Reader comments
BCS dreams for Utes and Cougars were hasty and fanciful
119 comments | Read story
Reality is ... the BCS was built with greed and cunning. They realized they needed the major TV markets and population centers. The conferences aligned with the BCS provide that criteria. The coveted TV markets the advertisers want are all in the current BCS system.
Reality is ... the MWC is kidding itself if it thinks that by having good teams it will automatically qualify for BCS inclusion. The BCS conferences encompass a solid majority of the FBS schools. Any further inclusion will decrease the returns by the existing BCS schools. (think back to the WAC 16 debacle and the financial reasons y'all cut loose from the WAC and you'll see exactly why the BCS schools have NO interest in including the MWC).
Reality is ... the BCS has no incentive to include more teams in the BCS.
In the case of Utah's loss, it could not have happened to a better team. When fans seem to think that their team does everything to represent the conference, they seem to be sadly mistaken. One team does not make a conference!!!! A conference is made up of many teams and between them they determine what happens after the season ends.
Let's help ensure that both BYU and Utah do not have a repeat of last weeks losses. Remember guys, one game at a time. Let's root for all of our teams in the Mountain West Conference to be successful this weekend.
Once again, a poorly researched article.
All the other college divisions have a playoff. Why is it not too demanding for these athletes.
They are not concerned about a true national champion as all. They just want to keep non-BCS schools from having the ability to pay $4 million dollar coaches salaries, the best recruting and the finest facilities.
It seems a special syndrome unique to BYU fans to think their team is underappreciated no matter how bad it is.
The BCS schools have incredible resources. When recruits visit the big schools they can't help but be impressed. I've been through Texas's facilities and believe there are NFL teams that would be envious of UT's resources.
I don't believe that small MWC teams can compete year in and year out with the big boys.
Please don't reference the Utes in your articles. It's just creepy.
az dave, reality is that you read this article. sorry, but true. you obviously care.
And true words from "16 Wins," too.
BYU has a senior QB, was playing at home where they claimed all week to be unbeatable, had jumped to #7 in the polls and were perfectly positioned for a Utah-like season with tough games at home all year, and had a team traveling cross-country to high altitude. They had everything going for them, and fell flat on their faces and embarrassed themselves and the MWC.
Utah was on the road against a decent Pac-10 team who is great at home, had their new QB playing his first real road game, wet weather, new coordinators who have not gotten into a rythum calling plays yet, and were the underdog going into the game.
Very rarely is college football an apples to apples comparison, and this is no different. Utah was not supposed to win Saturday, BYU was. BYU didn't show up and embarrassed themselves. Utah played terrible, fought hard, and had chances to win. Big difference Dick.
It's not good enough to put together a great season and bust the BCS, it's expected and anything else is a failure. It's not good enough to bust the BCS but we deserve a National Championship. (in fact, we will file a lawsuit if neccessery) In fact we deserve a heisman candidate too.
I have never seen anything like it since I moved here 3 years ago.
Reality is you speak of MWC representation but you really mean Utah and BYU. Who is rooting for TCU now to represent the MWC or are you hoping for a 1 loss miracle for your own team?
Your season isn't over, enjoy the games left.
Remember before the BCS when you were content to win your conference and go to a bowl game?
zoobs are all about they hype and catch phrases, they're not about good defense and solid QB play.
But that all begins on Saturday against CSU.
GO COUGARS!
Reality is you're out of touch with reality!
Face it, the Utes and Cougars are both sub par when compared to TCU. The Horned Frogs now carry the torch for the MWC after you guys both let it burn you big time in games you both SHOULD have won.
TCU should have carried the torch last year as well. They skunked BYU and in all facets of the game (with the exception of a bone headed kicker who botched 2 opportunities to beat the Utes on their own field) outplayed Utah. No sour apples here, Utah won fair and square and went on to represent the MWC impressively in the Sugar Bowl. I'm just saying, this year TCU is your best hope for respect at this point in the MWC. The Utes and Cougars have fettered away that opportunity.
Meanwhile, I'm going to hope that my team can rise out of mediocrity, and wish that they didn't have games like this.
In 1996, the Cougars knocked off Texas A&M, blew out Arkansas State, and then lost to Washington. They then won the rest of their games, including a thrilling Cotton Bowl over Kansas State. Even BYU team can recover.
I didn't hear one coach or player talk about NC, BCS, etc. - it was just the media and fans (red ones and blue ones!)
And only the 2004 Utes did it convincingly. The 1984 Cougars and the 2008 Utes needed luck more than once and got every break they needed.
Rare indeed.
I don't think a single Utah fan was ignorant enough to think BCS or National Championship this year so stop trying to lump Utah in with the asonine talk of National CHampionship and BCS talk because there never was any from fans or media up on the hill.
This isn't about having high expectations. It's about being realistic and not overreacting. There is quite a difference between mediocrity and playing for a NC after winning game #1 of the season.
BYU had a very nice win over OU, finally beating a ranked team, and all Cougar fans could think of was playing in the BCS, or for a NC. No sense of reality.
Here's some advice. As the fan of a team who has crashed the BCS twice (Utah), take each game for what it is and don't overstate any of them. Utah had a great team last year, as they showed in the Sugar Bowl, but even that great team had close calls during the season. One game doesn't win you anything, it simply puts you in position to keep winning. That is something BYU fans/players/media need to pick up on.
FYI - The Utah loss to Oregon was very disappointing. Unlike BYU, they had a shot to win.
I think both Ute and Cougar fans have way to high of expectations. . .lower your expectations and you can enjoy the season a bit more.
THE TRUTH
1F THERE WAS AN EIGHT TEAM PLAYOFF FOR THE BEST FOOTBALL TEAM IN THE STATE OF UTAH;I DON'T THINK A 10 AND 0 2A TEAM WOULD BE INVITED!
OR DO YOU THINK THE ADVERTISERS AROUND THE STATE WOULD BE HAPPY ABOUT MILLARD OR ENTERPRISE BEING IN THE MIX?
I'AM SORRY FOLKS BUT THE MWC IS THE MILLARDS AND ENTERPRISES OF COLLEGE FOOTBALL! BUT IT'S NOT RIGHT!
Lets see how good those utes are this year! BYU is going to destroy them. Bring it!
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Utah Jazz: Game at a glance 12:12 a.m.
- Phoenix temple inspires thanks 12:07 a.m.
- Knitting hearts together 12:07 a.m.
- Christmas gifts for your scholar 12:07 a.m.
- The spirit of the fast in nursery 12:07 a.m.
- Tips for living: Dining out with kids 12:07 a.m.
- The gospel in words: Civility 12:06 a.m.
- Thursday on TV 12:06 a.m.
- R.S. President serves from wheelchair 12:06 a.m.
- Birthdays for Dec. 10, 2009 12:06 a.m.
- Hot Rod behind mic for Lakers
- Cougars use depth to beat ASU
- Max Hall wants to look ahead
- Panel passes BCS playoff bill
- Non-BCS schools not given fair shot
- Psychologist: Mitchell schizophrenic
- Palin signs books, chats with fans
- Crash landing next to I-15
- Snow brings big chill
- Jazz go up against 'the best'
- Letters: Global warming a lie
229 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
206 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
184 - Cougars going back to Vegas
150 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
147 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
138 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
121 - Max Hall wants to look ahead
119 - Revive full food tax?
100 - Yet again, we learn BCS is a big joke
94
Four WAC schools earned invitations to bowl games this year and, since...
Kealia Ohai recently earned some national recognition ...
Utah is still BYU's BCS game. A little mind game: Which one of these is...
Seriously, Dick. You believe there is a bowl selection committee like the...
out of 80ish comments tho only like 6 people have no common sense. really...
This is really sad hope there can be a happy ending to this story. Also it is...
And how do they find these photos of Okur's defensive prowess? They had the...
Where to place the blame after this one? 6 pts in the 4th? Their bigs are too...
"Dan's reposting........" It was not only TOO long....but it is also just...
I hoped the Jazz bounced back against the Magic, loosing to a good team like...
Richest man on earth - Warren Buffet plays SERIOUS BRIDGE. Many chess...
Too funny...an anti-intellectual using big ol' words to sound smart. Just...



Depressing!!