Reader comments
Salt Lake City seeks input on gay-resident protections
113 comments | Read story
Why should gay and lesbian emotionally challenged individuals have more rights and freedoms than the rest of the american people? These laws are very damaging to everyone's rights and discrimination is only a figment of their imagination and self guilt for their unnatural lifestyles. They use their guilt as a crutch to blame others for what they are ashamed of.
Renters all ready have enough laws on their side.
This is Utah, Gays have no rights. Not a single one. This state works extremely hard to deny these human being ANY civil rights.
And "We all ready have discrimination law." Yes, that is the point, Utah laws discriminate against Gays & Lesbians and denies them equality under the law, without a single "ANTI-Discrimination" protection.
Due to the facts, proven by Salt Lake City's report, Gays & Lesbians are discriminated in housing and in the workplace, not for performance, but because of their existence offends someone else.
The moral thing to do is to protect everyone against discrimination, without excuse. Particularly when the facts prove a particular group is unfairly & disproportionately discriminated against.
And it is still legal to fire & evict someone because they are gay in Utah.
Great protection.
Discrimination is not protected under freedom of speech.
Think this law is unfair? Tell your boss or landlord you are gay. When they fire and evict you, please remember how you were against this.
Spoken like a true landlord.
If your of the mindset that:
'Oh, no! That's leftist propaganda!' Then you are the problem.
This was not done by 'Q' magazine or somesuch. This was done by the city of Salt Lake. The capital to one of the most conservative states in the country. Utah.
They have no 'agenda.' They went by the facts. And the fact is discrimination is alive and well in Utah.
Think these laws are unfair? Tell someone your gay.
I doubt you are aware of how much discrimination is protected in this state. I doubt many would have the courage to do it and the stamina to endure it.
So, please, if you think the gay community has nothing to fear being a legally discriminated class in America, tell someone you are gay.
I dare you.
I know of one gentleman (Theater Director) who resigned of his own free will. Who are these supposed people who lost their jobs? How many?
This is wrong, IF it actually happened. But two wrongs don't make a right, and those folks have laws to protect them.
Studies show, factually, that Gays & Lesbians loose their jobs due to discrimination. It seems a bit hypocritical to complain about one group (supposedly) loosing their job unfairly and then be against another group (factually supported) loosing their job unfairly.
Your candor is refreshing. Basically - "I don't like Gay people and I want to discriminate against another human being, simply because I want to."
Your post is filled full of misinformation and ugly prejudice, but at least you told the truth.
Probably the 13,000 people discharged under Don't ask, Don't tell.
But I still support the legislation! Good luck!
"Why should gay and lesbian emotionally challenged individuals have more rights and freedoms than the rest of the american people? These laws are very damaging to everyone's rights and discrimination is only a figment of their imagination and self guilt for their unnatural lifestyles. They use their guilt as a crutch to blame others for what they are ashamed of. "
"lose more rights" did you mean "Buttars"??
NUMBER ONE: we will not have "MORE RIGHTS". we will have ONE MORE right that we currently do not have.
NUMBER TWO: it was determined at some point in the 70s we are not mentally ill.
NUMBER THREE: WE ARE DISCRIMINATED AGAINST!! who are you kidding? ( utahrez: please!)
To reference a quote I recently found in QSalt Lake..
why you just might win the "best looking rear in logic pants award!!"
dear "landlord" do tell what amazing amount of tenant rights you speak of that Utah tenants have, period!
I'm sure your tenant was feeling the "too many laws on his side" when he slipped on the rent for ONE MONTH and you began eviction. That sure sounds like far too much leniency for tenants!!
My question is why do you feel that religion should be covered? Why do they get a special class? Why do blacks or latinos have a "special class"? All it is doing is limiting other peoples freedoms.
When you personally get fired and evicted for being a straight white LDS man, then you will understand what gay people go through EVERYDAY in this country.
No one will falsely accuse you of being narcissitic!
First off, SLC is such a small market that a good employee will think twice before filing something like this because, regardless of what the law says, they don't want to get a reputation for suing their employers. So the people who take advantage of anti-discrimination laws are usually lousy employees who were underqualified in the first place and only got the job because they were a minority. Then when they get fired for being a lousy employee, they bring a discrimination suit. The minorities that are good employees have too much to lose by bringing such a suit so the people who are least entitled to relief are usually the only one's who benefit.
Second, a $500 to $1000 fine is a slap on the wrist and not worth the company's time. This might get some positive press, but won't really make any difference.
And yet, almost a graduate, your doing so now.
'Do landlords actually ask the question "Are you gay or strait?"
No. The question is phrased. 'Are you married?'
'Being gay doesn't trump being a good citizen.'
Too true! I agree.
Now, about being TREATED as a good citizen....
The constitution does protect all americans. And yet local authorities choose to ignore or insult any claims about discrimination due to orientation. Like you are doing. State and federal protections are needed to ensure people work and treat others like they are meant to.
Or would you like the example of a police officer refusing to give CPR to someone because they were 'gay and had aids.'
There are many examples of discrimination you are ignoring. Nationally and locally.
Like Mathew Sheppard.
Like David Bell.
Like....
All these "special protections" do is provide opportunities abuse of the majority and for lawsuits. I think we're all beyond reacting to be called a racist. But the practical side of it is that minorities use these protections to abuse the majority. Someone can't be denied an apartment if they're destructive to property because they're 'gay'. Another can't be fired because he's 'gay' even though he's doing a terrible job. And on and on.
I am gay, it does not define me, but if my landlord kicked me out of my apartment just because I am gay (not because of poor payment history, or a bad tenet) that is just not right. I know if you got thrown out of a complex just because you were straight you would be just as upset.
Then please, are you kidding, go ahead and donate blood (which I cannot do) meet a nice woman/man and get married (which I cannot do) kiss on temple grounds (which I cannot do) get sealed on temple grounds (which I am not LDS, so I cannot do) serve your country in Iraq (which I cannot do) and then, when you get bored go to Hooters on 7100 South and State in Midvale.
And that last one...I have no interest in doing.
Observer, we've had this talk.
If I can see your wedding band, I can safely assume you are straight. (As 50 states allow staright marriage and only 5 allow gay ones) If you have a wedding ceremony, I can assume your straight.
Baby shower. Aniversary. Pictures of your spouse on your desk. Temple sealing. Etc, etc.
If you wanted to be fair in your comparison you would say:
'Your marriage should be a private thing...'
@ - 9:41 a.m.
They would also cover you. It would cover any sexual orientation.
And trust me, if you've ever gone through puberty, you have one.
If you don't discriminate against gays and lesbians, I guess you shouldn't mind the approval of this ordinance. On the other hand, if this is an issue for you. Perhaps, you are a bigot after all.
Think about it.
Salt Lake is the Berkely of Utah, so no, I dont give the research much credence - the outcome was forordained.
Have you been fired for your orientation? I have.
'So the people who take advantage of anti-discrimination laws are usually lousy employees...'
So, minority's are 'lousy employees?'
Your argument has a lot of assumptions and not a lot of facts. The fact is the SLC found 300 cases of discrimination based on orientation. If you think I'm making it up please read SLC's July '09 discrimination report. It's at SLC dot gov.
'This might get some positive press, but won't really make any difference.'
Well Pointless, your writting about it. Thanks for contributing.
This is not about discrimination - it is about gay activists having a club to silence dissent.
(and about political debts)
Finish the sentace Cat.
'If they act straight.'
'I don't believe in being unkind to anyone, but...'
Thanks for making my case Cat.
@ - 839a.
'Salt Lake is the Berkely of Utah, so no, I dont give the research much credence - the outcome was forordained.'
I guess the question then becomes what source WOULD you trust? How much information do you need before you can say 'Oh yeah, Mathew Sheppard IS dead.'
To those who feel you can't serve in the military. Yes, you can as long as your lifestyle is kept quiet. Once it becomes openly then you are subject to disciplinary action. The military is fully voluntary so those who are openly gay knew that before they enlisted. They also knew the rules and regulations before enlisting. That said the military is one of the most closed societies in the world. Whether I agree or not with the current policy that is the policy. If it changes then so be it, until it does then it is better to keep quiet about it, especially if you want to serve. I knew many who were gay while I was in and some served well and some didn't. The same could be said of those who were heterosexual. I never turned anyone in based on sexual orinetation.
Or the person who is evicted, not because he didn't pay his rent, or was destructive to property, but because of who the person is. Doesn't seem fair to me.
Um... they are protected under the law like everyone else.
Oh and the Matthew Shepard tragedy happened in Wyoming. And those who did it went to jail, cuz that was illegal.
We should be working as communities to foster tolerance of our own good will, and not use laws to ram our personal social agendae down other people's throats.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Utah Grizzlies fall in California 1:34 a.m.
- Panthers end 4-game losing skid 1:30 a.m.
- Sports briefs 1:29 a.m.
- Arena football back in Utah in April 1:25 a.m.
- Taiwan checking nuke report 12:52 a.m.
- Al-Qaida denies killing civilians 12:46 a.m.
- China finds $1.5 billion in corruption 12:46 a.m.
- Dale has fond memories of Bowl 12:39 a.m.
- Springville comes back against AF 12:37 a.m.
- Texas prep QB heads to Utah 12:34 a.m.
- BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
195 - Palin signs books, chats with fans
169 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
143 - Nude bathers cited for lewdness
138 - Max Hall wants to look ahead
130 - Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
110 - LDS to emphasize helping needy
107 - Revive full food tax?
106 - Panel passes BCS playoff bill
105 - Yet again, we learn BCS is a big joke
95
David Rankin, one of Utah's youngest and ablest astrophotographers has...
There was a time when free shipping was rare. This holiday season, you...
Can you tell I just got out of a budget meeting with Gov Gary Herbert?
Nick is an amazing kid. I go to school with him. This game shows that Lehi we...
I think that Salt Lake City would be a great place to hold the 2012 RNC. Salt...
Hernandez is much better than Pitta. Pitta was lucky to be nominated with the...
I think that's just plain "TORRIBLE"!
Holy Cow! Just how good is this kid?! That's impressive. Not only does he tie...
Boozer is bad medicine for the Jazz. He refuses to take hits and defend,...
Who has beaten your #1 & #2 state ranked teams? Oh...and your #10 team,...
Good job Titans another win.
Sorry..."Classless Ute". Max Hall is hilarious.
Good concert tonight. Not great. Natalie Cole was as good as I expected...I...


