Reader comments
Prop. 8 protest draws thousands in Salt Lake City

1,245 comments   |   Read story

CougarKeith | 10:51 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
Homosexuals have the right to choose, just like a woman has the right to choose. A woman's right to choose "Abortion" is the wrong choice in my opinion, but she has that choice. A gay person's choice to excercise his Gay tendancies to have sex with someone of the same gender is his/her choice and nobody is trying to prevent that although many believe it to be wrong. However trying to make it the NORM to be "Married" as a husband and wife have had the RIGHT to be since the beginning of time is WRONG and beyond acceptable in society. Why can't you just be "gay" about your ability to have sex and a romantic relationship with someone of the same sex? Why do you have to have this "In Your Face" attitude? It's wrong, and the behavior is wrong, yet you push for more and more and more. GIVE IT UP! Be happy with the perversions you excercise now, stop trying to push it down our throats! Your downfall shouldn't be the downfall of the whole society!
CougarKeith | 10:59 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
Fact: The Church has made it clear, the Savior has made it clear in the scriptures! What else needs to be said? If your LDS and you don't agree with the Church, then you obviously don't agree with the Savior because you don't read about what he says in the SCRIPTURES ON HOMOSEXUALITY. Therefore my suggestion is you do 1 of 2 things: 1. Repent and be sorry and get your act together. 2. Ask your bishop to have your name removed from the church records because you obviously don't agree with the Church's doctrines, nor that of the SAVIORS DOCTRINE! With that as the case you are in a very sad lot of selfishness and denial of what the Savior has said since the beginning of time, and you are being a student of the Devil and what he wants you to believe. If you have been to the temple, go back and PAY CLOSE ATTENTION! Your being dupped my friends, and selfishness and pride are controlling your thoughts, not humility, compassion and love. So many accuse the Church and it's members of hate and persecution, when quite the opposite is true, we feel for them, and love them.
georg | 11:10 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
The people spoke. Marriage is between a Man and a women. It has being and it will be. If those people want to push that again. we Will defeat them. We are the majority. Thank goodness.
Comments continue below
To: Doodles | 11:11 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
"I believe that those who choose to practice homosexuality damage themselves and our society and its Christian virtues."

Thats your belief- but honestly how does allowing gays to marry damage your society and your "Christian" virtues?? Seriously they are not the ones trying to take your rights away! Personally I believe your opressive Christianity has done more to damage our society- which was founded in freedom and justice for ALL.
Sam | 11:19 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
I am strong for PROP 8. I don't care if Gays marry, i really don't. I just don't want my children being taught in school that this is natural. Its not. I don't want children to be adopted into these gay marriages either. Its not fair to the children. They have no choice. They end of having a dad and a dad, not a dad and a mom. thats why I vote yes on 8
Clackey | 11:26 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
Our "Non-member" friends here in California have been thanking us for all of the work that we as members here did to get Prop 8 passed.
My prayer | 11:31 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
is that Religion is abolished from the face of the earth. I feel in my heart that I have a relationship with the Divine Creator, however the religious dogma that causes our world to be divided is nothing more than religion. My experience of being a part of the Mormon Church for nearly ten years, is that its members are fully commited to an organization and rarely do they have a relationship with the Infinite. When we as a people can learn to love each other unconditionaly without any strings attached, then and only then can we grow as a people. When we continually want to prove that our way is the right way, all we are doing is strengthening our egos. I have know ill will to any of the Mormon population or the Mormon Church, it is all that you know.....When the LDS Church is pushing their agenda on people who are not interested, people who live their lives through spirit realize their egos are doing all the talking. Have a great night....Love
Barakobama | 11:33 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
Our new elect president said it. Marriage is between a man and a woman. Thank you very much
RSL Forever | 11:35 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
I'd like to thank all the out-of-state gay people who stayed in Salt Lake County hotels for helping pay for RSL's new stadium.

:O

Bring more people next time - we need more TRT funds for the expo center/arts district/acquarium/etc... My heartfelt apology to Utahns who havn't stayed in a Utah hotel in the last 10 years who think THEIR tax dollars have gone to the stadium.
Wow | 11:44 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
This is crazy. So, you can't get married. Too bad so sad. The only reason why most of the Gay/Lesbian population wanted this to pass was to have society giving them a pat on the back a hey it's o.k. to live this type of lifestyle. Well, at least you are not being attacked for your lifestyle choice just for your wanting need to feel normal. Well, the masses have spoken and your lifestyle choice isn't going to get the green light from the masses. Keep living how you live; but, sorry marriage is between a man and a woman. Not a man and a man or a man and a cat etc.
By protesting it just shows that you can't accept the facts. That even though a judge granted a right that he didn't have the power to grant. That the checks and balances of the popular vote vetoed his decision.
George | 11:46 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
re: MoHo | 8:01 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008

Ditto.

Sick of Prop 8 | 11:48 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
Let's move on.
George | 11:56 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
re: Revoke tax exempt status | 6:05 a.m. Nov. 8, 2008


Give me a break. How many times did Obama, Cinton, ad naseum go to various democrat/left leaning churches and blame Bush and other republicans for all of the evil that is going on in this world.

Yes, please IRS, go after ALL these churches that decide to mix religion and politics. No exceptions.
Cheryl | 11:58 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
Welcome to our lovely city. Notice the cleanliness, the courteous people, the order and the unique beauty of our families. Our city was scratched out of the desert by the ancestors of the citizens you are protesting. This grit is generational as is the depth of our faith and our testimony. It is probably not anything you will ever understand. We have been bullied before and grown stronger. Our concerns are multi-generational and are more profound than you could understand in a short commercial or soundbite. How arrogant and terrifying to assume that one is wiser than thousands of years of tradition, not to mention the Father of us all. How foolish to try to wipe out generations of wisdom in one generation. Are your motives truly unselfish? I wonder. I wish you could have seen the face of my teenage daughter that we adopted overseas a year ago when I asked her if she would like to have been adopted by two moms or two dads. It spoke volumes. By the way, if an earthquake leveled S.F.,I along with hundreds of other Mormons would be on the frontlines helping you out. Can you wrap your brain around that?
To my fellow Mormons | 11:59 p.m. Nov. 8, 2008
I think its inappropriate in most cases to be quoting scriptures to these people that are already feel hurt by this situation.

I fully support Propostion 8 and donated to the cause but rubbing it in by reading scriptures that make you sound like their personal judge seems against the counsel of our church to not vilify or be disrespectful in this situation.

Please be careful about how you talk to our brothers and sisters and remember to be respectful.
multiply and replenish the earth | 12:07 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
was in the beginning...for a man and a woman...it takes this to do that. That is what marriage is all about and has been since the beginning. Marriage is fot this and for raising and protecting the children of that marriage. How do two men, or two women multiply and replenish the earth. Gay marriage is conterfiet marriage in the sigtht of God, man, and His church. The mother of the human race, created by God was Eve, not Steve. Get with it people. Just because they want it does not mean that they should have it.
Susan | 12:07 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
the lord teaches us not to judge one another.
Re: My Prayer | 12:15 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
People of various faiths can still love gays and lesbians unconditionally and vote their conscious. Just because I don't want to teach my kids in school that being gay is OK doesn't mean I don't love someone. That is a far-fetched accusation that protecting my children means I don't have unconditional love. Not supporting proposition would be unconditional stupidity and unconditional irresponsibility on my part as a parent.

By the way, I do have a love for the infinite and a relationship with him as well as people of many faiths and religions who voted down gay marriage. I am not sure who "the infinite" is to you but if he is the god of the Bible then I don't think you understand the scriptures so try reading them again. If he is another God then you should know that this country is a Christian nation which was founded on Christian principles. The founding fathers taught that the constitution was designed for a virtuous, God-fearing people and would work for none-other. The People have the ability to lose true freedom if they vote to do so against righteous principles. Freedom was preserved.
Friend of Plain & Simple | 12:25 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
As posted by "To Doodles":

"..how does allowing gays to marry damage your society and your "Christian" virtues??"

Allowing gays to REDEFINE marriage to include same-sex relationships damages society first and foremost by ceating the illusion that gay relationships contribute to subsequent generations no differently than straight relationships.

The former cannot and will never contribute to child-bearing and raising in the same way that the latter, as a man and a woman are crucial to creating a child in the first place, and a mother and a father are both key components to that child's well-being throughout life.

Some traditional families are deprived of such an ideal by circumstance, not choice. However, in all homosexual unions, such a deprivation is purely by choice. The mindset that says, "One type of parent (mother or father) is good enough for my kid" is borne out of selfishness, not out of what's best for children.

I'm a parent, and there's no way on earth I'd ever wish upon my children (or other children) a situation where they couldn't enjoy having parents of both sexes and realize the unique contributions that only a father or only a mother could bring to their lives.
Re: Doodles | 12:32 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Dear Doodles,

Actually, our freedom was founded on Christian principles. This is a Christian nation who's constitution was based on principles found in the Bible. Your freedom was founded on Christianity and if it weren't for God you would not even have your freedom.

You don't even know your country's own heritage. The Founding Father's always recognized the hand of divine providence from the God of the Bible but shunned any state-sponsored religion by a specific church.

BTW, atheism or humanism is its own religion so saying that you don't want to have Christian values pushed on you is really saying you want to push your humanistic religions on us - which will actually destroy the freedom of this country.

If you don't like living in a Christian land you don't have to live here. Christians accept and love people from all religions but they don't have to give up the values of religion our freedoms are founded on. You are free to practice whatever kind of lifestyle you want, even if it is perverted but don't pervert the values of this great country by changing its laws - keep it to yourself.
Re: To Doodles | 12:34 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
See Re:Doodles - really meant for you.
The Rock | 12:35 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Liberals always look to the courts to win what they cannot win at tha ballot box.

Want to be call a really bad name? Just disagree with a liberal.

Disagree with the gay activists and you are a homophobe.
Disagree with Obama and you are a racists.
Try to rein in the excesses of Fanny Mae and Freddy Mac when they brought affirmative action to the mortgages and you are a racists.
Disagree with abortion and you are a sexist.
They have names at the ready for every occasion.
different perspective | 12:37 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
it seems to me that everyone is overlooking the fact that everyones rights have been affected not just the GLBT community. I no longer have the right to marry a man due to prop 8 just as any gay man. homosexuality is defined as a sexual attraction to the same sex, they still have the right to marry an opposite sex person, but choose to ignore this right of theirs because of where their sexual preference lies. it seems all very ridiculous to me that laws should have to argued around the sexual preference of a minority
Sislis from Spain | 1:13 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
why are the protestors complaining. A vote was put, all those wishing to vote did so, and the outcome, legaland fair was not to their liking. Tough. It must also be pointed out that LDS. are not the only religious group involved, so where are the pickets outside other religious buildings??? Could it be because "they", the pickets, know that the laws of God and of the mass of people are the same. Marriage is between man and woman, always has been, and, one hopes, always will be.
hello | 1:17 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
I could not agree more with the comment posted above by "Hello my fellow Mormons". It is true that Prop 8 is the correct choice, but by quoting scripture especially the B.O.M we (as members of Gods true church) are, in a way, not loving them, but bashing with them and one thing we can not do is convince them of their sin. Love the sinner hate the sin!
boldlygo | 1:29 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Sadly, i suspect most of you posting on this site do not know a gay person - and within your own families likely someone who is gay would not come out in such a hostile environment. Likely these are your sons, daughers, brother, sisters, who for reasons unclear to you leave the state, and go to NY or California to find happiness and peace. So you all reinforce your beliefs and alleged "knowledge" with each other, never gaining any fresh perspective from an intimate one to one talk with maybe someone you love, who happens to be gay. If you had that talk, I think your eyes would open to the subtle truths of what is universal - the need to love, be accepted, and belief in your fellow man. This was what was all shattered with Prop 8
end of time | 1:40 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Think for a moment.
If we allowed a small state like NH to have only married gay couples.
Refused to let any gay couples in that state adopt children.
Within 2 generations all the married gay couples in NH would be gone.
Not quoting scripture-
God didn't set up the Garden of Eden with Adam marrying Bruce and Eve marrying Beth.
This earth life we have known would have ended.
Satan knew it- God knew it.
Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed for their own sakes.
wayne | 1:42 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
to sureshot 2:16

you say that you do not have the same rights as "married" people. civil unions gives you every right a married person has with the lone exception of the name.

why do you feel that you are being discriminated against? because prop 8 vacated the special protections and case law you needed to push your agenda forward and down the necks of unsupecting people.

How can you say that you should have the same leagle protections granted minorites espcailly African-Amaricans. have you gone through what that community had gone through simply for having more skin pigment. how about women and the handicaped. they are easy to see and understand why they were granted special protections the kind the california supream court gave the homosexual communities.

the only way to identify a homosexual is by his or her, its behavior. that is why the vast majority of minorites blacks and hispanics voted for prop 8.

so why attack or protest against the church. maybe because mormons have been discriminated against more than any other religious organization in this nation. maybe because they get a pass for attacking mormons.

so just how is bigited here? it's not the mormons.
Plain & Simple | 1:50 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To Straight Guy for Gay Rights: You define marriage and you will get the good reason you are looking for.
kid | 2:03 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Gays will never be satisfied because they know what they are doing is wrong and they just want another way to justify their actions... hate to break it to you, but prop 8 or any other law will never satisfy your insatiable appetites for that which unnatural. Yep i said unnatural, face the facts of your problem by yourself and quit making it everyone elses problem!
Plain & Simple | 2:04 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To John: Define marriage. If you use the word as we know it from any dictionary it is impossible for two person of the same sex to be married. What they have is a civil union. No one is taking their right away from being together. We merely ask to let words mean what they mean and stop trying to change the language until we no longer understand one another.
Plain & Simple | 2:16 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To reason: What is your source of Mormons giving 40% of the money for Prop 8. Do you people just pick a number and we are all supposed to accept it as a fact?
wayne | 2:17 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
patty 4:27you have some unresoved issues. I sugest calling Dr. loura on monday.

did you read the post delivered at the same time "did anyone ask the blacks?". this teacher gave a stark response from her research. you should ask some blacks why they supported prop 8 like this good teacher did.
blacks and hispanics voted overwellmingly in support of prop 8. the no on prop 8 should look at there actions in the black urban communities as a source of defeat.
stop spewing hate against the mormons. a little over $2000 doesn't seem like a reason to show so much hate against mormons.
Plain & Simple | 2:19 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To Blue: Nice dodge of the question. If name calling is your best shot no wonder you side can't win on the arguments when put to the vote of the people.
Plain & Simple | 3:07 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
The coalition is not going away.

The Prop 8 California coalition of protectmarriage will stay together to defned marriage. GLAD is mad they have a political challenge. They thought they held all the political clout over our elected officials. We will hold elected officials accountable. We will be watching the mayors of Los Angeles and San Diego, assembleymen and state senators who ignored the will of the people and sued the very people who elected them. For too long the gay community has held them hostage. They have no family and lots of free time to lobby and strategize. We have found our voices now and will be heard. We might have families to take care of, kids to take to soccer practice and other interests besides our jobs. However, we have learned how to manage our time to devote to a cause that is just. We are not going away. We have as much resolve and tenacity as our opponents, who with their tantrums have awakened a sleeping giant. We will challenge every unjust judicial decision, every school board member who promotes the disintegration of marriage and every other politician you thought you had in your back pocket.
Plain & Simple | 3:22 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To Anonymous at 10:45 a.m.: Marriage has always been defined between a man and a woman, in all societies and religions. They numbers may have changed at times depending on the society and religion (See Old Testament and Muslim to name two others besides early Mormonism), but it was never with members of the same sex.
Daniel | 3:26 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Being straight doesn't mean you get special rights either! The bigoted majority who voted in California's Prop 8 have crossed the line between church and state FORCING THEIR RELIGIOUS BELIEF into law. They are saying that others who do not share their belief or even churches who support gay marriage may not do so. That is immoral, unconstitutional, and downright selfish and evil. Your religious freedoms ends where my civil rights begin.
Plain & Simple | 3:34 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To Boyd Henderson:

"God said it is not good for man to be alone." You conveniently left out what God did about it. May I remind you he created Eve, a woman not a man. If you would look in any dictionary you would see that marriage is a union of a man and a woman as husband and wife. By definition gays cannot be married. They can live together and if they have enough clout as in California they even can get laws passed to give them all the same rights and privileges as married people. So it is not about rights but about what they call their living arrangement that has sparked all the protests.
Plain & Simple | 4:42 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
To @ Plain and Simple:

�Up until last Tuesday gay couples had the legal right to marry in California . . .
Marriage, along with being a symbolic act to formalize a commitment made by a couple, is first
and foremost a civil issue.. . .� Please define marriage for me. Here is my definition a union
between a man and a woman as husband and wife. Therefor by definition gay couples cannot
marry. They have a civil union. The fact that you and your partner have been together for 25
years and want the same rights and protections has been granted in the California Family Code. I
am assuming you are a Californian since Prop 8 only affected citizens of that state.
TW | 5:10 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
OF COURSE EVERYONE IS GOING TO PICK ON THE LDS CHURCH ! BECAUSE THE LDS CHURCH STANDS FOR WHAT THEY BELIEVE AND THEY DON'T WAIVER FOR NOBODY ! NOT CELEBRITIES OR ANYTHING OF THE WORLD !

I LOVE THIS CHURCH !!!!
THECHURCHISTRUE | 5:18 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
We don't care THAT YOUR'VE LEFT THE CHURCH it's YOUR MORTALITY THAT YOU'VE LOST BUDDY !!! TALK TO THE LORD WHEN THE SECOND COMING COMES !!!

THE CHURCH WILL CONTINUE TO GROW WITH OR WITHOUT YOU BUT YOU KNOW IT'S TRUE AND it's your loss really !!!

IT'S FUNNY THAT THE MORMONS ARE THE ONES BEING ATTACKED MORE THAN THE GAYS MAYBE THEY SHOULD BE THE ONES PICKETING !!! OTHER RELIGIONS WERE PART OF THIS TOO ???
Why the Surprise? | 6:13 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
The LDS was the major money and manpower force behind passing Prop 8. Be proud, you bought and paid for it. But with actions come consequences, the LDS Church is now officially the most anti-gay organization in this nation.
Watch the news | 6:33 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Do the gay activist watch the news. Fox news reported that the reason Prop 8 passed was because the african-american people turned out in record numbers to vote for Obama. These people have high family values and believe marriage should be between a man and a woman and they voted that way. Its just not the LDS church that have these values but the majority of americans believe this way. Gay activist want tolerance and understanding but they do not show any towards other groups.
Domestic partnership | 7:23 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Read the following and then, other than reinterpreting the word marriage, what legal right was lost?

297.5. (a) Registered domestic partners shall have the same rights,
protections, and benefits, and shall be subject to the same
responsibilities, obligations, and duties under law, whether they
derive from statutes, administrative regulations, court rules,
government policies, common law, or any other provisions or sources
of law, as are granted to and imposed upon spouses.
To Susan: | 7:26 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
If the Lord teaches us not to judge one another, then why do we have courts and judges?
Now I Know | 7:29 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
I've been undecided on this issue, but now watching the reaction of the gay community to a legal and fair vote of the people I cannot choose their side. It is obvious the gay agenda goes far beyond this ballot. Thankd you for your immature handling of the loss...it tells me all I need to know about your complete lack of character, and morals. Would the "Mormons" be acting like this if prop 8 had been defeated? No.
David | 7:41 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
The amendment to define marriage took away NO civil rights from anyone. If you are homosexual, you may still vote. If you are homosexual, you may still own a firearm and etc. Again, no civil rights were lost. You also retain the same rights under the domestic partner law, which unmarried heterosexual couples may not participate, as married spouses. The only difference is that your committed and legal relationship remains a domestic partnership while a heterosexual couple is either only "shacking up" or is equally legally protected as the domestic partnership and married.
In Jesus' Name Amen! | 8:07 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
Bigotry, particularly in the name of Jesus, is never justified. The Inquisition was based on the same logic. So were the Salem witch trials and Cotton Mather.
Thanks, really | 8:11 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
"I think its inappropriate in most cases to be quoting scriptures to these people that are already feel hurt by this situation.

I fully support Propostion 8 and donated to the cause but rubbing it in by reading scriptures that make you sound like their personal judge seems against the counsel of our church to not vilify or be disrespectful in this situation.

Please be careful about how you talk to our brothers and sisters and remember to be respectful."

Thanks for this post. Unfortunately, self-righteousness has overtaken the proud. Or maybe pride has overtaken the self-righteous. Either way.....
Mormons Disgust Me | 8:23 a.m. Nov. 9, 2008
There are more homosexuals in the world than Mormons by far. Do you want us to vote on your religion?

Add your comment

Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.

Words Remaining

E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.

Image
Courtney Sargent, Deseret News

The Salt Lake Temple is visible from the site of Friday's rally, which included a march around the two city blocks surrounding Temple Square and the Church Office Building.

previousnext

Latest comments

To all of you brainwashed and braindead Utahan's, this is what organized...

Thank you so much George! You made my day. And it is not just our paper,...

that every time the Global Warming gang holds a big conference in some major...

Letters: Liberal because LDS

The idea that taxes enslave or are stealing is the most anti-american...

Williams' late jumper tops Spurs

The Spurs are under new ownership this year. Their new owner is the Jazz....

Perhaps one thing that should be learned from this experience is that there...

Revive full food tax?

Welcome to socialism. This Obamaland mentality is becoming boring and scary....

nice to see american fork getting some wins and some love from dnews, and...

Revive full food tax?

Tax the religious organizations,you would have a windfall!

TCU or BSU should be playing Florida in the Sugar Bowl, and not each other in...

Advertisements