Reader comments
Dick Harmon: Utah fans fuel the fire behind heated rivalry
457 comments | Read story
Can't wait | 12:14 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Man, 5 more days. It's almost as bad as waiting 2 weeks for the Super Bowl!
Go Blue!
OK it's 4 | 12:17 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
But it's still Monday here in Washington!
Anonymous | 12:18 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Harmon you have once again showed what a poor reporter you truly are. BYU shows
just as much animosity and hatred as Utah shows BYU. You show us all how blind
Cougar nation is, thinking how they are better than the rest of us. I'm
amazed...
Comments continue below
AK Cougar | 12:37 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Antoher good article Mr. Harmon. The personal interest stories from the players
are great in rivalry week. I am hopeful the Jan Jorgenson and the rest of the
Cougars have a great game, no one on either side get hurt and they all play very
well. Cougars by 3, 24 - 21.
UTE 56 | 12:39 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
no doubt... Harmon I will never read another "piece" article from
you...you are a terrible (Walton) journalist....BYU hates Utah every bit as much
Wow... | 12:46 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Way to cherry-pick those quotes Mr. Harmon. Zoobs have been drinking this
Kool-aid for a while. I honestly don't know why they still think, let alone
say anything about "caring less." When their actions say SO much
more.
Just last year when I held my nose and went to the U/Y hoop game in Provo, I'm sitting behind some guy with a Y ball cap on that has "4th and 18" embroidered into the back. Are you kidding me?! And, they don't care about the rivalry, right?
I still see "Harline's still open" coming out of zoob pie holes. I recall some zoobies taking that sign to where the Utes plane landed in Oregon last season before the OSU game.
Trust me, they care. It won't help them much this year, but they care very much. When they say they don't care, it's in years they know they'll likely lose, like some 5-year-old on the playground.
Just last year when I held my nose and went to the U/Y hoop game in Provo, I'm sitting behind some guy with a Y ball cap on that has "4th and 18" embroidered into the back. Are you kidding me?! And, they don't care about the rivalry, right?
I still see "Harline's still open" coming out of zoob pie holes. I recall some zoobies taking that sign to where the Utes plane landed in Oregon last season before the OSU game.
Trust me, they care. It won't help them much this year, but they care very much. When they say they don't care, it's in years they know they'll likely lose, like some 5-year-old on the playground.
Get out much? | 12:56 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Attention Dick Harmon: The University of Utah was founded in 1850 under the
direction of Brigham Young, territorial governor. To suggest that the coaches
at Utah (three of which are former BYU players) spend all year hyping this game
due to some pychosis, that it has anything to do with religion, or to be so
ignorant to think that any college football fan - let alone a Cougar fan -
doesn't get into their rivalry contest for any reason, is absurd. Please
stick to politics. Sports is obviously not your thing.
Anonymous | 12:57 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Ahhhhhh, Dick..... Welcome to 2008. The series is tied 10-10 over the last 20
years. The current players wouldn't remember the series being one-sided.
The programs have been equal for two decades.
"Utah's philosophy on defense and offense is designed to take advantage of BYU weaknesses." Ummmm, Utah's philosophy on defense is to stop their opponents. They have 13 of them throughout the year. Utah's philosophy on offense is designed to keep their opponents off balance and to attack their weaknesses. Again, Utah has 13 teams they prepare for.
Your statement is true for this week. The statement is also true if you switch the school names around. BYU will also attempt to take advantage of Utah's weaknesses.
If you don't think the Y gets up for the games at the same level as the U then I'm guessing you never played a game of football in your life. Both teams have the same level of passion and are equally motivated for this game.
Read the blogs and you will find the fans are the same on both sides. It's called a rivalry. This rivalry was once controlled by the U, then by the Y, now it's equal.
52-33-4 UTAH!!!!
"Utah's philosophy on defense and offense is designed to take advantage of BYU weaknesses." Ummmm, Utah's philosophy on defense is to stop their opponents. They have 13 of them throughout the year. Utah's philosophy on offense is designed to keep their opponents off balance and to attack their weaknesses. Again, Utah has 13 teams they prepare for.
Your statement is true for this week. The statement is also true if you switch the school names around. BYU will also attempt to take advantage of Utah's weaknesses.
If you don't think the Y gets up for the games at the same level as the U then I'm guessing you never played a game of football in your life. Both teams have the same level of passion and are equally motivated for this game.
Read the blogs and you will find the fans are the same on both sides. It's called a rivalry. This rivalry was once controlled by the U, then by the Y, now it's equal.
52-33-4 UTAH!!!!
Utes obnoxious | 1:02 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
U and Y students mostly come from Utah and are mostly Mormon. The main
difference is most Utes live at home with Mom. From outside Utah, you guys all
look alot alike. I love the play at religious differences. Big deal from where I
stand...
Thanks Dick..... | 1:15 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
For once again showing us YOUR true feelings toward the U. of Utah!
You are absolutely a byu homer and a very poor writer. I for one are soooooo glad you are pro byu and anti Utah.
The level of passion is equal from the coaching staffs to the players on each team.
This is byu's BCS game. It's a huge game for them.
This is Utah's opportunity to go to their 2nd BCS game in four years. It's a huge game for them.
Wake up and join us in the year 2008. 1984 is nearly a quarter of a century past. Ronald Reagan was in his 1st term as president and none of the current players were born. Utah's domination ended 40 years ago and BYU's ended 20 years ago.
This game means exactly the same to both teams, period. If you pulled out a GPS and actually found your way to the U, you would find their current players would downplay the rivalry to the media as well.
Once again, your article reflects YOUR true feeling.
Your article would have been fine if published in the late 70s or during the 80s but doesn't make sense in 2008.
You are absolutely a byu homer and a very poor writer. I for one are soooooo glad you are pro byu and anti Utah.
The level of passion is equal from the coaching staffs to the players on each team.
This is byu's BCS game. It's a huge game for them.
This is Utah's opportunity to go to their 2nd BCS game in four years. It's a huge game for them.
Wake up and join us in the year 2008. 1984 is nearly a quarter of a century past. Ronald Reagan was in his 1st term as president and none of the current players were born. Utah's domination ended 40 years ago and BYU's ended 20 years ago.
This game means exactly the same to both teams, period. If you pulled out a GPS and actually found your way to the U, you would find their current players would downplay the rivalry to the media as well.
Once again, your article reflects YOUR true feeling.
Your article would have been fine if published in the late 70s or during the 80s but doesn't make sense in 2008.
Spot on, Harmon | 1:23 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Dick is calling it how he sees it. I'm a die-hard Cougar fan too, and it
seems the BYU players don't get as fired up as the Utes. I imagine it has
something to do with age but Utah has its share of RMs too.
The fans on the other hand are a different story ... No difference. This is a fun rivalry.
The fans on the other hand are a different story ... No difference. This is a fun rivalry.
Ron | 1:27 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
You forgot to mention the significant body of BYU fans who are sick of being
accused of "playing the church card" and "thinking we're
better than everyone else". To all Ute fans, LDS and non-: can we stick to
football please?
Big Mouth | 1:31 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
This player saying that Utah fans hate them because the Y has dominated the U
for so long..PLEASE.. the last 20 year has not been domination. actually 2004 is
what you call domination, 50+ points. The point is that Utah fans hate any Y
zombies because they say dumb things like this, "we have dominated
you". IT IS THIS SELF RIGHTEOUS AND ARROGANT attitude that we hate. We Utes
trash talk as well, but we don't pretend to be anything but rabid fans.
Essays like this Dick, insinuate that the kewgs are so well behaved and non
affected, when they have BIG mouths like this jeorgensen dude.
Anonymous | 1:35 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I don't know where you are getting this, BYU fans and players are just as
much into the Holy War as the Ute fans. The passion for this rivalry is what
makes it so great. Do some research about the rivalry next time.
Silly Bravado | 1:43 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Rivalry week is a chance for the young bucks to lock horns and duel one another
with their dull bravado's. Bragging is a young man's game, which lends
a flavor of immaturity to many of the posts.
The real reason | 1:47 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Why does Utah hate BYU? It is because of a double standard. If a Utah player
spent time in jail,(as some have and probably will again--not a slam, just a
fact), it is no big deal.No one expects any better from Utah! At BYU,a player
who had these problems wouldn't make the student body, let alone the team.
Now before you start throwing names of BYU players who did bad things, I hasten
to point out that not only did most of them get booted, sometimes the coach did
as well. If a BYU player or fan looses his cool and says something of does
something the least bit "inappropriate", everyone from Utah (and other
places) points their fingers and shouts, "hypocrite". If a Utah player
steps out of line, so what? Why do some BYU fans hate U of U? Have you ever gone
to a game in RES if you are a BYU fan? Last time I was there,we are treated to
drunk, X rated Utah fans and my family and I vowed never to go back.So much for
"hated' rivalries.
sob | 3:34 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
the biggest difference is that at res you can get a diet coke, not sneak it in
like you have to at les
by the way i have had a companion smacked in the mouth by a byu coed (no this is not another joke)
when utes won triple overtime basketball game
and have seen byu fans throw drinks and a blanket over the head of oregon fans at a game in provo .
i once heard a man dressed in a blue suit and white shirt and tie yell to a ute basketball player who was black,,, "smile more so we can see where you are"
boorish behavior is not excluded by the honor code i guess
by the way i have had a companion smacked in the mouth by a byu coed (no this is not another joke)
when utes won triple overtime basketball game
and have seen byu fans throw drinks and a blanket over the head of oregon fans at a game in provo .
i once heard a man dressed in a blue suit and white shirt and tie yell to a ute basketball player who was black,,, "smile more so we can see where you are"
boorish behavior is not excluded by the honor code i guess
Amused | 3:42 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
What a funny article. I can appreciate that Harmon "bleeds blue" and
that is where this is coming from. But really? The writer tries to make an
emperical assessment of something as subjective and malleable as which fans
bring more vitriole to the rivalry? Not only is the whole premise of this
column ridiculous, but the writer then attempts to add varnish to the false
veneer by quoting how BYU players "feel" going into Rice Eccles.
The truth is, BYU has been out of the national spotlight for a long time. True, they had a few weeks this season carrying the banner of potential BCS buster, but that quickly faded. The only real noteriety either school has received came in 2004 and now, with Utah on the cusp of another BCS return this year. Both times the Utes have been the center of national attention, not BYU. So yeah, Utah must envy BYU and that is why they are passionate about the rivalry. If that sort of envy gets a team a BCS bowl win and puts them in position for another--I'll take it, with deleusions of BYU fans in tow.
The truth is, BYU has been out of the national spotlight for a long time. True, they had a few weeks this season carrying the banner of potential BCS buster, but that quickly faded. The only real noteriety either school has received came in 2004 and now, with Utah on the cusp of another BCS return this year. Both times the Utes have been the center of national attention, not BYU. So yeah, Utah must envy BYU and that is why they are passionate about the rivalry. If that sort of envy gets a team a BCS bowl win and puts them in position for another--I'll take it, with deleusions of BYU fans in tow.
Mark Barton | 3:43 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
When I first started attending BYU in 1989 as a freshman coming from the Seattle
area I had never even heard of the University of Utah. I later thought that
Utah State and Utah were one in the same school. I attended BYU with several
other out of state students who thought the same. That would partially explain
to me why the rivalry isn't as big of a deal to BYU students.
Proved his point | 5:08 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
The way Utah fans have responded to Mr. Harmon's article proves how
overwhelmingly one-side the hatred is.
btw, I see the Utes are counting the spring 1896 scrimmage in their win total; just shows how deparate they are for any win. When is the U going to stop counting their wins over high schools and intramural teams in their overall record?
The overall series record is 49-30-4.
btw, I see the Utes are counting the spring 1896 scrimmage in their win total; just shows how deparate they are for any win. When is the U going to stop counting their wins over high schools and intramural teams in their overall record?
The overall series record is 49-30-4.
To U fans: Be afraid, be very.. | 5:17 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
U fans are nervous. There is so much riding on this game! I can't
remember a game with these implications.
Utah Forever | 5:29 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Jorgensen thank U for going to BYU--U belong on that team.
Easy on Harmon | 5:31 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Once again the inferiority complex of Ute fan is evident by what's been
posted so far. Utes define their existense based on their ability to beat the
Cougs. Harmon is right, I've been to both stadiums during rivalry week and
Ute fan without question is downright hate-filled. It's also important to
note here: if Ute fan can't win the game he/she attacks Cougar fan. Anyone
remember Ute fan swinging fists at the family of a Y player after a Utes loss in
SL a few years back?
The unfortunate thing this year is the undertones of the Prop 8 passing in CA. The church [and by association BYU] has become a proverbial punching bag for opponents of Prop 8. The atmosphere at the U lends itself more to being a haven to the gay and lesbian lifestyle. It would be unfortunate, but I wouldn't be surprised to see a few signs in the stands expressing the tolerance and respect that is being so graciously showed to the LDS church these days for standing up for their beliefs.
The unfortunate thing this year is the undertones of the Prop 8 passing in CA. The church [and by association BYU] has become a proverbial punching bag for opponents of Prop 8. The atmosphere at the U lends itself more to being a haven to the gay and lesbian lifestyle. It would be unfortunate, but I wouldn't be surprised to see a few signs in the stands expressing the tolerance and respect that is being so graciously showed to the LDS church these days for standing up for their beliefs.
Are you kidding me? | 5:33 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Dick Harmon continues to show his inability to publish a piece of intelligent,
objective journalism. If there is a bigger BYU homer out there, I would like to
meet him. It's a rivalry game. Ohio St. and Michigan hate each other ALL
year long. Auburn and Alabama hate each other ALL year long. I live among
Cougar fans. I read the message boards. They hate the Utes ALL year long.
Ute Lover | 5:40 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I live on the east coast and don't get too much coverage of the U or the Y
but have loved the rivalry for years. This year is no exception. Its strange
how you think Harmon. This years game is big because both teams are good...one
team can upset the illogical BCS. One team got clobbers by TCU playing away and
the other beat TCU team by few points at home. The results would have been
different had the field changed. Anyone should love this years game because it
will be competitive. I am not a Y fan because in big games like this, you and
your "fans" often show pre-game softness...always saying things
like..."oh, its no big deal...just another game"...."Utah takes
games like this too serious"....and then get all puffed up when the .500
winning percentage falls your way.
Not to Harmon and the "Coogie Nation"...grow stones...be fans...pull for your team hard before and after the game...when you win...win like a pro...and when you loose....loose like a pro...its no fun when you act ambivalent pre-game and then change posture only after a win...
Go Utes....
Not to Harmon and the "Coogie Nation"...grow stones...be fans...pull for your team hard before and after the game...when you win...win like a pro...and when you loose....loose like a pro...its no fun when you act ambivalent pre-game and then change posture only after a win...
Go Utes....
A "sheepish" fan base! | 5:49 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I don't hate the Ewet's! I hate their fans! Well at least the ones
that really think this is about religion.
My LDS Ewet friends are tolerable and I relish the back and forth with them. It's all about stats, how the year has gone, players that cry, etc. Heck, more than 50% of the Ewet staff, players, school admin, and fans are LDS. So why is this a "Holy War"?
But SOME non-LDS Ewet fans take this as another opportunity to rag on an institution or throw out insults that have nothing to do with this game of football.
I've attended the last 2 games and I could not believe the filth coming from the Ewet fans' mouths during and after each game and they had NOTHING to do with football, and everything to do with actual hatred toward a persons religion and their religious leaders. And what does a banner that says "Hey Beck! I gave your Mom an STD!" have to do with football?
Yes I would say that there is equal "hatred" on both sides, but at least BYU fans channel their hatred toward football instead of personal insults.
My LDS Ewet friends are tolerable and I relish the back and forth with them. It's all about stats, how the year has gone, players that cry, etc. Heck, more than 50% of the Ewet staff, players, school admin, and fans are LDS. So why is this a "Holy War"?
But SOME non-LDS Ewet fans take this as another opportunity to rag on an institution or throw out insults that have nothing to do with this game of football.
I've attended the last 2 games and I could not believe the filth coming from the Ewet fans' mouths during and after each game and they had NOTHING to do with football, and everything to do with actual hatred toward a persons religion and their religious leaders. And what does a banner that says "Hey Beck! I gave your Mom an STD!" have to do with football?
Yes I would say that there is equal "hatred" on both sides, but at least BYU fans channel their hatred toward football instead of personal insults.
Blue Ute | 5:53 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Dick is right. I grew up around here and graduated from the U and then moved
back East for 22 years. We had a Utah Banner and a BYU banner for our house and
we would root for both teams throughout the season and then whoever would make
the conference look best by winning the rivalry game. When we moved back a few
years ago I felt that things had really changed. Many of the Utah fans I got to
know had a disproportionate hate for BYU. While I suppose there are some
fanatical BYU fans, the Ute fans seemed to have the clear majority who hate all
things BYU. The operative word here is HATE. This year the conference will get
another BCS opportunity if Utah wins. ( And BYU stands to get a big chunk of BCS
money). So I am counting on Utah to win. But if BYU wins, I have to admit, it
will be fun to see all of the sour grapes from the Die hard Utah fans.
Anonymous | 6:02 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Since 1998 the the teams are 5-5 against each other. Since 1988 the teams are
10-10 against each other. I'm pretty sure Utah has stopped looking up at
BYU. Still writing Herald pieces Dick.
Provo Daily Herald | 6:13 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I thought I was on the Desnews website not the Provo Daily Herald. Maybe the
childish behavior is due to the fact that Utah will soon be headed to its second
BCS game in four years. Enjoy Vegas again this year Dick. Maybe you guys can get
beat by another mediocre 6-6 Cal team. The mountain west conference title is
going to go through Salt Lake and Fort Worth for years to come. Start getting
used to it.
The Spin Doctor | 6:19 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Ah another gem from Tricky Dick the spin doctor whose words fall from heaven to
my ears like manna!
Don't worry about the facts. You have all you need to spin the story so that everything is defined by BYU. And he wonders why virtually every team in the conference (or country if they were relevant) dislike BYU?
Don't worry about the facts. You have all you need to spin the story so that everything is defined by BYU. And he wonders why virtually every team in the conference (or country if they were relevant) dislike BYU?
Utah alum | 6:22 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Both side have obnoxious fans, but Dick, you are skirting the real reason for
the animosity. The real reason is that this game is all about school vs.
religion. If it were school vs. school, I would gladly root for the U, but that
isn't what much of it is about. It is about bashing Mormons. Therefore as a
U grad (my wife also) I have to root for the blue. If (I doubt it ever will)
change I will proudly wear crimson and white, or is it black and red?
Kafusi | 6:24 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
BYU stole utahs D-line coach a few years ago for the sole purpose of preparing
to play Utah every year.
DWR? | 6:26 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I once had a girl have with me, which afterwards I can only discribe as a D.W.R.
(Define WHAT relationship?). There was no relationship - we had gone on a few
dates. In her mind, it seemed much more than that.
Same goes for the BYU Utah rivalry. In all my years as a student at BYU, I never heard anyone talk about the U. No one cared that much about the commuter state school up north, or their "OK" football team.
But the Utes have never been able to stop talking about BYU. They have a huge complex of small-man syndrome.
The red-headed step child Utah is getting taken to school by Big Brother BYU on Saturday.
Same goes for the BYU Utah rivalry. In all my years as a student at BYU, I never heard anyone talk about the U. No one cared that much about the commuter state school up north, or their "OK" football team.
But the Utes have never been able to stop talking about BYU. They have a huge complex of small-man syndrome.
The red-headed step child Utah is getting taken to school by Big Brother BYU on Saturday.
Recently became close? | 6:26 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
They are 10-10 over the last twenty years. Let's not act like Utah being
competitive just started.
Anonymous | 6:34 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I don't know if Utes are more passionate about this rivalry than BYU. I
noticed that how my BYU grad. friends always tell me that as well. But I
don't think that is the case by reading all the blogs about this game this
weekend. It is very heated on BOTHSIDE. I think that is how it is regardless
of what they say.
Go Utes!!
Go Utes!!
ramper | 6:35 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
"There's nothing like this in college football." You are joking
right? You need to get out more often. Let's start with Army-Navy,
Alabama-Auburn, and on, and on, and on.
Are you kidding me? | 6:37 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I still can't believe the stupidity of this article. Deseret News, are you
actually paying Harmon to write this stuff?
"And there is a hype disconnect. Utah feeds off it; BYU manages it." This statement makes me want to throw up.
After this article, a Utah fan could say ANYTHING and it still wouldn't be as stupid as this.
"And there is a hype disconnect. Utah feeds off it; BYU manages it." This statement makes me want to throw up.
After this article, a Utah fan could say ANYTHING and it still wouldn't be as stupid as this.
ZEBA | 6:41 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Harmon, please listen to some sports radio in the state and then I think it is
clear that Ute and Cougar fans are pretty close in animosity. This is one reason
I stopped listening to sports radio in Utah, because I find the bickering
between the fans to be ridiculously insane. I'm one of the rare Utahns that
likes to see both schools do well. My bro. who is a huge BYU fan shows a lot of
animosity towards the Utes.
Prediction: Utes - 34, BYU - 21
Prediction: Utes - 34, BYU - 21
utahcountyute | 6:45 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Hey zoobs if Harline is still open, maybe he should get a job! Perhaps a Uof U
grad can hire him! GO Utes!!
can someone in Provo confirm | 6:46 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
that BYU is formerly known as Brigham Young High School?
Thx
Albuquerque Coog Fan | 6:50 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I believe the reason that there are more Ute Fans in Utah, and especially the
Wasatch Front, is that most Utah students are from Utah, they live by their moms
and dads, and can't imagine living outside of the 'shadows of the
everlasting hills.' Whereas BYU Fans come from around the world and all 50
states, and then return to those 50 states to work and live. They are not
afraid to venture outside of their comfort zone. I think both schools are great
institutions of higher education and have great fans who support their teams.
The difference is that one fan base is local, and one is national/global.
Johnny Moser | 6:52 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Familiarity breeds contempt.
Grew up in wyoming, torn between brown/gold and BYU blue. Attended games in Laramie, SLC and Provo. Found that the fans in SLC and Laramie to be the most disrepectful and vulgar people I had ever meet on earth at that point in my life, and they still rank right up in the top 5 today.
It is ok to have passion about a sporting event, but when it is taken to the level that is too often seen in Laramie and SLC, when you offend and belittle, its time to grow up and get something in your life that matters.
Maybe that is why the "laramie finger" was not be unexpected last year. That is why the cops will have to escort fans out of the stadium on saturday and why we will probable hear about several assault charges filed from within the antics of sports enthusiasts.
A week from now it won't really matter.
GO Blue. 28-24.
Grew up in wyoming, torn between brown/gold and BYU blue. Attended games in Laramie, SLC and Provo. Found that the fans in SLC and Laramie to be the most disrepectful and vulgar people I had ever meet on earth at that point in my life, and they still rank right up in the top 5 today.
It is ok to have passion about a sporting event, but when it is taken to the level that is too often seen in Laramie and SLC, when you offend and belittle, its time to grow up and get something in your life that matters.
Maybe that is why the "laramie finger" was not be unexpected last year. That is why the cops will have to escort fans out of the stadium on saturday and why we will probable hear about several assault charges filed from within the antics of sports enthusiasts.
A week from now it won't really matter.
GO Blue. 28-24.
BYU @ PSU | 6:54 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
First of all, I remember well the time when this was a lopsided rivalry (and
I'm not much older than many of the current players). Much of that 10-10
split record has came in the late 90s to early 00s when the Utes made up some
ground and beat BYU several times. And certainly the coaching staffs are old
enough (some were even players) to remember when the rivalry was more onesided
than it is now, so I think Harmon hit that one squarely on the head (not to say
that that is the only reason the rivalry exists, by any means). Secondly, I
think Ute fans do have a lot more vested in the rivalry. When Utah loses, there
are people calling for the coaches head, regardless of how the rest of the
season went. When BYU loses, the fans are crushed, but they don't try to
fire the athletic department. It seems that the success of Utah's season
(for the fans) is determined by their performance against BYU. Whereas BYU fans
measure success on more of a national level. Losing to Utah wouldn't
preclude a bowl game and top ten finish, for example.
Bob2 | 7:00 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
You and Mr. Jorgensen's theories make about as much sense as saying,
"BYU has simply thrown aside passion for this rivalry because they are so
hopelessly behind the U since it began. They just gave up caring because it hurt
too much to look at that disparity." Utah OWNS this rivalry, but I would
not be so stupid as to suggest that the average Y fan cares about that on this
Tuesday morning.
Outside Utah -Cougar | 7:07 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
I got more excited for the BYU ASU games being from Arizona until that one day I
took my 16 year old brother up to Rice Eckles Stadium for the BYU Utah game.
Then it changed... I entered a stadium filled with hate like no other stadium.
I had seen BYU play in many other venues and this venue had the intensity and
dislike for another team I have never seen. I've been to Texas/OU,
Michigan/OSU, ASU/UofA games and I had never seen this level of hatred and
disrespect for the opponent. My 16 year old brother was hit in the head with a
bottle as we sat in the U section (scalped tickets) and my eyes became open to
this hatred from up north. The language was unreal with more Fbombs than I
heard in a full week at the inner city basketball courts of Chicago. I learned
that day how much this game means to the U fans. The number of out of state
Cougars is easily 5-10 times the number of out of state Utes. That day made the
rivalry for me. I like to see Utah lose now just because of the disgusting/low
class behavior.....
Not again | 7:10 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Another holier than thou, we are better than you, prideful attitude coming from
someone associated with BYU. Not very becoming from a
�unbiased� reporter.
Don't Care? | 7:17 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Last year's basketball game at the Huntsman center, Zoob fans were chanting
"4th and eighteen". So you are telling me that they don't care?
Please.
Texas BYU Fan | 7:17 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Just want to remind the Utes, regardless of the outsome of Saturday's
game:
one team has a national championship, one team doesn't.
Just wanted to remind you.
one team has a national championship, one team doesn't.
Just wanted to remind you.
Wow Dick! | 7:32 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Wow Dick! Have you ever read the stuff BYU fans post on your comment pages?
This is not a one way street, there are idiots on both sides of this rivalry.
Hey DICK! | 7:34 a.m. Nov. 18, 2008
Look at how many stupid coogs have commented on your page, and then tell me who
has more passion in the rivalry. When utah won 4 years in a row, ute fans didnt
say anything or rub it in to coog fans, we just acted like we had actually won a
game before. But I have heard harline is still open, and 4th and 18 almost every
day since they have happened.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
Related content
- Palin tickets still available 11:33 a.m.
- BYU devotional: 'God loves you' 11:24 a.m.
- LDS engineer, 48-core chip 11:24 a.m.
- Witness defends report on Mitchell 11:15 a.m.
- Davis seeking donations for seniors 10:40 a.m.
- Obama to note conflict of Nobel 10:19 a.m.
- Dem health coalition survives deal 10:10 a.m.
- Obama directs $600M for health 10:07 a.m.
- Stocks turn mixed 10:06 a.m.
- EPA chief on U.S. regulating CO2 10:00 a.m.
- Snow brings big chill
- Expert calls Mitchell delusional
- Hot Rod behind mic for Lakers
- Cougars use depth to beat ASU
- Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
- Non-BCS schools not given fair shot
- Max Hall wants to look ahead
- Yet again, we learn BCS is a big joke
- Five players miss Jazz practice
- Ranking the bowl games
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
282 - Letters: Global warming a lie219
- TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl206
- BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall173
- Cougars going back to Vegas150
- Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil144
- Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax125
- George lost in rivalry hatefest120
- Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony100
- Revive full food tax?97
Isn't Utah State a program that should be able to flex its muscle enough...
Latest comments
When is Jan Jorgensen's press conference? I'm sure he is anxious to tell us...
Ryan6:01-"Government run healthcare is not competition." Well, then, it's...
Mary was loved by all who were around her. She had many friends in high...
Fesenko is the Bynum Gasol stoppper...The new Ostertag Eaton monster.
"Where are all the (PHONY) civil rights (ACLU, TRIAL LAWYERS etc.)activist...
This is getting beyound ridiculous. Dosen't any of you climate changers...
I think it's great that Utah provides the option to clean your criminal...
I guess they just give peace prizes away because he has done nothing to...
RE: fan....Teach your kids to quit fouling and the refs wouldn't have to call...
All you guys do is complain. Most of your assertions are FALSE. Like...
Advertisements