Comments about ‘Utah and BYU commits excited for change’

Return to article »

Published: Friday, July 1 2011 4:13 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
BlueSaint
South Jordan, UT

BYU will get more exposure, while the Utes will just get exposed!

Y Grad / Y Dad
Richland, WA

"Now, much more good Christian kids with high standards will become aware of BYU, and that will be a great thing for the program."

So let it be done!

Y Grad / Y Dad
Richland, WA

"BYU has a great winning tradition, and now everyone will be aware of that tradition," added Wolford. "Everyone in the country will come to learn about BYU which will bring great exposure for the other great things about the program."

I hope this young man is as good an athlete as he is a quote. He sees with a very clear perspective.

hedgehog
Ann Arbor, MI

"It's just an incredible thing, it's awesome to think that I'll be able to play in the Pac-12 with being able to play so close to home."
"All we have to do is win our conference now," "If you can compete well in a conference like the Pac-12, then you can compete with anyone in the nation."

Chase Hasen: Former BYU Legacy

Farid @ Pocatello
Pocatello, ID

The next few years will be fascinating for both programs.

With equal success, though, I think BYU will have the long-term advantage. If BYU again becomes a 10-win team, even more of their games will be on ESPN and the Idaho State's on their schedule (my alma mater) will quickly turn into quality BCS teams. This will draw even more stellar non-LDS players and the team will get even better, making them still more attractive to ESPN.

If Utah has the same success, though, if they continue their 10-win ways, they will still be a second-tier PAC-12 team (in terms of a national following, not potential championships). A fifth-ranked Utah team won't draw a fraction of the TV audience that a 15th ranked BYU would. I grew up a non-member in D.C. and watched BYU all the time. I couldn't have told you, however, what Utah's team colors were.

The reality of the relationship is that Utah is the woman and BYU the man. The woman has be twice as good to get half the recognition. That is the impediment that Utah faces.

Not fair, but true.

CougarBlue
Heber City, UT

Great for both schools and the state of Utah. I think BYU will have a struggle each year to get quality teams to play them once their conference schedules have started. The conferences frown on that.

Real Bass
Idaho Falls, ID

Sorry Chase, but you will have graduated before the u sniffs a conference
championship!

nomad1
American Fork, UT

Congrats to both Utah and byu. Big brother has gotten married and little brother turned 16 and can now date.

JMT
Springville, UT

Nomad, haha!

Both teams have a bright future. Utah has a tougher route per se but BYU has a very tough schedule. They place the SEC, Big 10, PAC12, and ACC I believe. Throw in Norte Dame and a bunch of Idaho St's and they are going to be hard pressed to win 10-games.

I think Utah will attract a great crowd if they go 10-2, no problem. BYU will definitely get a broader national audience, if they win the big games. This year Ole Miss and Texas to start the season.

Both teams have the world of opportunity via a very tough road.

Go BYU!

One Nil to the Arsenal!
Gilbert, AZ

I think it's going to be the other way around Blue Saint. Remember, no body will see us. But you can guarantee the whole country will see what TCU does to you at Texas Stadium, OR what Texas does to you at Texas Memorial. It's going to be ugly....LOL (threw that one in for Ducky)

Y Grad / Y Dad
Richland, WA

Nomad1

After the banter is done, it is interesting. Utah has been higher and lower, at least until last year, in which I am still in denial.

Going forward, I think BYU has the greater potential for lows, but also for highs. Marquee teams really share the glory with their conference, for good and bad. MWC marquee teams, like Utah, TCU, and yes, BYU, were shackled by their conference. On the other end, USC is marquee, but was pretty easily surpassed by Oregon.

Notre Dame though is literally in a league all by itself. And despite all the mocking that will ensue, BYU has a chance to do similarly. Mediocre to good seasons will look like Army or Navy: you know who they are but you don't care. Very good to great seasons ( yes, we have had them and we will again), will begin increasingly to look like Notre Dame in the good years.

Your thoughts?

GACougar
Atlanta, GA

"All we have to do is win our conference now," "If you can compete well in a conference like the Pac-12, then you can compete with anyone in the nation."

And therein lies the problem. While it is impossible to know the future, the past usually gives a good indication of what one can expect. And the past paints a pretty troubling picture for the Utes.

First of all, you can throw out anything that happened prior to Whittingham becoming coach. Oscar Meyer can't help you anymore. It is all up to Whttingham now and his past does not encourage great optimism.

In six tries in the mighty MWC, Whittingham was only able to win one conference championship. He finished 2nd one other time. The other four tries he came in 3rd or lower. And that was in the MWC.

Now what does this indicate for the future in the pac 10.2? Only time will tell. But if you can only win it all in the MWC once in six tries, what can you realistically expect in the pac?

This could get very ugly. Time will tell.

September 17th can't get here soon enough.

Idaho Coug
Meridian, Idaho

Both schools are in a better situation today than they were a year ago. What more can fans ask for?

idablu
Idaho Falls, ID

I'm going against the sentiment of my cougar brethren here, but, I think Utah is going to fair very well in the PAC 12. They'll have good years and down years just like everyone else and they'll win the conference every once in awhile. . . I just don't think they'll do it with their current QB. Winning a BCS game IS a big deal, despite what many of the detractors on here say, and Utah deserved to be let into the conference, and yes, I am jealous of that. Utah will NOT be a bottom dweller like WSU. I think Coach Whit will be contending for the title more often than not.

I think an honest observer would admit that Utah has a much better chance of playing in a BCS and playing for a NC than BYU does in their respective situations, and I think that gives them an edge in recruiting.

I am no fan of Utah but I think many posters here give the PAC way to much credit, saying Utah won't compete in the PAC12. Over the past several years MWC teams-and especially Utah-has faired very well against PAC teams.

idablu
Idaho Falls, ID

(continued)
Having said that, I think BYU and Utah are about as even as you can possibly be as football programs recently. Since the time I was in college, BYU has been the dominant team, but Utah has definitely proven themselves on the national scene this decade, and they have clearly caught up to BYU.

Strictly In terms of football success, I think the future is very bright for both BYU and Utah, but a little brighter for Utah because there is a lot more security and opportunity in being in a BCS conference. Head to head I think Utah and BYU will be 50/50 over the next decade, which is a credit to BYU's coaching staff considering the limitations on the types of recruits BYU can attract.

Now can we stop all the childish bickering and smack? This is why I'd be perfectly fine with the rivalry ending.

Gene Hinds
Redlands, CA

Utah, and Colorado, will take years to compete in the new PAC 12.
Must look outside football. The other sports, too.
SC, Washington, Oregon and Arizon schools, even UCLA, are licking their chops.
The above schools have in place a high school recruit pipeline that Colorado and Utah will have a difficult time breaking into.
No excuses when the season fails them. Suck it up.

Tommy2Shoes
Lehi, UT

Recruits are excited. Fans are rabid. Kick off getting closer as the dog days of summer approach. Maybe I'll go out and catch a Bees or Owls game. Have a wonderful 4th of July. God bless and protect America and the troops.

Duckhunted
highland, utah

one loss byu has their season done, as far as the BCS is concerned!!if UTAH loses 3 but wins the conference its Rose Bowl!!independence is the cougar no one wants to go home with!!

Brettski2024
Concord, CA

Keep spinning it cougar fans... Whatever makes you sleep better at night. The PAC12 is where any school west of Nebraska wants to be.

Riverton Cougar
Riverton, Utah

We BYU fans want Utah to do well, and Utah fans want BYU to do well! How much better could it get than if one team was 11-1 and the other 12-0 in the regular season? If Utah does poorly then it reflects poorly on BYU as well. Not to mention it strengthens the BCS's argument that the best non-AQ teams (BYU. TCU, Utah, Boise State) can't compete with BCS teams week in and week out. Both teams have the opportunity to prove that wrong! One or the other doing poorly only reflects on the other and weakens their SOS. Let's cheer each other on, guys! Friendly banter back and forth is fun, but let's cut all the hate.

"if UTAH loses 3 but wins the conference its Rose Bowl!!"

And then the BCS loses even more credibility (see UConn 2010).

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments