Reader comments
College football: Utah teams have plenty to play for
45 comments | Read story
If the MWC actually had ties to anything but third tier bowls there might be something to play for besides a BCS game. You'd think with two or three top-25 teams in any given year, the MWC could land a top 20 bowl. Not so. Of the 36 bowl games slated through 2011, our champion goes to a bowl in a four way tie for 21st in bowl payouts. It's well behind the payouts of such prestigious bowls as the Insight, Music City, Liberty, Alamo, Dallas Football bowl, and forthcoming Yankee Bowl. Thompson has failed miserably in negotiating decent bowl game tie-ins. The Holiday Bowl recently renegotiated its contracts, but we're signing four year deals with vegas. Ridiculous.
Utah girl am I
When Utah wins the MWC, they go to the BCS, as will TCU this year, and skip right past the Vegas Bowl. When BYU wins the MWC, the best they can hope for is Vegas.
That's just sad, but true.
y do they both think they are better than the other when they are equals.
minus boise state and utah and you have the sun belt.
I make fun of BYU in the Vegas Bowl because after they destroy the Pac-10 5th place team, all of the Y fans rush the field and think they have really done something. John Beck and Curtis Brown get hoisted in the air like they are heroes. Real big deal.
Utah will go there, win and go home - keeping their 9 bowl game winning streak in tact. No losses to Arizona. Where is BYU's bowl winning streak? Oh 0
That said, the WAC and MWC conference should team up for a game between champions on the same day as the SEC, Big-12, C-USA, and MAC championship game, winner to the BCS, loser to Las Vegas.
However, I note that ESPN bowl predictors are predicting both TCU and BSU busting the BCS this year.
As for the Utes, they will continue to live off last years sugar bowl victory like the Cougs have lived off the 1984 national championship. Both teams are irrelevant this year. TCU is the only team that has lived up to or exceeded expectations this year. What a disappointment for the State of Utah's football programs.
As was stated before, the MWC produces at least three top 25 teams every year. The WAC? Yeah, that's right, one (that's three times as many in the MWC in case you didn't know). Same BCS bowl count? Please, Hawaii got slaughtered and certainly didn't do the non-AQ's a favor in the BCS that year. 2-0 vs. 1-1 gives the advantage to the MWC again. Oh, and it will be a third BCS bowl after TCU crashes the party.
And remember, it's easier to get a BCS bowl in the WAC because it's easier to go undefeated. Major proof of the weakness of the WAC.
Why don't you put Boise State in the MAC or Sun Belt? Then those conferences could be just as strong as the MWC too (according to your logic).
TCU is head and shoulders the best team in the MWC.
BYU is next, mostly because
Utah is inconsistent on offense, due to lack of experience
It really doesn't matter which bowls BYU and Utah go to since they're all subpar bowls anyway.
Hopefully MWC is working extra hard to get the Holiday Bowl tie-in that's being freed up next year. If they really value their member schools then they'll work hard for better bowls (and drop the Mtn tv, but that's another story).
Might as well be recess as the local elementary. Here's to the NC game between the SEC and the Big XII. Looks like Texas vs Florida. Now that's college football.
The WAC is terrible, and everyone knows it. Here's how bad the conference is. The second best WAC team this year is.....IDAHO! So pathetic. That would be the equivalent of SDSU suddenly becoming a MWC contender!
TCU is the only team that has lived up to or exceeded expectations this year. What a disappointment for the State of Utah's football programs.
Are you serious? Utah was expected to place 3rd in the MWC behind TCU and BYU in a rebuilding year. The preseason polls had BYU second in the MWC. I can see where it is disappointing that the two major teams from Utah are a combined 12-3, posting wins against the Big 12 and Big East conferences. So tell me - are you disappointed as well when your kids come home with a 3.98 on their report card too? Yeesh.
The dream continues this Saturday at um (lower case intentional).
1. USC 2. UCLA 3. Cal 4. Stanford 5. SDS
6. San Jose St. 7. Sacramento 8. Hawaii 9. Oregon
10 Org. St. 11 Washington 12. Wash St.
The New MWC becomes the following:
1.BYU 2. Utah 3. TCU 4. Notre Dame 5. Arizona
6. Arizona St. 7. Boise State 8 Houston 9.Air Force 10. Army 11. Navy 12. Colorado State.
Time of change:
When the current acting BCS realigns all conferences
to have parity and totally eliminates the Bowl Championship Series and instead chooses the National Champions by having the two last teams standing fight it out on the field for the final said honor.
Sorry ... but your scenario is NEVER going to happen.
Even if the BCS has to retool itself in order to comply with a true National Championship playoff, the PAC-10 is not going to realign as you have envisioned.
If the PAC-10 does expand to 12 teams, Utah would most likely be one of the two new schools added.
And believe it or not, it has less to do with football then you might imagine. As a major research institution, Utah has a lot of desirable qualities which make it a natural fit for the PAC-10.
Still that being said, I don't believe the PAC-10 will expand any time soon. In my opinion, a true National Championship football playoff makes it less likely that the PAC-10 would add schools, not more.
At the beginning of the season, My prediction was a 10-2 Ute team with losses at Oregon and TCU. I don't see any reason to change that now and I'm not disappointed with 10-2 in what was supposed to be a rebuilding year. Not to mention, TCU still has to beat us to make that true. Something they have had problems with over the last couple of years. Why is it when TCU beats AF by 3 noone talks about how bad their offense is but when Utah beats them by 6 (in OT granted), our offense is horrible?
Hmm well David maybe it has something to do with the fact that utah had 6 first downs at the end of regulation against AF, not too mention a measley 242 total yards in offense. Compared to TCU which racked up nearly 400 yards in total offense and 23 first downs. The only thing that kept that game close was the bad weather and turnovers (TCU had 3).
Not sure if I'd count Utah out just yet --although I agree that Utah offense is very inconsistent.
We will see in a few weeks if Utah can upset TCU --I am sure TCU has revenge in mind since they've lost 3 straight games to Utah
All I really hope for is that Utah State will beat Boise this year. I can't stand the arrogance of the broncos. They are a good team but they need to show more respect to their fellow conference teams. I hope Utah State plays their best game of the year and squeeks out a win versus boise.
That's why the Pac-10 should bring in a couple of teams to make the Pac-12. BYU & Utah are the best fit. Yewt fans whine about BYU not being a research university and BYU fans whine about Utah's lousy attendance and lack of national following, but I direct your attention to the Oregon schools to counter both points. A lot of people make a big deal out of the Sunday play, but I don't see that as a valid argument. If the NCAA tournament can accomodate BYU's sunday play policy, so could the PAC-10.
While I think the BYU/Utah package is the only way it would happen, it does raise an interesting question of whether either school should ditch the other if the PAC-10 came calling. I actually think the schools are more loyal to each other than that, but I could be wrong.
65,000 people sitting in a stadium with their 1 and 2 year old children only to jam the exists mid-way through the third quarter in a losing effort is not the kind of following that is going to sell the Pac-10 on BYU.
Sunday play is an issue for BYU (though historically many basketball games at BYU have ended on Sunday morning if ESPN came calling...it's all about the mighty dollar).
Finally, yes...absolutely, Utah should ditch BYU if the opportunity came their way! BYU would once again be #1 or #2 in the conference...a win-win situation. Don't you think?
I don't know where you have been but "people like Ford and GMC" have no money and I would certainly hope that the "good people we have in important places" are not in any way responsible for that.
Making a MWC bowl the biggest payout in America is a dream that could only exist in the mind of a BYU fan...ridiculous.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- 8 hospitalized after lab accident 10:00 a.m.
- Parents rally behind fired teacher 9:57 a.m.
- Wrap-up bill clears Senate hurdle 9:51 a.m.
- Fugitive US doc's trail ends in Italy 9:51 a.m.
- 'Merry' man pays $72 for a taco 9:42 a.m.
- Bengals take Henry's death hard 9:06 a.m.
- Police: Murder/suicide premeditated 9:02 a.m.
- Yao targets next season for return 8:58 a.m.
- Mom of hiker asks for 3 to be freed 8:48 a.m.
- Boy to have ritual needles extracted 8:41 a.m.
- Susan Powell's family saddened
- It's official; Heaps signs with BYU
- 4 people found slain in W. Jordan
- Here are Max Hall's Top 10 wins
- Susan Powell notebook seized
- Frances Monson recovering well
- 'Avatar' a visual feast, but plot fails
- Conan mocks Orrin Hatch, Mormons
- Football forecast as predicted
- Cougars cruise past Wagner
- It's official; Heaps signs with BYU
161 - Here are Max Hall's Top 10 wins
161 - Conan mocks Orrin Hatch, Mormons
151 - Letters: 'Liberal conceit'
138 - Susan Powell's family saddened
125 - Susan Powell notebook seized
114 - Jazz stunned by Timberwolves
114 - TV mom gives birth to 19th child
113 - Josh Powell meets with WVC police
109 - Letters: Explaining Palin
102
Here are a few quick-hits from BYU's 77-61 victory over Wagner in the...
Before they play the New Jersey Nets here tonight, a few lingerings...
The Catalan region is ... um... very non macho. It would fit for them to...
They probably paid the bonuses out of the Stimulus Money they got from...
If you do not want development in a certain area. Buy the property, and pay...
If you are so blinded by your OWN personal rhetoric that you think you can...
Maybe the mother should have asked her daughter to use better common sense...
To everyone talking about the camping debate: yes, plenty of people go...
You've never heard a gay jab in network tv ever? grow up please and...
Uh - darling - it is the fear mongering right that tells us that criminals...
So the Iranians are STILL taking hostages, eh? That baboon Amedinejhad was...
I watch action shows, to a point, but there needs to be a balance....



