Reader comments
Jewish family makes peace with LDS baptism
144 comments | Read story
More importantly, thank heaven for this wonderful individual who sees, not divisiveness, but unity in mutual respect for each other's religious beliefs.
I really appreciate the author's tolerance and understanding since the Church has never ever taught me to be anything but try to be a good neighbor, citizen, parent and friend. When I personally don't measure up (like all of us fail at some point), the Church's teachings are there to help me get up and try again.
Tolerance is one of the bedrocks of Christian values.
I also appreciate the author sharing her family story in a very personal and tender way. I have attended Jewish Shabbat dinners in England, visited Jerusalem during my college days, and served my LDS mission in New York City. I have a great love and respect for the Jewish people and their strong families. I admire the devotion that they have to their faith and families. This was an excellent article to read.
Thank you
Many of the people killed in the Holocaust were baptized Christians. It was a racial, not a religious persecution, although that word is inadequate to describe the horror.
To try and use it as a club to attack others religious practices is a misrepresentation of it and the memory that should be associated with it.
This is an article I would recommend to any non-member interested in understanding our practice of baptism for the dead.
Surely, it is a "strange and peculiar" practice, but true and right and good non-the-less...
The opposite view has always puzzled me. What is the nature of their non-belief, when non-Mormons object to posthumous baptism, or when Protestants object to their Catholic ex-spouses having the legally dissolved marriage spiritually annulled by church authorities? If they don't believe the religious practice has any effect, I wish I could understand why they object.
And yet I appreciate the author's intellectual open-mindedness in saying she can see how I as a Mormon would never presume that my efforts on behalf of departed dead could ever force someone into Mormonism or any other commitment.
Good article.
1- If everyone needs to be baptized in order to achieve salvation, what happens to those who aren't baptized by proxy? For example, maybe someone in a remote Amazon tribe, which has no contact with the outside world, and no one knows their name. What happens to them>?
2- If God is perfect, couldn't he just save people based on their life? Why would he need other people to perform a ritual on their behalf? In other words, why is this even necessary?
Thank you for your time. DNews, thank you for not censoring your comments and printing this.
QUESTION 1:
It is true that baptism is, according to Jesus, essential to salvation.
I take your point about inaccesible peoples, and add that the same goes for the many millions of souls that have lived and died on the earth without having heard of about Jesus the Christ, and thus have been denied the opportunity to be baptised in his name as an essential step towards full salvation.
The Bible has the answer, although it seems that with some notable exceptions, only the LDS believe what is written and actually practice salvic rites for the unbaptised dead.
So, the provision has been made that those who have died, as in your excellent example, will not be unknown during the Millennium, and during that time, vigorous temple activity will extend and afford all who so desire the opportunity denied them on earth by the circumstances of their location and the time period during which they were born, lived, and died.
Question 2:
God is perfect, and in his perfection he has designed a plan of salvation for humanity in which an individual must be a willing participator in the work of his/her own salvation by exercising moral agency.
Everyone who didn't have the opportunity to hear the gospel in this life will have that oppotunity in the next.
Adn they will all have a proxy baptism done on their behaif.
This is why The LDs put such premium on genealogical work, and work for the dead. There is just so much to be done.
And it must be all done for all who have lived.
Unfortunately most of it will have be done in the "Millenium" the period after Christs return.
Point 2:
there are certain ordinances that must done in order for one to enter the hightest of degree of glory, that is to live heavenly father again, and mormons, the LDS, are taught baptism is the first, the gate ordinance for that.
"Save" is intersting term, and you would have to be more descriptive.
Those who do not accept the "LDS" baptism but the gospel of Jesus, will be "saved", they will recieve glory and existance with Jesus, akin what they are expecting now.
They Just don't recieve full glory and life with the Father.
This may be much more mormon doctrine than non-belivers may be able to understand, but I hope it helps.
It seems to me to be an excellent example of very substantial intellectual content presented in a concise, succinct and eminently accessible style.
My congratulations and thanks to Manya.
Short answers:
During the millennium the work in the temples will continue and ALL will have a chance to accept or reject. This means that everyone that ever lived on this planet will have their work performed. More hapens in the millennium that just temple work, but that is a significant part of it.
God is perfect. Why did jesus have to be baptized wince he never sinned and there was nothing to repent of? He showed us that the ordinances of the gospel need to be fullfilled by us. It shows faith to be willing to be baptized and confirmed.
I suppose it is not unlike the difference betwen being maried and living together. The former shows a committment and faith in the relationship. An outward act has to be performed.
My $0.02
1. Souls exist after death. Mormons believe our dead do missionary work among all those souls, wherever/whenever they lived. During the "Thousand Years of Peace" the barriers between living and dead will be thinner, and we'll be made aware of any and all who wish to be baptized. Our temples will be VERY busy during that time, with tens of billions of potential baptisms.
2. Certain classes of people don't need to be baptized because they are covered by the Atonement (e.g. little children.) Those who were "without law" (e.g. had no knowledge of Christ or this "ritual") are judged by the lives they led, as you suggest.
At the same time, the sinless Christ was baptised - not for remission of his sins, for he had none, but "to fulfill all righteousness." The ritual IS important. Another element of baptism is the choice to be "born again" as children of God. It won't count if you don't want it, but if you do, it's a must-have.
Someone else may answer better. But I hope this helps some.
Given this it only makes sense to hedge your bets, other religions should be happy that the LDS is putting their money where their mouth is.
If we truely love our neighboors, you can do no less than the LDS do given their beliefs.
Other religions with the belief that they are the only true one are apparently content to sit back and let all the poor souls with the bad luck to choose the wrong religion (any one other than theirs) burn in hell.
If nothing else, the LDS put their money where their mouth is and they put a lot of effort into it too.
To answer your second question first:
Christ declared that all must be baptised "to fulfill all righteousness", to fulfill Gods law, even Christ who was without sin. And that it was John the Baptist who should baptise him as an angel of God had given John the Priesthood of Aaron and therefore the authority to baptise in God's name.
During the millenium, the veil will be very thin between this earthlife and the hereafter, and all of those who did not have the opportunity in this life to be baptised, will have that choice, and then the information will be revealed to those on earth who have that authority, so that their baptisms can be performed.
Keith | 12:22 p.m. Oct. 11, 2008
1- If everyone needs to be baptized in order to achieve salvation, what happens to those who aren't baptized by proxy? For example, maybe someone in a remote Amazon tribe, which has no contact with the outside world, and no one knows their name. What happens to them?
This is why geneology is vastly important. MANY MANY miracles have been witnessed when searching for someone who is seemingly unfindable. Also, during Christ's reign in the millenium, temple work (baptisms by proxy and geneology) will continue in even greater amounts. Angels truly lead those who do God's work. People will be led by those on the other side, wishing to be found. Baptism isn't a condition of being presented the gospel plan, it's a condition of being able to accept it.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- 'Dinosaur Odyssey' insight to life 4:35 p.m.
- PETA unhappy with Utah laws 4:33 p.m.
- Waste incinerator settlement OK'd 4:27 p.m.
- Gas line prompts Parowan evacuation 4:25 p.m.
- Canal co. shareholders OK merger 4:24 p.m.
- Crèche convention opens in SLC 4:02 p.m.
- Utes focus on game, not 'GameDay' 3:58 p.m.
- Duchesne developers charged 3:16 p.m.
- Hall closing in on victory milestone 3:15 p.m.
- Pentagon defusing roadside bombs 3:11 p.m.
- House passes health care bill
324 - SLC council OKs gay rights policies
310 - TCU showdown has big implications
195 - Senators want food tax restored
158 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
155 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - Will state consider gay rights law?
129 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
119 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
116 - S.L. vote pending on gay protections
110
A comprehensive listing of missionary reunions being held this week.
One of my guilty pleasures is perusing the covers of celebrity magazines...
Especially the button he missed for this DA photo. Looks like he never...
Utah is probably the only "elite" football program in the world that has only...
i hope hunter plays bigham so the line can RUN EM OVER!!!! they wont know...
Angela You are too modest, The CHURCH OWNS Utah, it's legislature, it's...
While conservatives whine, you are trying to help American's. What a...
South Summit wins this one easily. After losing the first game in Blanding...
How many BYU fans does it take to make a well-educated football comment?? ...
IF you all feel so strongly about helping those who can't afford an expensive...
Badgering = asking questions that a high-school senior should be able to answer.
Good grief, can things get any goofier with Obama? This moron stands up and...


