Quantcast

Comments about ‘UVU president Matthew Holland speaks to LDS students on being 'in the world but not of the world'’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, Sept. 19 2011 7:38 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
watcher@75
SMITHFIELD, UT

Thank you Anne Squire for a well written article. Your reporting boosted the idea that spiritual learning and secular learning are compatible in today's divisive world. Christ is the Key to all learning. He will never give conflicting information, nor cause confusion, or even dilute His own work and glory. His learning is out of the best books, coupled with prayer, and discovered by the power of the Holy Ghost. Excellent article.

Brianwp
SANDY, UT

As you pursue this education, you will find things to which you disagree that will challenge things that you felt in the past. Guard against new ideas that (will) lead you down the path to accepting that which goes against the teachings of the Lord.

This right here is probably the worst piece of educational advice I have ever heard given. What is education if not to challenge ones previous notions about life? Is Holland really telling students to remain ignorant? to guard against notions that go against church doctrine, and ignore what professors and experts have to say? I understand balancing faith and morality with education, but to let ones religion blockade your mind and prohibit new possible discoveries is arrogant and regressive.

Think of this, what if Joseph Smith had "guarded against new ideas" which led him down different paths?

CHS 85
Sandy, UT

Was this BYU's graduation, or UVU?

Esquire
Springville, UT

The leader of a secular institution giving a religious speech at that same institution. While the message may be good and appropriate, I wonder if the messenger was appropriate. It is, frankly, insensitive to non-LDS students who attend this state school. I guess it shows there is no separation of church and state in Utah.

Montana Mormon
Miles City, MT

The event was hosted by the LDSSA, a recognized campus student organization. In fact, many public colleges and universities have LDSSA chapters, especially those that have an Institute of Religion adjacent to the campus. All LDSSA chapters are approved and recognized by the leadership of the associated students of the respective college or university. The UVU students who are not members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints would have known that the LDSSA was hosting this event and that the university president and his wife would have been speaking from the perspective of their religious affiliation. Consequently, they had the freedom to opt out of the event, or walk out if they had attended and found the president's and his wife's comments offensive. I don't see how this would have been insensitive to anyone given the circumstances I have just outlined.

nmsunshine
ALBUQUERQUE, NM

I agree with Montana Mormon.

speed66
Heber City, UT

Given the venue and event, I see no problem with him participating. I also didn't see anything in his "talk" that was either enlightening or controversial.

The posts about the event is a different story. Suggesting that there is no conflict between faith and reason is a stretch and a clear sign that a person hasn't done a lot of study.

A simple study of ancient texts, teachings and beliefs is enough to call into question many of the so-called beliefs that are held today. For those who believe the bible is literally true, then an education can be a illuminating event. Geology, biology, sociology can all be disturbing to those who have never venture outside the cave of evangelical-styled religion.

That is not to say that religion and science can't co-exist. They can...provided you don't spend much time reading the text upon which religions are based.

mightymite
DRAPER, UT

Perhaps the Prez should not be so polorized with his mormonism. He has a university to run and plenty of them are not LDS. With all do respect would he ever attend a GLBT event to lift the spirits of others? Better choices need to be made but after all this is Utah.....

itsmary
LAS VEGAS, NV

I don't know why the fretters must fret so. This was an event for LDS students and anyone else who wished to attend, and was not an event for anyone else. There are a fair number of LDS students at UVU, and an event for them seems reasonable. Hearing from the institution's president seems reasonable from the student point of view. Speaking at such an event seems reasonable for the president. However, he must have had a difficult decision: Do I turn down the invitation because people will comment negatively? Do I accept at the risk of alienating groups who didn't ask me to speak? Can I participate in an event with students when my role in that event is not to act as university president indoctrinating subordinates? What can I do to cause no controversy? Well, I suppose I could be dead 10 or 15 years and no longer upset these fine Deseret News readers. . . .

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments