Reader comments
Dick Harmon: Game erases memory of 2 losses decisively
116 comments | Read story
That's really awful.
The only way for a team from the MWC to go to the NC is if there is NO other undefeated team and the 1 loss teams are relatively weak.
In the Utes case they could have gone to the NC if:
1) Michigan would have been 9-3 instead of 3-9.
OR
2) They would have played and beaten another BCS team that is at-least bowl worthy if not ranked (ie...Florida State, Boston College, UNC, Cincy, etc) instead of Weber State.
OR
3) They knock of a high profile BCS team such as OU (TCU had their chance) or USC (ala OSU).
Since none of those happen, they won;t be in a NC. Still BCS is BCS....We'll take it! No one's complaining here!
Utah has been in the BCS once before and they looked just fine. Hawaii is in the WAC. No other MWC has been able to qualify for a BCS game...
Utah can hang with any school outside the two that will play for the national championship (Oklahoma and Florida).
"Can you say Hawaii"... Are you serious? Hawaii had NO defense. I have a better question for you: Can you say JEALOUSLY?
Go Utes!!
Can you say Sour Grapes...
Why is it that some BYU fans can't accept that Utah won and support them as they carry the Mountain West banner into the BCS?
If the situation was reversed, I would be supporting BYU. I guess some people just can't get pass the "they thumped us" bitterness. Had Utah not won the game, our league would have no one in the BCS.
I believe BYU will show REAL CLASS and wish the Utes good luck in the BCS, even if some of their fans won't.
By the way, why does Utah have to share the pot with the other non-BCS leagues? When did they change that? It's inherently unfair.
Utah busts their hump to get there and then is forced to split the money with those outside our league?
Anyone that is competitive and a champion wants the best opportunity. If Utah falls flat than so be it, but I am sure every Cooger wanted to play that game against Utah yesterday even though there was a strong liklihood they could be embarrassed.
See you in the Ward ball consolation bracket.
2007: "4th and 18"
2008: "Hall tries to make the tackle"
BYU was fittingly humbled, but that is part of working toward perfection. Congrats to the U of U for a great season going undefeated. Good luck with that new coach next year.
THE UTES SLAUGHTERED BYU THIS YEAR...ACCEPT IT WITHOUT EXCUSES...are you capable of that or are you one of these "entitled" people the nation is infested with that can't comprehend reality?
UTES 48 BYU 24...there's the only stat you should read and analyze.
Go Utes!
The other good part is BYU still gets the money even if Utah loses right? Just kidding. I hope they can represent the MWC well and prove that the conference deserves an automatic bid.
I was honestly surprised BYU ever got ranked so high this year. I thought the defense was mediocre and we were just playing bad teams. I think that was a correct assessment at the time.
Then yesterday the defense actually had a pretty good game but the offense implodes. That's the cycle of life in college sports.
Sorry to hear about some classless fans ruining what should be one of the best atmospheres in all of college football.
I keep thinking people will grow up but I guess a new generation is being "trained" all the time. The coaches seem to be leading the way with stupid jabs at each other and the opposing players.
Best of luck to ALL of the college athletes. One more game to go. Make it a good one.
That there were more coaches like Kyle and Bronco (and John Wooden, Ara Parsegian, etc.). Coaches with character.
That there were fewer fans who think cheering for your own team requires, or even allows, you to spout vulgar, offensive, filthy trash about the other team, its specific players or coaches, or its fans.
That there were more displays of sportsmanship like the lineman who pounds the quarterback and then helps him up after the whistle.
That there were fewer minibottles allowed in the stadiums.
That there were more second-stringers at various positions (but especially at QB), who could come in and fire up their team after a turnover on the previous possession. Max Hall needs an understudy.
That there was less money in the game, so there wouldn't be an exclusion to carrying it on local TV channels or the campus (KUED or KBYU) channels.
That there was more fan knowledge of cheers and songs - how about a 45,000-voice haka? Cool, eh? But the next best thing is the "B" "Y" "U" "COUGARS" that goes around the whole LEStadium at various times during the game. "Utah Man" karaoke with the JumboTron is the next-best thing.
Nice win, Utah.
"The Utah defense is still open..."
to the list of slogans.
And to the BYU fan who started this, what goes around comes around. You will not hear the end of this. My apologies to the BYU fans who have displayed a great deal of class on these boards but as in all things, it only takes one very obnoxious fan to make all look bad.
As a cougar fan I don't need to say "wait until next year" to see the Utes get disappointed.
Disappointment is right around the corner for the Utes--and I'm not even speaking about the outcome of their BCS game.
Disappointment begins on Dec 7th for the Utes when they find that, not unlike 2004, they will play a team barely ranked in the top 25--like Pitt. Because of this, they will find that, no matter what they do, the BCS world will be unimpressed.
For the conference's sake, I can only hope they play a Big 12, or SEC team, because they won't be playing USC, or Penn State. ACC or Big East, here we come! Even worse would be Boise State!! Can you imagine the outrage?.....you won't have to, wait til Dec 7th.
byu fans have been simply repulsive the last few years....and the team's luck has run out.
4 new O-linemen, from a line that was vastly over rated to begin with. If Collie decides to take a shot at the NFL, byu will be gunning for 3rd place again next year. It's not like that defense is going to improve.
I've never seen a defense run the same set the ENTIRE game. They never once tried to change coverage or confuse Johnson. Take Jorgenson out and they will be a horrible D.
I would love to see Boise destroy those guys in the Poinsetia Bowl.
I was in RES last night and watched provocative behavior from fans on both sides.
Jan Jorgensen had it right when he said there are fans of both the Y and the U who act like idiots.
Can't we figure out a way to change this?
I went to the '03 game in provo with a friend who had season tix in the TDS student section and I sat with him there all clad in red. I didn't get popcorn thrown at me, or insulted or pushed around. I was given hand warmers by the guy behind me.
Let the tds players and coaches eat crow for their pretentious mottos and slogans. The irony of us achieving perfection at the same time they made it their mantra is beyond satisfying. Let's enjoy it with some class.
Congrats to the U players and coaches. We are spoiled fans. Thanks for the memories!
GO UTES!
I respect the U and know very good people that went there and that are fans.
Why can't we all say, "Good Game" after it's over? Why is it all so personal, with so much hate? Winning and losing to eachother makes the rivalry great. Success of the other team makes it great. I for one am happy it is the U going to the BCS instead of BSU.
Wish we could've learned from pee-wee soccer that win or lose, we shake the other guys hand and leave with a smile, plus oranges and a juice box.
Kruger is still open!
Notice we went to Utah State and not Utah. That is because Utah Alums can't coach!!!
I don't know if it will ever happen. The fact is that a 6-6 Notre Dame team will have its pick of high paying bowls to go to even after loosing to a team like Syracuse.
See you at Utah games.
It cuts both ways and yeah, the most intelligent comment I've heard thus far was by Jan Jorgensen of BYU who called out "idiots" on both sides for their boorish behavior. With minor exceptions, take your cues from the athletes on the field. Their fine coaches teach them to behave with class and integrity and they do. The fans get my thumbs down. Congratulation Utah for last night, congratulations BYU for a great season overall and best of luck to both in their bowl games.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- USA Today poll: U. 14th, Y. 22nd 11:51 a.m.
- TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd 11:32 a.m.
- Tough road ahead in Senate for bill 11:05 a.m.
- Afghan vows to keep out corruption 10:35 a.m.
- Anti-Taliban mayor killed in Pakistan 10:27 a.m.
- Dalai Lama visits town near Tibet 10:26 a.m.
- Some saw trouble ahead for Hasan 10:21 a.m.
- China pledges funds, aid to Africa 10:20 a.m.
- 40 dead in El Salvador flooding 10:19 a.m.
- Dixie campus briefs 1:10 a.m.
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
207 - Dirk does dirty work in Dallas
190 - Lobo suspended
173 - House passes health care bill
150 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
141 - Speed has never been BYU's game
136 - RSL rallies to advance
102 - Thousands protest health bill
100 - Provo company innovating engines
98 - BYU cuts Women's Research Institute
87
It's almost tip time at the Spectrum as Utah State prepares to take on...
Sorry, it did not work this time. The Republican "No" was squashed. Our...
There's no reason for conservatives to be such extreme darwinistic...
I can't believe people can rationalize completely ignoring a large group of...
Separated by a wall and a generation of hateful propaganda, it's going to...
How hard is it for a country to declare bankruptcy. We can just do that and...
Charles, see the article above yours "Recent elections offered few new...
Well, Utah sure is good at doing the next-to-impossible. They executed very...
I think gorbachev gets short shrift in this essay. Gorby had a far more...
The carbon dioxide content of the atmosphere has jumped 40% in the past 200...
I agree. Definitely too much greed going on.

