Comments about ‘Robert Bennett: Americans are anchored in the center’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, Feb. 27 2012 12:00 a.m. MST

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Roland Kayser
Cottonwood Heights, UT

I'm an Eisenhower Republican. Another way of phrasing that is to say I'm a Democrat.

On the other hand
Spanish Fork, UT

Well said. Republicans would do well to choose a candidate they could live with and independents could feel good about rather than a candidate they love but who repulses independents.

Twin Lights
Louisville, KY

Senator Bennett,

From this and other pieces you have written it has become apparent to me that you are caring, intelligent, and politically astute. The nation is the worse for your loss.

Radicalism will not benefit either party and it will not benefit the nation (in part because it cannot lead the nation). Our politics favor center right or center left candidates. The farther up the food chain, the more this is true.

The ability to govern as president requires that person to be able to work effectively with both sides of the aisle. If they cannot, they will accomplish little. Our constitution requires some degree of unanimity for change to take place. And that is how it should be. A president who fully alienates the other side will accomplish nothing.

When selecting a president for our own party, one of the key issues should always be does the individual have a track record of working effectively with those of the other party?

ron holdaway
Draper, UT

General Eisenhower vied with Robert Taft for the 1952 nomination, not William Hioward Taft his father whop served as Presdient from 1908-1912 and wasd later the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

The Real Maverick
Orem, UT

Which is why the GOP has no chance in 2012. Which is why every week there is a different contestant in the GOP circus. One week it's Romney the other it's Santorum, etc.

They're trying too hard to appease their radical right tea party groups which turns everybody else off.

It's ultimately going to come down to this, does the GOP want to go back to it's moderate roots or continue on their current path of ultra-conservative destruction?

If they continue down the path, there's no election in the near future that they will win.

red state pride
Cottonwood Heights, UT

The campaign for the Democrat Presidential nomination in 2008 lasted until June so it's not like this is out of the ordinary.
I sort of understand Senator Bennett's point but there isn't a mythical "tea party" candidate in the remaining field. Other than Ron Paul the remaining candidates are basically centrist type Republicans. I know some Americans are frightened by Santorum because they don't understand that some people actually have values. The column doesn't say this but I guess it must imply that Barack Obama is a centrist. The tone of his voice is the only thing "moderate" about Obama. If you read what he says and observe his actions you'll understand that he is on the far left of the Democrat party (and that's Bernie Sanders territory).
Barack Obama said that he would cut the deficit in half (he increased it by at least 500 billion per year) Barack Obama told you with his stimulus plan unemployment would not go over 8%- it did. Barack Obama promised you that you would not lose your health insurance coverage under Obamacare- you will if you haven't already. Don't listen to the words- look at the actions and results.

pragmatistferlife
salt lake city, utah

There are a few things in life I've changed my mind about..but not too many. I've voted both republican and democratic yet I don't consider myself an independent. Tom Friedman nailed it perfectly for me when he coined the pharse a "radical moderate". For me the term radical denotes my acceptance of reality and the public policies that reality requires.

A country with hundreds of millions of citizens, more races, ethnicitys, life styles, and philosophys than can be counted. A nation with an economy that is moving towards a post industrial phase, and symbiotically linked to the economies of the rest of the world. A nation with a society where a majority of its wealth is concentrated in the hands of a small minority of it's citizens, simply must be governed and run differently than an argarian society of a few hundred thousand white men in order to survive.

This might not be the way some think the world and country should look, but it does. So what does the middle look like policy wise..it accepts reality, and honors the desire of the founders to allow all, life liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

ShaunMcC
La Verkin, UT

Senator Bennett is unfortunately correct in most of his assertions. Much of the electorate make their choices based on what the media tells them is acceptable and most of the media hates true conservatism and true constitutionalism. Where he is wrong is stating that only centrist candidates CAN be elected once they are nominated. His old position is now held by a very effective true constitutionalist. We have a president who is an extreme liberal (albeit he talks like a moderate conservative when it serves). A growing number of congresspeople espouse extreme positions on both ends of the spectrum and are still elected. As we as a nation move closer and closer to economic and societal disaster, those who are less "status-quo" and more "extreme" will become more prominent as new solutions become more imperative. Yes, we want a new Reagan. Someone who, by force of their very nature, can bring most of us together as Americans. Yes he was conservative, but even centrist liberals liked him because they saw his love for the country and his acceptance of them even as he rejected their approaches. Too bad we don't have one like him right now.

1conservative
WEST VALLEY CITY, UT

At some point we will be forced to stop "compromising" and just pay for our debt.

That can either happen with (both) political parties facing reality, or wait until our debt is foreclosed on by our creditors!

Yes, it will be painful, but the alternative is financial chaos!

Brother Chuck Schroeder
A Tropical Paradise USA, FL

Truth's from a Eisenhower Republican, "ME".

Seeing we got rain in forecast that moves Daytona 500 to 7 p.m. start, I'll address this right now. In todays world all bureaucrats and politicians treat us "common folk" like monkey's in a zoo. Why does politicians treat us like monkeys in a zoo?. Oh, they'll show up at your work place for a photo opp, then run out of the building as fast as they can, in fear you'll toss some poo at them, as a monkey would do, because you know what they really are. That's because politicians are elite, these politicians are rich Ideas for the untra-elite only, they are out of control and the politicians that run us are out of touch with reality also. They never ate a TV dinner, their strippers don't have strech-marks, their stupid rules take up valuable time and energy from business owners who have to understand and implement their requirements, time and energy that could be better spent serving their customers, expanding their businesses and maybe actually hiring more workers, reducing the high unemployment rate in this country. Who is responsible for these out of control government regulations?. It is the out of touch GOP politicians who concoct these stupid rules and laws with no sensitivity or experience on how the waste ripples through the economic system, hurting everyone in the process. Madness for the Koch Brother's. The United States government has maintained a ridiculous trade embargo with the island nation of Cuba for about 50 years in an attempt to force Fidel Castro from power. However, 50 years later, Castro is still in power, many of the Presidents who continued the embargo are themselves dead, the United States deprives itself of a good sized economic market right off its shores, and the Cuban people have lived in poverty for 50 years, especially since the fall of the Iron Curtain when the support from Russia dropped dramatically. Typical U.S. government program never ending, never accomplishing its goals, and the people of both countries worse off for the experience. Why do you keep electing them then?. Sorry Robert Bennett, For the Deseret News, that's why "YOU" were excommunicated by GOP and the Tea Party. "Americans are anchored in the center with their hands tied until re-election time comes around."

pragmatistferlife
salt lake city, utah

Red State, the only way Obama looks like he's on the far left of the democratic party is is you are so far right that the horizon is somehwere in the middle.

The Politics of Listening
A Tropical Paradise USA, FL

Why do you keep electing them then?. Same with Robert Bennett, For the Deseret News, that's why "YOU" were excommunicated by GOP and the Tea Party. "Americans are anchored in the zoo with the center of their hands tied until re-election time comes around." Then you rattle their cage's and toss them some monkey earmarks for peanuts for votes. And he's a researcher and lecturer at the University of Utah's Hinckley Institute of Politics ?. "HA!." Senator Hatch is the ranking member of the Senate Committee on Finance for almost 40 years, where he has been a leading advocate for policies to encourage savings and investment for the rich only, such as the Capital Formation Act, and many other pro-growth tax bills for the Koch Brother's. Why nothing gets done in Washington DC while they get paid for it. My staff and Sen. Mike Lee want my Washington D.C. office to be a place where visitors from Utah feel at home. Every Wednesday at 3:30 p.m., we host "Jell-O with the Senator." All are invited to come meet me and enjoy a serving of Utah's official state snack. How about Congress starts repealing the commodities modernization act ?. For better or worse the Magic 8 Ball has made more decisions for more people than the president and congress combined. Let's also ban a crooked culture hidden under the heavy dirty dust of politics corruption and crony capitalism the Koch Brother's and their Ethanol 15 and the 54 ethanol manufacturers, plus K Street and Wall Street Corporate sneakiness and their outright-scams and con-games, more corruption and crony capitalism in Congress along with insider trading, crooked offshore tax safe havens in secret bank accounts that they invested in up-market homes and hotels, tons of loopholes that allow qualifying Institutions to still serve as conduits for Tax Evasion, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae that caused the mortgage meltdown and toss the crooks in prison, this commodities modernization act helped create the ENRON debacle and is still having repercussions on the US and World economies with ill conceived market trades. Ex-Sen. Phil Gramm is credited with the ENRON language of the bill, but what about the other proposals that negated 'bucket shop' laws in the states? Who stood to gain then, as now? And did these self same greedy capitalists (lobbyists and lawmakers) conspire to 'help' Congress again with the $700 billion bailout of financial institutions in 2008? I think whoever drafted this proposal should be sent to prison and stripped of any and all wealth they amassed. This statute is now being high-lighted as one of the main causes of the financial crisis we are sliding into. Another Wall Street oil price swing?. IT'S TIME we all put the breaks on it. With our Congressman and Senator and tell them to do this. Gas prices most places are pushing $4 a gallon again. And news reports say it could be $5 or more by summertime. That's outrageous and unjustified. We've also got to stop a new brand of oil trader who has emerged in the last decade, a middle man of sorts, who's also driving up the price we pay at the pump. Many experts agree we should not allow these traders to bid up the price of oil and flip futures contracts like condos. Yet in the last ten years the share of the oil market controlled by investors and speculators has more than doubled. By bidding up oil futures, speculators also increase costs for our airlines, industrial energy users and other businesses. And these higher costs are passed on to consumers like you and me. The GOP Congress deregulated oil traders in December 2000. And it hasn't tackled a comprehensive alternative energy policy since Nixon and Carter first talked about one in the 1970s. I think Congress should pass legislation that aims to drastically limit the ability of speculators to artificially drive up energy prices.

red state pride
Cottonwood Heights, UT

@pragamatist for life - is that why your man went to the Summit of the Americas and gave Hugo Chavez a fistbump and called him "mi amigo"? Is that why his "affordable healthcare act" authorized the hiring of 16,000 new IRS agents but didn't hire one doctor or nurse?
You might want to wake up and smell the coffee before it's too late

Riles
Midway, UT

Former senator, your editorial hangs on the premise that the voters are always right...that "might (or majority) makes right". History proves that the philosophies of the center never inspire. One very prominent man even suggested the "lukewarm" middle was good only to be spewed out, prefering instead to judge between the hot and cold ideologies of those with principles to govern their actions. For better or worse I will always and only vote on principle and continually fight within the established system to upend the boring and ultimately erosive effects of centrist political philosophy.

TRUTH
Salt Lake City, UT

I dont care who runs.....PeeWee Herman could beat Obama! Even Jessie Jackson refers to Obama with pride as the "Food Stamp President"! Only a fool would vote for Obama whose answer to high gas prices is...."pump up your tires". the most embarassing moment Obama has brought to the USA is when he apologises to Karzai after Muslims killed our own American Soldiers! Disgraceful! This guy is out of control and hasn't a clue how to lead!

patriot
Cedar Hills, UT

Here is reality - sorry Bob. America is NO LONGER a center right country. If it were then far left wacko's like Obama , Pelosi, Maxine Waters , etc... would NEVER get elected. The fact that these people continue to get elected makes clear the sad fact that more than 50% of America is left of center and a large portion of those are socialist, welfare state want-to-bee's just like the bankrupt country of Greece. There is a slushy 10% that may still vote for the GOP depending how bad the economy is. America is no longer the great country it used to be back in the 1940's and 1950's. The Hippie movement of 60's started the change toward socialist Europe and every passing decade we become more like our friends across the Atlantic. The end result will be a totally BANKRUPT American - burning cars in the street as we demand our entitlements ... which idiots like Obama promised to get elected but now can't deliver... like Greece. Those who don't learn from the past are bound to repeat it!! Who said that anyway?? In our case - those who don't see what is happening to Greece and other socialist republics in Europe and LEARN from them are bound to BECOME THEM!!!

TRUTH
Salt Lake City, UT

Democrats are in serious trouble:

Jessie Jackson calls Obama, Food Stamp President...
High gas prices?.....Obama says, No need to drill, Just pump up your tires....
Democrat Rep explains Obamacare includes free contraception, but no free bandaids or cancer screenings, as they are not as important..
American Soldiers dead, Obama apologizes....

America may be in the middle Bob but its starting to look as though Utah is just one of the other 50 red state

UT Brit
London, England

Ha, American politics is so skewed to the right compared to the rest of the world that Obama would be classed as right of centre anywhere else. Everyone describing Obama as a "liberal lefty" obviously have no clue about politics outside the country.

TRUTH
Salt Lake City, UT

Utah may have been one of the only red states in 2008.....but if this is a shift to the middle that Bob speaks of....the Democrat Liberals are in deep trouble!

Obama answer to $5 Gas? Dont drill,just pump up your tires.
Jessie Jackson calls Obama the "Food Stamp President"!
American soldiers die in Afghanistan? ...Obama apologizes for the behavior of our soldiers!
Demo rep says Obamacare provides free contraception, but not free bandaids or Cancer screenings because they are not important healthcare items like contraception.
Media Matters President caught in Blackmail scandal....
Breitbart reports, In 2008, then-candidate Barack Obama admitted that, like his future Energy Secretary Mr. Chu, he believed that high gas prices would be a good thing because they would force Americans to ween themselves off of oil? Really...is this the leadership we want....someone who is trying to raise the cost of gas artificially so that alternatives like solyndra and others can get free govt money and go bankrupt!

NOBAMA 2012...or any other Democrat for that matter!

pragmatistferlife
salt lake city, utah

Red State, "is that why your man went to the Summit of the Americas and gave Hugo Chavez a fistbump and called him "mi amigo"? Is that why his "affordable healthcare act" authorized the hiring of 16,000 new IRS agents but didn't hire one doctor or nurse?" A fist pump???are you kidding? That puts him on the far left..seriously? If Obama were on the far left the affordable health care act would have been a single payer system, the bailouts and tarp would never have happened and instead the bakns would have been nationalized. There would have been no surge in Afhgannistan just immediate withdrawal. I could go on and on but this is just silly. Obama is firmly encamped in the left of center.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments