Quantcast

Comments about ‘Mountain lion kills family's dog’

Return to article »

Published: Wednesday, Dec. 30 2009 12:00 a.m. MST

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
beni

I think this this is a shame.

Pat T

It's upsetting that this beautiful animal had to die because someone didn't take proper precautions to keep their dog safe.

Sad thing is

The division of wildlife will investigate this and attempt to press charges. There are way to many lions around and the state doesn't do a thing about them. The state is in love with the mountain lion....

CLH

Read the story,,,the mountain lion was at his home! Thank God it was their dog and not their child that was outside! If it was his child would you peop;e still be so willing to pass judgement on a man protecting his family and property??

Irvin

Pressing charges is stupid. The man was protecting his property.

Anonymous

Goodness! Poor little Yorkie! But it was a blessing that the Cougar didn't attack a human member of the family. And that man did have a right to shoot the predator in self defense, and especially on his property.

And this is the opinion of a graduate of Kearns High School and BYU, in which the Cougar is the mascot of both schools. I also love Cougars and other wildlife, but the man was right to do what he did.

Protecting good, but understand

People do come over animals, but we can all do better to see this as not mutually exclusive except in such cases of physical safety. There is room for more of us and more of them, but it does require more discipline on our part to be more self contained and responsd responsibly. It is clear in any case of self defense that who the winner should be, but we all know who the "winner" would be in a "contest" by shear massive numbers and it is happening all to often and not just with the mountain lion. We have to be aggressive political thinkers about how our increasing presence will not repeat past mistakes and still manage to keep both our interests (which for humans who can choose) will have to adapt. Prosecuting is wrong if we are talking about protecing people in reasonable places, but what about unreasonably placed homes and properties? I'm not saying this person's was, but often they are and dead "property" is not more important than living beings we must learn how to share it with. Property is human defined, but humans make profound mis-definitions all the time. Rethink property.

Too Many!

As a hunter, there are way too many mountain lions around the State. The DWR needs to issue hundreds more kill tags.

RT

It is true, the wildlife was here first, but as we have in the past, we will in the future, continue to develope and inhabit new territory. Wolves and Mountain Lions need to recognize us as a threat. As with this particular case, the Lion came into an area developed more than a century ago. He apparently was thinking Humans and their pets were easier prey than deer, elk, rabbits, and such.
The dog owner was justified in the kill. The only result of any kind of hassle from government agencies, will be the lesson taught to the rest of us....Don't report the event.

If people

are going to live in the natural habitat of Mountain Lions, then they need to keep that in mind.
I am so sorry they lost a family member (the Yorkie), I would feel awful if this happened to my little baby.
But the lady's comments about the cat coming "in her yard" were ludicrous.
As longs as humans continue to encroach on the natural hunting area if predators, we should not be surprised when this type of thing happens.

Clem

Once again, the government's failure to protect the public from mountain lions has resuted in tragedy.

Resident

Maybe the fish and game should look at this problem I have lived in Oakley all my life and growing up never seen a cougar in the river bottoms. The problem is they are getting over populated and are moving into neighborhoods instead staying in the mountains. Maybe all these rich people building in the mountains where they don't belong need to go back where they come from and quit building where the wildlife live.

Cougar's Habitat

While, I am so sorry for the loss this family has suffered, they need to remember they chose to live in the Cougar's habitat and hunting grounds. The Cougar was only doing what comes naturally to it, so it should come as no surprise to the dog's owner. The owner was probably justified in killing the cougar but this is also very sad.

desrtrat

Give me a break, you choose to live in cougar country, be prepared to be bitten. Don't leave your dog out unattended. Are you telling me you let your child wander around the woods unattended? If you choose to live in the outdoors, that is exactly what it is. I am very sympathetic because I too chose to move into "cougar" country as a Utes fan and I deal with their obnoxious behavior every day but I don't shoot them?

Go Pat

I am with Pat. What can one expect living in the mountains that there will not be any wildlife? If someone was watching their dog, this incident may have been prevented.

rburg

The answer, as suggested above, is the 3 S method. You Shoot, Shovel, and Shut up. Desrtrat says you should prepare to be bitten. I assume he's a city dweller. Lions don't bite like a dog. They bite to kill and eat you.

desrtrat

re:rburg
You're disregard for our mother Earth is disturbing. You need to visit other places around the globe to appreciate what we have here in our country. We have opportunities and a quality of life that far surpasses those of most other countries around the globe because most of us at least try to preserve a link to our creator.
You are correct, I do live in the city at this stage in my life. That might be in part because of my contempt for the "me, me" attitude displayed by a goodly amount of the folks living in the rural areas of Southern Utah.
I've lived in towns so small in Southern Utah that you wouldn't even know what to do if you lived there. After a couple of days you'd be whining because you had to take your garbage 5 miles to deposit it or because you had to drive 60 miles because you forgot to gas up before the local gas station closed at 5 pm. Sorry rburg, no fresh Sushi in that town for you.
Once again, choose to live in cougar country, choose to deal with the consequences.

Andy

I had a friend that brought back some lion meat from CO- it's pretty tasty- just like sushi.

peachychris

people make comments and judgements without facts. none of us can accurately comment on this without facts. these are biased opinions only.

vonfatman

rburg and sushi. What a leap! Get a life huh? When I read such tripe I just laugh. "Mother Earth" huh? Geesh.

I live in Cougar country...they are moving in...and I will not hesitate to whack every one I come across. They are predators that do not belong near people. Oh, did I mention d-rat that I value people (well not you specifically but most sensible people) above animals.

The killing of the cat was totally justified and I hope no charges are filed...

vf

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments