Reader comments
Utah Utes, BYU football: BCS busting: the sequel
753 comments | Read story
24 years later...
BYU 24 UTAH 48
Just deal with it.
As for the Ute fans, you have a long way to go. I was at the game and was wishing I didn't go after being cursed at multiple times, food thrown at me and my wife and other vile things that happened that I can't mention on this post. I wouldn't be posting this if I thought my experience was isolated to maybe one or two nutty fans, but it was not by any means isolated. I'm frankly emabarassed for my Ute friends that are always classy and the many other Ute fans that are gracious. I sat by two Ute fans that were really nice, so it's just too bad that the many other before mentioned fans have to ruin it.
Max Hall Turnovers- Oblong shaped leather football with no topping but with visible seams, given up 6 seperate times on Rice-Eccles Field. These taste great for Utah fans, but they give excruciating heartburn and sometimes runny eyes to zoobie fans.
Get your Max Hall Turnover tray next year at any 6 of BYU road games. They are usually free. Milk makes them go down a bit better.
Though it might be a good idea for Max Hall to attend some anger management therapy to limit some of those personal foul penalties.
The Utes have shown that they can hang with the big boys. BYU? Not so much. Trying to beat Utah is now BYU's bowl game.
Max - You've gotta learn to take care of the football. It's way better to throw the ball away or even get sacked and punt it away than try to force a third down conversion, resulting in a pick or fumble. Notice how often in the NFL they punt and the QB ends up throwing away the ball out of bounds. There's a reason!!! Turnovers = YOU LOSE, plain and simple. Don't get me wrong, we love you as our QB, but it's just so frustating! Anyhow, hopefully we can play BSU in a bowl game and you can redeem yourself and show everyone that you are one of the best QBs in the country.
I travel 100% of the time for my job also and deal with executives of corporations who follow college sports and I have yet to hear a comment about the Utes until the last few weeks (AFTER BYU LOST TO TCU!!)
Boise State is much more recognized than the Utes as BCS busting.
P.S. How is Alex Smith doing? You know the QB from the BCS bowl in 2004.
It would be great if Boise State can be released from their WAC bowl tie-in so that a BYU-Boise State game can be arranged (even a TCU-Boise State game would be good).
Also, I agree with the previous comment about our #54. He really behaved like an idiot today and maybe shouldn't be allowed to play in this season's bowl game.
GO UTAH!!
GO UTES!!!
And last I checked there was no asterik to speak of.
Have fun Utah watching Bama or Florida play Texas for the National Title this year.
Howard and the other goon are pathetic.
Anyway, great game. I was impressed how the BYU players lost with dignity and were respectful after the game. Too bad BYU fans here can't lose with any dignity and have to cry about the big mean sinful utes. If you want to read classless banter go to the sltrib message boards. Both sides are pretty nasty.
I am a Ute and I don't like utes fans being rude and disrepectful but BYU fans need to open their eyes and see the crap coming out of their own mouths. Both sides do and no one in innocent, even though Y fans think they are.
To address your question regarding Alex Smith... He's doing fine. He is recovering nicely from a season ending injury. In case you didn't know, Alex was the first overall selection in the 2005 NFL draft. And is playing for one of the weaker teams in the NFL.
You may want to compare his numbers to those of Steve Young when he played at Tampa Bay, at the start his NFL career. Young didn't begin to excel until he played for a championship calibar team. He was very fortunate to have followed the great Joe Montana.
Smith's opportunity to shine is in front of him.
P.S. How are your former BCS quarterbacks doing? How about your former #1 overall draft picks?
Oh, I almost forgot... GO UTES!
ND beats USC
Oklahoma State beats Oklahoma, and
Texas A & M beats Texas
1.) Your fans are classless, crude. (Welcome to the world outside of Provo, ever been to a Boston/New York game?)
2.) You are going to get obliterated in your Bowl game. (I can't see the future but I can sure enjoy the present.)
3.) We have a national title and cling to our storied run through the 80's.(That's impressive, which makes the current victory that much sweeter.)
4.) You didn't win the game we gave it to you. (Do I even need to comment?)
Thanks to all the sporting Y fans that realize they just got beat by a better team. For the rest of you out there making excuses, talking trash, whining, there is always next year. Thank goodness this year is ours!
Better yet, how about "The Jest for Perfection."
Putting aside the cheap shot, both offensive lines were outstanding. Byu ran at will and Johnson dropped back 36 times and was barely touched.
And unless Austin Collie thinks playing on Sundays is not living right on the field, he will be playing for quite a while.
Now stick it to the so-called power conferences Utes and we'll be seeing BYU here again in another sellout.
I laugh though because you think you won because of your incredible play. What a joke. Max Hall did hand you guys that ball game and any BYU fan that says its unsportsmanlike to say it should take the blinders off. Also you UTE fans who say its a cop-out to say that Max handed it to you. Same advice.
As far as running up the score, anyone that complains about that has no sense of competition and absolutely no BCS knowledge. Anyone know why Oklahoma ran it up on Texas Tech, because it looks good to the BCS Gods!!!
Bronco Mendenhall is way more than a football coach and he knows what life is all about. Any man that can look him in the eye and tell him that his motivational strategies are bogus, is a liar!!!!
I am a die hard Cougar Fan. True blue through and through but even i realize the benefit to our conferance that comes with a UTE win tonight. Congrats to
Everyone is talking about the Utah victory being largely due to Max Hall's breakdowns without giving the Utah defense sufficient credit for causing them. Although the pressure on Hall superficially didn't seem that great at times, the variations on defense were amazing. To accomplish this, you need a smart defensive coordinator and also smart and versatile players. Utah's DC is as good as any in the Big-12 (which I follow because of my college roots). I would love to play on this defense; although, even in my best year, I would never have been fast enough for this team. Some might say the Utah defense didn't perform well because of the offensive yards it allowed BYU. Yards allowed can be one of the most misleading statistics in evaluating a defense's performance.
Regarding Collie: He is an excellent wide receiver and will play in the NFL. The smartest move he can make would be to declare for the draft this year rather than risk major injury during another college season (with a potential loss of millions of $). Anyone counseling him otherwise does not have his best interests in mind.
Notre Dame's problem isn't the coaches they've had. It is a paradigm shift in the type of ball players they can get into school.
first, the luster of going to ND is gone. Too many other teams out there on TV.
and
ND hasn't lowered their grade standards for athletes. It is a great academic school.
Why go to ND when you can go to another great football factory and major in 'eligibility' (heard this frmo Warren Sapp when he was asked about what he majored in at Miami. He was honest.)
Especially when you think your ticket is to the NFL and not the boardroom.
See you all in Church tomorrow."
As a student at BYU- let me just apologize for this arrogant and ignorant comment made by one of my fellow students, who is still confusing football with religion. I hope his testimony wasn't hurt by BYU's loss.
And as a life-long Ute fan who saw it all in person- let me just say 12-0 baby!!!!! GO UTES!!!
The only Utah team that got mentioned a lot where the Jazz. I never realized how hated they are outside of Utah.
Many Newties say don't live in the past, let me see, isn't '04 four years ago? Just last year you lost, the year before you lost. Next year you will be rebuilding, and will lose.
And we are yet to see if you will win in '08...
Just remember all this smack when the game is over in January. Remember Hawaii! I would rather see BSU against Utah, that would be an even match up.
People around the country are only being polite and when you say you are from Utah they realize UofU is from Utah. If the team was called Rocky U they would have no idea, just like most people have no idea where Notre Dame plays its home games and they are a national icon.
RE: '84 Champs, What asterisk do you mean? There is no asterisk after BYU's NC... where do you see that?
So Newt fans don't accept BYU's NC because it was 24 years ago, well, try to tell Notre Dame, Oklahoma, Alabama, Miami, and USC to take down their NC banners, or any sport for that matter. An NC is always and NC, and congratulations Utah, you are the MWC champs this year, for what it is worth.
I don't really understand why everyone keeps calling eachother classless here. Its a game. The rivalry makes it fun. Don't let the antics that make it fun, be personal. Its not persicution its sports.
Oh yea, GO UTES! haha
Utes Rule. BYU CHOKES!!!
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Man's ninth DUI conviction upheld 10:29 p.m.
- Man sentenced to 7 years in death 10:28 p.m.
- Ka-Chingle Bells has news yule use 10:24 p.m.
- Comments sought on cave staircase 10:22 p.m.
- SUU museum to honor local artists 10:17 p.m.
- McCoy keeps hauling in awards 10:16 p.m.
- Utah part of environmental settlement 10:15 p.m.
- Saints cost man 60-inch TV 10:14 p.m.
- Pistons spoil Billups' trip to Detroit 10:13 p.m.
- Utah Co. freeway should last 40 years 10:12 p.m.
- Nude bathers cited for lewdness
- Few details on missing W.V. mom
- Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
- Crash landing next to I-15
- Defense witness goes on offensive
- BCS = power conference monopoly
- Palin signs books, chats with fans
- I-15 expansion barreling south
- 5 officers lose their certification
- Y.'s Emery bruised, but rarely beaten
- Letters: Global warming a lie
256 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
206 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
193 - Palin signs books, chats with fans
164 - Cougars going back to Vegas
150 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
149 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
142 - Max Hall wants to look ahead
124 - Nude bathers cited for lewdness
119 - Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
110
When the 2008-09 season wrapped up, the Aggies had a 30-5 record and...
ESPN's Mark Schlabach ranked the Las Vegas Bowl as the seventh most...
This CD is filled with a variety of music and vocal genius. David gives us a...
You quote the NY Times, yet here is an excerpt from an article published in...
What is scheduled for next year: 42 inch TV sets and a new car? Do school...
I remember hearing about this when I first started playing hockey. We just...
The key word here is tax incentives......libertarians and conservatives are...
The Temple is not considered a landmark in San Diego! Maybe if your LDS but...
I think anyone would lose there Job for having sex on the clock. And those...
Writting a song celebrating Hanukkah in no way removes Christ from...
Wealthiest generation in the history of the world. Even Americans living in...
To Trevor | 1:48 p.m. Protests and boycotts CAN be bullying. Especially...


