Reader comments
BYU football: Cougars more resolved not to suffer late-season swoon
22 comments | Read story
TexasCougar | 10:50 p.m. Nov. 3, 2009
I hope there is a different mind set than last year. If not I see the Cougs
finishing out 2-2.
Talk is cheap | 5:54 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
When Wyoming scores the first touchdown on Saturday, the Cougs fragile
confidence will be shattered. I agree with Texas Cougar - the Wyoming game is
going to be tough and they can easily lose it. 2-2 or possibly 1-3, with losses
to Wyoming, Air Force and Utah.
Larry | 8:49 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
Let the boys play the game. That's why they call it sport.
Comments continue below
Of Course | 9:06 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
BYU will beat Wyoming. BYU almost always beats the mid to lower level MWC
conference teams. Beating them Saturday will tell us nothing. The question is
what will happen against Utah and in our bowl game? BYU always beats lesser
teams and then 8/10 times loses to top-25 caliber opponents. When we can
consistently beat top-25 talent then something has changed. Otherwise, it is
just status quo for the Cougs.
If I was WYO... | 9:30 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
I would hope to win the toss and elect to take the ball since I would know that
the cougars are 0-8 in getting a first down on their first possession of the 2nd
half.
I would get all hyped up for the first 8 minutes of the game knowing that if I score early, the Cougars fold like a cheap tent. Then when the hype fades I will still have the game under control.
I would buy off the Wyoming news services with donor money to say the weather will be cold and blizzard conditions...since the players are more concerned about the weather than the game.
I would replay over and over again the first 45 minutes of the Yewt game telling the players they actually won the game.
I would get all hyped up for the first 8 minutes of the game knowing that if I score early, the Cougars fold like a cheap tent. Then when the hype fades I will still have the game under control.
I would buy off the Wyoming news services with donor money to say the weather will be cold and blizzard conditions...since the players are more concerned about the weather than the game.
I would replay over and over again the first 45 minutes of the Yewt game telling the players they actually won the game.
Anonymous | 9:48 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
"Following last year's 32-7 loss at the hands of TCU, BYU was never
the same again."
Actually the Cougars were never the same after shutting out UCLA and then Wyoming last year. Their performance dropped and it was like they had decided they could take it easy and still win every game.
Actually the Cougars were never the same after shutting out UCLA and then Wyoming last year. Their performance dropped and it was like they had decided they could take it easy and still win every game.
Believe it when I see it | 9:56 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
"In the wake of the Cougars' 38-7 setback to the Horned Frogs on Oct.
24, coach Bronco Mendenhall said the mood of his team is much different than it
was a year ago as it prepares to visit Wyoming on Saturday (noon, The mtn.).
"This team is more resolved and more determined."
Ya know what, Coach, don't even bother making more promises about your team's performance, ok? I'm more than tired of hearing about "getting to the next level" and "executing at a higher level" and "27 easily correctable assignment errors". Please stop adding to the list already. I'll believe the Cougars are "more resolved and more determined" when I actually see it on the field, especially against good teams and in a bowl game.
Ya know what, Coach, don't even bother making more promises about your team's performance, ok? I'm more than tired of hearing about "getting to the next level" and "executing at a higher level" and "27 easily correctable assignment errors". Please stop adding to the list already. I'll believe the Cougars are "more resolved and more determined" when I actually see it on the field, especially against good teams and in a bowl game.
Talk | 9:59 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
I will believe that this team is better than last years once they prove it on
the field. If they can't win out, they are no better and maybe worse if
the lose 2 of 5, I think that this team is going down hill and the coaching
staff did not learn a single lesson from last year. We need a coach that can
understand how to adapt and not be so predictable. TCU and Utah have BYU
figured out and understand their tendices. BYU has no creativity in their
offense, they are too predictable! The rush from the defensive line is pathetic
with zero pressure.
Curly | 10:21 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
Hay fellas! Don't worry! If Southern Cal can blown out, so can we. We
still have a very good team. We can still beat Utah.
Y Fan | 10:55 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
Detmer kills. Go BYU godluck against WYoming and the U
@If I was WYO 9:30 am | 11:05 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
I'm a Ute fan but your claim that BYU is 0-8 in getting a first down on
their first possession of the second half seemed a little over the top so I
researched it.
In BYU's 8 initial second half possessions, they've gone 3 and out twice (OU and CSU). They've gotten 1 first down twice (Tulsa, USU). They've gotten 2 first downs 4 times (FSU, UNLV, SDSU, TCU).
It is true that they haven't scored on a first second half possession in 8 tries but they've certainly gotten first downs.
In BYU's 8 initial second half possessions, they've gone 3 and out twice (OU and CSU). They've gotten 1 first down twice (Tulsa, USU). They've gotten 2 first downs 4 times (FSU, UNLV, SDSU, TCU).
It is true that they haven't scored on a first second half possession in 8 tries but they've certainly gotten first downs.
Ute Fan | 11:37 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
Sincere good luck to BYU against Wyoming and Air Force. The Cougars will find,
I think, that both teams, especially Wyoming, are better than they have been in
the recent past--Air Force's defense is impressive.
I will interested to see if BYU can put up the big numbers it has in the past against the Cowboys and Falcons.
I will interested to see if BYU can put up the big numbers it has in the past against the Cowboys and Falcons.
NL | 11:51 a.m. Nov. 4, 2009
The article in the Tribune a week ago said it all. BYU will never be a power
house due to the lack of quality players. They are a consistent middle class
team. In our conference they will be towards the top most years but Utah and TCU
will have the advantage of drawing better players. More so TCU which seems to be
far superior in players and coaching. It is not being critical it is just a fact
that BYU is a church school and has requirements that other schools are not held
to. Just enjoy when they win a game or play well.
boyy | 12:19 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
First off, I appreciate the respectful comments by Ute fans on this message
board. Different than what I've seen the last few weeks. Your Ute team is
good this year, it will be a great game in Provo later this month.
Secondly, I am bothered by supposed BYU fans blaming Coach Mendenhall for lack of success. I was a freshmen during the last and miserable year of Coach Gary Crowton. It was miserable. If you don't remember, look up which teams we lost to during his tenure. Coach Mendenhall is phenomenal and was recently named by ESPN the best coaching fit for any Div I program. That is coaching fit...not necessarily the best coach. There are lots of good coaches, but many would not thrive at BYU. I appreciate the mindset and attitude Mendenhall has brought to Provo. I agree that changes need to be made...maybe with the OC (Anae) or DC (Hill), but to assume that changing head coaches will someone push us into a consistently top 15 school is absurd.
Secondly, I am bothered by supposed BYU fans blaming Coach Mendenhall for lack of success. I was a freshmen during the last and miserable year of Coach Gary Crowton. It was miserable. If you don't remember, look up which teams we lost to during his tenure. Coach Mendenhall is phenomenal and was recently named by ESPN the best coaching fit for any Div I program. That is coaching fit...not necessarily the best coach. There are lots of good coaches, but many would not thrive at BYU. I appreciate the mindset and attitude Mendenhall has brought to Provo. I agree that changes need to be made...maybe with the OC (Anae) or DC (Hill), but to assume that changing head coaches will someone push us into a consistently top 15 school is absurd.
Recruting | 2:12 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
I don't buy into what NL @ 11:51 a.m is saying or what any other naysayers
are saying about BYU recruiting. If BYU really can't "draw better
players" than why is the 2010 BYU recruiting class ranked 22nd according to
rivals dot com? When was the last time either Utah or TCU even came close to
having such a great recruiting class? Bottom line is that RIGHT NOW BYU
doesn't have as great of talent as Utah or TCU, but that is all going to
change, and that change is coming next year!
SOJOCOUG | 2:42 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
WE WILL SEE ON SAT. IF WE COME OUT FLAT I WILL BE VERY ANGERED WHERE DID THE
FIRE GO? ARE THE PLAYERS ENJOYING THE SPORT THEY DEVOTED THEIR LIVES TO? OR IS
IT WORK AS USUAL? I LOVE BYU AND THE COACHES BUT COME ON WE HAVE BECOME THE MOST
BORING TEAM IN THE MWC!
RealUteFan | 2:45 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
Amen, boyy. I agree with your comments. While their are better coaches in
America than Mendenhall, I doubt any of them would do any better at BYU with the
built-in issues they have to deal with there. Mendenhall probably does as well
as can be expected with what he has to work with.
BYU & Utah are equally below TCU | 2:59 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
I don't even buy the idea that both TCU and Utah have better athletes
"right now" than BYU. I agree TCU does, but Utah? We'll see!
My guess is that TCU will also run circles around Utah this year, proving that they are in a class all their own this year.
Hope the frogs get into the National championship game because if the ball bounces right I think they could beat anyone in the nation.
My guess is that TCU will also run circles around Utah this year, proving that they are in a class all their own this year.
Hope the frogs get into the National championship game because if the ball bounces right I think they could beat anyone in the nation.
Tracer | 3:56 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
I like the way the boys play the game. Methodical but sane when they get steam
rolled. The integrity of the team is attitude about bouncing back. It won't
be the last defeat they will face throughout their lives. I also love what
Kyle's boys are doing up North by winning the close ones with Wyo & AF
which goes to show that their is more equity in the Mtn that people want to
admit (TCU the exception).
Swooning again | 7:47 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
BYU is on track to end the season on a swoon again!
Don't know whether the schedule is set purposely, or just by coincidence, but BYU still has to face the entire top 1/2 of the MWC, minus TCU.
BYU has polished their schedule beating up on the bottom half of the MWC so far, now we'll see how they do when facing the better teams in the conference.
BYU could end the season with 4 more losses, and 2-3 more losses are certainly not out of the question.
Are the late season swoons because of the players/coaches getting tired of focusing on so many things ahead of football?
Is there a reason why it seems like BYU always seems to play the easiest teams in the conference in the first half of the season and then limps into the end by playing to toughest games toward the end of the season.
Maybe the characteristic late-season swooning is due more to unfortunate scheduling than anything attributable to Bronco and the gang.
Don't know whether the schedule is set purposely, or just by coincidence, but BYU still has to face the entire top 1/2 of the MWC, minus TCU.
BYU has polished their schedule beating up on the bottom half of the MWC so far, now we'll see how they do when facing the better teams in the conference.
BYU could end the season with 4 more losses, and 2-3 more losses are certainly not out of the question.
Are the late season swoons because of the players/coaches getting tired of focusing on so many things ahead of football?
Is there a reason why it seems like BYU always seems to play the easiest teams in the conference in the first half of the season and then limps into the end by playing to toughest games toward the end of the season.
Maybe the characteristic late-season swooning is due more to unfortunate scheduling than anything attributable to Bronco and the gang.
RE: Recruiting @2:12 | 8:25 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
You are correct, mostly. BYU is ranked 22 in part because they have signed 25
players. No other team according to Rivals have signed that many. Recruiting
rankings are based on some arbitrary point system each ranking service develops
and then totals up. As I look at Rivals I see a large number of teams in the 23
to 40 ranking that haven't signed nearly as many players so as their
classes fill up their total points will increase. Since BYU has filled their
alloted number of scholarships they won't be adding any more recruits and
will be passed by many of the teams currently below them. Rivals reports that
TCU has only 8 commitments and Utah only 14. Will they pass BYU in rankings,
nobody knows. Final rankings won't appear until late February. I suspect
that all three teams will be much closer to each other than you will admit. And
skill players don't matter as much as how they are coached. And based on
recent posts, the confidence in Bronco is split. National results are becoming
routine for Patterson and Wittingham. Bronco, not so much. How's that
working for you?
spudman | 9:48 p.m. Nov. 4, 2009
If the cougars enjoy practicing, maybe they should play the games like they
enjoy them too. Fire in the gut is what they cougs lack.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
Related content
- Dems defeat GOP's Medicare cuts 2:03 p.m.
- Pike rallies Cincinnati past Pitt 2:01 p.m.
- Cigarette sparks WJ house fire 1:55 p.m.
- Snowy roads cause accidents, delays 1:38 p.m.
- Fireplace ignites blaze in family room 1:07 p.m.
- Chain advent calendar countdown 12:58 p.m.
- Police seize stash of masterpieces 12:55 p.m.
- Freeman nails Mandela's charm 12:54 p.m.
- Keep holiday season merry, safe 12:48 p.m.
- Teen hurt while riding on car hood 12:41 p.m.
- Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?
302 - BYU says Hall incident resolved247
- Letters: Liberal because LDS244
- 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game189
- Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry188
- Aggies shoot past Cougars179
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing157
- N.Y. Senate rejects gay marriage120
- Max Hall: a fixture in rivalry lore118
- Unbeaten BYU takes trip to Logan105
Harvey Unga's future seems to be a hot talking point among fans so let's...
The publicity over Max Hall's "hate" rant against Utah, last weekend,...
Latest comments
@Chad You said, "So coupled gays should share the same legal luxuries that...
We in Southeast Idaho applaud the Utah decision! Thank you very, very much!...
First, its High School. Second, Its now Basketball Season. Bingham is...
Hey, I'm not living in the past. I'm looking at what will repeat itself...
Welcome one and all to the Big Tent; the let's-dump-Bob-Bennett tent. It was...
ive seen matthews play in highschool, college, and now the pros, and he keeps...
Reese, what do you propose is just compensation for an extra 8 years (I...
Matt: We will definitely miss what you bring to the Jazz. Thanks for the...
We don't need him. We never did!
Maybe YOU don`t get it,CJ has had 4+ years to "get in shape" do you...
Advertisements