Comments about ‘Blue roundup: BYU vs. So. Miss or SMU in bowl game?’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, Oct. 24 2011 1:00 p.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Clearfield, UT

BYU hasn't played either team in a while, so either one would be something fun and new, but a BYU/SMU bowl game rematch would be great.

Portland Trail Blazers
Sandy, UT

Ute "fans"/trolls have no right of coming on her and making comments.

By the way it's looking, Utah will not even be going to a bowl game.

Provo, UT

Let's play SMU, they're not as good as So. Miss so it will fit in well with this year's slate of games...

Tooele, UT

How can they predict that in the Las Vegas bowl it will be TCU against Utah?

Band Of Roscoes
Salt Lake City, UT

So either SMU or SMU?

I hope its the Southern Methodist as they got invited to a BCS conference. Let's see what they're about.

Salt Lake City, UT

Since when is beating an FCS (1-AA) opponent making a team bowl worthy?

Beverly Hills, CA

MJB | 2:40 p.m. Oct. 24, 2011
Tooele, UT
How can they predict that in the Las Vegas bowl it will be TCU against Utah?


They can predict that the Utes can go anywhere. They predicted that the Utes would be in the PAC 10/2 championship game, and where did that get them.

At least BYU will go to a bowl.

The Utes ended their season after the BYU game.


The NCAA started a few years ago allowing wins against FCS opponents count in the win category for bowl eligibility. There was a close call about five years ago when because of so many bowls, there almost was not enough teams to play. It is all watered down anyway and no one has the ability to say "we're number one" because of lack of a playoff. And that might open up a whole discussion!

Beverly Hills, CA

SLC BYU Fan | 2:46 p.m. Oct. 24, 2011
Salt Lake City, UT
Since when is beating an FCS (1-AA) opponent making a team bowl worthy?



It doesn't matter when you beat the FCS team. Many teams get those wins early in the season.

Omaha, NE

Agree. No Ute should be on here giving bowling advice when they aren't even going to one.

Who knows how they picked Utah to play TCU. Seriously, ESPN has some of the worst "experts" I've ever seen. I don't know how they pick Alabama to play for the NC. LSU is such a better team.

BYU should play the best team. It's always better to play the better team, especially if it's a CUSA opponent. Would Bronco really want to play the second place team when they can play the first? "We're thrilled to see our guys execute vs a lower level CUSA team. It will be a great matchup." He'd never say that. We all know he'd want the better team.

Omaha, NE

"Since when is beating an FCS (1-AA) opponent making a team bowl worthy?"

When a team has already beaten schools from the PAC, SEC, CUSA, and WAC (albeit two of the worst).

Johnny Triumph
American Fork, UT

Bring it! BYU v SMU would be fun, plus that June Jones coached Hawaii all those years.

Boise, ID

Either team should provide a good challenge for BYU and should make for a great game. Who knows, a win in the bowl may put BYU back into the top25.

Eagle Mountain, UT

slc BYU fan
Since it was accompanied by 5 other victories.

West Jordan, UT

I would love to see a rematch of the 1980 Miracle Bowl with SMU except for the fact that the Armed Forces Bowl is being played on SMU's home field due to stadium renovations at TCU. I would rather the Cougars play their bowl game on a neutral field so I hope they get Southern Miss.

Washington, UT

Whoop-ti-do-da...... Armed Forces Bowl? Give me a break When it comes down to it the only bowl games I care about are:

Rose Bowl
Orange Bowl
Fiesta Bowl
Sugar Bowl(New Orleans-National Championship)

The other Bowls are a waste of space and teams and that includes byu & utah, and if Utah makes a bowl game this year without a QB, then I will sit in my birthday suit on top of Eagle gate!

Frisco, TX

Utes get to count their win against Montana State, a FCS (1-AA) team, and they still may not have enough wins to qualify for a bowl.

FBS teams can count one win against an FCS team towards their bowl eligibility, but if they play two FCS teams, they can still only count one.

Liberty Bowl gets Conf USA winner. Armed Forces Bowl gets Conf USA #3 pick.

Houston will likely win the conference. Southern Miss and SMU are both good teams this year, but Tulsa could be in the running also. Even though they are 4-3, their 3 loses are to Oklahoma, Oklahoma St, and Boise St - all Top 10, non-conference teams. Any of the three will be far better opponents than last years UTEP match-up.

As much as I dislike the Ute trolls, I hope Utah gets bowl eligible. That would be a black eye against the program and the state to have a losing record in their first year in an AQ conference.

Salt Lake City, UT

"The NCAA allows one victory per season over a Division I FCS (formerly I-AA) team to count toward an FBS team's bowl eligibility".

The Deuce
Livermore, CA

BYU is far away from a credible bowl game. I can't believe that a team with the schedule that BYU has played this year would be even considered for a bowl game. Yes, many of the larger schools play less well known teams at the beginning of the season, not in the middle of the season. This was once a very strong program and now has just about dropped out of sight. It is time to take a closer look at where this program is going and the coaching staff.

Where's Stockton ???
Bowling Green, OH

A rematch with SMU would be ok with me...Love to see the plug get pulled on Craig James anytime.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments