from weaker conferences (thank you WAC for agreeing to play our Cougs so often!). But Holmoe has said repeatedly they want to consistently compete with the "big boys." Realistic or not, that's what he has said, not me. Mendenall is not the coach to get them there. Many Cougs fans point to how unique and special BYU is, and my children have done there so I get that. I realize "blue-chip" recruits are rare due to the honor code and other reasons, but the AD wants the program to move upward.

Who am I sir?
Cottonwood Heights, UT

LOL!

An article about Coach Whit coaching his 100th game this Saturday is understandable. So what does the Deseret News do to promote BYU relevence? Post an article the same day about Coach Bronco coaching a game "closing in" on 100. Can't wait to read of each count down game! Better yet, I can't wait to read how the Deseret News tries to make the November schedule of BYU relevant! Now there's a challenge!

Do I hear Idaho game tickets for $5? On the 40 yard line!

WisCoug
MOUNT HOREB, WI

No fan, I don't think, can honestly say this program is not in a better place now than it was when Bronco took over the program. That said, that is not enough. If this team could 1) figure out how to be productive offensively, 2) manage the game better, and 3) get up for the big games better, could be 8-1 or, possibly, undefeated. Unfortunately, those are all weaknesses of Broncos. He does not win the big ones and that is what BYU fans are crying out for.

Against BCS Opponents:
12-14

Against Ranked Opponents (ranked at kickoff):
4-13

Against Ranked Opponents (ranked at year's end):
2-12 (likely 2-15 at this year's end)

One the Road:
25-18

Just not good enough.

IJ
Hyrum, Ut

Look at where Coach KW started and where Coach BM started. The Utes were coming off of one of the best seasons they ever had. The Cougs - not so much. KW took over a championship team - BM - not so much. I believe Bronco has done a magnificent job with what he was handed. I have watched BYU football almost from the beginning of the Lavell era and there never was a defense like this one. Give him some time and the offense will catch up to speed and BYU football will be better than it has ever been. This year's version could very well be 8 - 1 right now. A little tweecking and we will be good to go. Go Cougars!

Uteanymous
Salt Lake City, Utah

Who am I sir?

Get over your small-minded jealousy!

The only reason Bronco isn't coaching his 100th game THIS WEEK, is because BYU has a bye.

Bronco will be coaching his 100th game the next time BYU plays.

I seriously doubt Jeff wrote his article in response to Dirk's article.

btw, unlike Utah fans and Kyle, at least BYU fans don't have to worry about Bronco losing to the Idaho's and Colorado's of the college football world.

Ronald Uharriet
SWun City, Ca.

" Six players from the 2004 recruiting class had become embroiled in honor code and legal issues, and BYU had suffered three consecutive losing seasons, resulting in Gary Crowton's resignation."

My, how time and people like to rewrite history.
I was at the Notre Dame game in Provo, when it was announced that Gary Crowton was fired by the same AD at BYU that was embarrassed by Crowton's win over Cal at Cal by more than 30 points while our current AD director was HC at Cal.
We won that ND game in Provo.

Gary Crowton was a great coach until the said 3 athletes, late in the night, off campus, in one of the boys own home, was involved in a bad honor code violation. After that, all of Crowton's time and energy had to shift from coaching to defending himself as though it was his fault that the violators did violate the honor code. This caused the 3 losing seasons to follow.

Ronald Uharriet
SWun City, Ca.

Rose did not go though this torture that Crowton was put into when Rose's player, Davies, violated the honor code. Neither did Bronco have to suffer through that pain when Unga violated the honor code.

I have always felt that had Crowton not won that game at Cal, he would go down as one of our greatest coaches, leaving LE still at #1.

Crowton went on to be the National #1 Asst Coach while at Oregon as the OC. He went from there to be the OC for then defending national champions, LSU. We, in my opinion, was unjust to Crowton and we are paying for it now.

Born in Provo
Logan, UT

Best D EVER! Long live Bronco!

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments