Reader comments
BLM gets an earful on oil, gas lease sale
25 comments | Read story
xscribe | 4:53 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
It's amazing how people can't just have a civilized debate, but
instead have to use terms such as "grafitti" when describing something
that is so important to those whose ancestors put it there in the first place.
Somehow, for thousands of years, those Natives were able to "make it"
without ever drilling for oil. I, for one, say, Yes, let's not only grant
wilderness status to the entire state of Utah, but give every inch of land back
to those who knew how to take care of it in the first place.
C'mon | 6:42 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Get real. Are they really asking for anything more than that a particularly bad
set of parcels was offered for leasing? The BLM leases parcels every 3 months,
and I have never witnessed such an outcry; in fact, the process has been pretty
invisible to the public up to now. Why is this one different, I have to ask?
Could it be because these really ARE terrible choices for leasing, issued on
election day in the fast-waning hours of the Bush Administration?
Comments continue below
Dave | 6:44 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Will tapping needed resources in these designated wilderness areas prevent
recreators from accessing such areas? Recreation's revenue streams will
not drop because of the presence of such enterprises. Let Utah move forward in
assisting our nation become independent in meeting our energy needs.
Only 4% | 7:25 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
As a Nine Mile Canyon activist I welcome the involvement of all of these groups
on reiging in control of our public land - it's about time the opinions of
someone besides oil and gas should be heard.
Right now only 4% of all oil and gas leases are actually being used. Keeping this in mind, could someone please give me an intelligent argument as to why we should still be opening up some of our most sensitive and treasured land for developement now? When the industry has exhausted the remaining 96% of their leases then maybe we can talk.
Right now only 4% of all oil and gas leases are actually being used. Keeping this in mind, could someone please give me an intelligent argument as to why we should still be opening up some of our most sensitive and treasured land for developement now? When the industry has exhausted the remaining 96% of their leases then maybe we can talk.
Paul | 7:39 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
There are plenty of areas of Utah to rape without having to put a wellhead or
road in every vista. Keep the view from Delicate Arch pristine. If it is
possible to access the ground through slant drilling or selective placement of
the pad, then go for it. Otherwise, we are just cutting off our noses to spite
our faces. (And either build a new road to avoid Nine Mile Canyon or get paving
parts of the road, to cut down on the dust)
Geezer | 7:45 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
If you've seen the landscape around Grand Junction, you'll know
what's in store for Arches, Desolation, Nine Mile and Dinosaur if these
leases go through. They've chopped the land up with multiple roads and
drillpads in every square mile. The damage is obvious.
Watchdogs?? Hardly | 7:52 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
These groups aren't watchdogs. They are single-minded special interests
with very small memberships. Usually one lawyer and a buddy or two.
And in the eyes of the media, one lawyer labeling himself as the Southern Utah Helper of Wilderness (or other creative name), all at once gets credibility and air time. They don't deserve it. There are thousands of Utahns that want to see economic activities and jobs in their communities. Let's talk to these folks once in a while.
And in the eyes of the media, one lawyer labeling himself as the Southern Utah Helper of Wilderness (or other creative name), all at once gets credibility and air time. They don't deserve it. There are thousands of Utahns that want to see economic activities and jobs in their communities. Let's talk to these folks once in a while.
ld | 7:57 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
It's not just about "recreation," it's about irreplaceable,
priceless natural and cultural heritage that can easily be destroyed because it
is so fragile.
Unfortunately, far too many of my fellow ATV riders and off-roaders have no comprehension of the irreversible damage they and their machines cause. Nor do those who see only dollar signs pumping from oil and gas wells instead of the God made beauty and goodness of our incredible lands.
There's a word out there that's unfamiliar to many in Utah: CONSERVATION. We call ourselves conservatives, but don't even begin to understand the root of that word. Instead, we follow Utah's blindly myopic environmental ethic: Multiply, multiply and pillage the Earth.
Unfortunately, far too many of my fellow ATV riders and off-roaders have no comprehension of the irreversible damage they and their machines cause. Nor do those who see only dollar signs pumping from oil and gas wells instead of the God made beauty and goodness of our incredible lands.
There's a word out there that's unfamiliar to many in Utah: CONSERVATION. We call ourselves conservatives, but don't even begin to understand the root of that word. Instead, we follow Utah's blindly myopic environmental ethic: Multiply, multiply and pillage the Earth.
TNT Ranch | 8:00 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Environmentalist will be the ones who bring our country to it's knees. let
them freeze to death in the dark.
Kevin | 8:00 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
I support the BLM completely, I dont have a problem with looking at some
area's and determining the use there, but I am sick and tired of the
envirenmental agenda always trying to stop progress no matter what. The
envirenmental socialistic way of thinking is destroying the free society I grew
up in and I will not allow my children to grow up and live under their
authoritarian rule. Develope our natural resources now that we may be able to
continue to have reliable and inexpensive energy.
malin | 8:13 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
The only single minded interest groups are the oil companies. Once gone these
places can never be replaced. We need places to get away from it all. I
don't want to hike the canyons of Zion with oil wells at every turn.
Opening up these small areas will do nothing to stop our oil dependence to other countries. However we will be known as the generation that destroyed priceless artifacts.
The US based oil companies have 62 million acres under lease already with no activity at all.
It's not about recovering the oil now, it's about stockpiling our oil resources for future use, and keeping others from getting them. That is greed.
Opening up these small areas will do nothing to stop our oil dependence to other countries. However we will be known as the generation that destroyed priceless artifacts.
The US based oil companies have 62 million acres under lease already with no activity at all.
It's not about recovering the oil now, it's about stockpiling our oil resources for future use, and keeping others from getting them. That is greed.
Dave | 8:39 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
These leases do not give anyone the right to drill. They only grant the right
to look and see what is there.
Yo to Id | 8:39 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
We are seeing conservation right now. It is putting us into a recession.
People are not buying or using what they would normally. How do you like it?
Do you have a 401K? Did you have a 401k? Are you one of the 550,000 that got
a pink slip recently?
I like conservation too, but probably not to the unbalanced extent that you do.
I like conservation too, but probably not to the unbalanced extent that you do.
Ungrateful | 9:31 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Many Utahns would happily fill in Zion NP if it brought "good" $10 an
hour jobs and a six month supply of gas, so it's not a surprise that they
so utterly devalue the treasures that draw millions here every year and disdain
anyone who would try to preserve them.
"Yo to id" - the recession is clearly a meltdown of a disastrous set of financial practices, not a product of environmentalism.
"Yo to id" - the recession is clearly a meltdown of a disastrous set of financial practices, not a product of environmentalism.
redrock mama | 9:53 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
The answer to would this impact recreation is YES... people come for the quiet,
the fresh air and the viewscape. How dare groups attempting to watchdog this
AND our rural economy and property values be called 'self interested'.
DUH! If you want to recreate in Bakersfield or WIlmington CA or Grand
Junction CO then great, you can mountain bike there thru a bunch of oil rigs.
Otherwise, let's consider keeping wild national jewels wild, since we are
talking about less than 1 day's supply of oil in exchange for permanent
loss of these places!
Also folks,this stuff takes A LOT of water, clean water we don't have to spare in the desert, and makes it toxic and poisonous... where will that go?
Also folks,this stuff takes A LOT of water, clean water we don't have to spare in the desert, and makes it toxic and poisonous... where will that go?
Mary | 11:27 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Dave,
I have to agree with you. I would hope that these parcels would not prevent people from recreation. I would also hope that the recreation enthusiasts (including) myself, wouldn't stop the developement of needed resources so we can be independent of other countries. I was always taught to work before play. Work is what makes us self sufficient. There has got to be a way or enjoying the beauty of our state and be self sufficient in drilling for oil as well.
I have to agree with you. I would hope that these parcels would not prevent people from recreation. I would also hope that the recreation enthusiasts (including) myself, wouldn't stop the developement of needed resources so we can be independent of other countries. I was always taught to work before play. Work is what makes us self sufficient. There has got to be a way or enjoying the beauty of our state and be self sufficient in drilling for oil as well.
Thinkin' Man | 11:36 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Ironically, nearly all of those who oppose a few small, hard-to-find oil wells
near a desert park support putting 400-foot wind turbines in scenic canyons and
mountains.
What a double standard!
What a double standard!
To Ungrateful | 11:38 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Utahns love the natural beauty of the state. That's why they leave here
and, for the most part, make less money they could elsewhere.
But they also want to have decent economic opportunities, much of which in rural Utah, involves resource development on federal lands. Get used to the idea. It is how families put food on the table in many of our rural counties. That doesn't mean there will be an oil rig right next to the dinosour bones in eastern Utah, or a big tanker truck on the beautiful red rock ridges in Moab. But, there may be one - for a time - within ten miles of those sites.
All we ask for is balance and some opportunity. The BLM and other federal agencies have been very reasonable for the most part and struck a decent balance. Don't know why y'all got so excited about these few thousand acres. It isn't like zero thought was given to the BLM proposals. It was studied for ten - or more years....
But they also want to have decent economic opportunities, much of which in rural Utah, involves resource development on federal lands. Get used to the idea. It is how families put food on the table in many of our rural counties. That doesn't mean there will be an oil rig right next to the dinosour bones in eastern Utah, or a big tanker truck on the beautiful red rock ridges in Moab. But, there may be one - for a time - within ten miles of those sites.
All we ask for is balance and some opportunity. The BLM and other federal agencies have been very reasonable for the most part and struck a decent balance. Don't know why y'all got so excited about these few thousand acres. It isn't like zero thought was given to the BLM proposals. It was studied for ten - or more years....
Common Sense | 11:42 a.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Don't drill for oil inside Zions National Park. No one is advocating
this.
Drill for oil outside of Zions or any other park. That way the environmentalists can have their wilderness and have electricity at their homes and gas in their tanks to drive them there.
Win, Win everyone should be happy. Why can't the environmentalist understand this simple logic. You can't have unlimited wilderness and sustain the level of population on the earth at this time.
Drill for oil outside of Zions or any other park. That way the environmentalists can have their wilderness and have electricity at their homes and gas in their tanks to drive them there.
Win, Win everyone should be happy. Why can't the environmentalist understand this simple logic. You can't have unlimited wilderness and sustain the level of population on the earth at this time.
ThinkAgain | 12:26 p.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Thinkin'Man, I challenge you to come up with one citation that demonstrates
that green groups oppose windmills. Yeah, yeah, the Kennedys griped when they
were proposed on the Massachussetts coast, and that was hypocritical. But can
you find any stands on it for SUWA, the Audubon Society, or any national enviro
group. I'm betting you can't, because they routinely support them.
Of course, if it were a windmill on the turnoff to Arches, probably not. That leaves plenty of places for windmills (mostly places other than Utah.)
Of course, if it were a windmill on the turnoff to Arches, probably not. That leaves plenty of places for windmills (mostly places other than Utah.)
Thinkin' Man | 2:03 p.m. Dec. 5, 2008
ThinkAgain, re-read my post--you got it backwards.
To 4% -- Oil only occurs in rare geological conditions. If they're not drilling on leases, it's because they have determined that there isn't oil there. And you don't have to drill to determine that.
To 4% -- Oil only occurs in rare geological conditions. If they're not drilling on leases, it's because they have determined that there isn't oil there. And you don't have to drill to determine that.
ThinkAgain | 2:31 p.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Thinkin'Man, your assertion is that the proposed wells are hard to find.
Not so with the Dinosaur leases, which are directly across the Green River from
visitor overlooks, and are in the viewshed for miles along the main park road.
I could chuck a rock across the river to 'em. (Well, maybe in my younger
days.) Your further assertion is that people like me (who oppose these
particular leases) support putting windmills in "scenic canyons and
mountains." Let me be clearer; if the "scenic canyons and
mountains" were internationally famous national parks or some other
spectacular reserve, I'd say don't build windmills there. If the
"scenic canyons and mountains" were not in such reserves, I'd say
go for it. I fail to see anything particularly striking about such a position.
Generate electricity, where it is feasible, where it does little damage to
industry (such as tourism) or ecology.
Anonymous | 10:51 p.m. Dec. 5, 2008
Six "ENVIORNMENTALIST GROUPS" filed an administrative protest Thursday
What else is new. to bad stephan can't call it by there names. They have
made enviornmentalist a bad name and now the news can't even use there
names. We can see now that high gas prices do to the economy and these people
would still rather have us live in a cave to protect some snail. wind mills
wont make my car go to work of course that is if I have a work. Time to add
enviormentalist to the endangered list
If Bush was for it | 12:39 a.m. Dec. 6, 2008
If Bush is for the wholesale of our land, it is obviously a wrong decision.
When has he been right? He wanted to invade Iraq, which has cost much more than
any benefits from Utah drilling. He has put us into a mortgage crisis and a
world recession. If he is for it, it is an ill thought out plan that will cost
the tax payers billions of dollars and leave us all thinking WTF.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Sports on the air 12:06 a.m.
- LDS families let TLC into home, business 12:05 a.m.
- Kehl represents faith in different blue 12:05 a.m.
- Why music lessons matter 12:04 a.m.
- Editorial: Trying to catch the wind 12:04 a.m.
- Gov't-run health-care system 12:04 a.m.
- Emotional intelligence is key to success 12:04 a.m.
- Hottest toys, superheated shopping 12:04 a.m.
- Bloggernacle Back Bench 12:04 a.m.
- Letters: Lunar H20? So what? 12:04 a.m.
- MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight
- Relieved Cougs prep for Falcons
- Wounded Utes limp home
- Jazz rookies had to grow up quickly
- Big games keep UHSAA coffers full
- Barzee is expected to plead guilty
- Sloan misses practice
- Low in vit. D? Beware heart disease
- RSL surprised by Chicago's Fire
- Jazz notes: Young bigs ride bench
- TCU creams U.
233 - BYU happy to escape with victory232
- Editorial: Mormons and gay rights226
- Will state consider gay rights law?162
- RSL heads to MLS title game134
- Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?133
- MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight123
- TCU stays 4th in AP; Y. 19th, U. 23rd115
- 5A: Bingham rolls to title game108
- Bennett at center of GOP storm89
The Gateway, 400 W. 200 South, will kick off the holiday shopping season...
I was a bit under the weather last week, which gave me some time to...
Advertisement
Latest comments
I loved Firefly. Own it. Own Serenity. Great stuff. But the Joss Whedon...
These two yo-yo's should be billed for the expenses involved and they also...
THANKS TO OUR COACHES!
The whole idea that academic superiority even factoring into an athletic...
It's to bad that my age group, being 25 is so out of shape and have no...
what a game! the teams were both out to play and win, only one could....
I hope they have bodyguards, because the Taliban is not going to be very...
Re: High School Coach? Yes, but UNLV is no Notre Dame. Notre Dame came...
Um Dick.....while BYU will be rebuilding next year losing the entire below...
@G.S. 11:40 a.m.: "While the legislature is at it, be sure to stop all the...
Advertisements
We will be hungry, cold and in the dark, but it will be worth it. We can walk to nine mile canyon to see the ancient grafitti without encountering any oil wells, fast food restaurants or roads along the way.