Comments about ‘Clouds, added crews aid fight against Idaho fire’

Return to article »

Published: Sunday, Aug. 18 2013 3:17 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Peter Carpenter
Atherton, CA

Hopefully the Fire Boss and the Type One crew will not attempt to save homes by risking the lives of firefighters. Anyone who has built in the wildland urban interface should understand the risks that they were taking and not expect others to risk their lives to save mere property. We have had far too many multiple casualty wildland firefighter incidents because those in charge did not value the lives of the firefighters over the value of home and the appearance of being heroic.

A former USFS Smokejumper - been there and done that.

Peter Carpenter
Atherton, CA

"We're simply not going to leave homes unprotected.""

Crazy and immoral if this means risking the life of a single firefighter.

wer
South Jordan, UT

Fire ground management is very good in these instances. The problem is the states and the feds won't open their pocketbooks to provide enough personnel and modern equipment. It takes large airplanes to make frequent, accurate drops to be effective. Unfortunately, there aren't enough such planes and they have to fly long distances to make their pick ups.

If urban fire departments were at the same relative level of personnel and equipment, there would have been a large public outcry years ago.

It's past time to get Washington and the states to invest tax monies to help preserve homes, natural landscapers, and wildlife habitats.

Peter Carpenter
Atherton, CA

Aerial suppression has never stopped a large wildfire - it just makes people feel like they are doing something.

And fire ground management has consistently killed 10-20 firefighters every decade because of their failure to follow the long established Ten Standing Fire Orders that require firefighters to be removed from unstable conditions. Hopefully that will not happen here in a misguided attempt to save structures.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments