As a BYU fan who thoroughly enjoyed the 80's, I want the rivalry to
continue, why not, since Utah will always be BYU's little brother? As a
season ticket holder, who cares what our little brother thinks, I have Texas,
Boise State, Georgia Tech, Notre Dame, and Utah's swan song to look forward
to at LES.Utah? See you in 2016 when several years of bottom feeder
finishes has helped U understand what it feels like to be the Wazoo.
@truecoug1No matter how U spin it, U look bad. ----------As a fan that lived through the 80s I want the rivalry
to continue, why not since we clearly own you now. But as a season ticket
holder who cares what BYU fans think, I have USC, Oregon, Stanford, Michigan,
Cal, Washington to look forward to @RES.BYU? See you in 2016.
I wish BYu good luck against Idaho.
U-H dude"30 years ago BYU was a good team. Now, it is all
over."For a couple of brief shining moments in the 2000's
Utah was a good team... BYU2006 11-2 #16/#152007 11-2
#14/#152008 10-3 #25/#212009 11-2 #12/#122010 7-6 unranked2011 10-3 ur/#25Utah2006 8-5 unranked2007 9-4
unranked2008 13-0 #2/#42009 10-3 #18/#182010 10-3 ur/#232011 8-5 unrankedTotal Last Six YearsBYU 60-18Utah
58-20Top 25 FinishesBYU 5Utah 3Top 15
FinishesBYU 3Utah 1Head-to-headBYU 3Utah
3now its all over as the Cougars surge past the faltering Utes.Need a tissue little brother?
It will be OK BYu.........you are a legacy program and the world cheers for U.
America's team = BYu
Can someone please give BYu a hug and hold their hand for a moment?
BYu needs a hug folks!
30 years ago YbU was a good team. Now, it is all over.
True storyOverheard between two Utah fans at work:"I
thought we'd be disrespected, but the magazine ranked Utah's coaching
job in the top ten! 9th best in the Pac 12!"*sigh*
fuddyNOBODY sprinted to the exits faster than Utah fans at the
Colorado game, except for possibly Utah fans at the TCU game in 2010.
To all who have come back at me with your comments. They are entertaining. And
Spokane Ute, provide the link. It still does not compare, read your link again,
there is cost involved also. You will not see $20.8 per year, your rederic is
comical. As to the rest of you who challenge any BYU fan with your lame BCS
Conference, BCS game, PAC-12.....Blah Blah Blah, doesn't matter when it was
played, doesn't matter who you played, as I said you played Awesome Pitt
for one of your BCS wins. But it still hangs in Lavell Edwards Stadium, a
banner that says National Championship and the only reason you bring up the date
of it is because U don't have one. You don't like me bringing it up,
I am trying to show you it is the same lame argument you use with the BCS
Conferance, BCS Game, just accept it. Read the comments and understand them
before you pop off. But I enjoy your comments, they are comical. Here is to
the Utes never winning a Pac-12 title, hip hip, hooray. You guys make me laugh.
I couldnt agree more with PAPA Smurf UTE. This is about nothing more than money.
I wish we could go back to the good'ol days when athletes didn't care
as much about money and when sports was about the fans and just playing the
game. Sports is just getting ridiculous. The NBA, NFL, you name it, its all
about money and being in the spotlight. Nobody cares about the fans anymore. As
long as they look good they are fine. Shame
@Uteology "Oh please. Texas and Texas A&M also canceled their rivalry.
It's time to move on, we have."So have I. Like I said, it
doesn't bug me that Utah wants to take a break from the rivalry. It's
not going to hurt BYU, we'll just schedule some other mid-to-low-level
'BCS' conference team that will actually HELP our TV ratings.I just think it's funny that U fans are trying to spin this in some way
to try to make Utah look better for doing it.No matter how U spin
it, U look bad. Texas and Texas A&M ended their rivalry and most everyone
blames the Aggies for doing it, since they were fed up with their older brother
Texas having their own network and being the big dog. So they moved to the SEC
and ended the rivalry, trying to stick it to the Longhorns.So either
Utah's doing the same thing to BYU, which looks childish and petty, or the
U administration feels that playing BYU makes their schedule too tough, which
makes U look scared.Either way, U lose.Go Cougars!
BYu needs to move on. Utah already has. Goodbye BYu.
Loving it. Keep it coming Cougar "fans".
Question of the day: With the well known fact that any team that schedules a
trip to Oahu to play the Warriors can schedule thirteen games, why isn't
Chris Hill making an effort to get that game on the schedule every other year?
Especially with Norm Chow as the head coach???? Seems like a no brainer. I
don't know what the Hawaii/Utah rivalry is/was like, but I'm sure that
fans of either school would not mind the trip to the islands or to Salt Lake
City. They aren't the toughest team in the nation, but that thirteenth game
could make it well worth the while getting them on the schedule. What to me
makes the most sense is scheduling the island trip the year where there are 5
home games and the Warriors trip to SLC the year of only 4 home games... Or
wait, would it be better the other way around?
Sammy"It's hilarious to see a team fanbase desperately
struggle on a daily basis for some media 'love' and national
respect."And yet byU "fans" have to copy and paste byU
stats every day to remind everyone of your team's long lost history. "Had BYU not played Utah last (year,) they probably would have
broken the top 20 or maybe 15, who knows?"HUH??? Yeah and if
Utah had not played byU in 2004, they would have played for the NC.I
guess you got your wish going forward. You will have to take a couple more beat
downs before the break-up though.Good luck in your "Quest".
ElmoSure, it did happen but the media didn't care and neither
did the Coach's Poll. BYU was recognized on the national stage
once again and the Utes... ignored as usual.That one game... like it
never even happened... according to the Coach's Poll. That game was all you
had last year. LOLWas it embarrassing, no doubt, 7 fumbles will
about do any team in, but it was nothing compared to Colorado beating Utah in
the 'all or nothing' game. The previous year, the Utes
embarrassed themselves in 'the most historic game ever played in RES',
then at ND by a bench QB and got thumped by BSU in a bowl.Tell me
how great the Utes are recently.The Utes are the 'Rodney
Dangerfield' of their conference. 4-5, tied for 8th place and "We get
no respect".It's hilarious to see a team fanbase
desperately struggle on a daily basis for some media 'love' and
national respect.Had BYU not played Utah last they probably would
have broken the top 20 or maybe 15, who knows? And the Utes would
have slid further into the abyss of mediocrity.Bu,bye! Enjoy more
…continued… But if you're really being intellectually honest,
the reality is these are very similar programs--neither is head and shoulders
above the other, and both remain quite insignificant in the big picture of big
time college football.Utah has a lot of work to do to build their
brand into what they envision. Just because they're "in" the
conference, does not mean they've arrived.(Yes, I understand
the same goes for the Cougars--like I say, they're very similar programs in
very similar situations and places in their evolutions.)
…continued… So once again, when you think about the national
perspective (where all of the specifics fade and you just have the major
achievements, when folks think about non BCS schools (i.e., bubble schools),
they think of Boise State, TCU, Hawaii, Utah and yes...even BYU. Those are the
brands Utah is synonymous with nationally. All have changed their situations to
improve their access to the bigger stages, but now all are newbies playing with
the big boys, and all have to prove themselves all over again on these
stages.The rub is that no matter how you slice it season in and
season out neither fan base has ever been able to really prove their team is
better than the other team. The rivalry game has always been the only way to
answer that question, and it's usually so close, it only gives the winner
temporary bragging rights (usually with a "whew, we barely pulled that one
…continued… They were terrible in hoops (2nd to last with just 3
conference wins). In baseball, they are dead last (.233 winning percentage), 2nd
to last in tennis, worst in softball, 9th in volleyball (.273), 8th in
Women's basketball (.444), 5th in Women's Soccer (.545), 9th in
Women's Tennis (.300). (Yeah, I know those are lame sports, but that's
what the PAC 12 website had). The point is, If anything, Utah is less
interesting now than they were when they were a stand-out story at the top of
their conference (which they only won 3.3 out of the 13 seasons they were
there--note BYU also won just 3.3 out of 13 seasons). Busting the BCS was cool,
but they weren't the only team to do it, (don't forget that Boise
State was also undefeated in 2004 but Utah got the at-large bid; and although
all of these teams didn't finish undefeated, Boise was eligible to bust the
BCS 6-times; TCU was eligible to bust 5-times and even BYU was eligible to bust
the BCS in 2009). Continued…
The thing that's so funny is that Ute fans say this isn't about BYU
and then they make it all about BYU. So let's take BYU out of the equation
and just talk about Utah...Rivalry game or no rivalry game, Utah is
still Utah. They're not an interesting college sports brand outside of the
state. To the outsider, they had some great years in hoops a couple of decades
ago, then they had Urban Meyer, and he had an epic season before leaving for big
money. Most folks probably associate the 2nd BCS year with the long tail of
Urban's recruiting. That trajectory (along with the fact that the other two
MWC schools that regularly stood out were Christian schools, and there was ZERO
chance the PAC 10's leaders would approve inviting them) got them into the
PAC 12. Now that they're there, they've been mediocre. In football,
they finished in a three-way tie for 6th place in the conference overall, (which
is the bottom half of a 12-member conference). Continued…
@ sammyg"And I remember every Ute fan whimpering like a child
having candy taken from him when the Utes lost 'everything' to
Colorado".Poor sammy, try beating Utah for a change before you
go out and parade behind other teams that are capable of beating Utah. You sound
like an annoying little brother who has to hide behind someone else to fight
your own battles for you. "And the stomping tantrums when BYU
was announced at #25 in the Coach's Poll".Wow! You must be
so proud of your team for beating all those WAC cupcakes. Good job! Name me one
team BYU beat last year that was good and would validate them top 25 worthy?"54-10... like it never even happened. LOL"Oh it did
happen! A national audience that tuned in were watching BYU quit and their fans
sprinting towards the exit. lol
Unfortunately the rivalry may end on the football field between opposing teams,
but it still doesn't end around the water cooler, on talk radio, on TV, in
the classroom, in church, in the neighborhood, and on the street.I
just want to be left alone with no slurs, one-upmanship, or snide remarks and
just wear my BYU shirt, cheer for my team, and let the other guy do the same.Go Cougars!
SoCalUtahFanAnd I remember every Ute fan whimpering like a child
having candy taken from him when the Utes lost 'everything' to
Colorado.And the stomping tantrums when BYU was announced at #25 in
the Coach's Poll.54-10... like it never even happened. LOL
@Bruin"Heck, even play in a National Championship game, and then
pop off."Remind me again which national championship game BYU
played in? You didn't play a single ranked team in '84, and your
"championship" game was against a horrible team that finished with 6
losses.It's always a nice accomplishment to go undefeated, but
don't compare 1984 with what Utah did in 2008.
Warrior Present1993 55-7Wow! 20 years ago.I
remember last year 54-10 when cougars gave up (like 5th grade boys) early in the
@truecoug1Oh please. Texas and Texas A&M also canceled their
rivalry.It's time to move on, we have.As a season
ticket holder, I'll be renewing each year. I'm willing to bet that
with a schedule of PAC-12 and BIG-12 teams 98% will do the same.Go
1993BYU 55 - Utah 7There was a 20 year Lavell Edwards period
where BYU clearly dominated Utah in Football. I also remember vividly the 55-7
shellacking of the hapless Utes as a Freshman in 1983. Steve Young tore them
up!here is the 20 Year BYU dominance: 1972-1992en.wikipedia.orgIn the early Years, Utah owned BYU until the
70's.Now Utah has a 19 year significantly dominant period
although BYU has won 7 of 19... soon to be 8 of 20, while Utah only won 2 out of
the 20 Edwards years.
@SpokaneUteAs for the trailer park talk, that's all in good
fun. A lot of Ute fans make fun of BYU's schedule for being WACish, when
we all knew that the first couple of years of independence would include a lot
of WAC teams to help the Cougs fill out their schedule and that, starting next
year, the schedule gets a lot stronger.That's similar to me
with the trailer park. I just like to poke fun at Ute fans for having
'WACish', trailer-park facilities while knowing full-well that,
starting next year, Utah will have some very nice, new football facilities.You're a good sport, Spokane. It was fun to banter back and forth
with you.Have a great evening!Go Cougars!
@SpokaneUte "I understand why you think they look scared, but I doubt
that's the case. I believe the decision is based from a buisness stand
point. Utah has very little to gain, if anything, by playing BYU."I can understand you saying that. However, if the rivalry is taking a break
because of a business standpoint, I think that's sad. In 2014-2015, with
the new playoff system starting, strength of schedule will be an important
factor in deciding who goes and who doesn't. If Utah wants to be in the
playoff, it should include BYU over a cupcake, since most college football teams
will be looking to bolster their schedule.I'm not saying that
Utah wouldn't get in if they went undefeated with their schedule in 2014,
since they've got a pretty daunting one. But there are 60-70 other big
name teams who will have similar schedules and scheduling a BYU over a cupcake
may be the difference that gets the Utes in, IMO.Either way,
it's sad, and I don't think Utah comes away looking very good because
Easy enough to figure out, putting BYU on the schedule would mean no room for
teams like Northern Colorado. @ Utes, you remember Max Hall but give Alex Smith
a pass. Both comments were awful.
@TrueCougI understand why you think they look scared, but I doubt
that's the case. I believe the decision is based from a buisness stand
point. Utah has very little to gain, if anything, by playing BYU. The rivaly is
not dead, just put on hold for two years. Playing Michigan, as opposed to BYU,
is neither childish or petty. IMOBYU will be fine without playing
Utah, and vice versa. Both schools get plenty of exposure. Get
passed the temporary trailers. I manage construction and it's pretty
common. I once housed a fire dept for over a year while we built their new
facitily. I have no say on Utah's scheduling; just a big fan.
Good luck in the coming season. When BYU isn't playing Utah or Utah St; I
pull for them. There's too much hate in the rivalry; and that's what I
see as petty and childish. For that reason, I'm glad it's taking a
pause. Take care, have a good evening................and GO UTES
54-10...So then why all the whining? Go play the bottom half of the
WAC and enjoy yourself...excellent point!let Utah and BYU part
ways.Utah will continue going north!BYU will keep heading south!
@54-10 "So then why all the whining? Go play the bottom half of the WAC and
enjoy yourself."Not whining, just curious as to why U fans think
BYU needs U, or how U fans think there's any way that they can come out of
this without their administration looking bad.And since I have yet
to get a good answer to either of those queries, I think I will go off and enjoy
watching BYU beat the bottom half of the WAC. As well as the bottom half of the
PAC (Washington St., Utah, Oregon St.).Should be a great year :)Go Cougars!
@SpokaneUte "Well, the score board says other wise. 54-10 last year. What a
wax job. Utah has won 2 of the last 3, and 7 of the last 10 head to head games.
Scared? Of what?"That's my point exactly. No matter how U
fans, or the U administration, spins it, U come out looking bad. Either U are
scared to play a 'mid-major' team that U have 'owned' the
past decade, or U are trying to stick it to that same university by essentially
saying "we're bigger than the rivalry", which just makes U look
petty and childish."Rest assured, Utah and BYU will be fine
without playing each other."I completely agree."You do realize that temporary trailers are industry standard when
performing construction? I'm sure you will see them on BYU's campus
from time to time."I do, I just don't recall our football
program being run out of a trailer park when we were building our new
facilities. I think it's hilarious!"Let's keep in
civil, no need for name calling."My bad, I didn't mean you
in particular there, just the U administration.Go Cougars!
Utah Bruin Said:"Pac-12 Channel, $23 Million Per year to be
split between 12 schools, so $1.9 a year for you and you don't even see
much of that for the first 4 years. Maybe my math is off, how does that compare
to ESPN and BYU's contract of $800,000 to $1,200,000 per home game. So if
they have even only 5 home games that is somewhere between $4MM to $6MM. And it
doesn't even matter who are what time and when they play. Hmmmm."Not sure where you are getting your information, But you are wrong on
many levels. Let me help, The TV contract is 12 year, $3 Billion with ESPN. The
PAC 12 channel will provide $250 million annually (or $20.8 million per
school)Would you like me to provide a link?
truecoug1Provo, UT"So again, why does BYU NEED Utah in
particular? BYU's gotten a lot more national exposure and money than Utah
has being in the PAC 12. And playing a team with trailer-park
football facilities really doesn't help the Cougars' image at
all."So then why all the whining? Go play the bottom half of
the WAC and enjoy yourself.
@truecoug1Little Bro? Well, the score board says other wise. 54-10 last
year. What a wax job. Utah has won 2 of the last 3, and 7 of the last 10 head to
head games. Scared? Of what?Rest assured, Utah and BYU will be fine
without playing each other. I've never said other wise. SoCalUtefan
nailed it (again)Utah doesn't need BYU. Already play 10 BCS schools.
BYU needs Utah, another BCS school on the schedule. "Bro,
BYU has had their 30 million dollar, state-of-the-art Student Athlete Building
for about 5 years now, and I'm pretty sure they weren't operating out
of a trailer park while they were building it. That's just sad, and
it's poor planning."First Off, I'm not your Bro. Just
a Utah fan trying to have a civil conversation/debate. You do realize that
temporary trailers are industry standard when performing construction? I'm
sure you will see them on BYU's campus from time to time. "which just makes U look childish and little brotherish."Let's keep in civil, no need for name calling.
UtahBruin....NC talk is so old--28-year-old.Fact is that
BYU has not done much to improve its program since 1984--over a quarter of
century ago. A 8-wins season here and there. A 10-wins season here and there.
Blah, blah, blah. BYU stillhas troubles filling its schedule with good
teams.From 20 miles behind in 1984, Utah has zoomed past BYU like a
Ferrari 485 zooming past the Nissan 300SX (that Dick Harmon once compared BYU
to) and left BYU 50 miles behind it.
@SoCalUteFanI'm not seeing any cup-cakey WAC games on the
schedule for BYU in 2013 or beyond.I can see what your point is, but
I still don't understand why BYU NEEDS Utah any more than Utah NEEDS BYU.
BYU can just go out and get another mid-level 'BCS' conference team,
and it will most likely be one that will help BYU's TV ratings.Tom Holmoe said at the very beginning that it would take two years before the
schedule picked up, and he's been as good as his word. I don't think
BYU will have any problems with strength of schedule in the future, especially
since most teams will be looking to replace their 'cupcake' teams with
stronger teams to bolster their SoS when the playoff comes around.So
again, why does BYU NEED Utah in particular? BYU's gotten a lot more
national exposure and money than Utah has being in the PAC 12. And
playing a team with trailer-park football facilities really doesn't help
the Cougars' image at all.Go Cougars!
@ Spokane UteAgain, "Win a BCS game." "Step up to the
Big Boy table." "Heck, even play in one."So again I
will say. Win a National Championship and then pop off. Hang a National
Championship Banner in your stadium, then pop off. Heck, even play in a
National Championship game, and then pop off.Pac-12 Channel, $23
Million Per year to be split between 12 schools, so $1.9 a year for you and you
don't even see much of that for the first 4 years. Maybe my math is off,
how does that compare to ESPN and BYU's contract of $800,000 to $1,200,000
per home game. So if they have even only 5 home games that is somewhere between
$4MM to $6MM. And it doesn't even matter who are what time and when they
play. Hmmmm. I wonder if Utah's facilities will be anything
like BYU's football multi million dollar facilities that professional
athletes say is nicer than NFL facilities. And as for Rice-Eccles Stadium. On
behalf of all Utah Tax Payers and the SLC Winter Olympic Games. You're
@truecoug1 and other confused coug fans...Why BYU needs Utah more
than Utah needs BYU?Easy to see...Utah: with 9 tough PAC-12
games plus another big-10 like Michigan/MSU/OSU/Iowa/, Utah hastough
schedule strength and does not need BYU as BYU adds little to its schedule
now.BYU: with the cup-cakey WAC games, BYU needs the likes of
Georgia Tech/Nebraska/Utah toargue that its schedule is competitive.
lol, Utes' heads are getting too big for RES
@SpokaneUte "You must be referring to the temp facility used during the
construction of Utah's $20 million, state of the art, Football Facility.
It'g going to be nice."Bro, BYU has had their 30 million
dollar, state-of-the-art Student Athlete Building for about 5 years now, and
I'm pretty sure they weren't operating out of a trailer park while
they were building it. That's just sad, and it's poor planning.It IS nice that Utah finally got the memo that it's the 21st
Century and that they need to update their facilities, though. Heck, even NMSU doesn't run their facilities out of a double-wide. As for the whole 'PAC 12 network thing, do you mind telling me what
channel that's on? And how much of that $23 million do U get this year?
Or next year?I think it's funny that Ute fans are quick to bash
on BYUtv, but quickly laud their PAC 12 network, when the PAC 12
'National' channel is expected to be in 40 millions homes along,
mostly in the west, while BYUtv is in 50+ million homes across the nation. How ironic.
Again, not a Ute or Coug fan. But I get so tired of hearing Ute fans tell BYU
fans to win a BCS game or join a BCS Conference and then they can talk. Join a
BCS Conference. Really? By doing so all you did was just become another puppet
to the BCS who might I remind you is loaded with SEC and ACC Board Members. Have
you not learned already that the BCS monopoly is occupied by the SEC and ACC.
The President of the BCS is the President of an SEC School. You will never get
anywhere. Second, Win a BCS game. Congrats on your wins! You beat a very
subpar Big East Pitt team, you beat a very good Alabama team who in my opinion
got beat because they looked past U, but you won and socked them in the mouth in
the first quarter. So congrats, honestly, Congrats! Now remember you played
Pitt and are touting to win a BCS game. So 1984 Michigan doesn't matter.
Actually the way you talk, it does. So Win a National Championship and then pop
@SpokaneUte "Sorry, but there's just no room on the schedule for a mid
major when a team like Michigan comes calling."Actually, there
is room for that 'mid-major'. As UCLA Bruin pointed out, U have two
spots open to fill in 2014, including a home game. In 2015, U have 1 spot to
fill, which is an away game. Since BYU is such a
'mid-major', as U call them, and U want to schedule those
'mid-major' cupcakes, why not play BYU? U have room on your schedule
to. So again, what's your point? If BYU is a 'cupcake,
mid-major, easy win', why not schedule them? U have no
argument, Spokane. Either U are running scared from a so-called
'mid-major', or U are trying to stick it to BYU, which just makes U
look childish and little brotherish.Pretty sure BYU's going to
be just fine without U in 2014-2015. Heck, I'm willing to go out on a limb
and say that we'll schedule a team that will actually HELP our TV
at truecoug1Sorry, but there's just no room on the schedule for a mid
major when a team like Michigan comes calling. My point is simple, when you have
3 non-conference games, you have to be selective. When you play in a BCS
conference, you play 9 (in Utah's) case, BCS schools automatically. Now
look at BYU's schedule. 5-6 BCS games. Simple math 9+ > 6. That's
not spinning it, just the facts. Instead of BCS, let me simply: Rose, Sugar,
Fiesta or Orange Bowl. Win one, then move up to the Big Boy table. Heck, even
play in one. Trailer park facility? You must be referring to the temp facility
used during the construction of Utah's $20 million, state of the art,
Football Facility. It'g going to be nice. KJZZ? Actually Utah will play on
the PAC 12 channel. You know, the one that pays out $23 million/year. No spin
here, just the facts. I hope that helps.
@ UtahBruin,Utah has Michigan in 2014-15 and USU in 2015. Utah has
only 3 open OOC games left available for those two seasons. I hope Dr. Hill
schedules one OK team and a cupcake in 2014 and a cupcake in 2015.
No BYU vs. Utah game. Incredible poor decision by Chris Hill, not to mention
the lame excuse used by both he and Wittingham. I am not a Ute or Coug fan, I
am a football fan that lives in Utah so I look forward to this game and Monday
mornings in the office following. But, Chris, Mr. Hill, Dr. Hill. You have no
other Non-Conference games even scheduled those years. You have Michigan in
2014, that leaves two open spots for a BYU Rivalry game. You have Michigan and
Utah State in 2015, that leaves one open spot for a BYU Rivalry game. If
anything, bump Utah State, you haven't played them every year, it is not as
big of a rivalry and BYU would be despite the "lame comments to follow"
a better game than USU. Bad Move and an icredibely Poor Excuse. I am a Pac-10
fan, not Pac-12, may the Utes go down in flames for this one and lose to the
likes of Wazzu. Your over rated Ute fans, you will never win a Pac-12 South
Title, not with USC, UCLA, Arizona, Arizona State there. They won't let
@SpokaneUte "One of the biggest reasons, has to be that Utah has nine
conference games."So...what's your point? Chris Hill said
on two radio interviews that Utah's goal is to go to the Rose Bowl.So how does scheduling BYU affect Utah's goal? U fans are always
reminding BYU fans that U can still lose your non-conference games and get to a
BCS bowl. Getting to the Rose Bowl in the PAC 12 will most likely mean going
undefeated in conference play, and if you're good enough to go undefeated
in the 'mighty PAC 12', shouldn't U be good enough to beat BYU in
a non-conference game?Sorry, that argument just doesn't hold
water. Like I said, any way U spin this, U come out looking bad.As
for BCS bowls and BCS conferences are concerned, since the BCS is a thing of the
past, I'm not sure what your point is. Maybe U meant that BYU should call
U when U get out of your trailer park football facilities and cancel your
contract with KJZZ. U know, start playing big boy football on the big stage.Go Cougars!
@Ute fansI'm also confused by the 'BYU needs Utah'
talk. Why? Last year, outside of the ESPNU contests against SJSU
and NMSU and the ESPN2 game with Idaho, Utah was our lowest rated TV game. Utah
is not a good TV draw. ESPN knows that and the PAC 12 knows that. That's
why the U tied Oregon St. for the fewest games picked up by the PAC 12 networks
last year at 4. U had 2 games picked up nationally in 2011: the BYU
game on ESPN2, and the Pitt game on ESPNU (the infamous game where the
commentators apologized to those watching for how bad the game was). To top it
off, the PAC 12 stuck U on MWC Lite (Versus) in your first ever PAC-12 game
while Colorado got featured on ESPN against the Trojans.As far as
national games and exposure are concerned, Utah doesn't help BYU at all.
So I'm still confused why BYU would need a Utah team that is in a
conference that doesn't respect them and that runs their football
facilities out of a trailer park.Answer: they don't.Go Cougars!
@ True Coug1One of the biggest reasons, has to be that Utah has nine
conference games. I highly doubt Utah would have dropped BYU if they played 8,
like every onther BCS conference. As an independent, it's easy to pad your
schedule with 4-6 cup cakes. For Utah, that's simply not possible. I
don't see this making Utah look bad. They still play each other this year,
in 2013 and 2016. As far as Utah being little Bro goes; win a BCS Bowl game, or
join a BCS conference, then let's talk.
@ Cougs4Life"It's funny that the U fans make the claim that
BTU's move to Independence has lead to this decision by the Utes".Don't you think the timing was ironic for BYU to declare their
Independence 2 months after Utah was invited to join the Pac-10? Hmm..... To any
reasonable person, this independent move was a move out of jealousy and envy.
"Are you really saying that had BYU stayed in the MWC
that the Utes would have kept them on the schedule in 2014 and 2015?" Nope, BYU would still be off the schedule. It's still a matter of
BCS Utah vs mid-major BYU. Chris Hill's decision would still be the same.
BYU as a mid-major program does nothing for Utah anymore. "Let's be real here, this move has happened because the U has moved
to the Pac10 and know their head is bigger than their hat".If
BYU wanted to keep the rivalry going as well. They could swallow some pride and
accept Utah's 2 for 1 offer. But, BYU still thinks that they're bigger
than what they really are....A mid-major program.
@Ute fansIt's fascinating to me to see your responses. No
matter how you spin it, this makes Utah come out looking bad. Both K Whitt and
Chris Hill have stated that the reason for not scheduling BYU is because it
would make their schedule too difficult. But that was BEFORE scheduling
Michigan which, as Spokane Ute intimated, is a 'much tougher team'
than BYU.So now Utah looks hypocritical.But then, if
Michigan is a much tougher team than BYU, why not play BYU to pad your schedule,
since the Cougars are obviously one of those 'WAC-ish',
'mid-majorish' teams that should be chalked up as an easy W, right?So there must be some other reason for not scheduling the Cougs. Either
the Utah administration feels that playing BYU would be much tougher than
playing Michigan (meaning U are scared of the Cougs), playing both BYU and
Michigan in the same year would be too tough of a schedule (again, scared) or
the U administration is trying to stick it to BYU, which makes U look petty and
childish.Good ol' Utah. Once a little bro, always a little
When a football team can't deliver on the field for decades............when
in doubt.......print t-shirts, posters and claim the national championship
before the season starts. I'm glad the mighty Utes haven't had to
resort to that pathetic behavior.
mormon ute...Utah does not need to play with mid-majors as long as
Utah has Michigan (14-15), and future gamesperhaps with Michigan St, Ohio
St, and Iowa.Holmoe should only call Dr. Hill once BYU is actually
in a big conference --not just supposedlybeing invitted to one
eagleProvo, UTBottom line, Florida and Florida State are big-time
programs from DIFFERENT conferences. A loss on their schedule is certainly at
risk every time they play.-----Poor example. Florida
hasn't played a non-conference game out side to the state in over 25 years.
Also, neither FSU or Florida are independents. What's tougher, going to
Provo or going to Ann Arbor? It's a no brainer.
.....ContinuedIn any case, the rivalry is over. We’ve seen
what happened to the Utah/Utah State rivalry. That was a result of a
combination of not playing every year and Utah State’s program taking a
dive. I predict we will see exactly the same thing with BYU. Yes, that
includes their program taking a dive. I don’t know if they will fall as
far as Utah State did, but I don’t think there is any way they can
maintain the level of play they have had in the past as they struggle to
schedule top opponents and their funding begins to dry up from boosters.
......Continued. It is obvious by the comments being made who needs this game
and really wants to see it continue. Some Ute fans want it just for sentimental
reasons, but the Ute’s program doesn’t need it. With the teams we
have on our conference schedule, the Michigan deal and the upcoming Big 10/Pac
12 deal the Utes just don’t need the BYU game to reach their goals as a
team and a program.Personally I have enjoyed the rivalry over the
years. I have been on both sides of it at different times in my life and it was
truly fun to be a part of it until that famous Max Hall comment. That year it
became way too personal and inappropriate. I too was disappointed that the
administrations from both schools didn’t step up and say enough is enough.
If that incident had been handled better by both schools, it could have gone a
long way to making the rivalry better. BYU didn’t do enough to put Max in
his place and the U should have said something about the fans behavior that
upset Max. Continued........
It’s interesting to hear all the different perspectives on this. Chris
Hill didn’t name the Max Hall rant, but he did say he was uncomfortable
with how negative some aspects of the rivalry have become.It’s
also interesting to note that most of the people claiming the rivalry needs to
go on are BYU fans, players and staff. How the tables have turned. Since Ron
McBride took over as coach we’ve gone from BYU being THE BIG GAME on our
schedule ….. to BYU being a big game on our schedule and one of the most
important for us to win ……. to now we don’t really need them,
but boy do they need us.......Continued
@ Counter Intelligence,Cheer for BYu all you want to my friend.
Because, "America's team" every week is BYu's opponent.
@ Counter Intelligence, The LDS influence has a "storied'
past of impeding social progress. It is that simple. BYu may be disliked, or
not........but I know this, they are avoided big time.
@Counter Intellignce,When so many players and fans of schools that
BYu plays make the same claims.......? Hey, where there is smoke, there's
fire. I've seen many BYu cheap shots in recent years. I never thought BYu
was dirty before that. They played hard and acted like gentlemen. I don't
feel that way now.
I've read a myriad of bigotry claims by BYu fans. Ok, fair enough. Then
please explain to me why NO Cali PAC team will schedule BYu anymore? None of
them have been scheduled so far, nor will they ever. Even Steve Young and his
wife voted "no" to Prop 8 in 2008. Talk about bigotry all you
wants........the world has identified the true bigots. That is why BYu is indy,
PERIOD, the end.
The U doesn't need the Y anymore. Now if the Y were in the BIG 12 the U
would suddenly have great interest once again. Pac 12 vs Big 12 and combine the
natural long time rivalry between the two schools ... this would be great for
both. BYU has to understand that it is in no mans land right now with no future
as an independent. Recruiting has fallen off already at the Y and that trend is
going to continue until BYU gets itself into a BCS conference. If Bronco leaves
after next year then things will really start to crumble. Bronco won't
leave if BYU is in a BCS conference.
Chris Hill said it best:"I didn't think we were a good
enough to play BYU and Michigan in the same year."Hill decided
to throw 90 years of tradition under the bus because it was
"inconvenient" for Utah to play BYU and Michigan.Utah could
easily lose to both BYU and Michigan, killing Utah's bowl hopes.In other words,the mighty WHIMPY Utes are all squawk, but no
walk... coiled in a fetal position, while pretending to be brave.
Cougarfan in texasStop with the lame comment about cupcakesWeber StateIdahoNew Mexico StateSan Jose StateThose are the schools your team is playing, I would have to call this a lame
It's funny that the U fans make the claim that BTU's move to
Independence has lead to this decision by the Utes. Are you really saying that
had BYU stayed in the MWC that the Utes would have kept them on the schedule in
2014 and 2015? Let's be real here, this move has happened because the U
has moved to the Pac10 and know their head is bigger than their hat...It is satisfying to hear though from Dr. Hill that he didn't feel that it
was "fair" to the football team to schedule such a difficult schedule
for those two years. Bottom line...Dr. Hill is afraid to play BYU those two
years. Since they have won 7 of the last 10 he probably shouldn't feel
that way, but apparently he is scared.
@Alpine CougGreat comment. I, too, believe the rivalry has become
too heated and out of control. Perhaps a break will only provide a greater
appreciation for once was.Now, we just need the MIGHTY PAC 12 UTES
to put those "Mid-Major" cougarettes in their place for the next two
UHA, the observation is that the hatred is a shared relationship by both sides,
be it the religious arrogance of fans of the private university or the
anti-religious tone from the public school fans according to the wiki
description of the so-called holy war.You can understand the hatred
toward BYU from those who don't share the same faith. What is intriguing
is the hatred of the U by BYU fans when many LDS attend there and are athletes
on its teams. It also seems counter to BYU's mission to love and serve
others.Perhaps the hatred is just over-zealous competitive
attitudes, based in the desire to defend their universities by proclaiming each
Still too smart?I brought up Northern Colorado, not CU. You brought
up CU. I was pointing out the fact that beating BYU is like beating Northern
Colorado (Utah's first opponent this season) in that it matters nothing to
the PAC-12 which is a bigger deal than winning a non-conference game, and that
it is almost as automatic. Now, obviously BYU is better than Northern Colorado,
but it is still fun to make the comparison. You went on a diatribe from one
word out of my statement and go with it completely out of context, so yes you
@ Counter intelligence,Yes, Utah fans would go after the BYu
football team if a great Utah player was taken out by another BYu cheap shot.
Devonte Christopher could have been killed last year. TCU's Jerry Chambers
has complained about BYu's dirty play as well. I've never thought BYu
played dirty until recent years..........but they do now, because they
aren't very good anymore.
Bottom line, Florida and Florida State are big-time programs from DIFFERENT
conferences. A loss on their schedule is certainly at risk every time they
play.Utah fans are delusional if they think they have outgrown BYU.
BYU has a far better athletic program from top to bottom, that isn't in
dispute. Utah has had the better of it in football over the last 10-15 years.
But despite the blowout last year most of these games have been incredibly close
and entertaining, some of the best games to watch in college football period.
Blocked FG's, Harline's catch, 54-yard FG's to win games, fourth
down conversions, 3-0 shutouts in the snow, this rivalry game has seen it all in
the past few years. Arguably it is one of the most competitive rivalries out
there, more so than Alabama vs. Auburn over the years. Didn't Auburn win
six games in a row? When was the last time BYU or Utah won six games in a row
in this rivalry, probably in the late 1980's, early 1990's and it
wasn't the team wearing red. This game needs to be
@ Igualmente,Hate Utah all you want sir, as you've been shown
the door and the hand. Relish in BYu's November schedule this
year........the worst in college football history, never to be much better. Good
Since they played in Provo in 2011, SLC in 2012 and Dr. Hill indicated that they
would be back in Provo in 2013 and then won't play again in 2014 or
2015...does that mean that the Utes have agreed to a 2 for 1 with the Cougars?
"I don't like Utah. In fact, I hate them. I hate everything about them.
I hate their program, their fans. I hate everything. It felt really good to send
those guys home."— Former BYU quarterback Max Hall
"I really hate them. Playing in the game helped me understand. They are the
most arrogant people. It's the whole church and state thing. They're
the 'good kids'. We're the 'bad kids.' I didn't
feel it in my gut last year like I do now."— Former Utah
quarterback Alex Smith
Come on, get real. Things have changed for both school. The last game was not
the same. I am neither happy nor sad. It is just the way it is. I care more
about having Utah successful than anything else.
@ Flashback,BYu stands ZERO chance against the Utes in the
foreseeable future. BYu has no way of beating Utah.........with what and who?
BYu has ONLY Kyle Van Noy, and that is all they have.........and he has a bad
Takin a break from the hate?
The bottom line is BYu is a hard-fought game. With facing 12 PAC talent for 9
weeks, now a major Big 10 team....... that is 10 out of 12 tough games. Playing
BYu, a meaningless game in Utah's current conference, SOS and danger to
player's health........why should Utah play BYu anymore? It is absurd. What
if some BYu cheap shot blew out a great Utah player's knee? The U fans
would assault the BYU team in masses. Utah has a contract with a very honorable
USU team. That works for me.
Somehow many other rivalries continue across the country between schools from
different conferences because the teams want them to continue... obviously Utah
does not care enough about the rivalry and has moved on to bigger and better
things. This game has become so hate filled that I wouldn't care if the
game didn't ever come back. People on both sides get too heated and
ridiculous and most of it has nothing to do with football. Good riddance.
The PAC 12 has the finest all-around schools in the nation. The Ivy League can
rival PAC academics, barely, but not when you consider the "whole"
Face it Cougar fans your big move to Independence and irrelevance just became
even more irrelevant.
@Flashback,Utah whooped the snot out of a SEC undefeated(regular
season) Alabama team that spent 6 weeks as the #1 team in the nation in 2008
with MWC quality recruits. With Utah's last two recruiting classes, depth,
coaching, etc......I think Utah will be just fine sir. I know Michigan fans are
worried about Utah.......read all the various sports boards my friend.
Flashback,Need a tissue?
Oh by the way, money has indeed ruined college football. Just check out the
sham playoff the BCS is trying to foist on folks. The Mountain West conference
would have been the strongest in football with the Y, the U, TCU, Boise State,
Air Force and maybe the others. Those schools should have forced the
commissioner out, dumped the TV contract and gotten a new one. There would have
been no need for the Utes to jump to the Pac 10 at that point. The Mtn West
teams were regularly kicking the Pac 10's teams butts for several years.
Now money has ruined a good rivalry. The Utes don't stand a chance against
Now I won't cheer for the Utes even if they play Notre Dame. Chris Hill
should be fired. I know the Utes would get too big for their pants when they
went to the PAC 10. As I have always said, the Utes are a second tier team in a
second tier conference. They will never prosper. Added incentive for the Y to
kick their butts this year.
More tidbits...........the reason Utah and Colorado went to the 10 PAC is
because their schools are top notch and offer the PAC great all-around academia
and tv markets. The only other schools that would fit their academic
requirements, within the PAC's geographical footprint and tv markets, is
definitely New Mexico and possibly UNLV, if they improve their graduate
programs, which is possible. Schools like BSU and BYu, although very attractive
for a possible "PAC-16," cannot cut the mustard academically or in
BYu's case, the social issues as well as academia. Nobody cares about
accounting programs in the PAC!
Who was talking about BSU, TCU or Utah football 30 years ago? Very few in the
nation. BYu was relevant then. In the 21st century, everyone is talking about
BSU, TCU and Utah, as they are all BCS busters from non-AQ conferences. Nobody
is talking about BYu, a team that has done ZERO in the BCS era.
A few weeks ago it was said that "BYU puts the ball in Utah's
court" on the rivalry game issue.That was like saying that your
16 year old put the "I need a car" ball back in dad's court!Utah has always held the ball since the Pac-12 invite. They
simply decided to take the ball, put it in the closet, find a better ball
(Michigan) and move one. That's what happens when dad makes a
decision. The kids get upset, cry a little, and have no say.The
rivalry game will continue to be played, when it's convenient for Utah.
That's pretty obvious. BYU needs it, is dying to schedule it, it's
become their bowl game. To Utah, it's just another OOC game that will be
played when the schedule sees fit. Just accept your irrelevance
BYU, and this will all not feel as painful.
It would be interesting to know the conversations/negotiations between Hill and
Holmoe. My guess is Hill demanded a 2-1 or 4-2 and Holmoe told him to stuff
it.I see no purpose playing USU and BYu every year. We need to play
teams in the fertile recruiting grounds like Texas, Florida, etc. We already
have a long term contract with USU and I'm glad about it. USU is surging,
nice fans and adds an instate rivalry game. I could care less about BYu. Their
program is tanking, horrible/zany fans, a terrible reputation in their dealings
with everyone. Heck, they kicked USU in the teeth AGAIN by demanding a 2-1. My
goodness?????The good news is Utah will pound BYu again on 9-15-12
at RES and then really bad in 2013 at LES, as BYu will be in complete rebuilding
mode. Then, a two year break.........the Y fans are gonna be so bummed out
having to wait two years for revenge in 2016. PRICELESS!!!!!!!
BYU: Tradition, Spirit, and HonorUtah: Money, Money, and Money?
I see many other solid programs trying to book BYU now that the national
championship will rely more on strenght of schedule. BYU wont have to worry
about their schedule.
The appropriate way to fix this in the years ahead will be for Holmoe to insist
Utah give 2 for 1 when Utah comes begging to play again.
If all of the above do not care then why are there 152 comments? Because you
all do. Are you telling me there will be a 152 comments about a Utah Colorado
game - ever? No way.Do you really think that Michigan fans will be
on these boards talking about the "Big Game" never. In
the end this is fun. The rivalry exists because we all care. Without a game you will all still be here comparing schedules and talking
about the last games played. But there will not be a game. And no
one to really care enough about to hate. Sad.Which is
why my previous comment still stands....Whatever.
@ pocyUteNo, I'm not reaching. You brought up Colorado trying
to put down BYU. My guess it that you're under 25 at most. If I were
reaching I'd point out a coach named Lavell Edwards, a National
Championship, a Heisman Trophy Winner, Beck-to-Harline, 4th-and-18 to Collie,
etc. But I don't want to bore you with history. Just remember last year
when Rose Bowl, Rose Bowl, Rose Bowl was all any Ute fan could say and they had
a perfect opportunity to get to the PAC 12 Inagural Playoff Game. EVERYTHING
that had to happen actually did, except for onme small item: Beat the worst
road team in America the last 4 years, playing on your home field with
EVERYTHING to play for and EVERYTHING to lose. So what did you do? You lost!!!
Who'd have thought that after just one year of being the offensive
cordinator at the school that Chow would be the one leaving and Doman the one
staying? Also, recently, how many top 25 finishes for each school? Tell me,
please. The Utes are the 12th team after Big 12 didn't implode. Colorado
was invited first!
eagle lamented "I don't get it. Florida State and Florida are both in
big time conferences and yet find a way to play each year."The
better comparison is Oklahoma and Tulsa. OU is a BCS school which doesn't
play mid-major Tulsa every year. Its nice when they play, but for the most part
its a blowout win by OU.Taking a break from the series was
inevitable when Utah moved up to the BCS and BYU chose to stay mid-major.
It'll be funny when USC, UCLA, Stanford, and Oregon leave the Pac, and the
conference degrades into a MWC. Big money will make independence look
attractive to alot of named programs, and BYU is in a good situation.With big money, and new television technology, these teams aren't going
to support the utes, and other low tier pac teams. Mark it down.
Shame. Generally speaking over the past two decades, these have been some of the
best games I've seen played in college football. I'm wondering how the
players feel...Plus, I can't stand the Wolverines (UM, of
course, no hate to UVU)---doesn't make for a good trade in my opinion.As a Utah Alum (BS-2000), this is one decision for which I don't
agree with Dr. Hill.Some Y fans will say Utah is "chicken"
and BYU can now schedule "better" opponents. Some U fans will
claim Utah is now one of the "big boys" and have moved on.I
say hogwash. Money has spoken and driven these two "brothers" apart.I suppose there's always hope for 2016.
I am a huge Ute fan, but I think this is a horrible decision. The rivalry is
sometimes very ugly and blown out of proportion, and although neither side
really "needs" the game, what about the fans? Win or lose, I want to see
BYU on the schedule every year. I. want to enjoy the good natured ribbing at
work, at church, and even at home, where my wife and 3 young daughters are all
hard core Cougar fans. There is no good reason to take a break in this game.
Utah has won 7 of the last 10, and even the painful losses on last second plays
hurt, it was still fun. From a fan's standpoint, I feel we are all losing
on this one. I do not agree with Chris Hill at all. I want to see a good
schedule. The best part of last year, the first in the PAC 12 was that I
didn't really know if the Utes would win from week to week. Didn't we
leave the MWC to not play the Wyomings, New Mexicos, and UNLVs of the world?
What is Dr. Hill thinking?
adelman"This is common sense for the Utes, why risk a loss to an
excited BYU team when they have a chance to play higher quality teams. It goes
both ways, BYU refuses to play UVU in basketball"One of the
dumbest comments ever made on these blogs.BYU not playing UVU in any
sport isn't even remotely in the same universe as Utah not playing BYU in
football. The BYU-Utah rivalry was decades old before UVU even existed.The reason Utah is running away from BYU is because, as Chris Hill said,"I did not think we're good enough to play Michigan and BYU in
the same year."
CougFaninTXFrisco, TX" I hope Ute fans enjoy watching their Utes
beat up on the cupcakes, knowing they could have had a game against a real team
". Like those spankings of 54-10, 48-24, 31-17 against Alabama in the
Sugar Bowl on CBS PRIME TIME !! Now that's a REAL team. Not the New
Mexico States of yesteryear. Should be interesting to watch next years
2013 fire sale recruitment no stars play in Moscow.. Idaho that is.
Too Smart?You're really reaching aren't you?54-10 must still hurt7 of the last 10, 55-34-4Thanks
for the memories. LOL
I don't get it. Florida State and Florida are both in big time conferences
and yet find a way to play each year. This rivalry needs to continue. This
saddens me as a college football fan.
Amazing the sour grapes that emerge when your team isn't calling the shots.
If BYU can ever build a schedule like ND then the fans can whine all they want
about Utah being 'chicken'. Better schedule for the Y this year but
drop 4 of the lower tier teams, add 4 more big names and then you can talk. I
am happy playing USC, UCLA, Oregon, Stanford, and Michigan (plus 6 more PAC 12
teams) if that means dropping the Y from the schedule.
Razzle2Bluffdale, UTLet me help you out. Florida/Florida State
are most likely the most spirited rivalry in the country that is not two teams
in the same conference. Why? Because Florida State hates the SEC and the
toot'n Seminoles. Florida State has to prove every year that the ACC is as
tough as the SEC.---------Given Florida State has been
National Champions twice and played for the Championship three other times, they
hardly need to "prove" themselves. Their fans, and Florida's fans,
would riot if someone tried to stop their rivalry game.
Obviously the Utes have bigger fish to fry than our little (WAC) brothers down
@Mountainman56With no chance of winning a conference championship,
what else will Utah have to play for?-----------Alamo,
Holiday, Sun bowls vs. Big 12/ACC teams for starters.What about BYU?
Tier-3 bowl vs. CUSA.
This is a short sighted decision that Utah will live to regret. With no chance
of winning a conference championship, what else will Utah have to play for?
You've certainly enjoyed having bragging rights over BYU for the past year
when you had nothing else to brag about in a very mediocre season. Since the
majority of BYU fans are not originally from Utah, the game really doesn't
mean any more to us than playing some other random mediocre team. BYU has
played and beaten PAC 12 teams for many years so no big deal if we play Utah or
not. Now what is exciting is looking at a schedule that has Notre Dame, Texas,
West Virginia, Nebraska, Georgia Tech and others of their ilk on the schedule.
Yeah, yeah, we all know that there are some patsies from the WAC on the schedule
but we also all know that the schedule will be including more high caliber
programs and less and less patsies so don't bother repeating the useless
blather about Idaho, NMSU, SJSU etc. BYU's strength of schedule going
forward will continue to be similar if not better than Utah's, with or
@pocyUteInteresting that you talk about the nothingness of beating
BYU and compare it to beating Northern Colorado. Speaking of beating a team
from that state, how about regular Colorado? How'd Utah fare against them?
Did it mean anything, like a better record, a successful ride along a greased
path to the PAC 12 Inagural Payoff Game, or any respect from around the country?
Was the game in SLC? Remind me again, wasn't it less than 50 yards total
offense in the first half (for the migthty Utes and their wizard offensive
coordinator- Norm Chow)? Hadn't Colorado gone winless on the road for 4
years? That's Utah's new true rival---Colorado.
Let's see you beat them consistently in the future. Right now in PAC 12
play you're 0 - 1 against the Buffalos, a real poor performer of late and
you lost to them at home. Of course all that came flashing back when you
said..."Colorado." Thanks for the memories.
Coug fanin TX ....BYU plays tons of WAC teams Utes play one cupcake the first
game of the year...Your thinking is so flawed.
Boo on you, the U...Now what are we gonna doWithout a regular
opportunity to destroy BYU.No other win provides as much joy as does their
defeatNor near enough heartache and anger and pain when we get beat.
17-14 hurts don't it....I think 54-10 would hurt much worse!!!! Come back
down to earth!
worf said:"Bleed Crimson,It'll be a few
years.Why would USC, Stanford, UCLA, or Oregon want to carry the
utes? Money is a big issue with Utah, and a few others being a burden. Changes
in television broadcasting revenue will lead to the utes being dumped. They
won't be as kind as BYU, who carried them for several decades.This will happen. College football in changing."Keep dreaming
CougFaninTXFrisco, TXDon't be fooled - Michigan is not
replacing BYU on the Utah schedule. Northern Colorado or Montana State or Idaho
will be the replacement game. I hope Ute fans enjoy watching their Utes beat up
on the cupcakes, knowing they could have had a game against a real team._________________________LOL!San Jose St, New Mexico
St. and Idaho are excited to play a real team. Or so they think. For some reason
BYU keeps scheduling cupcakes. I hope BYU fans enjoy watching the cougars beat
them up. Because that is the schedule of their future.Go
Spartans!9-6 lifetime against BYU.
Bleed Crimson,It'll be a few years.Why would USC,
Stanford, UCLA, or Oregon want to carry the utes? Money is a big issue with
Utah, and a few others being a burden. Changes in television broadcasting
revenue will lead to the utes being dumped. They won't be as kind as BYU,
who carried them for several decades.This will happen. College
football in changing.
I Bleed BlueLas Vegas, NVWhat a shame. College sports were great at
one time. Then the greed set in. Mid major and small market BCS schools have no
chance to compete. Shame on the NCAA. Best of luck to BYU and the U. The way
things are now, both schools are going to need it. When the day comes soon, both
schools are going to be sucking for air when the stands are half full and there
is no chance for at least one sure sellout. Sad day for Utah. All the other big
boys kept their rivalry games and the state of Utah gave up on theirs. SEC wins
again._______________________Not true. Other big boys
did not keep their rivalries. Here are two.Texas vs Texas A&M is
over.Kansas vs Missouri is also done.
" I hope Ute fans enjoy watching their Utes beat up on the cupcakes, knowing
they could have had a game against a real team."And who would
that team be...... are you talking about Utah State? Can't think who
that other team would be....
What a shame. College sports were great at one time. Then the greed set in.
Mid major and small market BCS schools have no chance to compete. Shame on the
NCAA. Best of luck to BYU and the U. The way things are now, both schools are
going to need it. When the day comes soon, both schools are going to be sucking
for air when the stands are half full and there is no chance for at least one
sure sellout. Sad day for Utah. All the other big boys kept their rivalry
games and the state of Utah gave up on theirs. SEC wins again.
Don't be fooled - Michigan is not replacing BYU on the Utah schedule.
Northern Colorado or Montana State or Idaho will be the replacement game. I
hope Ute fans enjoy watching their Utes beat up on the cupcakes, knowing they
could have had a game against a real team.
17-14 Hurts Don't It?Springville, UTMediocrity moves on.
Let's hope that the "fans" follow.Go Buffs!____________Meiocrity did move on. BYU went independent!And
both Colorado & Utah will make more money in the PAC than BYU with its
whimpy ESPN contract.Go San Jose St!9-6 all time against BYU.
Well, I guess all good things end someday. So the new rivalry for Utah is
really Colorado? This is like when a new company takes over and scales back the
Christmas bonus from a $500 gift card to a 'Seasons Greetings' card,
left on your desk with the usual corporate drivel. Lame, lame, lame. There is
nothing waiting at the end of the season for either fan base anymore. For Ute
fans, it's the glimmer of hope of a possible Rose Bowl (but probably Sun
Bowl) birth and for BYU fans, it's more 'exposure' whatever THAT
means. Again, lame.
worf said:"BYU will be playing Texas, Notre Dame, Nebraska, and
West Virginia.Why would anyone be sad to see Utah go bye, bye?College football will soon be evolving to independence, and conferences
will be dissolving. Mark my words, it's in the cards as technology
progresses, and conferences won't be needed. The day will come when USC and
the likes won't want to carry the Utah's of the conference."Here we go again with the manifest destiny of follow BYU to independence
mantra.Not going to happen. Schools are tied to conferences in more than
just football. Have you every heard of other sports and academics?
ND95CA "Would USC not play UCLA? Michigan not play Ohio State? Navy not play
Army? Florida not play Georgia? Texas not play Oklahoma? Unthinkable!"All of these examples are of teams fighting for position in the same
conference, except for the Indy's. No conference position for BYU makes it
not so attractive anymore.Let me help you out. Florida/Florida
State are most likely the most spirited rivalry in the country that is not two
teams in the same conference. Why? Because Florida State hates the SEC and the
toot'n Seminoles. Florida State has to prove every year that the ACC is as
tough as the SEC. Can you imagine the rivalry we could have in Utah if BYU
joined the Big 10? It would be beautiful. BYU - sell whatever it takes and get
a conference to brag about.
I hope to see the rivalry continue, but as a Ute fan I really want to see a
national championship. The two BCS bowl years showed that Utah can compete at
the highest level. Adding a team like Michigan to the schedule gives the Utes an
opportunity to legitimize their program as one of the best in the country and
play for the national championship. Playing BYU does not. One of the
key reasons that the rivalry was so intense was due to the fact that it was
often a winner take all affair, whether that meant a conference championship,
bigger bowl game, etc. That element of the rivalry is now gone and the reasons
for continuing it far less compelling.If Utah finds themselves
undefeated going into the last game or with one loss and still in the hunt for a
national championship. I want the team they play to give them the best chance of
playing for a national title. If that team is not BYU then so be it.
Mediocrity moves on. Let's hope that the "fans" follow.Go Buffs!
This is common sense for the Utes, why risk a loss to an excited Byu team when
they have a chance to play higher quality teams. It goes both ways, Byu refuses
to play UVU in basketball because it would look horrible for them if they lost
to School in a tiny conference, when honestly they could have an awesome rivalry
between schools that are only 10 minutes apart. It is not worth to Byu. The same
goes for Utah, why continue to play Byu when they are getting more money to play
schools that have more national attention and will give them a better shot at a
championship and also continue the growth that has just started at the U.
@ worf"BYU will be playing Texas, Notre Dame, Nebraska, and West
Virginia".Where are the home and home series with these schools?
Don't "legacy and storied" programs get home and home series with
other "legacy and storied" programs?"College football
will soon be evolving to independence, and conferences will be dissolving. Mark
my words, it's in the cards as technology progresses, and conferences
won't be needed. The day will come when USC and the likes won't want
to carry the Utah's of the conference".Don't get your
hopes up! All the elite schools will remain in conferences. There is a lot of
money to be made being apart of a major conference. With the College Football
post season evolving to a Final Four playoff and contracts are being signed with
their respected elite bowl games. Schools will be foolish to leave a major
conference and go Indy. Only Notre Dame can pull off Independence because of
their whole history of being independent.
What ! I am a huge BYU fan and I say good bye, fairwell, adios, aloha and good
ridins.Who needs the utes. Oh yeah the pac 10 to round up to 12 yep
they needed more weak teams to fit with the Washington State Cougars, Beavers,
Buff's and now the door mat Utes.
Time for change, and no time like the present. Out side of the state of Utah
the U of U is that add on team that rounded out the pac 10 to the pac 12 nothing
national about the utes.BYU has plenty of national and international
recognition. With the LDS Church as its foundation and the ESPN contract
exsposure BYU for good or ill is much bigger draw. Sorry Utah, other
then the local Utah fans thats about it.
I love people hitting the overreact button on this. I think tradition is the
most overrated argument in sports. Now, I think Utah could continue to play BYU
because they are rapidly becoming the Louisiana Lafayette of the west. Good
grief. My Utes have taken 7 of 10 and last year was. 44 point beat down in RES
with a one armed quarterback. Look, overwrought BYU fans, just cause it takes
your biggest game of the year off your schedule doesn't mean we we need to
kowtow to tradition and rivalry. The Utah goal is bigger than that. And to the
shortsighted Utah fans, it isn't 20 years ago. Beating BYU is like beating
Northern Colorado. It matters nothing and is one of the 3 least important games
of the season..
Everyone ragging on Chris Hill needs to understand that he is performing for the
PAC 12. It's payback time to the conference for greasing the schedule so
Utah could play in the inagural PAC 12 play-off game. Only trouble is the
Ute's laid an egg in SLC be losing BIG TIME to Colorado but now they still
have to pay the piper the proverbial pound-of-flesh, bowing to the whims of the
conference. That's what happens when you sell your soul---someone else
tells you what to do and you're powerless to do anything different. With
the big home-and-home with Michigan there will be yet another excuse to empty
RES at half-time.
@ cougarfanzz"Yewts running scared. BYU will play anyone
anytime". "Utes" running scared? Dude! 54-10, 7 of 10,
55-34-4. Utah owns BYU and it's not even close! "Michigan
hasnt been good forever".Didn't Michigan go 11-2 last year
and beat Virginia Tech in the Sugar Bowl? I believe Michigan was a very good
team last year.Gotta love these desperate kitty cat fans!
BYU will play anyone anytime cougarfanzz?Yeah right. New Mexico St,
Idaho and the rest really make us look good.We are going to before forced
into scheduling D2 schools in the future.I don't look forward
to that. Schools like James Madison & App St could beat BYU.
26 out of the last 40. Maybe chickenhawks can be their new mascot
when General Scott and the Stanford/Cal groups demand that they not be the Utes
ND95CA.Many of the schools you listed automatically have to play
each other if they are in the same conference.They don't have a
ND95CA, nice piece of melodrama. News flash, USC - UCLA, Georgia-Florida,
Texas-Oklahoma, Michigan - Ohio State are all in the same conference so of
course they play each other. Too funny. And in the case of Notre Dame, BYU is
no Notre Dame. As to the Service Academies, that is a whole other enchilada as
they each want to win the commander and chief trophy and to do so they have to
play each other. Pray tell what became of Texas vs. Texas A&M, Nebraska vs.
Oklahoma if you are going to claim such schools would never end such a storied
rivalries; nice try.
esodijeALBUQUERQUE, NMAt the end of the day, BYU still has the
bigger fan base and the week-in-week-out national TV exposure. Utah's
having its wank of joining a "power" conference at the exclusion of
BYU--now let's see it avoid settling into perpetual Pac-12 doormat-hood in
a year or two. BYU can beat OSU, Wazoo, and U-Dub...._____________________At the end of the day, a bigger fan base and
national exposure with low ratings will not get you into the playoffs.Try
winning against Utah and quality opponents for a change to get noticed. A WAC
legacy will get you nowhere.And you are 6-9 all time against San
BYU will be playing Texas, Notre Dame, Nebraska, and West Virginia.Why would anyone be sad to see Utah go bye, bye?College football
will soon be evolving to independence, and conferences will be dissolving. Mark
my words, it's in the cards as technology progresses, and conferences
won't be needed. The day will come when USC and the likes won't want
to carry the Utah's of the conference.
U 90 said...Corona, CAJD Tractor said, "Booooo Utah. The ball
was in your court and you dropped it. BYU carried your program for two decades
and this is the best you can do?" JD, please explain how BYU
carried Utah for the past 2 decades because I didn't see any BYU players at
the Sugar or Fiest bowls. However I did see a few Y players at the 54-10 game
:).JD does not have his History right... there was a 20 year Lavell
Edwards period where BYU clearly dominated Utah in Football. I also remember
vividly a 55-7 shellacking of the jogging Utes as a Freshman in 1983. Steve
Young tore them up!here is the 20 Year BYU dominance1972-1992In the early Years Utah owned BYU until the 70's.Now Utah has a 19 year significantly dominant period although BYU has
won 7 of 19... soon to be 8 of 20, while Utah only won 2 out of the 20 Edwards
@ CougFaninTX"Arizona State, UCLA, Northern Colorado, Arizona,
Colorado, Washington St, Utah State, Oregon State - Wow! I see what you mean,
this is a very demanding schedule".If you think Utah's 2012
schedule is weak. Let's look at BYU's demanding 2012 schedule.
Washington State (for some reason you cougie fans like to mock them), Weber
State, Hawaii, Utah State, Oregon State (again, why mock them when your playing
them too?), Idaho, San Jose State, and New Mexico State. That is one weak SOS!
LOL."I don't think any team in the Top 25 would see this a
a demanding schedule. But for a team that hasn't finished in the Top 25 for
a long time, it probably is a demanding schedule".Ditto, but
more so to BYU's schedule! LOL
Any BYU or Utah fan that does not see this as a TRAGEDY, is not a true fan of
their respective team. It's not about any one team not needing another.
Neither team needs each other. It's about tradition. The quest for the
almighty dollar is killing what has made college football so great.
Hey U 90, you're right to look for the Utes to have a bright future with
their New Rival---Colorado!!
This one is solely on Chris Hill if he really wanted the rivalry to continue
every year he could of made it happen, BYU was and is more then willing to keep
it going. The build up from 2013 to 2016 ought to be interesting to see, maybe a
break is what is needed but I would much rather see it continue to be played
Yewts running scared. BYU will play anyone anytime. Michigan hasnt been good
This will help the Utes on their quest for the perpetual 5-6 to 6-5 Season
HURRAH! Let's schedule other big teams often.
A sad day for Utah.Would USC not play UCLA? Michigan not play
Ohio State?Navy not play Army?Florida not play Georgia?Texas
not play Oklahoma?Unthinkable!That's because legacy
programs value traditions.Like Notre Damme playing USC and Stanford
every year.The new-kid-on-the-block legacy-program wannabe just
layed a huge egg because he doesn't understand traditions.
So which is better? Utah in the PAC 12 or (soon) BYU in the Big 12/16 with
Notre Dame, Texas, Oklahoma, WVU, TCU... in the end both schools will get a
great deal and the State of Utah will benefit.
Now with Utah off the schedule we can add one of the many schools that have been
lining up to play us.
Bob from Santquin,You do understand that in a few years Utah's
TV revenue will be about 4 time more than BYU's ($32MM vs. $8MM). A piece
of the BYU TV pie sounds really nice Bob but I think Utah will stick with their
current gig. Thanks
chris hill has been a whimp for years. he has been the luckiest AD in the
country. not that many years ago alumni wanted him out. i suspect that is coming
JD Tractor said, "Booooo Utah. The ball was in your court and you dropped
it. BYU carried your program for two decades and this is the best you can
do?" JD, please explain how BYU carried Utah for the past 2
decades because I didn't see any BYU players at the Sugar or Fiest bowls.
However I did see a few Y players at the 54-10 game :).
That the rivalry game would go away, along with Utah State, reflects badly on
Utah. But predictable given the horrible state of college football right now.
However, doing so for Michigan is just stupid. Something that should NEVER
happen in college football is for the same teams to play twice in the same
season. And any games between the Big Ten and the PAC 12 during the regular
season should not occur. The only way they play should be the Rose Bowl.
The time machine worked, although something doesn't seem right?Utah 1985 fans are now BYU 2012 fans! Everything is upside down.If you take every BYU fan response on this site and back-date it to 1985, it
will be exactly what Utah fans would have been saying had mighty BYU decided to
stop the rivalry game. When they were the top dogs, the largest fan base, the
best football program, the team people around the country know about. Had they
drop the game back then, Utah fans would have cried, complained, called BYU
chicken, etc. While BYU fans would have said big deal, we don't need Utah
on the schedule.Yeah Cougar fans, that is where you program sits
today. You have relegated yourself to Utah 1985.
Don't put all the blame on Hill.... lets not forget Holmoe could have
prevented this by agreeing to a 2 for 1
Smart planning by the utes. Losing to BYU will not enhance their reputation.
Perhaps if they continue to lower their eligibility requirements they can
Good riddance! I won't miss BYU in the least. Good job Chris Hill. Go
Utah-Hawaii Alum - "College football is evolving quickly these days. Utah
has a very demanding schedule now." Arizona State, UCLA,
Northern Colorado, Arizona, Colorado, Washington St, Utah State, Oregon State -
Wow! I see what you mean, this is a very demanding schedule. Lol. Somehow, I
don't think any team in the Top 25 would see this a a demanding schedule.
But for a team that hasn't finished in the Top 25 for a long time, it
probably is a demanding schedule.Don't worry UHA, someday
you'll get there.
I have grown weary with the bad blood of the rivalry but will admit to feeling
empty with the official word of no game on tap in 2014 and 2015. Life goes on though. Go Utes and sometimes Cougars.
Chris Hill kills 100 years of tradition- I think this call for a 'Max was
baaaawk, bawk bawk bawk!!
I meant to say. I wonder if USC and Stanford will stop playing Notre Dame
because their schedule will be too hard.
How's Dr. Hill doing with the other sports? He is, after all, the athletic
director, not just a football guy. Seems like the other sports are all in the
middle of the pack (the Red Rocks rock, but that's about it, isn't
it). Oh, and then there's basketball...talk about exciting: The
runnin' Utes are running right off the floor and out of the program.I'm one Coug that can do without the Utes. I will root for them
casually, glad to know when they win, but will only read the headlines. I
won't miss the rivalry game at all. I wish them well and I think the Cougs
will make their way just fine.
I wonder if USC and Stanford will stop playing USC now because their schedule
will be too difficult. Hill just tarnished his Legacy in one bold, dumb
decision. Maybe he should have asked the players if they wanted to play BYU. I
doubt the U players would have said, "no that will make our schedule too
Look on the bright side Cougar fans. BYU can now schedule a team that will
improve BYU's strength of schedule.
At the end of the day, BYU still has the bigger fan base and the
week-in-week-out national TV exposure. Utah's having its wank of joining a
"power" conference at the exclusion of BYU--now let's see it avoid
settling into perpetual Pac-12 doormat-hood in a year or two. BYU can beat OSU,
Wazoo, and U-Dub....
I can honestly say I care less if we do not play the Utes. I know Holmoe will
bring somebody to fill the vacant spot that I will enjoy watching. As a season
ticket holder I can think of at least 30 teams I would rather see at LES than
the Utes. Talking to the Florida State before and after the games was an amazing
contrast to the vitriol you experience with the brash Utah fans. My prediction
is that in the next few weeks BYU will announce an addition to the schedule that
will fill the spot left by the Utes for those years. As far as I am concerned I
hope the rivalry is over.
Brocno owns the You so it makes sense for them.
Yo Bob- Careful there buddy. All that chortling, snorting, chuckling, LOLing
makes you sound a little delirious. Not to worry my friend. Utah's games
will be on the PAC12 network on national tv from now on.
@ chazzmichaelmichaels"Its fans like you that arent really fans.
You dont care about the game so much as you care about sticking it to the
'other team'. Maybe thats why this rivalry has gotten so nasty".
It goes both ways! It's fans of both BYU and Utah that like to
stick it to each other. That is why the rivalry is so heated. Quit blaming just
Utah fans for this!"Have some class. Look at Notre Dame fans.
Even when they lose, they have class".Notre Dame fans are a true
example of good sportsmanship. I think every school needs a fan base as classy
as Notre Dame's fans. BYU in particular needs to show more class because
it's their fans behavior that reflects on the LDS church. I'm a true
believer that good sportsmanship is needed in all sports.
BobSantaquin, UTNeed a tissue?
I grew up with the rivalry, in fact my mom got hit with a bottle in the
50's attending the game with my dad - presumably from a BYU fan. Sure,
there has been plenty of poor behavior from U fans too. Inappropriate at times,
yes, on both sides, but most of the time it was manageable. With rivalries,
emotions are high and things happen. I love the back-and-forth with BYU fans at
Church, the whole thing. This Ute fan is extremely disappointed. I feel like a
rich part of my past is going away. I am excited about our future, but wish it
included the "Holy War."
I hate to see the rivalry fade but we all saw this coming when Utah was invited
to join the PAC-12 and BYU wasn't.If the shoe were on the other
foot and BYU was now part of the PAC-12 and Utah had been left behind, BYU would
be taking the same steps with their schedule.Good luck to both
BYU fans, lets not forget this, lets put it on Hill! Hill did it, Hill did it,
Hill did it! Hill's legacy! Personally, I don't care if BYU ever
played Utah again! All of BYU's games are now on National TV, two of
Utah's games??? Then there's all those replays--- And the very hint
of the idea that BYU offered Utah a piece of the BYUtv pie makes me----retch!
Lol, Im sure glad Utah got the better deal chortle, snort, chuckle,LOL----- I
can hardly wait for the day when both teams are scheduled to play different foes
on the same day, same hour in Utah. Which school really owns the Utah market
will show up vividly on that day----Bob
I don't think the rivalry would be interrupted if the PAC12 played an
8-game conference schedule. In that vein, if the PAC12 goes to an 8-game
schedule to be more competitive with the B1G and SEC I believe the rivalry would
be renewed without interruption.
I'm excited to see what both schools do to increase their exposure, which
is what both schools claim to want. Seeing the likes of Michigan vs Utah as
well as Texas vs BYU are exciting substitutes for BYU vs Utah.
Wow! A'lot of Y'ners out today! DNews has an article a while ago about
Tom Holmoe and Bronco saying the "Ball is in Utah's court". Well,
Chris Hill has made the tough decision for the better of Utah Athletics.
We're proud of you Dr. Hill for taking the bull by the horns and dropping
this silly rivalry that has no relevance on our schedule anymore. The Utah-BYU
rivalry was a great one. But now that both schools are not in the same
conference. The meaning of the rivalry has changed. Utah has a lot to play for
now and BYU does not! Call us cowards all you want Y'ners! But,
until U beat us. Your trash talking is nothing but hot air. Go Utes!!!
I actually agree with the more logical Cougar fans in that I am a strong
believer in playing tough teams and Mr. Hill has admitted, per Bill and Hans on
the radio, that the schedules in the two years of the hiatus are strong enough.
That is complete trash. Play Michigan and BYU. A team that desires to be great
should desire to play anyone, anywhere, anytime. I love the fact that we play a
tough schedule. Why duck the Cougars in an attempt to soften the schedule? Not
good in my opinion. Show up. Man up.
Glad the rivalry is taking a break. Fans not handling the rivalry very well.
Can't even talk about it with co-workers anymore. Two years off may not be
As much as I loved owning BYU over the last decade, I think I can live with
Hills legacy:2014:HOME: USC, Oregon, Stanford, ArizonaROAD: Michigan, Arizona State, Colorado, Oregon State, UCLA, Washington
State2015:HOME: Michigan, Arizona State, Colorado, Oregon
State, UCLA, Utah StateROAD: USC, Oregon, California, Washington, Arizona
I think the Y fans need to simmer down the jealous rhetoric a wee bit. College
football is evolving quickly these days. Utah has a very demanding schedule now
and BYu is an afterthought, actually a non-factor for Utah. I think if BYu was
EVER nice to people they wouldn't have been left in the dust. But, they
weren't and have been left out to pasture........all by themselves. What
comes around, goes around BYu fans.
BYU pretty much just plays WAC teams anymore anyway,Utes have much bigger fish
To Ute fans:So your beloved Urban Meyer and Alex Smith were wrong
when they reported last week that it would be a "major mistake" to
interupt this rivalry, huh? For decades, all Ute fans could say about BYU fans
is that they were 'holier than thou.' As a Cougar fan, I would have
to admit there was probably some truth to that, over the years. Look in the
mirror Utes. Brushing USU and BYU off your schedule in the face of heavy
opinion from some Ute heroes of yesteryear smacks of Mr. Hill making decisions
with the blinders on. Who looks 'holier than thou' now?
@ Scott Farcus,Don't forget a few donuts. Nothing better than
eating away your pain. Good one!
"Booooo Utah. The ball was in your court and you dropped it". You see JD Tractor, when you belong to a major conference like the Pac-12. You
get to play big time schools every year. Utah wants to play the best teams every
year. What does Utah do? They schedule Michigan (storied football program) home
and home. Only major conference schools can schedule home and home with other
major schools. But you being a fan of a mid major school, you wouldn't
understand that. LOL. "BYU carried your program for two decades
and this is the best you can do?"And Utah carried your program
for 4+ decades before the 70's and Utah carried your program for the last
10 years. Utah was busting the BCS and establishing our program in the modern
BCS era. While your silly school in Provo was collecting their BCS money from
Utah's hard work. BYU sure has fallen off a cliff since Edwards retired!"You should have stood up for the rivalry but I guess the PAC 12 is
your daddy now".No, we like our sugar daddy! Thank you
commissioner Scott! We'll enjoy our $20+ million. LOL.
Time to take up the Utah State rivalry again. You remember the Aggies
don't you? They are the ones you dropped like a red hot stove a few years
ago and are now demanding two-for-ones from. What goes around comes around.
@ Scott Farcus,They need some crackers to go with the cheese and
whYne as well. HAHAHAHA!
Let's see, the Utes will play USU in these years, but not BYU. My first
thought is "gutless", but my overriding thought is, "If it means
getting rid of the utterly stupid expression, 'holy war', then
I'm all for it!
Good! This will bring hope and change to the utes. Let's cancel another
Way to go Utah. We're glad to see you have no sense of tradition or
rivalry. Way to throw away one of the best rivalries in college football with a
116 year tradition. I hope michigan crushes you both years. Shame on you chris
hill and whittingham, we all knew it was always about the money.
Chris Hill should be ashamed of himself destroying this rivalry and backing out
of playing another in state rival.
@ THE MTN MAN"Someone explain this to me: Why not play BOTH
Michigan and BYU in the same year? Like, host BYU in Salt Lake the same year
Utah travels to Ann Arbor? Why wouldn't that work?"
anyone one posting today want cheese with your whine?
I sensed this would be the case. There is just no way to play BYu in 2014 at
all. I think Dr. Hill was very nice not to demand a 2 for 1 deal from BYu
however, but understandable. Additionally, playing USU, a rising program, seems
to me as the right fit for the mighty Utes and our fans for the future. BYu
continues to be problematic and their fan base, for the most part, is awful.
Ahh..Too bad.. Now the Duck won't have to hide in Tulsa.. if you believe
that crock. BYU should be happy as there would have been more double digit
losses om their Top Ten goal.The Yners should all be breathing a sigh of
relief. I do hate to see the rivalry go , but maybe a couple years of
cooling off may actually bring some ethical awareness to the Ute haters.
Don't flatter yourself owl. Why should Holmoe need to announce that Chris
Hill has canceled these games? The whole jist of this article is, "Utah
thinks they're all that and more." Thanks for dissing on the Aggies.
USU would have thumped the jogging utes in Romney Stadium.
Re: @Juice Box.. Its fans like you that arent really fans. You dont care about
the game so much as you care about sticking it to the "other team".
Maybe thats why this rivalry has gotten so nasty. Have some class. Look at Notre
Dame fans. Even when they lose, they have class.
This is not a decision by Utah to play against Michigan instead of BYU. It is a
choice not to play both Michagan and BYU in the same seasons. In other words,
Utah is admitting that BYU is too strong of an opponent to add to its
non-conference schedule along with Michigan during 2014 and 2015. Sad, sad day
for both Utah and BYU fans.
Booooo Utah. The ball was in your court and you dropped it. BYU carried your
program for two decades and this is the best you can do? You should have stood
up for the rivalry but I guess the PAC 12 is your daddy now. Well best of luck
to you, being in the PAC is great, but this is just as bad as an onside kick
when your up by 40.So since you backed out of those games I guess
BYU wins by forfeit. Thanks.
BYU needs this game more than Utah. With 9 conference games, there's no
room on the schedule for BYU. I hate to see the game go; but both fan bases have
become so hateful; it's probably for the best.
byU should be happy with this announcement!! They now have the potential for
one less loss in those years, so that by the time they get through the rough
patch of Idaho, Idaho St., NMSU, SJSU, etc., they may have the chance of
sneaking into the top 25 again and qualifying for yet another meaningless,
preordained bowl game. Yipee!!It is indeed great to be a Ute and
Look on the bright side TDS - no more awful Ute fans throwing their beer on you.
No more Ute cheer leaders beating your cheer leaders up. No more embarrassing
losses to your "little brother" and no more red ties and sweaters at
church after a loss.Dropping the rivalry is a tough call - tradition
or the caustic environment the rivalry game has become. For Utah, playing the
most prestigious schools as part of a prestigious conferences for 20M+ each year
is better than playing more emotional games on the Mountain. At least Utah is
not trading playing TDS for Idaho State, Fresno State, Utah State, etc.Hopefully uncouth and sometimes offensive Utah fans can learn some proper
college football fan decorum from attending games at Michigan, Nebraska, Texas,
Ohio, USC,and the other Pac12 schools.Honestly I loved the energy of
the rivalry with friends and family, but the rivalry turned many people just
plain nasty. Luckily for Utah there are greener pastures ahead.Good
Luck to BYUGO UTES!!
If the Cougars don't get in a legit conference, the Utes will have to buy
out the 2016 game too.
Rational,Enough of them to never have lost to them.
Someone explain this to me: Why not play BOTH Michigan and BYU in the same year?
Like, host BYU in Salt Lake the same year Utah travels to Ann Arbor? Why
wouldn't that work?Just too hard?
Sweet. This means all the closet U fans who wear the Y shirts can cheer freely
for the U.Also means that no U fan will cheer for the Y still.
BYU needs to realize the situation they put themselves in. That's fine with
me if it takes them 2 years to do so. Those Novembers will get long and they
will come begging...
"Cowards! There's no way they have simply moved on to bigger and better
things and are doing what is obviously best for their program, they're just
scared!"-jealous little brothers
Dearly beloved we gather here to day to mourn the death of a great national
rivalry... actually I'm pretty ambivalent to this move... the Utes are
bigtime now so they don't need the rivalry and most BYU fans will continue
to resent the Utes recent success. I for one won't miss Playing the Utes. I
find comfort in the fact that they will more often than not be a middle if the
pack in the PAC 12.GO COUGARS!!!
No announcement from Holmoe?This show what we already knew. BYU needs the
Utes. Not the other way around.
@LoveTheNewsWhy do you need Michigan?Because UC-SLC now
takes their marching orders from commissar Scott.
When we beat Michigan we will care and we will remember it for years to come.
The new "Rivalry:"BYU: So how about we play in 2013?Utah: Sure, nothing better scheduled yet.BYU: Can we lock in
2014 & 2015 now also?Utah: Awe that's sweet, but no.
Michigan >>> BYU.BYU: Really? Seriously? How about
2016? Please, Please, Please say we can get you on our schedule for 2016,
right? That Michigan series is over, the Big10 series doesn't start until
2017, can you squeeze us in? Please?Utah: I guess. Nothing better
on the horizon yet that year.BYU: That's awesome, thanks guys.
And just remember, if you get a slot opened up in 2014 or 2015, please give us a
call. We badly need you on our schedule.Utah: Sure, we'll keep
that in mind. Thanks for calling Tom.It's tough to see your
place in the college football landscape forming before you eyes isn't it
Way to go Utes. If BYU want's the game on THEIR terms... who needs em? They
have enough problems filling up their Indy schedule and THEY want to make the
terms? High maintenance.Way to stick to your guns, it is NOW on
@CougFaninTX"Hill will forever be remember as the one who ended
the rivalry. I hope he's happy with his legacy."I'm
certainly happy with his legacy. Utah continues to move onward and upward while
BYU is left to scramble - yet again - for someone willing to play them. Maybe
Tom Holmoe should call SW Missouri Tech...they may have a weekend available if
BYU can offer them enough money.The only criticism I have of Dr.
Hill in this situation is that he didn't cut BYU off completely, and we
still have to deal with you in the other sports. The day Dr. Hill cements his
legacy is the day he removes BYU from all schedules for all sports, forever.
Funny how this board is flooded with Cougie fans crying out how bad Utah is for
letting it go...did you Cougies not claim YOU didn't need
US?BYU needs anybody right now for their schedule....anybody.
Oh well! I guess it's just the nature of the college football landscape.
I hate for it to go. Surely the administration at Utah will see that
the fans (the ones that donate and buy all that gear, food, tickets, watch
television, radio, did I say donate?) will demand this rivalry to happen every
The BYU U rivalry game should be cancelled forever. It has become a hate fest
instead of spirited competition.
The rivalry has gotten out of hand as proven by the antics in the stands of the
past couple of years and the poor sportsmanship portrayed. I love to hate Utah
and look forward to each rivalry game but to be honest, with the game being
played earlier in the season it doesn't have the same feel. Good luck
Cougs! Show Utah what they will be missing!
Heck, we should just rename the University UC-SLC.
There we go. Who needs the Cougars anymore? The Utes have bigger, more relevant
fish to fry...GO UTES!!Good luck padding up that Indy
Papa Smurf UTEHerriman, UT"we would only have 4 PAC 12
home games that year. I wish this was not the case. There is nothing that I love
more than the UTAH vs yBu game every year, and beating them into the
ground."--------Just out of curiosity, how many of
those games did "you" actually play in? How many times did
"you" beat anyone into the ground?
As seen already, this will only fuel the rivalry that much more. Both sides will
be watching what the other is doing and then when they meet, it will be even
more crazy than before. It is a bummer for the players that look forward to the
clash each year though. Oh well, Utah will clash with USC each year
Here is a video I made about this a couple of months ago.
This is a shame and a testimony of director Hill's short-sightedness. The
rivalry has been around much longer, and means much more to us fans and alumni
than the short term thrill of a lucrative series against Michigan. Lets get
real, if our conference foes are all PAC 12 schools, why do you need Michigan? I
would rather keep the rivalry going. Because in years from now, noone will care
about the Michigan games, but the exciting rivalry games of recent years will
always be talked about.
Very disappointing. As a Ute season ticket holder, I always look forward to
this game. I understand the reasons for discontinuing, but I feel that big
money and conferences are taking the fun out of college football.
Bradleyc,They may have better options some years, but most years,
not so much. You aren't going to get those great teams as of right now
giving you home and home. Actually wins some games against ranked teams, or
teams above .500 to end the year, then they might talk to you. Plus, your better
options are only in Sept. You need better options throughout the year. Your
schedule is WEAK!!!!In 2014 the UTES have home games with Stanford,
Oregon, USC, and AZ, along with 2 other teams not scheduled. Probably both crap,
but who cares when you have USC, Stanford and Oregon, Plus road games against
Michigan, UCLA, AZ St, etc. That is a GREAT schedule. Having yBu at home to beat
that year would be icing on the cake. I am sad to see the rivalry go away for a
couple of years, but that is what's happening with college football. It is
all about the money and power.
It's good that Utah is getting to play UMich, the team BYU beat to seal its
Wow. The end of life as we know it must be near. Oh the agony! Weeping and
wailing and gnashing of teeth! Or, maybe duckhunter said it best: meh.
Good news for college football fans in Utah. Let the rivalry continue.Go Utes! I can't wait for football season.
BYU certainly has better options. Now why would I want to travel to Michigan
again? Go Cougars and everyone else that Utah plays.
Lame! College football having a playoff is a step in the right direction, but
all the realignment garbage has ruined too many good traditions and rivalries.
It doesn't make any sense at all. I mean San Diego in the Big East? and
these are supposed to be institutions of higher learning. Institutions of greed
if you ask me.
Unfortunate but somewhat predictable. Decades and decades of a great rivalry
just cast aside. What a shame but, again, not a surprise.
Sounds about right. They needed to make room for Michigan, and buying out Utah
St in 2014 will allow us to have another home game, since we would only have 4
PAC 12 home games that year. I wish this was not the case. There is nothing that
I love more than the UTAH vs yBu game every year, and beating them into the
ground. My wife and I even made sure that we did not have our first kid during
football season, so there was no conflict with this or any other game. This will
only make the rivalry that much more intense. 2 years off, will only build the
trash talking between teams.
Bailing on BYU and USU? Utah really has no sense of tradition or rivalry. I
pity any Utah fan that actually cares about football.BYU and Utah
won't play for a world war... and for joining the Pac-12.I
guess those Utes are just nothing but the "big time" now.
That's a shame, it really is. I think saying "that's just the
current landscape of college football" is just a cop-out. I'd be
surprised if it's picked up in 2016 - it will be too easy to replace it
with 'better options.' Sad to see. When will the craziness end? To
think that all of this is in the name of "it's in the best interest of
our school and our fan-base." Not sure whose best interest this is.
Awesome news for both programs. Make fans of both schools appreciate the
amazing rivalry in a new light. Couldn't have come at a better time. On
the other hand, can hardly wait until September. Ought to be an awesome
showdown!All the best to both schools in the hiatus and beyond.
Go USC Trojans! Beat the Utes.
I have mixed emotions about this. I don't mind it so much since the rivalry
has reached unhealthy levels and will relieve at least some of the tension
between the two teams. But college football is also missing out on one of the
best rivalries in sports that often provided thrilling finishes. Best of luck to
you Utes. Go Cougars!
What a tragedy for the fans! Of course, both programs will survive without the
game, but ending one of the best rivalries in college football is shameful.
Hill will forever be remember as the one who ended the rivalry. I hope
he's happy with his legacy.
This is a shame
This is great news for byu. Just think of all pickle juice byu will be able to
drink to get ready for the big game in 2014.