Comments about ‘Guv candidate Peter Cooke distances himself from national Dem platform’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, Aug. 13 2012 6:36 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
draperj
Draper, UT

I served under Gen. Cooke with the 96th RRC. He was a good commander and welcomed me home from Iraq. I don't understand however how he can say he doesn't support gay marriage or abortion but then says he will vote for President Obama. That, in my mind, is a contradiction of character that cannot be overlooked.

Furry1993
Clearfield, UT

This shows the very real difference between Republicans and Democrats. Republicans either walk lock-step and kowtow to the far right elements of the party. Democrats are like herding cats -- they go all ways at once, and it is very hard to keep them in line.

3grandslams
Iowa City, IA

This guy waffles too much on his positions to be taken seriously. And the worst thing he did was say, "See, I'm a Mormon." That's as bad as a car dealer who claims the same thing, then proceeds to sell you a lemon.

Conservatives are always looking for the candidate that has backbone and conviction, not one who has several definitions for one word.

JohnnyJingle
SOUTH JORDAN, UT

Utah values? I was born and raised in Utah, and support gay rights and pro-choice. Confusing.

ute alumni
Tengoku, UT

good luck with your party's left leaning platform. you haven't a prayer to win in utah. saying you will vote for obama seals the deal for me. no way cooke. four more years of obama would totally leave this country in ruins. thanks for your military service, but supporting someone that doesn't support or respect the military is mind numbing.

dustmagnet
tremonton, UT

I sure wish the newspapers would discuss the candidates' stand on all issues - where does he stand on the environment, and cleaning up Utah's air, ground and water pollution? Is he willing to tax the dirty industries for the pollution they cause and give tax breaks to "green" industry? And will he stand strong on issues?

On the other hand
Spanish Fork, UT

Gary Herbert is the waffle king. Peter Cooke has a distinguished record of rock-solid leadership both in the military and in business. Unfortunately, as evidenced by the comments above, Utahns do get hung up on wedge issues and even go so far as to ascribe to the Democratic candidate beliefs contrary to the ones he holds. Politics in Utah is such a sad state of affairs.

Rick2009
MESA, AZ

He supports O, enough said. He will say any thing to get elected. Republicans aren't much better look at Sen. Hatch, but dem's are worse. We can't survive as a nation under 4 more with O.

Esquire
Springville, UT

The typical sacrificial Utah Democrat, disowning a platform that has not been written. Sen. Machin of West Virginia does the same thing, but at least in West Virginia, a Dem can get elected. Imagine WV being more progressive than Utah. (I know, the hyper partisans will point out Matheson to disprove my assertion, but Matheson is really a Republican. Just chill out. Utah is as close to a one party state as they come. Even Putin's United Russia gets more competition).

lost in DC
West Jordan, UT

“Children are entitled…to be raised by a father and mother who honor marital vows with utmost fidelity” LDS proclamation on the family.

“(Cooke) later, through a spokeswoman, backed adoptions by gay couples.” Article

Regardless of which statement you agree with (if either), I do not see how they can be compatible. A “father and a father” is NOT a “father and a mother”, nor is a “mother and a mother”

Matheson "has spent his whole career" making his differences with the national party clear to voters.

No, Matheson has spent his career fooling folks into thinking he has differences with the national party. If they really need him, like his procedural votes leading up to the passage of Obamacare, they know they can count on him.

Furry,
Hard to keep dems in line? Is that why unwavering support for abortion on demand is a judicial litmus test as far as dems are concerned?

Esquire,
in a way, you are right. If Cooke wants to make a difference, he should switch parties. I know good conservative folk in other states who have to be dems to be heard.

Jeromeo
Salt Lake City, UT

Hmmm. Does this candidate really believe in his own position or is "in line with Utah values" merely pandering to the Utah electorate? In Politics, having a "position" is often not the same as having the courage of one's conviction. I agree that we need to dispense with the politics of ideology and focus on Education and such. But does a candidate for office in the State of Utah really need to resort to ideological subterfuge? Apparently so.

Sad.

cval
Hyde Park, UT

This is why Democrats have such a tough time in Utah. While there are many things in the Democratic philosophy that are pretty good, they take such a strong extreme position on some issues like abortion and gay marriage, that moderates who would like to support them cannot do so without also supporting those divisive issues.

I applaud Cooke for trying to distance himself from those issues, but it is not a winning strategy in the long run. Matheson has been able to do it to a limited extent, but even his days are numbered.

J Thompson
SPRINGVILLE, UT

Straddling a fence never works. Why would anyone who believes that traditional marriage is the only form of marriage, associate himself with a party that thinks traditional marriage is passe? Why would anyone who respects the right of the unborn to be born associate himself with a party that believes the mother has the right to destroy the life within her?

Compassion does not come from the government. Compassion comes from the people. It is a duty that is left to the people. Compassion cannot be legislated without taking away our agency.

When we pledge our support to government and assign government a duty, such as defense, we are obligated to give money and our lives, if necessary. That is why we have limited the duties assigned to government.

The State must not mix "compassion" with "duty". The Democrat platform has forgotten the difference between "duty" and "compulsion".

Christians believe in helping all people. Real Christians don't need to be forced to search out the poor and offer aid. Government must not become a pseudo-god that forces us to do good.

Mr. Cooke should re-evaluate which party best fits his personal principles.

Shelama
SALT LAKE CITY, UT

There are realities for Democrats even in Utah if one hopes to ever get elected. Still, if Cooke had chosen to apply his Mormon beliefs about abortion and gay marriage to his own personal life while recognizing there are other public concerns and choices, it might have been interesting. Certainly laudable. But he loses in any case.

Look forward to the coming day when gay marriage will be legal everywhere, including in Utah and when even a healthy number of Mormons support it. Also look forward to the nomination and election of a secular humanist, but that will take longer.

Rifleman
Salt Lake City, Utah

Re: Furry1993 Clearfield, UT
"Democrats are like herding cats -- they go all ways at once, and it is very hard to keep them in line."

A kite without a tail and a ship without a rudder go all over and are very hard to keep going in a straight line. Conservatives know who they are, know when they are going, and tend to go in straight lines.

There is nothing praiseworthy about being a kite .... without a tail.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments