Reader comments
Dick Harmon: Y. offense far from perfect
91 comments | Read story
Look at it this way: for three quarters of that game the Aggies won 14-10. I doubt the remaining teams on their schedule will let them get a big first quarter lead to live off of the rest of the game. Good thing those mistakes are correctable--I hope...
the only good thing that i hope come out of this, besides BYU learning from it, is that USU picks up and runs with what they did tonight. because from what i saw in the second half, i would have thought they were 5-0 and 8th in the polls.
They still won't come close to winning the WAC, but they won't utterly embarrass themselves, either. They've got more pride, guts and grit than people have been giving them credit for.
So Cal fan, I'll have to agree with you that BYU played as if it spent too much of its bye week reading press clippings. Or as if playing only one halfway decent quarter of football is enough to win a football game. Let's hope it's back to basics and away from the press coverage from here on out.
Pride goeth before a fall--and here come the Lobos and TCU. Gotta wise up in a hurry.
I think the BYU players don't have that killer confidence that the top teams have. They'd have just gone into Utah State and showed who's boss. They didn't. Oklahoma showed Washington and TCU who's boss. BYU didn't at Washington, and probably won't against TCU. BYU doesn't look like it's in Oklahoma's league.
Combined with Utah's squeaker over Oregon State at home, the MWC looks a little less strong. Hopefully, Air Force can win their game Saturday. A loss there would add another chink. Still, the MWC has a great non-conference record this year.
5-0 isn't anything to be disapppointed about. So, I guess we should be happy.
It doesn't matter. A win's a win, even against a team like USU. Just ask USC, USF, Florida and Wisconsin.
Hopefully this will wake the team up to the fact that it has a huge target on its back and the opposition will bring everything it has. I'd rather they meet some resistance, get rattled and find themselves in a dogfight when up 20 points late than early in the TCU game. Bronco was visibly displeased and I'm sure that he has plenty of "teaching moments" to drill into them before next week's game.
BYU has a HUGE bullseye on its back, with the national ranking, and every team they play is going to pull out all stops to beat them. Opponents are NOT going to rollover and die for BYU this season. They are going to try and knock them off their nationally ranked pedestal.
If BYU does not play EVERY game executing at their highest level, a loss will be assured this season. It is time for BYU to dig deep and decide if it really wants to be one of the top football programs in the nation, or be just another also ran, constantly whining and begging for respect.
Quit resting on your laurels, and stop reading your own press clippings. The season starts next week with New Mexico! Show us what you can REALLY do by dominating the teams left on the schedule. You have the talent to do it!!!
Hall need to move the ball to others. Distribute the ball to all the receivers. Quit going to Collie every other play. To all the receivers: focus on catching the ball. Yesterday had shades of UW where it seemed no one was ready to play.
I am all for pulling back when you jump to a big lead. Scoring 24 in the first quarter was great. But keep the hammer down until the end of the half.
I'm happy BYU won and was pleased to see the Aggies put up a fight. It was ugly yet fun to watch. Just like the Utah game.
So Cal BYU Fan,
Hi there neighbor. Better prepare for LV in December. It's only about 5-hour drive.
I'm driving to AZ to celebrate New Year fiesta.
I think I only saw Max Hall look-off the defensive secondary twice. But for that, I could tell where he was going every time. Makes defending BYU easier.
Borel and Locker are similar quarterbacks and it is evident that BYU doesn't handle athletic quarterbacks well.
They better stop being primadonas who are ranked in the Top Ten (for another 30 hours at least before they get dropped behind Utah) and get back to the basics that got them ranked as high as 7.
This one game risks blowing everything. Yesterday afternoon a BCS game was very much in reach. After last nights pathetic performance...no one wants another Hawaii versus Georgia game.
If we keep playing like last night let's get ready for Podunk State in the John Deere Bowl in Hooperville, Kentucky. I think that's the newest bowl game.
Get back to business!
What's that you say? They LOST by THREE freaking touchdowns?
You mean BYU played it's worst game in two years and STILL won by THREE freaking TOUCHDOWNS?
Even if it felt to you that Utah State outplayed BYU, it doesn't matter. You can feel like Superman, it doesn't mean you can fly.
It is time to be consistent Cougar fans. (You all remember consistency, right? It's one of Bronco's first commandments?)
It is time to say the same thing that we said after the Washington game. It doesn't matter what fans, pundits, fish-wrap quarterbacks or anyone else thinks. Scoreboard is all that matters. Period.
Remember; oh, remember my children; the dark days of Gary Crowton when a victory over Timpview would have caused a major celebration. Be grateful that ye not be filled with pride!
Cougs, up the intensity at New Mexico!! Go Cougs!
That was a good article. I love it, like the humor.
This was a horrible win, but a win. The D was great and spent way to much time on the field. They never should have been out there that long in the first half.
The offence, well let us just hope that they do not spin out in any more games through the rest of the season. This was a good game to be a little off since our D is good enough to win the game inspite of the O. That will not be the case the rest of the season.
Sportswriting is NOT journalism. It's entertainment. It's a person writing about a GAME for idiots with nothing better to do than read about it. That's why REAL journalists call the sports department the "toy department."
All in all, it was a very ugly game. After the first quarter dominance, it should have ended 60-0 with our second string in for most of the second half. I think this game was good for a couple reasons. One is that their performance should bring them down a few notches so they come in strong and humbled a bit for the rest of conference play. I think they let the two shutouts and high ranking get to their head. Two is that they actually had to play a full game, something they are going to need to get used to for when they play TCU, Air Force, and Utah.
a bit if the Cougars are planning to finally play some quality teams to justify your top ten rating.
What happened to a more methodical pass attack hitting Pitta, Unga and others for short to intermediate passes? What happened to the blocking from the offensive line? Why the ho-hum effort in catching passes by Collie (I love ya man...but let's focus and not act like we're doing a walk-through) and others?
Despite the win, this game gave me more heartburn and anxiety than any for a long time. I don't know how many times I let out choice words because of the stupid uninspired play!
Yes, USU has definitely improved over the last two games largely due to the insertion of the new quarterback--and the rest of the team is gaining confidence. I think that's great for them! But still, this should have been more like a 50-14 win. I couldn't believe we couldn't score TD's the 2 times we tried FGs (and missed one).
BYU is better than this-let's see it next week!
As for the USU/BYU game, USU is MUCH improved since Utah played them. With the new QB they have really picked it up! This was by far BYU's worst game of the season and they will wake up after this poor performance. I watched Utah barely beat Air Force too and BYU will handle them by a much larger margin I guarantee it.
I have been watching BYU football for 30 years of my adult life and I don't recall seeing a better BYU team (when they are firing on all cylinders). So get ready "red man" to get a red face the last conference game of the year!
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Death penalty possible in slayings 12:15 p.m.
- Senators seek cost controls 12:07 p.m.
- 'Slight' Games impact on Vancouver 11:54 a.m.
- Nadal cruises, Spain leads Czechs 11:52 a.m.
- U.S. looks to expand drone attacks 11:52 a.m.
- Tiger, alleged mistress keep quiet 11:50 a.m.
- Stocks edge higher 11:48 a.m.
- Study: Global warming not easing 11:43 a.m.
- Obama: Plan to 'jump-start' hiring 11:41 a.m.
- 20 killed in Indonesian fire 11:33 a.m.
- Mr. Football 2009: Tuni Kanuch
- Harpring's NBA career is over
- Miller predicted Tiger's rough road
- Phoenix signs off on LDS temple
- MVPs wrap up stellar prep careers
- 5A high school football All-State
- Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
- Utah Jazz going green with unis
- Jazz: Miles, Kirilenko to play Friday
- 4A high school football: All-State
- Hall reprimanded by MWC
407 - Max Hall issues apology
393 - Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
362 - Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?
288 - Utes won't respond to Hall
278 - BYU says Hall incident resolved
247 - Letters: Liberal because LDS
228 - 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
188 - Aggies shoot past Cougars
175 - Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
172
Harvey Unga's future seems to be a hot talking point among fans so let's...
The publicity over Max Hall's "hate" rant against Utah, last weekend,...
Some Ute fans might be wringing their hands over still another loss,...
To "@RedShirt | 11:41 a.m." please provide the Glenn Beck quote to prove that...
It's amazing how right wing rhetoric keeps making the rounds becuase people...
Great job Bradley! We love you and will miss you a bunch! You will never be...
How could this have happened? The US has the best healthcare in the world!...
I have an old pale blue leisure suit somewhere. I'll find it and wear it...
Now after having spent millions to keep this guy alive and provide him legal...
Interesting article in the wake of Climategate and the whole global warming...
Somebody needs to worry more about buying cat litter.. like Scoopa Away.
Can anyone tell us what MVP's from previous years are doing. What schools etc?
I like tiger more than ever now. I thought he was a robot before. I see now...



"sorry guys, we spent more time reading the newspapers and watching ESPN clips and analysis of our forthcoming perfect season and BCS buster predictions than we did game film of the pathetic Utah State defense. They made us look confused most of the game and unfocused.
Hopefully the best thing that came out of this game was eating one giant piece of humble pie.