Reader comments
Utah Utes, BYU football: BCS busting: the sequel
753 comments | Read story
Congratulations U of U fans!
Game on for the BCS!
No excuses, you won and in an impressive fashion.
Represent the MWC well. Going to the BCS twice is an impressive feat.
Back and forth wins in the rivalry is what makes this rivalry so good.
Again, congratulations, I've swallowed my lumps, but luckily do not have my personal value hinged on the success of a football team like some other fans on here.
Go Utes! Bust the BCS again! Better the U than BSU.
By the way somebody tell Hall that Kruger is still open!!
Both teams are very good this year, but Utah got better as the season progressed, and BYU isn't as strong as initially thought--a fact made clear by getting beaten soundly by TCU and the Utes. Hall's current skills are not good enough to succeed against very quick defensive backfields. But he's a great quarterback, and he'll be even better next year.
As for distant history, yes, BYU won a national championship two plus decades ago. Very cool. Utah won the NCAA hoops championship in 1944. And Washington beat the British.
Yeah right cougar fan, and even your buds will look strange at you for that one. And last year you think the refs help UTAH? I think there are a bunch of cougars here that had dreams last night of an alternate reality.
Gotta love Bronco's comments. If this was in Provo and BYU won, the fans rushing the field would have been worse. Sad he's having to grasp for something.
No amount of BYU refs could have fixed Halls implosion.
The quest for imperfection shirts on sale at a BYU store near you.
"The Quest for Imperfection"
Did BM really say that....laughable.
Without the 4 blow outs we the ride to Disneyland would have been different.
If it weren't for the fire the Hindenburg would have landed correctly.
Somebody give BM a personality injection. I think he is trying to be a LE Clone.
Did Whit say anything nutty or condescending? I don't think so.
Whit is the class of the MWC coaches. I'm glad we have him.
Unfortunately, Utah will not be selected to play in the BCS Championship Game. It's all about the money, and the Mountain West Conference is considered to be a minor conference.
We should all remember that no team has ever won a National Championship. Championships are mythical because of this. So, in my book, Utah has as much right to lay claim to the title as anyone else.
I'm also a Ute fan. My son graduated from the University of Utah, and I've paid a lot of money for the honor of being a Ute fan. Of course, graduating from Texas trumps the Ute, but not by much.
We need a playoff system.
Another year that you can't run replays over and over again on Channel 11 and BYU-TV. A 10-2 year that will be ignored. That's sad. A real school would show its defeats along with its wins for years that were good. Well I guess you can alway rerun the Utah State game (just remember to cut out the fans yelling "over-rated")
Thank you for showing those Utah past loses - a true Ute fan loves it and I loved watching memories of years past. Nearly all BYU wins in the past decade were by luck and its clear in the replays - keep them coming - cause even when we lose we look good.
I'd like to see a playoff between BSU and Utah for the BCS bid, but such is life.
I watched the game last night and thought that Utah looked pretty good, but not dominant. Considering the margin of victory was 24 points off 6 turnovers... The turnovers were more on Max Hall than effort by the Ute defense in my opinion. At any rate, Utes deserved to win and deserve a BCS bowl.
As a BCS system hater and fan of the mid-majors I really hope the Utes show up for the bowl game. Last year's Hawaii team was a good team, but they sure didn't show up against a very good Georgia team.
I have my doubts that Utah can hang with any of the top 10 except maybe BSU and PSU. Please prove me wrong.
12-0! Who could have seen this after the 2005 letdown? Hopefully we can keep some good coaches and continue to bring respect for our state, the conference and so-called "mid-majors" in general.
GO UTES!
All I can say is we can't wait to see who we play and where we play. I'm guessing it's either Alambma or Florida in the Sugar Bowl.
Brian Johnson completed 30 of 36 passes, for 303 yards and 4 TDs! That's freakin' sick, man! Great game, BJ!
And I'm so proud of the ENTIRE Utah defense--they were all over Max Hall. Numerous batted balls, 5 interceptions, and a forced fumble. Amazing!
What a demonstration of strength, poise, and determination. I can't think of a better way to end the regular season than a resounding victory over that blue team from Provo. Bring on the BCS!!!
All the bantering aside, CRBURB summed in up better than any post here or on ESPN. Check out his comment
However, as is often the case, I am even more disappointed and embarrassed by the actions and statements of many of my fellow BYU fans. This year we lost and the Utes won. Period. Always falling back to the past (1984, etc.) to assuage current disappointment makes us look pathetic. I now live in Texas and you would never hear a U of Texas fan respond to the defeat of Texas by Texas Tech by citing the history of Texas domination over Texas Tech or throwing out the fact that Texas has won prior national championships. They live in the present here. Utah beat us this year. Deal with it in the present. I am really down because we lost but to respond to Utah fans by reminding them of old news is really weak.
We all should hope that BYU, Utah, TCU, Air Force and probably CSU do well in their bowl games. I would welcome a trip to the Poinsettia Bowl -- great city, great stadium and possible match-up with Boise State if the bowl brokers can arrange it.
BCS title game or not, Whittingham is one of the hottest coaches in the nation; he's 36-14 and has three bowl victories since being promoted from defensive coordinator to take over for Urban Meyer after the 2004 season. Will Whittingham bolt Salt Lake City? Meyer did after he led Utah to the Fiesta Bowl, leaving to coach Florida. Whittingham's tough style would work well at, say, Washington.
Good job to Utah, I didn't think they were that much better than BYU. But, they outplayed on every front last night, and Johnson really surprised me, he was outstanding.
We have to accept the fact that he is an good QB; not a great QB. He may have a decedent arm but he is short, slow, fumbles alot and only an average decision maker. And although he may be a competitor he is not a gamer. He struggles under pressure. In the two biggest games of the year, he either gave the game away (Utah) or was a no show (TCU).
I realize that we want to keep our QB our icon and leader but he is not our strongest link; in fact, he may be our weakest (at least on offense).
...ALONG WITH THE ENTIRE UTAH SECONDARY.
Thanks max,
lol
You mean like "Harline is still open" or "4th and 18"?
By the way, Hall is still throwing picks.
Go Utes!!!
And I blame Bronco's "bend but not break" defense. Cowboy up and stop giving a 10-15 yard cushion on every play! Cowboy up and blitz! Stop being so cautious and conservative that you allow any team who wants to to march down the field every possession.
So Hall was responsible for 6 turnovers, but the coaches should know better than to put him in a very predictable situation. Credit Utah for figuring out what everyone who has watched a BYU game this year knows--guard Collie. Heck, put 5 guys on Collie. Hall won't look at anyone else... just leave them uncovered.
Enjoy Las Vegas once again or wherever your path to mediocrity takes to you.
preparation, and by far more desire to win. They had much more to gain by winning and certainly everything to lose by losing. They played a near flawless game. Much more so when compared to how we played. I hope that they are rewarded by a good BCS bowl and will represent the Mountain West and Utah well. To what bowl game we might be invited to go I don't know. But I certainly hope that we will be better prepared than we were for this game.
What a totally classless player.
congrats to byu on making your conquest to 3rd place in a mediocre conference and qualifying for the blue rug bowl.
Florida is downright scary, I'll give you that, but Utah is no paper tiger like Hawaii. Hawaii had a weak defense and relied on their high powered offense to win games-which went virtually untested until they met Georgia. As others have mentioned, the Utes have rolled through 3 ranked opponents, and a MWC that is as strong as its ever been.
I guess it just kills you to think your team lost, boo-hoo, cling onto the delusion that the Utes are terrible. Utah can play with anyone and I'd pick them as a favorite over anyone right now except Florida & Oklahoma.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Pilots blame air traffic controllers 12:55 p.m.
- Senate confronts abortion in debate 12:46 p.m.
- 2 bombs kill 34 in Lahore 12:41 p.m.
- U.N. climate conference opens 12:29 p.m.
- Messy Monday morning commute 12:28 p.m.
- Stocks extend gains 12:06 p.m.
- Top 3 stay same in AP Top 25 12:05 p.m.
- Two arrested in pharmacy robbery 12:03 p.m.
- GM to invest $336M in Volt plant 11:54 a.m.
- Church History Museum D&C tours 11:52 a.m.
- Letters: Liberal because LDS
268 - Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
244 - Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
190 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
187 - Aggies shoot past Cougars
179 - N.Y. Senate rejects gay marriage
134 - Cougars going back to Vegas
127 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
117 - Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
98 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
98
The San Francisco Chronicle is reporting (perhaps speculating) that Utah...
I got some e-mail from Aggie fans regarding a column I wrote last week...
That game was fan-tastic. Eight lead changes??? How can you beat that. Tyson...
"CO2 is NOT the pollutant." They are not saying it is THE pollutant - they...
I have ridden my horses on this land last for the last 10 years. It is a...
Barry was the only reason I got back into baseball after the 1994 strike that...
To "wallofvoodoo | 11:46 a.m. " why doesn't reprocessing take the issue of...
Oh really miskky than how do you explain double digit leads of 20 plus in...
Bennett is right to oppose and delay this bill. It’s a bad bill, and...
"CO2 is not a pollutant." Could you please provide the background and...
Pardon Skeptic and me for tossing a little water on your TRAX celebration....
"FYI - Cal beat Stanford by 10, who beat USC by 20, who beat Oregon State by...




As a cougar fan I don't need to say "wait until next year" to see the Utes get disappointed.
Disappointment is right around the corner for the Utes--and I'm not even speaking about the outcome of their next game.
Disappointment begins on Dec 7th for the Utes when they find that, not unlike 2004, they will play a team barely ranked in the top 25--like Pitt. They will find that, no matter what they do, the BCS world will be unimpressed.
For the conference's sake, I can only hope they play a Big 12, or SEC team, because they won't be playing USC, or Penn State. ACC or Big East, here we come! Even worse would be Boise State!! Can you imagine the outrage?.....you won't have to, wait til Dec 7th.