Comments about ‘BYU football: Cougars scheduled to play Middle Tennessee State’

Return to article »

Published: Sunday, Sept. 23 2012 10:00 p.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Phoenix, AZ

Home and home with who? I can see why they announced this Sunday night at 10:00pm.

idaho cougar fan
Twin Falls, ID

I know we want a cupcake for next years schedule, but can't we get a 1 year deal or a 2 for 1. Maybe the BYU brand is not very strong after all.

Two For Flinching
Salt Lake City, UT

And I thought Utah had a rough weekend

Danbury, CT

Can someone PLEASE explain to me again why we are independent?

Sandy, UT

Texas did a home and home with Wyoming
BYU does home and homes to get out all accross the Country to recah their fan bases.
It's good will and PR.

Highland, UT

What's wrong with the home and home? BYU needed a lesser team on its schedule since the schedule is very tough. It also fullfills the goal of playing around the country so fans that don't get the chance to attend a BYU game can go.

Frisco, TX

With Texas, Boise State, Utah, Georgia Tech, Wisconsin (all good teams); and Houston and Utah State (solid teams) already on the schedule - we need a game like this. I expect both Hawaii and Washington State to be better next year also. I hope this game is scheduled for Week 1, which is still open.

I hope Hill is ready to go next year, and we are able to replace our D line. We should be solid at all other positions next year.

DEW Cougars
Sandy, UT

Expect this one to be on BYUtv. Whatever.

caleb in new york
Glen Cove, NY

@ eastcoastcoug - BYU is independent because the top conferences such as the Big 12 and the Pac 12 have not offered BYU an invitation to join, and independence so far is better than what the lower conferences who want BYU, such as the MWC and the Big East, have to offer.

Not that complicated.

Riddles in the Dark
Olympus Cove, Utah


You're always whining, but I've never, ever, seen you offer one single viable alternative to Independence.

Do you really think that staying in the MWC with their horrible television deal was preferable to Independence and having an 8-year deal with ESPN?

Who would BYU be playing next year if the Cougars were still in the MWC? Are New Mexico, Wyoming, and UNLV any better than Middle Tennessee State?

Instead of constantly whining, why don't you give us your realistic alternative to Independence?

O-town, UT

@Riddles in the Dark

Yes, New Mexico, Wyoming, and UNLV are all better than Middle Tennessee State. The Blue Raiders lost to McNeese State this year of FCS.

I think playing in the MWC would be better than independence. I think BYU could finish third or fourth in that league this year--behind Boise State, Nevada, and Fresno State.

I think BYU dropped LA Tech off the schedule as they were afraid to lose that game, which they would have for sure. USU and SJSU may be tough games for BYU this year. I still like BYU to beat USU as the Aggies always lose in Provo.

If USU has any pride, and they don't, they should now only schedule BYU home-and-home only or not at all since BYU does home-and-home with Sun Belt teams.

Get used to more Sun Belt, C-USA, and MAC games to fill up the schedule as has been foretold. The Big 12 would have been great. Better join the Big East now or have to go crawling back to Craig Thompson on bended knee in the future.

BYU independence--Go get'em!

Just the FAX
Olympus Cove, Utah


"New Mexico, Wyoming, and UNLV are all better than Middle Tennessee State."


Wyoming lost to Toledo and Cal Poly and barely beat Idaho in OT
New Mexico was destroyed by Texas and Texas Tech and only beat NM State by 13 points
UNLV lost to Northern Arizona and Washington State

Current Sagarin Rankings
#104 Wyoming
#124 New Mexico
#127 Colorado State
#128 Middle Tennessee State
#131 UNLV

Yes, it's easy to see how much better off BYU would be playing the bottom half of the MWC than playing lowly Middle Tennessee State.

Old Navy
Provo, UT

So I guess this means that Weber State and Idaho State were not available?

Park City, UT


"Get used to more Sun Belt, C-USA, and MAC games to fill up the schedule as has been foretold."

Don't most power conference teams fill their schedules with one or two teams from lesser conferences? Just be grateful that BYU was willing to invite your Wildcats to be one of those schedule fillers.

As an Independent, BYU will also get used to playing Texas, Notre Dame, Georgia Tech, Wisconsin, West Virginia, Boise State, Utah (when the Utes aren't runnin' scared), Nebraska, and many, many other quality programs.

The biggest issue with playing Utah State home-and-home isn't the quality of their program, it's the miniscule size of their stadium and fan base that makes it impossible for the Aggies to guarantee a decent gate for visiting teams.

Gilbert, AZ

"So I guess this means that Weber State and Idaho State were not available?"

No, I'm sure they're still available if Northern Colorado is already booked.

O-town, UT

@B C

I bet Riley Nelson isn't glad that Weber State got invited to play at Provo--poor kid has never been the same since!

Yes some schools play one or two games of lesser conferences. Some actually play the best game available instead of going for 7-8 green light games a year as per Bronco's request.

2013 games: Texas and GT at home, that is nice along with Middle Tennessee, Boise State, and Utah. Notre Dame, Hawaii, Wisconsin, Houston, USU, and Washington State on the road

2014 games: Houston, Hawaii, Southern Miss, USU at home. Texas, Boise State, Middle Tennessee, UCF on the road Yeah that is worth being independent.

2015 games: Boise State and Utah State at home. Southern Miss, Hawaii, Nebraska on the road

Anyone can schedule big teams for one-game road agreements. Idaho State played Nebraska this year, USU played at Wisconsin, FAU played at Alabama, etc.

Props to Utah and TCU for stepping up! Big 12 would be much better for BYU--but that might mean some tough years. Cougars tucked tail and ran from LA Tech on the road this year--that is why independence is great! BYU in retreat!


Scheduling MTSU is probably the only way they'll get games out that way. I don't see the SEC (other than maybe Ole Miss) being willing to play them. They want to be a national team playing all across the country. I'm sure BYU fans in Tennessee will show up in droves. Also if you want recruits from the area to watch you play, this is another way to get them to the games instead of having them fly in for a home game.

Who am I sir?
Cottonwood Heights, UT

BYU's 2013 schedule is more challenging than probably any other. So the Y fans support the need to schedule a team such as Middle Tenn. State. Yet when the U said they needed to schedule a "lessor" team in 2014 when the U plays 9 PAC-12 teams including Oregon and Stanford and as one of three out of conference games - Michigan. What was the Y fan's reaction. Afraid to play the Y etc. But scheduling Mid Tenn State for 2014? Look at the few games scheduled. Do you really need a "lessor" opponent when you have so few opponents?

Predictable "fan" reaction - critical of other teams; justifiable for your own!

WeakTakeLake, UT

Tennessee State???? Are they serious??!! What is wrong with our athletic depatment! They are not even 1A, they are in the Missouri Valley in 1AA. If they were coming here for a paydate I would understand but they did a 1 and 1? Is this a joke? We should get two wins from the Tigers, or 1AA Kittens.

Two For Flinching
Salt Lake City, UT


MTSU is an FBS team (1A & 1AA no longer exist) and are members of the Sun Belt Conference.

What I think is weird about this deal is that BYU refuses to do a home-home with Utah State due to the size of USU's stadium. Yet MTSU's stadium is only slightly bigger and is never full. Wouldn't it be cheaper and more appealing to take on the Aggies in Logan?

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments