Reader comments
Brad Rock: NCAA adds 'Riley Nelson Rule' to books
118 comments | Read story
One small problem with calling it the "Riley Nelson Rule."
Riley Nelson was not on scholarship at Utah State, and never signed a National Letter of Intent (NLI) with the Aggies.
He was basically a walk-on.
He did have an academic scholarship (as a 4.0 student).
So, he technically would not have been considered a "scholarship athlete" in regards to this rule.
Give me just one example of a mission president, bishop, or other representative of the church recruiting a missionary in the mission field.
The fact is, BYU haters assume this is the case anytime a player decides to transfer to BYU.
BYU is very strict about having anyone outside the athletic department involved in recruiting. In fact, just last week at the Cougar Club Luncheon, BYU STRONGLY reminded BYU boosters that if they knew of an athlete who might be a good prospect for BYU, the booster should contact the BYU Athletic Department and not do ANY recruiting or have any discussion at all with the athlete about attending BYU--this goes for high school players, college players AND players serving missions.
The haters will believe whatever they want, but that doesn't prove anything.
Many times, the local fans are trying to convert the missionaries to the local university, NOT to BYU. If you ask around, you will find that BYU athletes serving missions are often contacted by local members and informed that they should transfer from BYU to a better school.
Those of you who think the leaders and members of the Church are all recruiters for BYU are simply ignorant of the real world.
Don't let your sour grapes color your thinking on this. BYU did nothing wrong.
That said, I like this new legislation because I hope young men will focus more on their missions and have less football distractions---from ANY school.
BYU certainly does have a double standard in most cases. The Lavell era is ladened with athletes who were given exception after exception on honor code rules, unless of course they were riding the pine.
BYU athletes routinely underhand their mission experience by spending two years "working out." Every missionary knew one. We had an Elder who played at the Y, and his companions all hated it (well most) because playing football was his focus, not serving a mission.
However in this particular case Riley or BYU did not perform any impropriety and really who cares about Riley. Borel serves our system well. Riley is good but will probably not play much for y.
For example, Clueless in Arizona. Up here is Washington, we don't prefer the UW or WSU over BYU. We save our resentment (hate is such a strong word) for institutions that we feel inferior to. Which presently for both schools is so many, it's hard to focus on one school anyway.
I'm still not convinced that Riley won't end the year as the starting quarteback anyway. Which would change the whole order of things next spring. And greatly add to the bitter grapes way up north. So just be nice to them (that will bug them most anyway). Or at least ignore them.
boys got the Heaper Creeper and his pose to commit so poor 'Riley will just be another back up to a what?
Nelson is a sophomore, Gaskins and Hall are both Srs... so it is likely that he'll be starting the next two years, depending on what Heaps does...
The fact the some members, church leaders and BYU fans try to get promising athletes to go to BYU doesn't change the fact that BYU doesn't approve of anyone outside the athletic department recruiting players. I'm sure you can find lots of examples of fans and boosters from every school, including Utah State, who try to recruit athletes to their chosen school. MANY schools even encourage this (unofficially, behind the scenes, of course). BYU is not one of them. In fact, BYU is one of the few schools that goes out of its way to discourage such activity.
You're joking right... We had 1 BYU football player in my mission and he did not work out. To suggest that most BYU football players go on missions to work out is crazy. I'm sure McKay Jacobson went to Sapporo, Japan to become a better football player! Maybe John Beck went to the football hotbed of Portugal to perfect his QB skills?
As for BYU having a double standard for football players, I'm sure you could cite some examples. But I do know while I attended BYU in the late 1990's, our star running back, Ronney Jenkins, was kicked off the team for honor code violations.
On the balance, BYU probably gets more players than they lost due to missions, but I think this is beneficial for everyone including BYU because it provides certainty. Hopefully coaches outside of Utah will be more willing to have their players go on missions if they know they can count on getting them back. Also, BYU's job of juggling missions is difficult enough and the added certainty will be a bonus for the program.
The only people who lose with this new rule are the players who won't be able to change their minds without sitting out a year after being two years removed from football. It's not the same as sitting out when you transfer right after being on the team. Coaching and personel changes can really affect a players decision, but now the WAC has ensured that the players have no choice.
What a shocker!
He chose the stiff challenge of competing with several other OUTSTANDING quarterbacks to have the opportunity to prove that he was good enough to play one of the premier positions in college football.
Instead of starting at Utah State, where he had practically no competition for the job, he accepted the much more difficult challenge of trying to earn the starting job at BYU. That's what great athletes do.
Robbie Bosco rode the pine behind Steve Young who rode the pine behind Jim McMahon who rode the pine behind Marc Wilson.
Nelson may not ever be the starting QB at BYU, but he was willing to accept the challenge.
I congratulate Riley for having the guts to do what he felt was in his own best self interest.
Shame on Aggie fans who can't support a young man for choosing what's best for him over the selfish interests of some of the Utah State complainers.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Dr.: Mitchell seeks signs from God 6:18 p.m.
- Storm pounds Utah for 2nd day 6:18 p.m.
- Rare Scouting document donated 6:16 p.m.
- Vaccine available to all in Utah Co. 6:16 p.m.
- Farmington Jr. principal dies 6:12 p.m.
- Charter school laws among best 6:09 p.m.
- UT Co. to bond for convention center 6:08 p.m.
- Victim's mom wants teen in adult court 6:05 p.m.
- Ex-Mapleton official extradited to UT 5:43 p.m.
- State Capitol preservation dir. resigns 5:38 p.m.
- BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
- Yet again, we learn BCS is a big joke
- Storm pounds Utah for 2nd day
- Williams' late jumper tops Spurs
- Cougars in better mood about bowl
- Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
- Ranking the bowl games
- $2M error could mean layoffs
- Witness: Mitchell stalked victims
- Dr.: Mitchell seeks signs from God
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
276 - Letters: Global warming a lie
209 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
203 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
155 - Cougars going back to Vegas
147 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
141 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
119 - Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
101 - Harpring's NBA career is over
99 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
94
Most college students can't wait for this week to be over at Utah State...
PG got beat up by Springville this year, and a nearly identical Syracuse team...
They also got slaughtered by Springville.
@ Miles It will be fun soon when Miles is fully recovered from his injury....
That was REALLY insightful. Thank you for sharing your views! I've always...
Russian citizens have freedom of religion - they are free to belong to any...
Redshirt, can you tell me exactly what data has been manipulated and what...
I knew her only in passing but what I know of her is admirable. I truly hope...
They had to split it up for the rest of the schools in the MWC (twice now)....
Susan I am concerned and hoping for your safe return. Please be safe, and...

