Mr. Peterson makes a good presentation of wondrous food for thought. It would be
good if the world had answers, but because there are no true answers each faith
dresses up their claims exaggerations and lies to the point that it is almost
impossible to study the true source from the fiction. Enlightenment without
Authenticity is Mythology.
Good advice.John Lennon gave similar advice:"Imagine
there's no heaven..."You know the rest.During a
1980 interview for Playboy magazine, Lennon commented on the meaning of
"Imagine":"It is the concept of positive prayer... If
you can imagine a world at peace, with no denominations of religion; not
_without_ religion, but without this 'my God is bigger than your God'
thing - then it can be true... The World Church called me once and asked,
'Can we use the lyrics to 'Imagine' and just change it to
'Imagine one religion'?' That showed [me] they didn't
understand it at all. It would defeat the whole purpose of the song, the whole
idea."Just imagine how very intelligent and talented people can
believe that your Church is NOT "the one and only true and living Church on
the face of the whole earth with which [god] is well-pleased"!
RE: Great Christian thinkers.@Aquinas, God reveals himself in ways that we
can understand. God is our Father. ‘He is like a human father but in other
ways he is not. God is not a human being, for example. Nor does the necessity
of a human mother point to the need for a divine mother. God reveals himself to
us at our level. Scripture compares God to a rock , this does not mean God
is a rock, he is like a rock.@Augustine,” My whole hope is
only in your mercy, His sense of being was totally dependent upon God.The
point Augustine makes is that we have no control over the fact that we are
sinful. It is something that contaminates our lives from birth, and dominates
our lives from birth. He uses the term ‘original sin’ to refer to
this inbuilt human problem. We are born alienated from God, and need to be born
again(anothen ,from above)if we are to have full relationship with God. Sin is
a state which we have no decisive control. Pelagius believes we are the master
of our own destiny.
I can’t help but think that much of what passes for religious dialogue
looks a lot like two kids discussing the relative merits of Batman vs.
Tyler: Or "my mom says you have to git off my proppity..."
RE: Tyler D,It is easy to concur with your views because in organized
religion no one knows what they are talking about because it is just a bunch of
pie in the sky political non-sense that makes some powerful and rich, some poor,
most exploited and confused and a few happy. Now spirituality may be some thing
different; what is your take on that. If God is not in the church of man is He
in the spirit of man.
sharrona,"The point Augustine makes is that we have no control
over the fact that we are sinful. It is something that contaminates our lives
from birth, and dominates our lives from birth."Augustine's
"Confessions" are a remarkable study of religion-induced guilt. No doubt
Augustine was profoundly confused and emotionally traumatized by being a
Manichaen for so long.Such emotional, psychological, and cognitive
trauma is to be expected when one assumes such things as:"...we
have no control over the fact that we are sinful. It is something that
contaminates our lives from birth, and dominates our lives from birth."I, for one, deny such unsupported, damaging, inhumane perspectives on
humanity in general, or any particular individual. Asserting the
"sinfulness" of mankind is the horribly abusive, disturbing, and
ultimately unethical and immoral "sin" of religion. And more often than
not, it results in a self-fulfilling prophecy and a distorted sense of self and
social relations in those who are indoctrinated with such nonsense.
Professor Peterson has highlighted our common human desire to be respected as
honorable, capable and good-hearted, and the deleterious results of failure to
recognized this in political, religious, academic, or cultural conflicts.
Social psychologists and therapists have shown if we feel others respect our
integrity, competence and intention, then we can be open to hear their intense
criticism of our ideas and beliefs without angry resentment. In any human
communication how we feel about the other is silently transferred ahead of what
we think about the other's ideas or beliefs. The "silent dialogue"
of contempt or admiration will determine more than anything else the results
from the "verbal dialogue" over conflicting world-views, ideals, or
religions. The real problem: we cannot fake this respect like we can civil
politeness. We actually have to change our attitude about our opponent, really
granting the benefit of the doubt in advance of engagement, or we will come
across as phony emotional manipulators. Ah, ancient scripture says God looks on
the heart of a person--and we seem to be wired to do the same thing. Those who
desire to influence without coercion must honor those they desire to influence.
Maybe this same courtesy could be extended to unbelievers as well?I'm so tired of hearing people say atheist/agnostics/non-theists are just
"denying" God because they don't want to "obey" Him; that
we somehow know deep down that there is a God, but we just don't want to
believe it.I don't believe because there is no proof. I
don't see anything magic or divine in my daily life. I know that all
religious people, if they are capable of thought, are capable of doubt. I deny
subjective experiences as objective evidence.Children are born
atheists, they have to be taught theism.
RE: skepticGreat point. Yes, I would agree that by all accounts
(across all religions) there seems to something in our nature that, when
accessed, presents itself as transcendent, loving, oneness, and even
“other.” The problem as you said is that, based on a powerful
spiritual and completely SUBJECTIVE experience, people then make fantastic (and
in my mind, totally unjustified) leaps in logic and concoct all sorts stories
and claims about the objective world. Most religions are guilty of this,
although best I can tell Buddhism (in its secular form) does this the least, and
at the same time (and perhaps ironically), records some of the deepest and most
profound spiritual experience of all the world’s religions.
great article David until you tipped your hand with "anti Mormon
Crusaders." so much for respect I guess, which is very sad because the rest
of the article was very respectful and well reasoned.
Daniel not David, sorry my apologize.
@A ScientistHas religion, but no my God your God Has no
denominationIs that not really just one unified religion or
religious belief?In other we are living the one true religion of
the one true God.I am not so sure Lennon knows what he is talking
To Scientist: IF you are going to cite scripture then do so correctly; " And
also those to whom these commandments are given, might have power to lay the
foundation of this church, and to bring it forth out of obsurity and out of
darkness, the only true and living church upon the face of the whole earth, with
which I, the Lord, am well pleased, speaking collectively and not
individually."This election is doing just that bringing The
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints out of obscurity and darkness. The
fulfillment of prophesy is happening today whether you or anyone else wishes to
accept and believe it or not. It is happening and happening rather quickly.President Hinkley stated emphatically that all Churches have some truth
and what is needed is for them to come to us and we will add to their truth.
This is as truthful today as it was when it was said. This is the Church of
Jesus Christ, restored to the earth today. The Book of Mormon also written for
our day. This is the Church of Jesus Christ restored to the earth. Believe it
To: A Scientist It is something that contaminates our lives from birth, and
dominates our lives from birth; I, for one, deny such Unsupported. Wrong,The Book of Mormon,”because of the fall our natures have become evil
“.Ether 3:2. And see Mosiah 3:19.Never again will I curse the ground
because of man, even though every inclination of his heart is evil from
childhood. Gen 8:21;. Behold, I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother
conceive me. (Ps 51:5) supported by the .O.T..All of us also lived
among them at one time, gratifying the cravings of our sinful nature and
following its desires and thoughts. Like the rest, we were by nature objects of
wrath. Eph 2:3. Supported by the N.T..Jesus was the only one without a sin
nature. He had no sin.
sharrona,I invoke the words of your alleged Master:John
8:46I repeat, I deny the horrible, immoral, unethical assertion of
original sin or any other form of "sin" that requires some
"savior" to swoop down from empereal realms to save us from something in
which we had no choice, or from absurd "commandments" that have no moral
merit in the first place.Mistakes? Sure. Errors? Yes.But
"sin"? No!Sin is a fiction, just like the fiction of
"god", designed by power mongers to usurp bogus authority over others.
Bill,This election has nothing to do with anything with the LDS
church. It has everything to do with two diametrically opposed views on the
role of government and the future of this great nation. Just because Mitt is
Mormon is irrelevant to any Mormon scripture you quote. His rise to prominence
and to be on the cusp of winning the Presidency is because of who he is, his
ideology, his ability to communicate his views and how they resonate with the
electorate.As to those intelligent people believing in a Higher
Power or God, I can understand how people of all IQ levels and backgrounds and
cultures believe. I believe in God but I don't believe any religion speaks
for God. Many religions have creeds and tenants that I find "true." But
no one speaks for God any more than I do.Reason tells me there has
to be a Supreme Being to explain why we are all here on this planet. However, I
believe that God is a very hands-off type of God and wants us to be kind, do our
best, forgive others, obey the law and be a good person. That is it.
@A Scientist, I invoke the words of your alleged Master: (John 8:46) Can any of
you prove me guilty of sin? If I am telling the truth, why don’t you
believe me?Jesus Christ, though tempted in every way just as we are
(Hebrews 4:15), never committed a sin (2 Corinthians 5:21; 1 John 3:5). The
apostle Peter stated it clearly: “He committed no sin and no deceit was
found in His mouth” (1 Peter 2:22). Indeed, as Jesus Christ is God, He has
no capacity to sin.(No sin nature as humans) The, Theanthropos.RE: A
Scientist , dominates our lives from birth; I, for one, deny such unsupported.
Wrong again,… just as sin entered the world through one man(Adam),
and death through sin, and in this way death came to all people, because all
sinned.( Romans 5:12). For just as through the disobedience of the one man the
many were made sinners, so also through the obedience of the one man(Jesus) the
many will be made righteous.(Romans 5:19),Check, John 8: 47.
Wow Thinkman you take a statement that with Romney running for President that
this is helping to bring the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints to
spill your own propaganda. Yes, this election is helping tremendously to bring
the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints out of obscurity and darkness.
It is bringing it to the forefront of every Americans doorstep and home whether
they know it or not.Whether you want to believe this or not is
irrelevant. Whether he is elected or not will be determined on many other
factors not his religion. However, there will not be many that don't know
about the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints after this election.
There won't be many that will be asking questions about it of which many
other things will be noted. We will have to wait and see how it brings forth
the good works of the Church and all. Fact is that it is prophesy being
Great article calling for mutual respect of sincerity!Objectivity is
important. Without it, MDs would sell snake oil. But objective truths change.
Einstein gave the same tests every year. He said students
couldn’t cheat because the answers change. I have seen the answers change
in medical science, physics, and cosmology.But certain subjective
truths remain constant. Throughout history, couples still fall in love and
still love their children. We cry when separated from loved ones. In selfless
acts of heroism we reverence an eternal principle of sacrifice.Once
while walking I came upon a 6 foot black snake. I froze with nausea and chills.
My subjective experience warned me of danger. At times, a wondrously beautiful
experience confirms to me that God lives. Having faith in these experiences, I
make decisions changing my life.Man is that he might have joy. Joy
comes from accomplishing good which pleases God. Pure religion teaches us how
to live and love each other for a fullness of joy. The reality check is that it
applies here and now, and it works. Without the subjective
experiences, we might as well be lizards.
sharrona (and other believers),I will put it more bluntly.None of you can possibly convict/convince me of sin.I challenge
you to do so.You cannot.Sin is a fraud perpetrated on
innocent, good people to exploit them. It is a shameful doctrine that has caused
more suffering than should have ever been tolerated by decent human beings.
To;A scientists, Sin=(hamartia, Greek) an archery term ,to miss the mark. Have
you ever missed the mark?The sin of omission. ‘If anyone, then,
knows the good they ought to do and doesn’t do it, it is sin for
them(James 4:17 NIV) For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet
offend in one point, he is guilty of all(James 2:10) Like breaking a glass
window, it crumbles.RE: None of you can possibly convict. You
cannot.True ,that’s the work of the Holy Spirit/Ghost same Greek
word(pneuma). When we compare ourselves horizontally to other humans were not
all that bad, but when you look vertical to God as Isaiah did who came into
God’s glory , one should be in awe: Woe (oh vey)is me! for I am
undone; because I am a man of unclean lips, and I dwell in the midst of a people
of unclean lips: for mine eyes have seen the King, the LORD=(*YHWH) of
hosts.(Isaiah 6:5)These things said Isaiah, when he saw his (*YHWH)glory,
and spoke of him.(John 12:41)