Comments about ‘One Lord, one faith, one baptism? Political differences among evangelicals worldwide’

Return to article »

Published: Friday, March 2 2012 5:00 a.m. MST

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
RG
Buena Vista, VA

Of course Jesus wants us to care for the poor. But he never said that government is the best way to do it. We all know government is full of inefficiency, waste, and corruption, and provides perverse incentives, such as the incentive to have kids out of wedlock. A lot of Catholic bishops found out the hard way: they supported Obamacare on humanitarian grounds, then found out that too much government comes back to bite you. The law of consecration -- and similar faith based charitable efforts -- works differently. It is not by coercion, has very low overhead, and provides only good incentives. Liberals are usually well-meaning, but it is not only the intention that matters, it is the results.

Esquire
Springville, UT

What might be the biggest threat to religion is its politicization. Being identified with any particular political party is bad for the religion and bad for the fabric of the nation. Beware. This does not have to be formal or overt by the Church. A de facto identification is essentially the same and is equally dangerous.

MAYHEM MIKE
Salt Lake City, UT

There's only one view the evangelicals agree on: The Mormons aren't Christian.

m.g. scott
LAYTON, UT

Re: Esquire

How is it bad for "for the fabric of the nation", when religious people participate in the political process? If you say not the people, just the institutions, then that is a cart before the horse argument. It isn't surprising that people of like mind and values might also have like political views. And since I assume you are referring to the LDS Church, remember, the Church never officially endorses any party or candidate. They make that clear frequently.

Ecclesiastes 10:2
PROVO, UT

Mayhem Mike - Many (most?) Evangelicals don't consider Catholics Christians either. They really want to have a very tightly restrictive club...which is fine with me. I'm comfortable with my religion and I don't need those people to tell me what I am or am not.

Michael J
SANDY, UT

RG it is not just the government that is full of wasteful spending in the name of helping people out churches do as well. I am the ward financial clerk and write checks every week for fast offering payments that I am sure you would agree are wasteful (large cell phone bills, cable television bills etc). Leaving welfare into the hands of the churches is not the way either.

RG
Buena Vista, VA

To Michael J
I agree that church welfare can waste money. I am the ward clerk and I write the checks too. In fact this is the 2nd time I've been a ward clerk. The first time was when I was a very poor grad student in another state 15 years ago, and I wrote checks for peoples' rent that lived in nice apartments that cost far more than our trailer that was falling apart. But I still say church welfare is far less wasteful than the government because it is overseen at a closer level, and all done by volunteers, so no overhead costs.

Locke
Rexburg, ID

I strongly object to the statement that "her Christian upbringing motivates her to vote Democrat, because of Jesus' teachings to care for the poor and love all people."

Jesus' admonitions were for individuals, NOT a prescription for government policies. In practice, conservatives demonstrate their care for the poor and love for all people by giving substantially more to charities than do liberals.

Lane Myer
Salt Lake City, UT

Locke
Rexburg, ID
I strongly object to the statement that "her Christian upbringing motivates her to vote Democrat, because of Jesus' teachings to care for the poor and love all people."

-------------

How can YOU object to what motivates another person? It might not motivate you, but you cannot object to how it affect another, can you?

That is a personal interpretation and she is justified in believing in it.

Twin Lights
Louisville, KY

Religious belief does not fully inform or govern political views. Good people, of honest heart and full faith and fellowship within their religious denomination do disagree on political matters and belong to different parties.

On a similar note, the First Presidency has said: "Latter-day Saints as citizens are to seek out and then uphold leaders who will act with integrity and are wise, good, and honest. Principles compatible with the gospel may be found in various political parties."

If we try to make our personal political opinions seem somehow endorsed by the church, we do both ourselves and the church a disservice.

If the Lord feels the need to expound His political preferences, then we will hear about it from the current First Presidency.

Absent that, we can safely assume we are to guide ourselves based on their last statement (see above).

sashabill
Morgan Hill, CA

There is nothing in Christian teaching which requires the use of the government as a mechanism for FORCING people to help the poor, especially if it results in generations of dependency.
I find it interesting that for liberals to consider themselves "Christian," taxpayers have to foot the bill.

Kevin J. Kirkham
Salt Lake City, UT

The political philosophy most closely aligned with the Gospel is libertarianism. It states that people should be free to do as they please as long as they do not harm the person, property or rights of others. We may not agree with the choices people make with their freedom/agency and we are free to use kindness, gentleness, meekness and love unfeigned to encourage righteous choices/behaviors. People should be free to reap the natural consequences of their choices and be free from others interfering (good or bad) in their receiving those consequences.

Other parties (GOP, Democrat, Constitution, Green, Socialist, etc...) all believe in using the force of government to impose their subjective ideas upon the population and punishing those who disobey. We must always remember that using force to obtain obedience is what Satan proposed. Libertarianism is the only one that rejects Satan's tactics.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments